Visited on a Saturday - the pizza was again. excellent - made well, generous toppings and clearly made with fresh ingredients. There were quite a few people there so it was busy enough but not crowded. The music was a bit loud for an afternoon, but not bad. So there was no real reason we should have sat there for 10 minutes waiting for a waitress. So service list s half-star today. We will definitely return as we love the pizza & always willing to overlook a bust wait staff, within reason. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Grabbing happy hour specials on a hot Friday! - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

What a Wonderful Place!! The staff was incredible, especially the bartender. She took such excellent care of our party of two tables. Pizza was delicious!!! The raspberry donut topped cheesecake was incredible!! So Happy we discovered Old Shawnee Pizza!!! read more

Stopped in on a Monday to try their Monday meal deal (an 11inch pizza for $11) and paid to upgrade to a specialty pizza. I opted to try the chicken, bacon, ranch pizza, and added artichokes to it. This was delicious! Their crust is crispy and almost cracker like and it was incredible. I got a side of the ranch as well and this is some of the best ranch I've had from a pizza joint. I was glad I took up a local recommendation since I was visiting the Olathe area. read more

Checked out OSP in Lenexa and I would go back again and for that Rangoon dip they have!! It's absolutely delicious. We half & halfed 2 pizzas and tried 4 kinds. Their pepperoni is so good! Good flavor on good crust. The margarita was delicious also! Their luau was okay. I do really like their crust. Not too thin and crispy enough. The cannolis were okay. The staff were super nice and it gives a woody bar vibe. read more

See all

First things first, I wasn't the biggest fan of the service here. The place was decently empty with just a couple people sitting at the bar area chatting amongst themselves. I walk in to retrieve my pick up order and I was met with just some stares as everyone proceeded to continue their conversations, leaving me standing there for some time. No hellos or welcome in, which is fine but still would make the place seem a bit more welcoming. Anyways, finally got my order which consisted of the crab rangoon pizza, pepperoni pizza, and garlic knots. Unfortunately I wasn't super impressed with the crab rangoon pizza. It was just like eating a glob of cream cheese on soft bread. Pepperoni pizza was pretty basic, regular. I did enjoy their garlic knots and marinara though! It does remind me of the garlic knots from Walmart, which would be a much cheaper alternative. Glad I gave the place a try, but probably won't be trying again. read more

Pizza here is so fresh and worth it. I enjoyed the vibes here and it's always a pack here whenever we come in. Friendly staff as always. They got daily deals and lots of drinks to choose from too. Would come back again. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

Old Shawnee Pizza is honestly one of my favorite pizza places. I haven't had a pizza from there that I haven't enjoyed. I hear the crab rangoon pizza is amazing and I hope to try it soon. read more

AMAZING!!! such good food, kindest staff and clean atmosphere! we got our pizzas in no time. they came out hot and ready to eat! 100% recommend going! read more

I've been coming to OSP, here and the one on Nieman Rd. I usually order the Carne Italiano, and add a couple items. On this particular visit, I was less than pleased as, while the service and food was as good as always, the preparation of my pie was not. Usually the toppings cover most of the surface area and are evenly distributed. This time however, there was a large area near the edge of the crust that didn't receive the love it should. An area of little to no meat or cheese, only sauce. While the meats were there, they were mostly in the middle. This doesn't mean I won't be back, but next time I may ask for a replacement it the same situation is encountered. read more

The service and atmosphere was great. Family friendly. The food was hot and delicious and the menu had a great selection. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Cannoli (1) - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

See all

I sat at a table for 7 minutes while the wait staff complained at the counter. I went to the counter to be told another person would help me. Apparently they were too busy to help me. No thanks. Tried to speak with a manager at the Lenexa store. The person that answered said is this about the pizza? When I said no, she said tell me your ticket number which I said I don't have one. She said well, what do you want? I said a manager. I don't understand how they stay in business. Double no thanks. :( read more

If you want to spend 55 bucks for a large pizza and two salad salads so be it. No pizza is worth 55 dollars.

Always consistent delicious pizza from OSP - tried their garlic knots for the first time -

The service is always great (I really like the Saloon for happy hour). It's a typical pizza place vibe and the pizza is good. There's a lot of competition in this area, so not a place I would go over some of my pizza favorites, but they have a great $10 lunch special during the week. Give it a try! read more

I was going back and forth between a 3 and a 4. We came here after a dinner for some night caps but I couldn't help order some pizza since I love pizza and it's in the name of the restaurant. We ordered two whiskey flights and a small personal pizza as a snack to soak up the whiskey even though we just ate . It was a pretty chill environment but we came later in the night so I don't know how normally weekend nights are for this establishment. I will say they had the best whiskey collection I have seen! They have everything you can imagine from rare and allocated products. Our waitress was having a long, tough night but she was super sweet. The pizza came out fresh and hot. Since it was smaller, it reminded me of pizza I made at home but I will say that it had a nice crust. Topping, cheese, and base wise was fine but the crunchy cracker like crust was solid. I will probably be back here to try a larger pizza to get the true experience and also definitely for the whiskey flight specials like on Wednesday. Tequila will be on Tuesday I hear. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

Our FAV! This is a classic pizza pub vibe. Not a huge place. Quaint and cozy feel. The staff has always made us feel welcome. A younger high school or college staff. Crispy cracker crust makes this pizza soooo gooood! Generous toppings and a crunchy crust. Try the crab Rangoon dip too. We go back almost weekly. read more

I really, really wanted to have a good experience here since my families long time favorite went bad. But... First visit my pizza sat on the bar for 20 minutes while the cashier flirted with her boyfriend. So I thought, anyone could have accidentally hired a lack luster employee or maybe the owners daughter so thought they deserved another shot. But again, disappointed. Sign right at the front door said "2 large, 2 topping pizza for $39.95" but received 2 medium pizzas. Not sure if this was accidental or a scam they pull but think I'm onto looking for my next favorite. Too bad too, the pizza was good. Wish I had taken photos of the sign... UPDATE: I just noticed while doing my bills, they actually over-billed me! Guess they thought they deserved more than the 20% to serve me a smaller pizza than ordered. WOW! read more

Good pizza, nice atmosphere, good for kids and hanging out, fairly attentive staff, and high prices. I took my two grandsons (6 and 12) here to meet up and hand them back to their dad. We got seated at a booth immediately (seat yourself). It was fairly busy. There appeared to be only 1 server for the entire restaurant, but he seemed to be on top of all the guests. We wanted wings to start (one of the main reasons the 12 year old wanted to go there). But they were OUT of wings at 5:45 on a Friday night. That seems very unfortunate, and the 12 year old was mopey. After passing through the lack-of-wings debacle, we ordered two pizzas and some garlic knots. The food was great. Getting the attention of the single server was sometimes difficult, but in all we had a great time. Also worth noting is that the booths are tall and solid, so the active 6 year old could be active without bothering people next to us. read more

The beer is always cold and pizza is consistently good! The staff is always friendly providing great service in a bar/restaurant type setting ... read more

I have heard good things about OSP but had never tried it before. I thought my girls would love a pepperoni pizza and garlic knots for dinner and gave the Lenexa location a carry out order. Now I take 100% responsibility for not checking the prices before ordering a single topping large pizza (14"). The call taker knew this was my first time ordering from OSP and didn't take the time to offer specials or best choices from the menu (called at 4:30pm on a Sunday) I was shocked when I arrived and was charged $33 for 4 knots and a large pepperoni pie. I figured maybe the pie is "that" good... When I got my order I was sadly disappointed to find the pizza very lacking for the $22 price tag and the garlic knots burned on top,$8. From service to ambiance to food quality OSP Lenexa is a pass, for now. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Large (14") Pepperoni Pizza - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

See all

I really enjoyed my salad. As a lactose intolerant person, I am a bit limited at a pizza joint but Lola added some BBQ chicken to a salad and it was great. I was accompanying my husband to a whiskey event here and I thoroughly enjoyed the Manhattan as well as the 'Drop the beet' which showcases gin steeped with beet. It was amazing: herbal, hearty, fruity. Lola was fabulous and is clearly an expert bartender. read more

A Circus of Inconsistencies, Inacurracies, and Ineptitude. So I've been an Old Shawnee customer since 2004 going to the Shawnee location all of the time until I moved to Lenexa at which point I frequented the Lenxa location always. After last week that will no longer be the case. The should call their Tuesday special the Toss up pizza special meaning you order what you want but you will actually get some sort of combination of the toppings on either pizza. Both of my pizzas were incorrect so we ended up picking most of the toppings off. Ordering over the phone was a challenging since the person taking the order had no idea that there is more than 1 type of sausage offered. Employees knowing their own menu would be good. I arrive and wanted to pay with my gift card through egiftia. I handed my phone to the cashier and the cashier ended up charging me twice for my order which left my gift card balance to zero. I was able to talk the manager into writing a paper gift card for the balance owed. Got home and after noticing the pizzas were incorrect I called. The manager offered to send me gift certs through my email/egiftia? I called again after not seeing them the next day. A different manager took my address down and told me he would send them in the mail. It's almost been a week and still nothing. Perhaps they will arrive next week, or maybe the week after. Since Jason the old manager left, this location has been riddled with inconsistencies. Whether it's time before pickup will be ready(15 minutes turns into 25 minutes or 25 minutes and the pizzas were done in 15 minutes) or the consistency of the cook of the pizza it's almost never the same. This was not a problem with this location even last year. If I go to Little Caesars and get a cheap pizza for $6 and it's wrong fine whatever. But if I shell out almost $40 for food I expect it to be correct and kind of consistent. Furthermore, if you aren't going to honor incorrect pizzas don't tell me you will take care of it twice then just forget about it. That implies to me that you either don't give a crap about a repeat customer, or you think I'm lying and am trying to get free food which is hilarious since I've been going to Old Shawnees since 2004. read more

I love this place! We sat on the bar side and had very attentive service from the awesome bartender. She quickly realized the guys liked whiskey! She told us about Wednesday night whiskey flights and their Christmas pop-up bar opening soon. Our food was fantastic. And there was a great 3 man band that kept us entertained. Highly recommend! read more

My wife and I have been coming to the Lenexa location for almost 4 years. We have enjoyed using the $14.99 coupons for a large 1 topping pizza. Last week we learned that they no longer honor these and now that same pizza is $28! Two topping Tuesdays used to be $16 for a large and now is $17 for a medium. I understand the cost of doing business has increased but these price hikes are a bit high for our taste! read more

Walked in and met Alex, accommodating for a traveler. I sat at the bar, and Caleb was fantastic, they were both focused on outstanding customer service. and the food was amazing. read more

Good food. Great bourbon selection. Would recommend to a friend. Bartender had great recommendations.

Great event with some hiccups. It was confusing to know where to go without any signage or directions when we arrived. Once we figured out that the line was for the event it was okay. It was just a long line and not enough space to accommodate everyone. I don't believe they were prepared for the amount that showed up and stayed because as you waited in line the pizza was gone before you could get any and people were waiting for more to be brought out so the line stayed the same. They did pass out some items table to table which was helpful. They had a raffle drawing and my husband was drawn but since the rooms were divided they passed it to someone else before we could get to them in the other room. Hoping the next event is a little more organized and they have a way to keep the lines flowing and food warm/cold. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

My favorite pizza!!! Reminds me of pizza shoppe. We have gotten take out and dine in. Super yummy

Service had really gone down hill but, not to worry, they are more expensive than ever. There are lots of choices to get pizza, I'll never return. Another horrible experience, never happens again because we're not coming back. read more

This spot is a neighborhood favorite. Occasionally the service can be spotty if you're dining in but the food makes up for any service issues. I ALWAYS get the crab Rangoon pizza and try one new flavor. The nice thing about OSP is you can get 1/2 and 1/2 on speciality pizzas and you don't even need to have the same base sauce. With one large specialty pizza, my husband and I always have a meal the next day. However, don't get one medium pizza thinking it will be enough for two people, it's a lot less filling/smaller. Let's be honest, people in the Midwest tend to judge a pizza place based off of their ranch.. I can attest that they have the best ranch around and they bring an entire bottle to the table if you're dining in. They also have a special garlic green sauce my husband LOVES. Their house salad is amazing and one side salad is always enough for my husband and I to split. The OSP dip is unique. One time we were accidentally given this instead of the artichoke dip but we were pleasantly surprised and will probably always get this over the artichoke dip. Oh and did I mention the crust?? It's so crispy and flaky. I LOVE this place. 10/10 recommend! We have continued to support them through takeout during COVID-19. I never want this place to close. I remember going here as a little girl and it's so engrained in the community. If you opt in for texting deals, they will send you weekly specials. Sometimes they're really good deals. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Crab Rangoon Pizza - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

This was my husbands and I's first time trying Old Shawnee Pizza and they were gooood! The Fixin's pizza has everything anyone would like, hamburger, Canadian bacon and sausage! My husband and I don't eat pork so we asked for pork to be taken off and doubled the hamburger and this pie still tasted delicious! Now, our eyes are bigger than our stomachs and we asked for a biggie pie size and if it's just two of ya stick with M or L. Lots of pizza leftover for us. Our two year old just likes good old fashioned cheese and she ate her whole pie. She didn't care too much for the garlic knot. I was kinda disappointed because they only carry chocolate milk and not white and our toddler is a milk drinker. The crab Rangoon dip was amazing! Hot and ooey! Tasted just like the middle of a Chinese crab Rangoon but in dipping style. Thumbs up! read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - The Fixin's - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

See all

Food was good. Service needs some more experience. Atmosphere is a good old fashioned lodge.

Horrible Service! This used to be our go to pizza place. Our last visit they overcharged us. We had to wait 20 minutes to order because the one waitress could only handle one table at a time. read more

We recently loved nearby and tried this place on the recommendation of my son. They have gluten free crust which is a big plus for the wife. I loved the cracker thin crust meat shack. Great spot read more

My local go-to spot for a caprese salad. Unfortunately, it's a seasonal dish (summertime). Off season, I love their house salad dressing (creamy green garlic). Divine and Luscious! It is so popular, you even have the option to purchase the dressing on its own to take home. Best purchase ever! read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

Do *not * buy their gift cards. They cannot be used on delivery orders. Which is weird. You're a pizza place...

Caution, Gluten Free people!! The options for the GF crust were mini and small, so I ordered the small (based on the pizza pans on the wall, small is 9"). My husband also ordered the small regular crust. We waited so long that we had to ask for the pizzas to go, which was strange because we saw at least 5 people standing around in the kitchen. Side note, most of the tables are set up so they can't accommodate a high chair, so we were trying to corral our very curious toddler the whole time. Anyway the pizzas finally came out and the GF pizza was TINY- 6.5"! We paid $18.50 per pizza and we were both still hungry. One pro: they had a guy singing and playing the guitar, which was cool. We'll go to Minsky's next time we get a pizza craving. read more

See all

We had a great night with a party of 7 (4 kids, 3 adults). OSP knows that kids get hangry when waiting for pizza to cook, so they brought out four little bowls of shredded cheese, ham pieces, slices of pepperoni and crackers! One of the kids thought the pepperoni was a little spicy. But other than that it was good! It was so helpful. The small pepperoni and the biggin Fixin's pizza were plenty of food, including two slices as left overs. The big pizza had tons of toppings. It had a thinner than average crust. read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Biggin Fixins Pizza. - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

Been almost year since we've eaten at OSP. Ordered carry out and the pizza was absolutely perfectly cooked like we requested . Salad was good great pizza read more

Old Shawnee Pizza-Lenexa - Medium Fixins well done - Italian Near Me - Lenexa, Kansas

The cracker crust on the pizza is amazing! If you like thinner, crispier crusts, this is the place for you. We stopped in on a Friday night and it was PACKED. I overheard the staff say they had not seen the place that just in months and that made me smile thinking that perhaps things are getting back to normal. Ohhhhhh...and as a bonus when I checked in on Yelp, I got a $5 off coupon. Sweet! Perhaps the best part? They have live music on Friday nights. I should have asked for the entertainers name because he KILLED. Just a guy and his guitar. Heck, I'd come back just to listen to him! read more