Our family of 10 had dinner last night at the Polaris location and Meickialle, our server, was fantastic. She was attentive, answered questions and helped clean up a water spill (my fault) and she made our visit so very enjoyable. read more

The atmosphere was fun. Service was wonderful. And everything that we've ordered was perfectly made and delicious. read more

See all

We don't eat here often but, when we do its scrumptious. Clean, friendly staff, no wait to be seated. Also portion sizes are generally large. However I was extremely disappointed with the calamari which explains why I don't visit often as that is one of my favorite appetizers. And I wish a salad was offered with the entrée like most Italian restaurants. read more

See all

Ibrahim is the best server I've ever had. He truly cares about his tables on a personal level and is very attentive to every need. He talked about what occasion brings my mom into town and labeled her left overs "Mom". He tastefully embodies why I enjoy coming to Marcella's. Hats off Ibrahim (EB). read more

See all

The food was 50/50. My daughter was looking for gluten free pasta and was more than pleased. This was first time eating here and we traveled 2 and half hours for one of the worst server experiences. We were celebrating my daughter's birthday and it was so hard to get a word in or get her attention. This server ruined the experience and we will not be back. read more

Came for a bookclub get together. Was the first to arrive. Simply inquired if there was a room/etc for the party. I wasn't the one who made the reservation. Hostess rudely informed me that "You are the first to arrive. It's not available till 6:30pm. It's 6:02pm now". Girl! I can read a clock. Just KINDLY say I can wait at the bar if I like. You have one flipping chance to make an impression. You did well. Too bad they don't have 1/2 a star read more

My wife and I made our first visit to Marcella's in June of 2024. The food was outstanding. We had Chicken Parmesan, Tortellini, Roasted Garlic Bread, Caesar Salad, and Chocolate Almond Cake. The prices were as expected: not cheap, but not outrageous. Because it was celebrating our anniversary, they comped our dessert. OUR SERVER, Mika, WAS AMAZING! She was beyond amazing. She was kind, friendly, accommodating, effective, and checked on us periodically. Very impressed by her. Mika is a jewel. Thank uy Also, I took the time to chat with the manager on duty (Christian) to compliment our server. He was kind and nice to talk to. read more

Great food, atmosphere and waitress. We love coming to this location even if it's over an hour drive. Our family had six different dishes and every one of them was top notch. Carafe of Red sangria was amazing. Can't wait to come back. read more

Disappointing for a Cameron's restaurant. Service was great, server connected with the table, food was just ok. read more

I came here with my friends on Thursday at around 1PM. The restaurant was nice and clean with great vibes. It wasn't busy and we got a table right away. My friends and I were greeted immediately with a super nice waitress. Unfortunately cannot remember her name but she had really cool and fun jewelry. We had complimentary bread at all times. I ordered the lunch combo with half chicken parm panini and tomato basil soup. It was 12.99 for this combo. The panini was delicious, the bread was crispy and the chicken parm was delicious, juicy, and crispy with great flavors. The tomato basil soup was very very flavorful and comes in a fun container. With the complimentary bread the soup was perfect. It was delicious worth it! The "you pick 2" combo from Panera is even more expensive than this! I would definitely come back! read more

Marcella's - Lunch Combos - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Marcella's have the BEST meatball! Literally melts in your mouth! One of my favorite happy hours! Monday through Friday 4PM-6PM. Half off small plates, pizza, & sandwiches. Cocktails & selected house spirits $5. Half off selected wines up $9 and beers $3/$3.50. Service is always great! I will continue to come back for their happy hour. Not pictured but also amazing, their linguine and clams! Chef's kiss! read more

Marcella's - Calamari, Arancini, & Braised Veal Meatball - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

My mom and I visited Marcella's today and had an awesome lunch!!!! We had Colin as our server and he was an absolute ray of sunshine, and made my mom's birthday lunch wonderful. He took great care of us, and went above and beyond to provide us with everything we could possibly need. Both of our food was awesome and I highly recommend the spaghetti and meatball!! read more

Marcella's - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Marcella's is amazing for date night, family affairs & anything nice/intimate really. I love the location..obviously super convenient right by the mall. The staff is a bit wonky. But the food is awesome, I would love to check out the other location!! I got a bottle of the Sauv, of course. I got an app with a salad. It clears out kinda early here, so book your reservations early. You feel almost pushed out by closing time. read more

My boyfriend and I came to celebrate our 1 year anniversary! This is where we went on our first date! When we first arrived, I felt like the vibe was off like the hostesses were not super friendly like just okay so my expectations were low. We get sat and our server was immediately attentive and asked us if we were there for a special occasion. I told her we were celebrating our one year and she was so happy for us. She ended up bringing us a happy anniversary card which was so sweet and thoughtful. Everything we ordered was great and delicious but the real star was our server, Ali Henderson! I'm not sure if I've ever had a nicer server before. She was awesome! read more

See all

Tyler was an awesome waiter he was super informed of the menu, everyone made my wife feel so welcomed for her birthday with the card, desert, and just saying happy birthday. The food was outstanding as always along with the drinks always hitting the spot. Overall just another great experience here! read more

Marcella's restaurant is one of my favorites. Their Shrimp risotto is amazing and one of my guilty pleasures. I have eaten there several times. I love eating outside in the summer, they have an amazing patio. Their Italian food is second to none. I can't wait to go back. read more

Marcellas is a great restaurant to take the family to. I always get great service and fantastic food at this place. The atmosphere is lively and well decorated. Pictured is the chicken Marsala with extra vegetables, lasagna and the spicy Italian sausage. All three of these dishes are amazing. read more

See all

I appreciated that the server let us know from the beginning that the food was coming out a little slow, because it was Mother's day and it was jammed packed. The waitress was very attentive to our table and made sure we were doing fine. It was a long wait, but our food came out hot and it was amazing. I appreciate that they were honest and everything was delicious! read more

Great experience. All the food was delicious. Penne alla vodka, meatball, calamari hit the spot. Nice holiday decorations. Good wine and service read more

Marcella's - Pasta Your Way. Meatball, arribiatta , fettuccine - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We had a group of 8 and had the best service! Appetizers: Calamari (very good), and veal meatball (one large meatball with lots of flavor). Meals: Salmon with potatoes (good but it was a little greasy), tenderloin (very good), and chicken Parmesan (very tasty and nice size). Desserts: Cannoli (delicious) read more

I hate to leave a bad review...but this was ridiculous. We waited an hour for our pick up order (which gets scheduled for a certain time!). When it finally came out, there was zero acknowledgment of the wait time. Just "here ya go". The food was all cold so we raised a concern. The manager half heartedly offered to remake the food, but again, no apology or anything. We literally watched two tables get seated, eat their meal, and leave in the time we were waiting. The remade food took another 30 min, was still not warm, and honestly, I'm not convinced it was actually remade. The food ultimately was pretty good (pasta was pretty salty) but again, everything was cold. This was an extremely disappointing experience. read more

Marcella's on high is so much better it's hard to believe it's the same restaurant. It's loud in there and the food wasn't nearly as good as the other location. Service was fine read more

Super fun. Date night is Friday night for us and we rotate to diff restaurants. Garlic Bread with cheese. Cocktails. Fettuccine with one HUGE meatball and a lasagna was just delightful. So good! Our service was spectacular. Neil was awesome. Very friendly and very personable. He was efficient on point with timing and spacing out our meal. Marcella's is very COVID conscience. They are mindful they are professional and it was a really good night out. I had been to Marcella's for lunch several times as my office is located up the street (pre Covid) and now, it's a nice option to consider for dinner and drinks. So impressed. Lasagna pic...we smashed it. So good! read more

Marcella's - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

UPDATE - Back for another great dinner. Sat outside on the bistro and enjoyed the mild temperature of the day. We ordered the Crispy Chicken Caesar and the Penne alla Vodka. That last one was new to us. Both excellent. The baby portobellos make this very hardy dish. read more

See all

We come here every year for Valentine's Day and just came for our anniversary. Our server Ali was super sweet- wrote us a card and offered us a free dessert to take home, which even had a chocolate disc that said "Happy Anniversary" on it. Our service here has always been exceptional, and Ali was very attentive and kind to us. The food was delicious- our favorites are the calamari, which is always so delicate, and the garlic bruschetta. This place is a must-stop: just make sure to get a reservation especially during the weekend, as they're always busy! read more

See all

I really enjoyed our experience and food tonight at Marcella's. We were celebrating our 30th wedding anniversary. The service was great. Our server Vanessa was very attentive and friendly. When she heard it was our anniversary she decorated a card and they gave us dessert for free. Now, the food. We had the arrancini appetizer and it was delicious. My husband had the sausage pizza and I had the linguini with clams. The serving sizes were good and this was the best linguini with clams I have had. The dessert was a cherry crostata with honey vanilla gelato. Everything was great. read more

See all

Food was excellent. Love the ravioli with pancetta and cabbage and the Italian Wedding Soup. I keep wanting to try new things but I come back to this dish. Service was great. I enjoy sitting at the bar when I'm going solo for lunch. read more

Delicious food. Nice low lighting atmosphere. Will definitely return here again soon. read more

See all

Loveee their outdoor patio, it's such a nice vibe on a Sunday afternoon with the sun out and a little breeze. I would definitely recommend the cheesy bread but honestly I wasn't that thrilled about anything else. Our calamari was undercooked which as you can imagine is a bit like chewing rubber. The salmon and chicken parmigiana were just okay, they both lacked actual seasoning and really just tasted like salt and butter. The service was a bit slow but as it was Father's Day I wasn't too bothered by that. read more

See all

Great dinner spot with friends for my birthday. Marcellas has a diverse menu of Italian food and can accommodate many food restrictions. Happy hour is only in the bar area. They have a nice outdoor patio. read more

Marcella's - Chicken Marsala - GF - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Marcella's at polaris is a must try, here is why Fresh italian chef level dishes and gives you this authentic feel in the food(now please dont debate that if i know my italian really well, but i can distinguish basic v/s something different). I liked how the overall inside is of this restaurant, it is not filled with these booths but like middle of the floor plan tables. And it feels very family-ish at the same time you are sitting in this fine dine private spot. It is a mix of both. I am definitely adding this to my list of "no search no thinking of an italian place" when i crave for one. read more

See all

Their Food is always good! However if you order online for carry out you may run into a problem. The last time I ordered online, they totally did not check their system to see there was an order. When I go to the restaurant to pick up my order at the time they said it would be ready they totally had no idea what I was talking about at the front desk. They went back to the kitchen to discuss it with the staff and then came back and told me it would be ready in a couple of minutes as they were getting it ready. 2 minutes turned into a 20 minute wait. They apologized and it was only after I asked to speak with the manager about it, that he felt compelled to give me a $15 gift card. I love Marcella's good, the customer service I'm still on the fence about. But I plan to visit again in the future as long as they can keep up with their orders. read more

I have been here a twice, and have had a great meal each time. This is the type of restaurant were you can go on an intimate date or as a family meal; multifaceted. I am not a huge Italian food person (I actually like Olive Garden ), but did enjoy my meals - even when being lower carb. I have dined on creamy tomato basil soup, Marcella's chopped salad, caprese, and Sunday salad (which is served with a HUGE meatball). I am not a fan of veal, so the meatball was my least favorite of the chosen meals, but my husband really liked it. My favorite was the tomato soup followed by the chopped salad. The soup was a beautiful balance of tomatoes, cream, while not being too acidic; the basil drizzle is the perfect topper. I would stay away from the caprese; while it was good, the size doesn't match the price - and there's nothing that sets it apart from what I can make at home. read more

I was expecting a Cameron Mitchell's experience and felt it was on par with Olive Garden which we do not frequent. So no we won't be back. The service was fine, the calamari tasted okay but the ratio of actual calamari to peppers and zucchini was basically 10% calamari. The arancini was just okay as well. My wife liked her potato pizza which should be described as potato chip pizza. Son liked his chicken fingers and my daughter's filet mignon was nothing to write home about. I had the eggplant parm and it was okay, again nothing special. Most disappointing though was we used a gift card which I would have much rather used at a nicer Cameron Mitchell's restaurant. We were also celebrating my wife's bday and they kindly offered us free dessert, but based on the menu we passed. Not sure I can ever say we've done that before. Lol. When we want good Italian we will continue to get it from Moretti's on Sawmill Rd. read more

Lasagne all around because of this guy's claims that Marcella's has THE BEST lasagne in the world. He was videotaped in Milan, Italy making this claim. And yes, the sausage lasagne was delish. Fabulous cocktails during happy hour ( half price) and a smooth affogato for dessert. We drove down from Cleveland to meet my college roommate and it was worth the trip! We'll be back when in Columbus. read more

Marcella's - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Wonderful service from Jared! Very gluten free friendly options, from the bread through the pastas. Everything is made fresh in house and it shows. Loved the pecorino cheese with flatbread, honey, and apple appetizer. My penne alla vodka was al dente and very flavorful with mushrooms, tomatoes, chili flakes, and parmesan cheese. A touch salty but not offensive. Very filling and satisfying. Plus, my nephew adored his spaghetti and meatball. Reasonably priced all around. Nice, lively ambiance. read more

See all

Marcella's is amazing with service, food quality and ambience. Make sure this is a must stop while in Columbus.

Really good Italian food and very popular spot. Assuming there were several holiday parties going on, there were not many extra seats available. Service was a little slow but we were with a larger party so we expected a few delays plus everywhere we go nowadays has delays. I ordered the burrata app and it was awesome. It comes with bread and a side of marinara/ tomatoes which I liked as much as the burrata. I don't know many places where you can order burrata so this was a nice surprise. For my entre I ordered the eggplant parmesan. It was cooked perfectly and comes with a side of spaghetti with sauce. The noodles and sauce were hearty and flavorful I couldn't stop enjoying them. I was with a party of seven and I heard no complaints. A couple of folks with my party enjoyed some of the craft cocktails and could not stop talking about how well they were made. The bartender were obviously on point. read more

Stopped in for dinner recently and was not disappointed, but not impressed either. Maybe it's because I didn't order pasta. Since I'm cutting back on carbs, I ordered the chicken giardiniera. $17.99 for a chicken breast with a few veggies sprinkled on top. My mom ordered the risotto on special and found it to be gummy. I do like the atmosphere, though, so I'd come back but stick to more simple pasta dishes. read more

Marcella's - Chicken giardiniera. Meh - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Service provided by Jodenya was absolutely top notch! Best server I've had in a long time ! Food was delicious and the patio was beautiful! Can't wait to go back ! read more