Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mugsy’s

    4.0 (5 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Mugsy’s Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Mugsy’s

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Grab and go sandwich shop with limited menu. However, what is available is fresh and creative.

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 5
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Matt C.
    253
    18
    720

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Steve J.
    0
    176
    95

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 2,064 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Kitchen 35

    Kitchen 35

    3.9
    (10 reviews)
    1.8 mi

    The Kitchen started up the Wednesday twofer thing again. Prices are way up from last year, as they…read moreare everywhere from Bideniflation. So for 32 bucks you each get an entree with soup or salad and desert. Still a fair price. The salad was standard, the tomato bisque was amazing. What makes a bisque a bisque? "A traditional French chef would define a bisque as being a thick, creamy soup made with shellfish and thickened by a paste made from their shells. Cooking shells? I had no idea! Julia Child was one chef to popularize lobster bisque in the United States; her recipe uses both the shells of the lobster and rice to thicken the bisque. Today's definition of bisque has expanded to include vegetable bisques, like tomato and butternut squash. The word is more related to the smooth texture of the dish and the use of cream. Most modern bisques are thickened using rice. Some cook the rice in the broth and strain it out later, using only the left-behind rice starch to thicken the soup. Others puree the rice into the soup to thicken it. Almost all bisques are finished with hot cream for a velvety texture." A little info from your uncle Steve. I got the lasagna,very good. My wife got the drunken burrata, which is a chicken cutlet in a vodka sauce over penne toped with mozarella and burrata cheese. It was outstanding. I had to look up burrata cheese. Burrata, meaning "buttery" in Italian, is a fresh cheese made from a mix of mozzarella and cream. The thin shell of the cheese is a pasta filata curd made of buffalo and/or cow's milk mozzarella, while the insides contain a soft, doughy, stringy mixture of curd and fresh cream. When you cut open a Burrata, it oozes with buttery and creamy panna containing scraps of mozzarella. The cream has a rich flavor and must be eaten immediately. So, I'm on the hunt for burrata now. The cutlet itself was thin, crispy and perfect. Almost tasted like veal. I've followed dozens of chicken parm type recipes but could never get my cutlets like this. The penne could have been more al dente. The deserts we chose ,chocalate pudding and red vellvet cake were ok. Friendly staff.

    This place closed. They reopen an amazing dinner. Great fresh food always delicious…read more I only wish they would have more gluten free food. It's now called Manasquan Diner

    Photos
    Kitchen 35
    Kitchen 35
    Kitchen 35

    See all

    Shipwreck Grill

    Shipwreck Grill

    3.9
    (345 reviews)
    1.0 mi
    $$$

    This is the first time I've ever been to Shipwreck Grill, which is crazy because I've grown up in…read morethis area. I've always heard good things, and I thought the food stood up to the reputation. The restaurant was packed on a Monday night, which was probably a good sign for what led to a delicious meal. I really enjoyed the roasted oysters topped with yummy breadcrumbs. My daughter enjoyed a sushi appetizer and wedge salad with blackened tuna that she claimed was delicious as well. Our other dinner partner enjoyed his halibut. I really loved the show-stopping, gigantic jumbo lump crab meat risotto. It was very filling, but super delicious. The food was rich and, in some ways, basic, but executed perfectly. I added some of the street corn and that really made things even better get this dish. You won't be disappointed. The atmosphere was busy, if not hectic. Our table was in the middle of the room, next to a large family with little kids. One was seven months old and the other was two. That seemed like a bit much for a dinner with these price points. It's not an inexpensive restaurant and certainly not a family-vibe Houlihan's. We had mixed feelings about the atmosphere, but I kind of thought it was cool--a really pretty building with some rustic charm.

    Service was awesome- but for my $68 ny strip steak it was overcooked and flavorless. For a Tuesday…read morenight I was hoping for a better cooking execution. I will still go back - just felt a little discouraged.

    Photos
    Dining room.
    Dining room.
    Delicious risotto-- I personally would add corn and added some street corn that we had as a side
    Delicious risotto-- I personally would add corn and added some street corn that we had as a side
    Seared Sesame Tuna

    See all

    Seared Sesame Tuna
    The Food Shack

    The Food Shack

    4.5
    (147 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $$

    Good food, attentive and friendly service . They have outdoor and indoor seating…read more There is also gift shop inside

    We had a great experience here! We got here at around 2:15pm to kick off our day at the beach. Even…read morethough the The Food Shack closes at 2:00pm, the server behind the counter was very gracious and still took our order (and the orders of some people behind us) without complaining. We were really impressed by the location. The Food shack is located right on the beach which is the perfect way to enjoy a lunch on a Summer day in Point Pleasant. They have lots of umbrellaed outdoor seating, and some benches in the sun, so there are options for everyone. They also have some indoor seating, and the inside is adorable. We ordered a swiss grilled cheese with tomato on top, and a BLT. Each item came with pickles and a bag of chips. Each item was priced reasonably, especially considering typical Jersey Shore pricing. My grilled cheese was great. The bread/cheese/tomato ratio was perfect. The cheese was gooey, and stayed gooey even as the sandwich cooled. The bread on the grilled cheese was crispy on the outside and still soft and warm on the inside. I didn't know what to expect from a small shack on the beach, especially with something as simple as a grilled cheese, but I really enjoyed it. The BLT also had a gread tomato/bacon/lettuce/mayo ratio and wasn't too greasy. Overall I will definitely be coming back!

    Photos
    Cali Bowl w cherry tomatoes and avocado over hash browns and my choice of eggs  HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
    Cali Bowl w cherry tomatoes and avocado over hash browns and my choice of eggs HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
    Quiet, peaceful time, prior to later boardwalk Patrons filling The Boards & our walking/Cycle local friends making their way down to the end
    Quiet, peaceful time, prior to later boardwalk Patrons filling The Boards & our walking/Cycle local friends making their way down to the end
    Outside

    See all

    Outside
    The Committed Pig

    The Committed Pig

    4.1
    (604 reviews)
    2.1 mi
    $$

    We were searching for a place to eat yesterday online. When I came across the committed pig. I…read morefigured why not give this place a shot. The menu looked quite interesting and what caught my attention was one of their burgers. They baked brie burger with bacon and fig preserve. Upon entering the establishment, we found it quite pleasant. The food was absolutely amazing. We all looked at each other and said we will definitely be back. The menu looked amazing as well with selections for breakfast with lemon ricotta, pancakes, and stuffed French toast which we will definitely have to give a try. The staff was on point and a tentative I give this establishment a 10 out of 10.

    We stopped by for lunch and sat upstairs on the rooftop deck, which is first come, first served…read more The restaurant is beautiful with plenty of seating and a great atmosphere. Although it wasn't very busy, service upstairs was fairly slow, and several nearby tables also seemed to be waiting a while for food or checks. For drinks, we ordered the Boardwalk Lemonade, which was sweet and refreshing, and their version of an Aperol Spritz, which had a beautiful presentation. My dad's Baked Brie Burger was delicious--the fig jam paired perfectly with it, and the waffle fries were fried to perfection. I ordered the Mr. Beautiful Burger, which tasted great at first. Unfortunately, I felt VERY sick almost immediately after eating. I can't say for certain what caused it, but since my dad didn't try my burger and felt fine after his meal, I suspect mine may not have been cooked properly. Despite that, I enjoyed the atmosphere, drinks, and overall experience. I'd definitely give this place another chance, though I'll skip the Mr. Beautiful Burger next time.

    Photos
    First Floor bar
    First Floor bar
    The Committed Pig
    Rooftop bar

    See all

    Rooftop bar
    Tommy's Tavern + Tap

    Tommy's Tavern + Tap

    3.7
    (41 reviews)
    3.3 mi

    Part One: Sunday This review is for two different visits…read morethis past week. One was for this past Sunday. We had Randi as our server and as first time visitors to this Sea Girt location, she helped us get acquainted with the menu and the restaurant as a whole. We were scouting it out for the following day to watch the Knicks Finals game. The restaurant is loaded with screens! They have larger screens on the wall and smaller ones all next to each other above the bar. And they pipe in the game sound once the game starts! So all boxes were checked off for us. We also had a delicious lunch. I had the Apple Salad with grilled chicken. It was fresh as could be, huge and so delicious. One of the best salads I have had in a long time. My husband was just as happy with his Caesar Salad and hamburger patty. He raved about the hamburger meat and we both ate every morsel of our meal. A great location as we just had left the beach and were starving! Randi's service was top notch and she is super nice and friendly. Matt, the Manager also stopped by to check on us and make sure everything was OK, which was great to see. Part Two: Monday The next day, we watched game 3 of the NBA Finals at Tommy's. Now we're already starting to become regulars! We had Julian as our server. Another great Tommy's employee! Turns out he went to high school with our son! Small world. It was our first time watching a game at the restaurant. We had a huge booth and plenty of room. It was drink special night on Monday, so we got 1/2 price specialty cocktails, which was nice. We ordered bar food this time - - wings, brussel sprouts, Caesar salad and margarita pizza, all of which were very good. Very impressed with the wings, that are baked and come with onions and peppers on top. Julian kept our glasses and bellies filled and, even though the Knicks lost, we had an amazing time at Tommy's for the game. Thank you Randi, Julian & Matt for a great week at Tommy's. We will be back soon.

    This was suggested to me as a great place to have lunch with family when I was in town recently…read more This establishment is a lot bigger on the inside than you would think plenty of seating areas, TVs and a good sized bar area. The servers were very helpful and friendly, they guided me through all my questions about menu choices. The food was amazing, there was nothing that we ordered that we all didn't love from the Brussels sprout appetizer to a nicely done Cubano sandwich. I understand why it's a local favorite.

    Photos
    Bar
    Bar
    Tommy's Tavern + Tap
    The tavern roll

    See all

    The tavern roll

    Mugsy’s - tradamerican - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...