We read some great reviews about this diner. Bookmarked it. Stopped in with my wife recently on a Sunday. The place was jammed but we scored a table. Very friendly, fast service. An outstanding breakfast. The best omelette I have had in a long time. Home fries, well done. A properly toasted english muffin. Great coffee with refills. So glad we stopped by. read more

Nutley Diner - Keep the toast. Give me a toasted english. - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

If I could rate this experience 0 stars, I would for obvious reasons!! We ordered a chicken finger wrap and balsamic chicken wrap and received undercooked, chewy, inedible chicken!! It was 32 dollars for two wraps that we couldn't eat, we called them to let the manager know and all she said was "thank you I'll let the chef know". If you don't want to waste money on inedible food especially chicken, I definitely do not recommend!! read more

Nutley Diner - Balsamic Wrap - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

I sampled food from here for a takeout order. The food took some time to be ready, but nothing terrible. The foods I tried are below. Breakfast Burrito - This was what I initially ordered. The burrito was packed. There was a lot going on here, but it was very good. The flour tortilla had scrambled eggs, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, and shredded pork served with home fries, salsa, and sour cream. The shredded pork to my surprise was what made this burrito what it was. It was succulent and juicy. The pork went nicely with the rest of the ingredients. The home fries were seasoned well too. Banana Pecan French Toast - The French toast was topped with bananas, pecans and apricot cinnamon sauce. The sauce was the highlight here. It had just the right amount of sweetness. Without the sauce, the toast would have been too dry and have no flavor. French Toast Napoleon - This French Toast was filled with strawberries, bananas, and whipped cream topped with whipped cream and cinnamon. It was far too dry. Lots of regular maple syrup had to be added. The fruit did appear to be fresh. The toast needed some type of sauce like the one previously mentioned. read more

Zero stars. This place was one of our family's favorites. Tonight at 8:30 on a Saturday, they told our party of 6, as well as at least 2 other parties, they were no longer sitting because they were closing soon. 9 p.m. is the closing time as per the website not 8:30. Such a shame. read more

That's a special freakin burger they make here! Wow! Angus beef only. Amazing charring perfection. Brioche bun. Nutley, NJ. Perfection. Come here and try this burger. Half pound but feels lighter... it's that good. The char is memorable. I still taste it in my mouth, actually. read more

Came here with a group of my friends for lunch and I did not enjoy the food. Service was a bit slow. I had the french onion soup and the cheese tasted fake. I also got a panini and it looked like a sandwich. Wasnt a fan... read more

Was eating here and wasn't receiving any attention from anyone and have been trying to order for 15-20mins and the place was not busy. After ordering , food quality is below average, and I don't know who the old white guy is that we had to deal with but he was VERY RUDE to us, we had parked in the diner parking area and started walking to the diner and explained to us aswell that we were parking on the wrong area and told him we were going to the diner to eat, his words were "I wasn't born yesterday I'm not stupid". Clearly as we were walking into the diner. VERY RUDE old man. read more

My boo and I just moved down the street from this diner a couple weeks ago. Last night we got drunk and woke up with a hankering for diner breakfast. We've walked past the Nutley Diner and it's always poppin! for breakfast we got a classic combo of Disco Fries (bc that's just hangover medicine), the brooklyn omelette, and the jalapeño breakfast bowl. Now this photo is after we stuffed our bellies with as much brekky goodness as we could. Sharon, our waitress, was so nice and very attentive. There's a different vibe here at the Nutley diner than there is in any other diner. Everyone looks happy to be here, and treats you like family. After moving away from our friends it's nice to feel like you're family! The food was delicious, the portions are huge and the prices are fair. Come to Nutley and visit the Diner for real family dining! read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Diner's are the best. The Nutley Diner is a great diner. The food is good, the menu is large and the service is great. You are in and out and well fed. My husband and I go here often with his father (he is a regular), I have only been for breakfast but their Taylor ham, egg and cheese sandwiches do not disappoint. read more

We frequent here often ! Love the service and food! Every time we come we leave satisfied with the service and food! The staff are awesome

My husband wanted to try this Dinner and i'm glad we did. Good Food and Quick service. Kiddless for the day and we can enjoy food with no bathroom brakes or fights. They seated us quickly and the waiter was at our table in few minutes asking for our drinks. Food also came out quickly and it was delish. Definetly will be visiting soon. read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

The Colorado omelette was very good. All and all anything I have ordered from the Nutley Diner has been prepared healthy, using less oils and salts. read more

Have been back several times, basically once a week for breakfast or lunch. Just wanted to say each and every waiter or waitress we have ever had has been terrific. Our food has never disappointed either. We have eaten here probably two dozen times since my last review and we have never had a complaint of any kind. I am leaving this second review because I think it is important to praise a good experience and share it so others give it a try. Keep it up, we will keep coming here for sure. read more

Long time customer, been going here since it was the Park Diner. The prices are just getting out of control. I ordered 2 cajun chicken sandwiches on wraps and a Malibu panini. Total cost? $62... that's right, $62 for 2 wraps and a panini. We ordered take out and their receipts aren't itemized so I contacted them telephonically to inquire about the ridiculous price... i was told there is an upcharge to turn a sandwich into a wrap (ridiculous) and the spicy mayo with our wraps was extra. Also, there was a 3% charge for using a credit card. After 30+ years of this diner I think i'm done. read more

SPOILED, GRAY EGGS: I went here with my boyfriend the other day. I got a club salad that was $15, SUPER OVERPRICED. It had cold cuts in it and some veggies. Def cost them $2 to make. The eggs in the salad were SPOILED and the yokes with GRAY. This means they had to have been out for days. When I showed the waitress, she was confused since she thought they were still ok to eat. How can you work in the food industry without knowing how to tell what spoiled/expired/rotten food looks like? I live in Nutley and have my whole life and won't be back. everything is super super overpriced and not even that good. read more

See all

Never, ever disappointed! Been coming here my whole life. (formerly Park Diner) Dinner specials are always great. Monday nights are Steak Night! $25 gets you: soup or salad, pasta vodka or stuffed mushrooms, choice of steak, usually with 2 sides (i prefer the ribeye), and dessert! This a true greek diner... get the moussaka! Or if lamb is one of the specials, get that! Or the braised short rib special! It's ALL good! read more

I do not recommend this place at all. I lived in nutley for 20 years and this was always the go to spot. Last night this was not the spot. I have been in bed and the bathroom all day. I 100% got food poisoning from the breakfast sausage. I have been throwing up all morning and recommend you go else where. Maybe they need a health inspection and a thorough cleaning in the kitchen. read more

Horrible food, group of 5 and no one liked their food. Save yourself the money and go to a restaurant on Franklin Ave like Luna.

Food was yummy service was good. Not much more I could ask for. It was pretty busy we didn't have to wait which is a plus since they had a table ready. They don't take reservations so it's up in the air if you will have to wait for not. read more

Nutley Diner - French Toast Napoleon - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

One word. Pie. You are not going to find better pie and desserts in all of Nutley. The pieces are generous and you are always left with a bit to take home (unless you are feeling extra hungry!). I often come here for dessert when I have a sweet tooth, as I'm never disappointed. Also should note that it's open 24-hours. Saying that, it's a bit nicer than most diner, as it's extremely clean and service is great. read more

Food is great, but the server did not bring our food correctly and it's not the first time. Between the hostesses and servers, they kept talking amongst themselves and looking in our direction and laughing as though we did something wrong. We (my husband and myself ) are NEVER coming back here again. read more

This place has been going slightly down hill little by little. One time they forget to bring the dressing, then the wrong dressing. The hostess (all of them) barely give you a hello, drop the menus on a table where you're gonna sit and walk away. We have been going there for years, probably 50+ times, never a hello from any of the 3 managers walking around doing barely anything. Never a "Hello" or "Thanks for coming in" from the owner who we see sitting at the small booth in front of the dining room. The salads have gotten skimpy-no more Greek olives, cheese or scallions. The overall quality of food has gone down a notch or two. The fries have to be the cheapest fries from Canada, they were nThere are a ton of other places to go dine. Gonna be taking a break from The Nutley Diner for awhile, not sure we'll be going back. Guess you have to be Italian and from Nutley before you will get acknowledged. You think the owner would stop by your table and say a simple "Thanks for coming in" Go to Nevada Diner in Bloomfield. Much nicer, both decor and attitude. read more

Diner food Is always awesome But then Nutley diner is beyond. Food is always tasty and quick. Great for late night bites read more

Nutley Diner Recently refurbished, the Nutley Diner is on the site of the old Park Diner. The renovations are a welcome change from the old, tired former diner. There is an open feeling which makes the actual seating seem more comfortable and inviting. The food was delicious and the service was wonderful. Although we would avoid the Park Diner on our visits from Florida, we will be returning here every time we are back in Jersey read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

So rarely ever go here but they had something on the menu that I've been dying for. And since my favorite diner is still closed , I decided to order from here. I ordered the open steak sandwich with American cheese. It was alright. I mean I asked for extra cheese and as you can see there is barely anything. There was also BARELY any meat. I paid over $20 for this and I honestly feel it was not worth the money. Don't think I'll be ordering from here again. read more

Nutley Diner - Open Steak Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Giving this place 5 stars for the 5 star burger I had TASTIEEEE. The disco fries were also some of the best I've had from a diner. Good soup too read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

We've been going here for several years 4-6 days a week. There's been food and order issues as to be expected. Ordered the California breakfast without bacon but upgraded to turkey sausage (extra fee). After having several bites, I realized the sausage had a freezer burn taste. So I took it off the sandwich. It was a Sunday and very busy , by the time the waitress came to the table I was almost finished. I asked if they could comp the sausage and it wasn't good and was clearly taken off the sandwich. She asked Maria and was told no. Ok, all you had to do was take $5 or whatever the up charge was off the bill. Needless to say we haven't been there in 2 months . Shame on you, Nutley Diner! We found other establishments to take our business. read more

Nutley diner been there for as long as I can remember . The staff is friendly. Food is ok. Atmosphere is good. Will return again. read more

Nutley Diner - Breakfast with family - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

This was my go-to diner, seeing how I live so close to it. It wasn't until today that I decided maybe I should start going to the Arlington or Lyndhurst diners. While I was eating my omelette, I found an entire egg shell in it. Talk about a buzz kill. read more

Nutley Diner - Omelette - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

They have plenty of outdoor seating and the tables are a good distance apart. At the "entrance" there is hand sanitizer available for guests! The service and food is the same as always; great! Came here for lunch on a Monday and it wasn't too busy. The food was so delicious!! Fries were hot and crispy. The pulled pork bbq sandwich had so much flavor and the club grilled chicken was perfection! read more

Nutley Diner - Grilled Chicken and Avocado Club Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Burger wasn't bad but the waffle fries were inconsistent. Some had a good crunch, others were soggy. The meat on the loaded nachos had an odd taste so we returned them with no issue. We never saw our waiter again after he gave us our bill and even though my son wanted to take home the rest of his quesadilla he decided to finish it. It went "down the wrong way" and I couldn't get anyone's attention for water. Finally got the doggie bag and water after finishing this review. read more

Nutley Diner - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Never been here, ordered from uber eats. what a mistake. I wasted $60.00, Ordered breakfast, eggs soggy, homefries dry and no flavor, Bland, English Muffin burnt. Like what the heck. I also order chicken tenders and ff. WOW!! horrible. Tenders where so huge, looked like a big piece of chicken breast in bread crumbs, pink inside, the fries soggy. Why not poke a hole on plastic to prevent soggy fries. N yes $60.00 on 2 meals. NEVER EVER AGAIN!!!! read more

Fried Fish Sandwich was breading with some kind of thin layer of mushy pablum. French fries were very good. Tuna fish sandwich was fresh but surprisingly lacked flavor. Coffee was good. I have only been here for breakfast. That is OK. No reason ever to return. The staff was very nice and efficient. read more

I highly recommend this place because the workers are attentive and polite, almost every thing on the menu is delicious, and the atmosphere is nice and chill so you can eat your food in peace. read more

Great food even though I only visited about twice! I enjoyed everything about this place and hope to return.

It was a nice place went there with my lady and food was good,I will definitely go there again.

Not the best diner. To be fair we are in NJ. So it's like playing bench for the Yankees. You at least are on the Yankees versus being on the Pirates. But! They are open all the time. The food is consistent. Parking is always open. And desserts are plenty. Can't go wrong for these reasons. Got time to go to an all star diner? By all means... But gotta eat at 3.00am or need parking or somewhere close but consistent? Nutley diner will hit the spot without striking out. read more

First time coming to this diner with my boyfriend and all I can say is We are looking forward to coming back here again. They give you really good size portions. We couldn't finish all the food it was so delicious we wish we had more room in our stomachs. Also forgot to take pictures of most of the food because we ate before thinking of taking pictures we were so hungryI had the Napoleon French toast and I must say it tasted amazing and not because of the fruit and whipped cream but the French toast itself was fresh and flavorful. I did ask for scrambled eggs but got over easy which was ok because it was delicious and it came with home fries, turkey bacon and toast. My boyfriend had an Mexicana omelet with chicken sausage and pancakes and he enjoyed it. When you come here make sure you are hungry The waiter was welcoming and took our orders quickly and the food arrived way sooner then expected. It was a great experience. We plan to come again sometime in the near future. read more

Nutley Diner - Napoleon French Toast - Diners Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Ordered take-out one night. The Greek wrap was okay, had grilled chicken, feta cheese, lettuce tomatoes and tahini sauce...came a little soggy. Waffle fries were delicious, as expected. Grilled crab cake appetizers were absolutely delicious! Would definitely order them again. read more

See all

Where have I been the last 2-3 years??? Corned beef hash, Belgian waffles, coffee and strawberry cheesecake.... Yes please! Breakfast and Cheesecake at Nutley diner might be our new thing! A few weekends ago we were in search for some corned beef hash and stumbled upon this diner! Once I saw my homie Neal's review, I knew we were all set and good to go! The diner is in the "busy" area of Nutley on Centre street. They have their own private parking lot and I suggest to avoid wait times go a little early or a little late around people's main dining times. The food was great! The portions were on point! The service was awesome and the price was banging! The decor is pretty cool too! You must try the strawberry cheesecake, it fluffy creamy and just enough of sweet! We can't to go back and try the burgers and disco fries! Enjoy folks... read more

See all