5 star for the food and staff, just wish the place was larger and cooler. But it was worth it. We've been there twice. Hubby gets eggs Benedict and I got eggs Benedict with sausage (both delicious! I took half mine home for a second meal). This latest time, I got one of the specials which was strawberry French toast! Oh my!! Soooo good! Again, I took half home and thoroughly enjoyed it a second time. Not badly priced- these dishes were about $15 (and I got a side of meat included with it). [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is very clean and neat, just small.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Staff were really friendly and attentive. We'll go again! read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Strawberry French Toast - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

About 7 minute drive from the Jenkinson's Boardwalk and Beach in Point Pleasant. Opens at 7am! Greeted with smiles! Noticed sign The Cookie Lady's Cafe is under new management! Head Chef was greeting customers. Hot latte and eggs Benedict! Were great! I like my poached eggs well done- soft! Thank you just perfect for me! Fresh squeezed orange juice to go! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Good vibes![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Wishing you much success! read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]I just found the cutest and coziest restaurant in Point Pleasant![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The Cookie Lady Cafe is the place to be for homey vibes and delicious food![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] And if you're looking for something fun to do, every Wednesday night they open up their doors with a special menu to have trivia night hosted by Quizzaholics! My boyfriend and I had such a great time getting competitive and investing ourselves through each round to answer each question. There's awesome prizes for the winners! Their pancakes were like a a warm hug on a plate. They were thin and golden and lightly buttered with the right hint of sweetness. We added chocolate chips to ours and they added the cutest little powdered sugar flower design on them. The cheesesteak was monstrous in size. The gooey cheese and tender meat made this a great savory meal. The wings were sauced to perfection! Each wing had tons of meat and made the perfect appetizer. The hot honey chicken sandwich was a solid choice. The coleslaw on the sandwich really complimented the kick from the hot honey! Service was so friendly and attentive. It was nice trying a bit of breakfast and lunch. I definitely want to come back during their breakfast hours! read more

See all

I really wanted to like this place. It wasn't quite what I expected. It's on the corner at a traffic light, you have to be careful or you will you miss it. The door is a screen door, with a solid wooden door behind it to get in. It's kind of rustic, a small dining area with a long counter. On Sunday Dec 21st I met my ex here for a late breakfast, early lunch around noon. It was fairly busy, but I was able to sit down immediately. The staff seemed very nice, very kind. I asked the waitress what she recommended. I went with her recommendation of a build your own omelette turned into a quesadilla. She said it would be very filling. It came with diced breakfast potatoes which were decent, served very hot, the way I like it. Unfortunately they had no sour cream to go with a quesadilla, not a big deal. The problem with this dish was there was very little sausage and almost no cheese. A quesadilla should be real cheesy to hold it together that would have kept all the egg from falling out. It wasn't very filling. I had to use a lot of ketchup as glue, it kind made things worse. My ex had an avocado toast with egg and topped with greens and she chose garlic aïoli dressing. She seemed to like it. The other diners seemed happy with their meals. I saw a lot of cute beignets and breakfast bowls, and delicious looking toast. The coffee was cold, and not to my liking. The waitress did heat it up for me in the microwave, but I did not get a refill. If I'm ever in the area again or passing by at the right time, I might give it another shot and try something different on the menu. read more

See all

Used to rave about this place. New owners. New menu. Ice cold potatoes and toast. Cheese doesn't melt. Not worth the ride anymore.

Nice menu with some great specials. Everything we ordered was very good - the pork roll fries were perfectly cooked. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Friendly and helpful waitstaff, and it's a cute little place too[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Came here for the first time today and it was soo good! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Such a cute place, really great service, and great food especially for the price.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Will definitely be coming back!! read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Omelette with mushrooms, spinach & ham, pancakes and the Mega Meal - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Was one of the best breakfast's that I've had in a long time. [[HIGHLIGHT]]very cute ambiance and the staff was super pleasant![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Got the Greek omelette with a short stack of pancakes on the side. Might be the best pancakes in NJ. Above all the bee sting bacon side was to die for. Would take anyone her for breakfast any day! read more

Delicious food, great service and [[HIGHLIGHT]]super friendly atmosphere[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Felt like going for breakfast over a friend's house![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Easy to find, decent parking. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Went around 11:30 for brunch and found it to be semi-busy.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] My husband loved his stacked French toast with a side of honey bacon, and I almost fell off the bench when I received 4 HUGE fried chicken fillets over a Belgium waffle, dressed with hot honey. It was delicious, and I shared a generous amount of the chicken! The young man manning the front end was incredibly busy the entire time we were there, but remained polite and attentive. The chef? Well, she gets a chef's kiss from us. The food was perfect! read more

This was our first visit to the Cookie Lady, and we will certainly be back. Very cute café. We were greeted with a warm and friendly staff. Service was fast and pleasant. My husband enjoyed his scrambled eggs, soft, just the way he ordered it. His side of bacon was a meal in itself. The portions were generous, and the prices were very reasonable.​ read more

I've visited the Cookie Lady for breakfast many times over the last 5 years. Admittedly, I'm only in the Point Pleasant area on summer weekends. I visited today for brunch and suspect it has changed ownership. Different staff and different (not improved) quality of food and service. I ordered eggs Benedict and asked to start with a fruit salad. The eggs and fruit were served together and I didn't get home fries. The eggs weren't so much poached as they were hard-boiled and were hit with a drop of hollandaise sauce - literally. The primary server also seemed largely disinterested. Don't believe I'll be visiting again. read more

Ordered breakfast for me and my 6 year old granddaughter. When the bill arrived it seemed high so I checked the items on the bill. EVERY item was a few dollars higher than stated on the menu. When I questioned the waitress she said it was stated on the menu that they reserve the right to raise prices (I did not see it) I understand that prices have gone up but this is just BAD business! I will NOT be back. read more

Lovely outdoor and brunch spot! Excellent cappuccino and food. Service was a little slow but it was busy. No trouble walking in over the holiday day weekend. read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Crab Cake Benedict - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Nice breakfast this morning for my daughter's birthday. Sat outdoors which was very pleasant. Good selection of items on the menu. My daughter had short stack of pancakes which were thin not overpowering like some hotcakes. I had the Midwest scramble which is like an open faced omelet. Always a fine breakfast. read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Entrance - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

See all

Delicious! Fun, cute, great little place for a nice experience and excellent food and service! read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Banana Split French Toast - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Discovered The Cookie Lady on Easter Sunday. Adorable little place. Super friendly staff and delicious breakfast! Will be back.

We love it here. Food is always fresh and on point. The service is always great. Can't go wrong on anything you order. We have tried almost every type of offering over the past couple years. Never had a bad bite Wish they stayed open a bit later so we can come for dinner! read more

Highly recommend Such a warm and friendly staff. The outside seating was perfect. Heard they have live music on Sundays Fresh squeezed orange juice was amazing as well as the blueberry pancakes. We will definitely be back! read more

Best place for breakfast in point. Got the fresh squeezed oj, delicious with pulp. Food and service were top notch. Will be back for sure. read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Pancakes with fresh strawberries, blueberries, and bananas - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

See all

Okay my bad indeed! I've been going to the Cookie Lady now for six years at least weekly and sometimes twice a week for breakfast. I have taken it for granted for sure. Cute little ambience including an outside grotto in the summer provided by Christine the owner. Sorta reminds you of a fifties dinner on the inside. If you sit outside be sure to say hello to Butter Nuts the resident feline, he's a ginger boy. Now for the grub - very decent eggs, omelets, scramblers and what not but my favorite is their link sausage, one of the very best around and their buttermilk pancakes, which can be had with real maple syrup. BTW always fresh squeezed OJ on hand if you so desire and of course a decent bottomless cup of Joe. Best part of the deal - You can't spend more that $15 bucks for two before tip if you try. Forget those many high priced joints around that now cost an arm and leg just for a simple breakfast meal. Just a nice place to go to there at Cookie Lady and you can take that to the bank. read more

See all

Have family that just recently moved to the area and they suggested we try The Cookie Lady's Cafe for breakfast on a recent visit. The outdoor seating area is so quaint! My daughter said it reminded her of Butterbeans Cafe (a show on Nickelodeon...definitely a win in our book!). The food was very good. Their bacon was crispy and didn't have a lot of fat. They also gave you a fair amount...enough that I was willing to share a piece with my daughter. We ordered the kids pancake for her with fresh strawberries. They are baked into the batter. We would have preferred them on top. Now we know for next time. Prices are reasonable. Three of us had breakfast, two coffees, a fresh OJ and a kids apple juice came to $35 before tip. We will be going back next time we are down in Point Pleasant! read more

great food great people! i would recommend this to family and friends. my breakfast was excellent and would fed 2. keep up the great work. read more

Obsessed. The Cookie Lady is the cutest little breakfast/lunch spot. It only has 7 tables and a small countertop area to sit, so I imagine it may be tough to get a spot especially on the weekend, but the smaller space added to the charm. It's the kinda place where you walk in and everyone there looks up and smiles. Can we get more of that in this world? The food was also delicious...we had the fried chicken & waffle benedict and pumpkin pancakes. I'm fairly certain that everything on the menu would be just as good. I cannot wait to go back! read more

Best breakfast deal in the area. I've driven past here literally hundreds of times and never thought to stop in, figuring it was a cookie shop. I just recently discovered that it's really a breakfast /lunch place. This is the type of great little hole-in-the-wall that "the locals go". It is unpretentiously hip, in the way that true nerds are. When you walk in, it is as if you've stepped back in time to a "50s" diner, complete with round counter stools (several of which have been amateurishly reupholstered) and a window air-conditioner. They are really not trying to be "retro", as, for example, that regrettable chain Johnny Rockets is. Rather, it appears that the Cookie Lady just never saw the value in spending money to re-do a perfectly functional interior. Of course, the wheel had turned full-circle several years ago. "Old" is now "retro" and considered "chic". The food here pretty basic fare, solid, fresh, and well executed.. As evidence of their commitment to quality, you'll find *REAL maple syrup* (for a whopping 75¢ extra) available, as well as fresh squeezed orange juice for example. What you're not going to find here are things like acai bowls, wheatgrass juice or cauliflower pancakes. Like the decor, the food is reminiscent of the heyday of the great American diners. There is virtually nothing on the menu that wouldn't have been recognized in the 1950s. I've had two meals here so far, a Double Decker Club Sandwich and Eggs Benedict. Neither dish deviated one iota from their classic versions. The Club was fresh turkey, bacon, lettuce and tomato, with mayo on two levels between three slices of white toast, served some very good coleslaw. That's it! If I order a club sandwich, that's exactly what I want, not the latest brain fart from a short order cook. Ditto for the Eggs Benedict. Poached eggs and Canadian bacon on an English muffin, covered with homemade Hollindaise sauce, served with home fries. Keeping it simple. I did have two issues however. The Hollindaise could have had more lemon juice and it wasn't completely emulsified. In addition the home fries were luke warm. Other than that, it was a solid dish. Classics, whether it's music, literature, or food, are classic for a reason, they're timeless. They'll be listening to the Beatles, reading A Tale of Two Cities, and eating Eggs Benedict a hundred years from now. Granted, the food doesn't have the panache of the Buttered Biscuit in Belmar. On the other hand, breakfast here won't cost you almost as much as a dinner. As I stated this is the best deal in the area.The prices are also apparently retro. Good solid food at a very fair price. In fact, I can't really see spending much over $10 per person, for breakfast or lunch, even if you go full tilt. read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Cookie Lady's Cafe inside. Did I just step through a time warp? - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

See all

Food was good but the wait for our food was ridiculous. Almost an hour and thirty minutes for our food. we were a large group but the wait was out of control. The waitress did thank us for our patience but can you throw in the coffee at least? and more thing. the bathroom was not well maintained at all. There was a towel on the floor to prevent the toilet from leaking. This is not the first time I had to wait a long time for my food. read more

This was the first time trying this quaint place. The service was very friendly and helpful with making the tough selection between delicious sounding items from the menu. We definitely weren't disappointed with our selections! I had Texan Wrap with home fries. The wrap was filled with flavor and the home fries had the perfect amount of crispness. I can foresee plenty of visits here in my future! read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - The Texan Wrap - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Barely a got any food whatsoever, the biscuits were burnt to a crisp, and may I also add is there a gravy shortage in that place, I got a teaspoon on my biscuits. The home fries were probably the worst I've ever had, no seasoning no onions no peppers no nothing, just greasy potatoes that were deep fried. Genuinely disappointed after going for my first time and people saying this was good food. read more

Order was wrong. They did not give me the items I ordered. I specifically ordered no banana as I am allergic and the order came w banana. Another meal came as a different dish. Food was burned. Awful experience. Will never come back again. Not worth the price. My family who had the French toast has been sick all day since breakfast. The one who didn't have the French toast is fine. read more

Very good home cooking breakfast! Fast service and not expensive!! Quaint atmosphere, Very country like! read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Me and my boyfriend have been looking for a place to eat and call THE place and this is the winner. The food was phenomenal with a care to every ingredient so flavorful and delicious. Music was perfect it's small quiet welcoming and the workers are fast. Food was out 15 minutes not even from putting it in. And every last bite was savored plates were cleaned from the food it was that good. 10/10 will be coming back again always. read more

Extremely good food, fast service, and nice management. I ordered by Uber eats and there was a problem with the app where it was overcharging me and when I received my delivery they put the refunded amount in cash because the system wouldn't let them refund it over the app. so sweet and kind. They really went the extra mile to provide great customer service :) thank you! read more

Everything you want in a cute little breakfast eatery. Almond milk for your coffee. Quality food and very nice service! Todays lunch special Beer Batter fish n chips... might have to come back same day! read more

So cute! The owner asked where we were from and thanked us for coming! Crab cake Benedict was awesome! Truffle fries did not disappoint! The mega meal stood up to its name! read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Called in an order for pickup and got the stuffed French toast with a side of bacon as well as a full stack of chocolate chip pancakes. The stuffed French toast was cinnamon raisin bread with a cream cheese and walnut filling. It was very good! Not to mention the bacon was extra crispy. My boyfriend also enjoyed his pancakes, which was a large portion for the price we paid. All in all I would definitely return here, but I think the food would be better if I ate in the restaurant. read more

Outstanding cafe.. friendly, cozy atmosphere.. outstanding service, extensive menu but not overwhelming and the food was excellent. Reasonably price.. worth the trip ! read more

Thanks to Yelp reviews I found this place & had a wonderful breakfast this morning with my daughter. We noted a beautiful outdoor area to eat but with the blistering heatwave we're experiencing I opted for indoors. Note to self, return when it's not so blasted hot & eat outside! When we walked in the place was full. We were literally greeted by the entire staff with a "Good Morning", WOW! Don't get that often! I knew I was going to like this place. We were told by the owner (presumably) there would be about a 15 minute wait. Ok by us as we had all day. In the interim she was very personable & welcoming. We were seated in just about that time frame. A very personable waitress promptly came to our table & told us of the specials for the day, one of which was the Crabby Benny (please take no offense) which was crab cake eggs benedict. I opted for a glass of fresh squeezed orange juice as well. My meal came with a side of hash browns & I thoroughly enjoyed it. My daughter opted for the choc chip pancakes w a side of home fries which she enjoyed as well. This was a nearly flawless breakfast. The only negatives I have are, 1) my orange juice came over ice. I don't think I've ever had orange juice served over ice before so I never thought to tell our waitress to skip the ice. To me, that just dilutes the fresh squeezed orange juice. I'm sure I could have sent it back but opted to just suck it up. 2nd, some of the home fries were sliced so thin they were a bit hard to chew. 3rd, a serrated knife would have made the english muffin easier to cut. It was a bit of a struggle with a butter knife. These are pretty minor issues that in no way would keep me from returning. This place is a gem & I plam on returning. read more

The Cookie Lady's Cafe - Great little place! - New American Near Me - Point Pleasant, New Jersey

Cute little establishment! Coffee/tea comes with any breakfast which is always a plus. During the warmer months there is outdoor seating, which is nice because the inside can be a little cramped depending what time you come! Servers are friendly, food is delicious. Very good pricing for a place so close to the beach! read more

See all

After reading the reviews, my sweetie went for take out. It was so-so. My pork roll sandwich (a Jersey thing) was not what I had in mind- and that could have been the fault of the one reading the note I wrote to the waiter...ahem. My idea of the perfect pork roll breakfast sandwich is a grilled hard roll with pork roll (aka Taylor's Ham) with a fried egg and some melted American cheese. What was brought back only had pork roll and catsup (ick). Be warned. Be explicit, especially if the middleman is not originally from New Jersey! read more

Staying at a hotel in Point Pleasant and saw this place along the way. I called in my order, arrived about 15 minutes later and drove back to the hotel. The food was decent, not much to mess up as we ordered an egg scramble platter and pancakes and an iced coffee. Got back to my hotel and noticed there was no coffee, no utensils, no napkins, no ketchup, anything. By the time I was able to go find the things I needed locally the food was ice cold with no way to heat it. It's my fault partly for not checking the bag but maybe a little more attention to detail from the restaurant would have helped. Still annoyed that I had no coffee and tipped $7 for a phone order. read more