This sub shop across from Culver's has been a favorite for years. It had been a while since we ate there -- the building was traffic cone orange the last time we visited and is now a more sedate beige -- but it's still as good as always. They have hot and cold subs, paninis and flatbreads. I had the Boss Man hot sub with ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, jalapeños and mustard. My son had the roasted turkey cold sub with provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions and mayonnaise. We got the order to go but the dining area is large and decorated with Americana. The employees are friendly and on top of things. Pub subs get all the hype in this town but I like Old City better. read more

Old City Subs - The exterior of Old City Subs, which used to be as orange as the logo. - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Also being a Veteran, This is the second time this kind of thing has happened with the delivery driver; it's disrespectful and insulting, the first time they wrote "tip your driver" with a frown face. As a business owner myself it's up to the employer of an establishment to take care of their own staff with salary, not the customer to feel uncomfortable being forced to tip with comments being left like this. This sandwich this time had ants all over it and was left on the ground in front of the door outside instead of on the railing like it normally is. It was left like that intentionally, and it's not able to be fed to my 3 years old daughter today for lunch.D isgusting customer service happening for the second time, I will not be ordering from here again. Whoever is writing this kind of disgusting messages on recipients deserves to be fired immediately. I will not support a business like this. read more

I work in the building behind Old City Subs, so whenever I need a quick lunch but can't go far, I head over. Every once in a while, I crave a really good sub, and this place always delivers. They have a full menu with tons of options, and their seating area is spacious and comfortable. The food is consistently fresh and delicious, and the staff makes ordering a breeze. Service is super quick, and the food never disappoints. Highly recommend if you're in the area and want something satisfying! read more

You can always count on Old City to have a great sub. Been going there for years. On my go to local place. read more

Great sandwiches and good selections. They are quick for pickup or dine in. It gets busy at lunch!

My husband and I tried Old City Subs today. This was our first time. I would say that this is an average sub place. I got the meatball sub w provolone and my husband got the Dagwood. The meatballs on my sandwich were barely above room temp - certainly not warm enough to melt the cheese; one of the 4 meatballs was burned on a side so I had to take that off (it was hard and not chewable). My husband enjoyed his sub, so that was good. When we arrived there were 4 employees in view and no customers (we had a late lunch so not unexpected). As we entered and gazed at the board, no one welcomed us or offered suggestions. We approached the counter and placed our order, ate in the dining area, cleaned up our table, and refilled our drinks. As we left there was another (not one of the original 4 we entered to) employee seated by the door - no 'thank you for coming' or even 'goodbye'. Not a hospitable employee in the bunch, sadly. read more

Old City Subs - Dagwood Medium - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I had the chipotle steak panini and it was very good -- served hot with just the right sauce. I also had a slice of the cinnamon cake -- a good treat after the spiced chipotle. The shop is simple and clean with some vintagey & patriotic decor and a few mentions of God. read more

Great food and service I have never had a bad order from old city & the food is always fresh. Recommend trying read more

My favorite sub shop in St. Augustine. Generous portions, always fresh, huge variety. James has hit the perfect medley of toppings and flavors for the subs, just get it 'like it comes' , stfu & eat. read more

Went back for the first time in 10 years and this place is still off the rails. The portions are big, the ingredients are fresh, and the folks are friendly as can be. The value per dollar is unmatched. I regret taking such a long accidental hiatus. read more

Old city subs has never disappointed me. The food is always good and the staff feels like family. The restaurant is always clean and it open and airy. read more

My wife had a coupon for a free sandwich so we decided to try out Old City Subs. It was a good decision, both sandwiches were very good. I had the French Dip, my wife had corned beef. The sandwiches were big enough that neither of us finished them so we got two meals for the price of one. The service was fine, you order and pick up from the counter. I'd say if you're hungry and in the area it's worth the stop. read more

We went to this place for lunch today. We were greeted with a smiling, friendly, and welcoming staff. We had a couple of alterations to our sandwiches and the staff jumped in to advise that they can make everything the way we like We ordered a Philly and an Italian and they were both delicious. The homemade apple cinnamon bread was delicious as well. We don't live around here, otherwise we would make this place a regular. read more

very good excellent menu. the food is prepared fresh and made to orderservice is quick and professional. excellent read more

Hit the spot! The menu is varies and the price is right. I ordered online and arrived just as my order was ready. The place is immaculate and staff is very nice. read more

Oh, goodness, all these years and I missed out on the Philly Chicken Hot Sub?! This may be my new favorite. I'll preface this by saying I live about 25 minutes from Old City Subs and chose delivery service and ordered this sandwich on a whim in addition to my standard Ham & Cheese. Delivery was flawless! Warm sub was warm, cold sub, cold. The chicken though! Juicy, fresh, seasoned perfectly and the green peppers were cooked perfectly. Substituted pepper jack and highly recommend. Is it wrong that I finish the other half of the Large now? read more

Old City Subs - Philly Chicken Hot Sub from Old City Subs. - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Ooo myyy! The Italian sub was one of the best I've had! You will be pleasantly surprised.

This used to be a staple location for my family... but we just went back after a short time away, and discovered their prices have gone way up. We used to get a large Reuben for a reasonable price that would feed you for two meals. Now it's over $10 for a "large" Reuben that comes with nothing additional and isn't quite enough for a single meal. For the increased cost, we don't think it's worth the price anymore. Tasty, but not worth the money these days. read more

Don't know what had taken me so long to eat here, but wow this place is good!!! What makes this place so unique is how large the menu is. If you can think of the sub they probably have it! Being that they are a very popular place, I recommend calling in ahead of time. They tend to get very busy ! read more

Nope. In the middle of a pandemic, in a city where masks are required, nobody working here was wearing one. I've enjoyed them in the past... Subs are good, excellent location, friendly staff, but I sure won't be going back any time soon. read more

Old City Subs is excellent in all areas. The subs are delicious, customer service couldn't be better and Chow Now provides exceptional delivery. read more

Best subs in town. The staff is really nice and their sandwiches never disappoint. Highly recommend

The only place to get your subs in St. Augustine. As long as their is an Old City Subs, there will be a place for me to get an Excellent Sub. The atmosphere is very inviting with a lot of great signs on the wall to enjoy. Their Customer Service is Top Notch. The Daily Specials are the best deals you could get and their Premium Subs, that no one else makes, are to die for. They also have a Stamper Card that you can get stamped for every sandwich you buy. When you get 10 Stamps you can get a Free Medium Sandwich. read more

On a recent lunch excursion, I was in the mood to try something new... Tired of Subway and Quiznos, I was looking for a GOOD sub, and based on a few recommendations from friends, (and being surprised that this place had not been reviewed yet on Yelp) I stopped into Old City. Located on US1, near the Old Moultrie intersection, I walked into a wide open, retro looking dining area. For some reason, I was expecting a small shop, with a few tables sitting next to a large deli counter, but this place has tons of tables, and a large counter with lots of space to order. The menu is pretty impressive, a LOT of both hot and cold subs, a bunch of good looking salads and pitas, soups, and even homemade desserts! I had a really tough time deciding which sandwich I wanted to go with, but I ended up choosing the Chicken Cordon Bleu for lunch, and an Italian to go (so I could have it for dinner at work). After placing my order, I grabbed my drinks and headed to my seat. The food was delivered to my table about 3 minutes later, and it was AWESOME. The chicken was cooked just right, juicy and tender, and the ham and cheese really kicked it up. Throw in the mayo and spices, freshly cooked bread, and you've got yourself one humdinger of a good sandwich. I couldn't wait to devour the Italian for dinner that night, which was also spectacular. The meats were fresh, sliced right, and the toppings of fresh veggies, mayo, and italian dressing really made the sandwich pop. After finishing my lunch, the worker came from behind the counter to talk to me about how everything was, then picked up all the trash to take it to the trash can, even after I told him I would do it myself. Can't beat service like that in a place like this! A lot of other folks in the area must know, too, as I noticed a lot of people stopping in, and also noticed a LOT of orders being taken out and delivered (Free delivery in a 2 mile radius). They also offer up party subs and drinks for your next big get together! Overall, I loved this place. The food was spectacular, the service was amazing, and there's still about 20 different subs I want to try. I would give it five stars, except it can be a bit pricey. You're looking at about $7.00 for a large sub here, and it certainly isn't a footlong, you can definitely get more food for your money at Subway or Quiznos, however you will NOT get a better tasting hoagie or better service, that's for sure. Will definitely be back, and I recommend this place to anyone looking to grab a delicious, quick lunch or dinner. The bomb! read more

Old City Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Tried for the first time so hubbie and I ordered a sandwich and 1/2 chef salad to split. Happy with both. Everything very fresh and they don't skimp on the meat on the salad. Finished with fresh baked cookies and they were delicious. Nice, friendly staff. Will be returning. read more

Solid subs. I know an independent restaurant hates to be compared to a chain, but this place most resembles Larry's Giant Subs. Good hot subs with good portions and decent value. The best things they make are the small desserts made fresh daily. The spiced apple cake is a personal favorite. read more

Subs make by the book. Indiana Jones & Moses would have eaten here had they not been before own their time! read more

Old City Subs - Southern Style - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

My fiancé loves the sandwiches I think they're all right at best doesn't help that the staff usually is not that great and tend to be rude with really crappy manners read more

I'm a strong believer of good bread makes a great sub and beyond the ingredients, customer service is key. Old city subs has a small town feel with big town flavor. I recommend this sub shop to any and everyone. read more

I love this place. The food has always been outstanding, and I think I have ordered almost everything from the menu, and the delivery service is great!!! The always deliver quicker that expected. Great group of people!!! read more

Just wanted to say that Old City Subs were awesome during hurricane Irma. They stayed open as long as possible before the bad weather and then opened up as soon as possible afterwards. Thank you OCS for being there when we needed you and for having awesome food!!!!!! We love and appreciate you!!!!!!! read more

First time here. ... Average sub, decent amount of meat. Best to order"to go" because they serve up those orders first. Waited a bit for ours not realizing that fact read more

Awesome sandwiches and a great place to hold a lunch meeting . Friendly atmosphere !!! Local ownership! read more

Old City Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Love this place and the amazing fast and good subs! Specials daily are nice! Employees take pride in the job for sure!

Took my family to eat and believe that is the worst sub I have ever had. You are better off eating at subway.

came down to visit from Boston and had the worst chicken ceasear salad I have ever had. no romaine, no croutons, all spinach and ice berg lettuce. terrible I should of went to McDonalds. read more

Old City Subs - this is what a real chicken caeser salad looks like fools. - Sandwiches Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Great place even better people. The owner is the best there is when it comes to hospitality

Down visiting relatives, always like trying local places. Frankly, I don't trust most of these reviews. Ordered a Reuben sandwich that didn't have sauerkruat and 1K island? WTF? All I could do is laugh. The average age of the employees seemed to be about 15. They get 2 stars instead of 1 because the prices aren't too high. Its the kind of place that's probably just dandy to people who have no clue what good sandwiches are but to anyone from a major metro, don't expect to find 'city' level quality here. Its po-dunk, but not in the 'charming' way. Bush league operation. read more

I just found my new fav sandwich - their Italian Philly - so full of flavors; simply delish!! Plus no delivery charge - just please tip their delivery guy well!! read more

Love, love, love this place. After hurricane Matthew it was the only place we could find open and even though it was crazy busy, the service was fantastic. The food was great and loved all the old fashioned signs and decor. My kids loved the sign pointing the way to the bathrooms. It said Poop Deck with an arrow. The boys still get a giggle from it. Great place!! read more