It's not the original but it's still pretty good. The service is alittle slow. Our server did have two big parties though. The food is good. The butter is the classic herb butter that have always had. The chicken parm was good. My carbonara was delicious. The cocktail I had was really good. It was some kiwi strawberry mule. Yum. We will continue to go. read more

See all

Knowing this was a chain, I was expecting something along the lines of Olive Garden, but honestly Olive Garden is better. Everyone working there was really kind and helpful, I must give them credit. As for the food, everything was kind of bland. We all thought the tomato sauce was extremely too sweet. Portions are huge. Prices are cheap. The whole restaurant felt dead. No real ambiance, just a big room. If there's an Olive Garden nearby, go there instead. read more

See all

Three of us ordered chicken parm dinners and three salads. One salad was supposed to be without onions, but with ranch. One normal salad with ranch and one normal salad with Italian. All salads came with onions. Two came with Italian. Halfway through our salads the waitress brought our no-onion salad. Then another waitress showed up with our three "double-down" chicken parm entrees that we did not order. The "double-down" entrees are $3 a piece more. We sent them back, just for our waitress to bring them back and said "Sorry she's new." We questioned the double-down cost and we were told it would be the same price as the regular entree. We got our bill and before the price was adjusted we were charged $66 for the three entrees plus two sodas. The waitress told us they'd keep the entrees on the check and take the drinks off to make up the difference. Instead, two drinks remained + the entrees. Again we had to ask for the adjustment. We didn't order the "double-down" chicken parm entrees and we weren't going to pay for them. Finally the bill was adjusted when the drinks were all removed to account for the extra $9 on the bill. When we were wrapping up our dinner, the table next to us also got a chicken parm entree and when it arrived they also questioned the "double-down" portion. This place is clearly trying to pull one over on people! You can't tell me this is an isolated 'accident' either. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Do not recommend. The food is barely edible. The cheese garlic bread was definitely warmed in the microwave- so soggy. Meatballs were hard. Mozzarella fritta was also soggy- not crispy. Not impressed. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Garlic Cheese Bread (soggy) - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

What a great birthday celebration time! The staff had an extremely large group during the same time as our 12 size group and they were great. Our waitress and waiters were all on point and made sure we had a great experience. While we miss the old location the food was still amazing and the new location has some great views of the commons. read more

See all

Love the ambiance here! If you're expecting the old, crowded warehouse feel, this isn't it. What you'll find is a modern space with echo's to the past. The Spaghetti Warehouse offers a new experience while showcasing some nostalgia. If you had never been to the old location, then take a look around and enjoy all the little details. Honestly, the food was even better than I remembered from the Original W. Board location. I had the Chicken Parmigiana, and my partner ordered the Spaghetti Warehouse Carbonara with added chicken. We also shared the Sicilian Sampler, which was delicious. For dessert, we split the Red Velvet Cake (who wouldn't t love this)! We don't visit often, but always experience good food & service, and have great evenings out! read more

See all

I was worried that the new location wouldn't be as good as the old but was pleasantly surprised last night. Our waitress Michelle was amazing. She knew when we needed something before we even had to ask. She said she had worked for Spaghetti Warehouse for 30 years and her knowledge of the food showed. The food came out quickly and was very good. I got the chicken parmesan sandwich and he got the dinner. The chicken was great! We will definitely be back. read more

Having frequented the old Spaghetti Warehouse many times, we were expecting much more. The food was good - nothing spectacular, but the new place lacks almost all of the charm and ambience of the original restaurant. After one visit, we feel no need to return. read more

Food is still good even after all these years. Pricing is very reasonable for a downtown restaurant. Service was also good.

We loved the old Spaghetti Warehouse location and have many fond memories of family celebrations there. I'm happy to report that we love the new location, too! We eat at a lot of Italian restaurants since it's our daughter's preferred food- and this is one of our favorites! The garlic butter and warm bread is killer. Plus, the spaghetti and meatballs here is the best in Columbus, in my opinion. We love the new Columbus Commons views - and the short walk through the park from the Commons garage. Don't forget to ask for a parking validation! It brings the cost down to $2 from $5. I love all the old decor touches they brought over from the original location - especially the stained glass lamps. We will be regulars here! read more

See all

So, Anna, Mark, Marlena, and I went there today for lunch this Thursday morning. We were quickly seated and then greeted by Folando, who was a super great server. Knowledgeable, helpful, and very pleasant, we'd ask for him again. The manager made it a point to stop by a few times to make sure everything was good as well As far as ambiance, I liked the view of the Columbus Commons, and it's cool to know that they have huge garage doors that they can open when the weather is nice. Great place to watch one of the concerts on the lawn. The space is nice enough, but I really missed the visual overload of the old place. On a side note, the space really needs something (decor overload) to dampen the noise as it's rather hard to hear others talking at the table with all the hard surfaces The food was good. I tried Anna's Mozzarella Frittas, which were quite tasty and had a nice crispy crunch. My Grande Chicken Caesar Salad was also very good but was a little light on the protein and cheese. Mark and Marlena got the 15 Layer Lasagna, and both said it was quite good. And the bread. It was good, as was that delicious garlic butter, but bring back the old sourdough loaves. Please. All in all. A very good experience. I'm calling this 4 stars. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Grande Chicken Caesar. I Think Eric B In Las Vegas Would Approve. - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This new location has a lot to offer. They did a great job on incorporating the old location into the new location overlooking the Columbus Commons. While they were not able to bring over the old trolly, they built a replica to give you the feel you are eating in a trolley. They also brought in brick to give it the feel of the old location along with light fixtures. Still a great dining option for families where everyone can order something they will like. We had exceptional service. The prices are also very reasonable. The salads we got with our dinners were very good and the calamari was delicious. I ordered the Herb Grilled Sirloin with Brussel Sprouts and enjoyed it very much. If you are hungry for pasta I encourage you to order the 15 layer lasagna on spaghetti with meatballs. The only challenge is parking. If you lucky you may find a spot on the street. There are also plenty of public garages around. If you park in a Columbus Commons garages, bring in your ticket to get it validated. read more

See all

I was a bit apprehensive at first in visiting this location since I have heard and read mixed reviews on the "new" Spaghetti Warehouse, but I am glad I got to visit here and check this place out. This particular location is still relatively new, and while they have some kinks to work out, it also has some things going for them. Parking downtown is never fun, but there are several large garages in the area, and we parked at the Columbus Commons garage. To our pleasant surprise, SW provides a "semi-validated" parking where our $5 parking charge was reduced to $2. The speed of the service overall was unevenly paced - our host was slow to address and then seat us (even though there was only one other party waiting to be seated). It looked like our server was assigned too many tables, but she did a great job taking our orders, checking in on us, and bringing out our food on time. We tried the Sicilian Sampler, the Calamari, the Chicken Marsala, the Chicken Parmigiana for our appetizers and entrees. We also ordered the Grilled Chicken with fries from the children's menu (they have one that is not posted on their website, but you have to ask for it). Between the appetizers and the complimentary breads, we were very full by the time the entrees (which also include Caesar salads) arrived. The appetizers were just ok, nothing bad but nothing great. We found the chicken marsala unreasonably salty and the chicken parmigiana was overcooked. The grilled chicken and the fries were a hit with our daughter, and it was a good portion size. The dessert items - we got the Godiva chocolate cheesecake and the tiramisu - were the highlights for us. Spaghetti Warehouse has a great location adorned with huge windows overlooking the Columbus Commons. The interior of the location was old school, however, some of the seats and the floor generally were dirty and sticky. If I am in the area, I can see myself coming in on a warm summer day for a drink and dessert. read more

See all

Last year you provided an awesome experience offering tickets for $55 to enjoy dinner and a concert overseeing columbus commons....how can you triple the cost of tickets this year??!!! Shame on you! Totally not worth $150!!! It's a spaghetti buffet not steak and lobster! DO BETTER read more

I visited on opening night of their new location. I was greeted warmly and welcomed into the celebration. The first thing I noticed was the absolutely beautiful view of the Christmas lights on the green outside! You can see the view from more than half the seats. The windows roll up so it will be nice in the summer to listen to concerts while eating. The menu was limited since it was the first day, however they will had gluten free spaghetti. I got it with grilled chicken, marinara and toasted mozzarella. It was very good! Price point was average. Parking is what you would expect downtown. I parked at the state house since I was attending a show and just walked. read more

See all

Heard so many mixed review on this place, we just had to try it out for ourselves. Parking- There are few parking garages around Spaghetti Warehouse. We parked in the Columbus Commons garage. Spaghetti Warehouse validates parking to a reduced price. Location:- It's a great location where you have a great view of the Columbus Commons ground from inside. Inside of this restaurant however, was a little dirty. The floor and some of the chairs were very sticky. Service- Service was a little slow but ok. Food- average to not good. So we ordered the Sicilian Sampler and the Calamari for appetizer and Chicken Marsala, Chicken Parm with Spaghetti for the entrée. For dessert, we ordered the Godiva Chocolate Cheese Cake and the Tiramisu. Both of the apps where average, just tasted ok. The spaghetti for the chicken parm was way overcooked and the chicken could have had a little bit of flavor. However, the Chicken Marsala, was the opposite. I was not able to eat it because it was SO salty. I also got the Brussel Sprout with my Chicken Marsala, which was actually good. With our entrée we also received a Caesar salad. Compared to all the other food, the desserts were good. Spaghetti Warehouse serves cheesecake factory cheese cake, which is the Godiva Chocolate Cake that we ordered. The potion size is pretty generous for the price of the food. By the time you finish your complimentary bread and apps, you will be full. With so many restaurants around, I definitely do not see myself coming back here again. read more

See all

BLACK CHERRY LIMEADE $9 Black cherry puree, fresh lime juice, simple syrup topped with Sprite, optional dash of cherry bitters OUR INCREDIBLE 15-LAYER LASAGNE $17 Our all-time guest favorite! Layer after layer of lasagna noodles, your choice of meat sauce or alfredo sauce, Italian pork sausage, ground beef and Romano, ricotta and mozzarella cheeses read more

See all

Stopped here before a Broadway show without a reservation and were able to grab a table. Ordered drinks immediately, just missed happy hour which runs until 6 and has some nice discounts. For dinner we ordered Ravioli and the Italian burger which was a super unique dish along with salad, minestrone and Italian wedding soup. Everything was good and our server Anthony was great. A nice place to stop when downtown for an event. read more

See all

So my best friend and I was downtown at the commons looking at the lights and we smelled a smelly smell that smelt delicious! So we were on a hunt for the source! Long behold it was the spaghetti warehouse!!! Now I never went to the old location and we had no clue that this was the new location downtown lol We walked in and it looked like a dinner and it smelt aooooooooo good! We didn't have a reservation so we had to wait 30 mins which wasn't bad! The lady at the stand was rude but I can also tell she was tired and stressed out. Once our table was called we walked back and down the hall were booth that looked like trolly suites! They had lights on the table then in the very back it was open with small tables and tv on the wall! The windows were higher and open so we could see the lights at the commons! Our waiter was super sweet and after chit chatting we found out she waited us at her old job also! Which was cool! We ordered the lasagna and fettuccine Alfredo and added chicken. Got a Caesar salad. The chicken Alfredo with chicken was bland and had no sauce! IT WAS HORRIBLE!!! the chicken was tough and for 6 they give u four stops of a chicken breast! I had them take it back and I ordered the lasagna AND IT WAS DELICIOUS!!! omg! I wish there was more sauce because it was a little dry but over all it was a lot better than that Alfredo! lol It's a bit loud and I couldn't rly hear my bestie and the tables were rly close where we were sitting! Will I be back NO, did I have a good time YES! Was the food good?! It was ok! GO CHECK OUT THE NEW LOCATION AND TELL ME WHAT YOU THIBK!!! read more

See all

Food was pretty good , app we got was not very hot , but taste good. Sauce on the pasta was very good Service was good , they were busy so wait time was long after we were seated. Felt like we were being rushed. Would try again read more

Just left after a wonderful lunch. The food was great and the service was so friendly and fast. The restaurant is really clean and decorated for Christmas. read more

The restaurant was not busy. We got to see as soon as we entered however, considering the taste of the food, I understand why there was seat available the only common denominator between this spaghetti warehouse and the original is the name and the low light read more

First time at the new location and was extremely underwhelmed. This restaurant is a cookie cutter of every modern restaurant out there. Spaghetti Warehouse used to be a special place to celebrate occasion now it's a restaurant to just eat at. The food was good nothing special I can get Italian at other more convenient places. The "Trolley ". Was a joke my wife kept asking where it was and we walked right through it. It may have been better just to a mural of an old Trolley. It looked like a joke. Probably will not return unless we have to be downtown. But not a destination to go anymore read more

Good Italian food, relaxing atmosphere. Friendly service. The food is not top of the line but I would come back again.

Food was fine and service was nice... the place just smelled like a sewer. (This sentence added because there is an 85 character limit to post.) read more

Terrible customer service. Ordered takeout and half the meal was missing. Called to ask for partial refund and was denied. The person on the phone said they could not do anything over the phone and I would have to come back in the morning to get the missing items for breakfast. read more

They call it 'reimagined'..I say it shouldn't be a spaghetti warehouse anymore. Its just another downtown upscale restaurant with a few vintage recipes trying to survive on the name legacy. The food was good, but no-not the same, and our server was great but it is not worthy of the name. Bread and butter seemed close to 'old times' the lasagna good but the carbonara was very dry and bland. Mozzarella Frittas were highlight of the meal and all servings were large and came out hot. The joint used to make you want to go for the ambiance/quirkiness with good food and now its small, cold and dry with expensive drinks and crappy parking. Once was enough for us. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great service like always at the old place . Food was amazing . Location was on High st. Parking was difficult. But we'll worth it read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - The trio - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Great spot for family dinner, happy hour drinks or large party. Lots of seating that overlook the Columbus Commons with garage doors that open. Cute bar area. Food was good and they offered gluten-free pasta options as well. Service was great! read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Appetizer - calamari - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

My true rating would be a 3.5/5 but I'll give the benefit of the doubt and round up. I arrived here at 5:45 on a Thursday and was seated promptly. To drink I ordered the Pixy Martini which was super unique! It was sweet and sour and took me back to my childhood. I would definitely order this again! We then received the complimentary bread which is really delicious, especially with the compound butter they provide. I was dining with someone who was here for an event that included a free appetizer and dessert and he shared these with me so I'll share my opinion on them. Just a disclaimer that these were free for my friend but I am still sharing my honest review! For the appetizer we did the mozzarella fritta and these were amazing. Super crunchy breading, gooey stretchy cheese, and some nice fresh herbs to finish them off. These were one of the highlights for sure. Another highlight for me was the Italian wedding soup that came with my meal. It looks pretty unassuming but I thought it had a ton of flavor and I liked the inclusion of the chicken as well as meatballs. I would definitely order this again. The low point for me is unfortunately my entree. I tried the zucchini al aglio olio. What I did like about this was the cook on the spaghetti and the broccoli. What I didn't like was the size of the broccoli, the thickness of the zucchini "noodles" and the general blandness of the dish. The menu says it is in a garlic and olive oil sauce but I wasn't getting much of either flavor from it. Once I added salt it brought some flavor forward and I ended up enjoying it. But I think I'd have liked it better if the broccoli had been in more bite size pieces and incorporated in. Due to their size I ended up eating the broccoli more as a side dish. For dessert we tried their tiramisu. This was good, not the best I've had but it did have nice flavor and texture. My main note for this is that it had way too much cocoa powder on top, it was coating my spoon. Overall I think I'd be likely to return if I'm in the area but probably wouldn't make a special trip all the way downtown for it. read more

See all

This was my first time at spaghetti warehouse and it was very delightful. Service was very nice and speedy quick. I loved that this Yelp event was able to provide an appetizer, entree, and a dessert!! A lot for a meal. Everything was very clean and new! read more

See all

This was my first time trying this place overall the food was great and also our waiter traders very nice even though it was near closing time I highly recommend the salmon read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

First time visiting this place. Great food and great service. If you are curious what it's like, think a step above Olive Garden. Very reasonably priced. Our server (Sonciere) was terrific. No complaints at all. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Salad and bread with fried cheese - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

The best solution is to go in with a very open mind. This is not the classic restaurant. The modernized trolley concept greatly hurts traffic flow into the main seating area and really looks nothing like a trolley. Somehow in the back corner of the restaurant I could perfectly hear the conversations happening at the bar above the General noisy din of happy diners. The service was great, the chairs were far more comfortable than the old place, the food was again different. With the slimmed down menu sometimes mixing and matching is in order to get back to a classic such as adding a shrimp skewer to the Alfredo to make their shrimp Alfredo option. The parsley overload is interesting, but thankfully did not extend to desserts. The service was absolutely amazing. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Red velvet cake - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Great food and service. Great place to come for lunch or diner really great food. Loved spaghetti

Made our reservation a few weeks in advance for a Thursday (12/21/23). Love that it is beside Columbus Commons. I knew that I was coming during what they consider the "soft opening". We are from the Akron area and would frequently the Akron Spaghetti warehouse and only got to go to Columbus location once before it closed. We got gross food covered paper menus that should be thrown away after each guest. The bread was ok but the butter isn't how I remember it. No plates for the bread so crumbs everywhere. I got the chicken marsala and it was terrible. Dry with two tiny pieces of dry chicken. And I got what they call "Parmesan & Rosemary Steak fries". Two small handfuls of hard as a rock fries that look like they came in a bulk bag from Walmart frozen foods. Couldn't eat any of it. $19 for that small plate of food. My Dad got the 15 layer lasagna. He was expecting the huge piece that Akron serves with the flag toothpick on too. It was small and a mess. So I decided to get the Cheesecake factory plain cheesecake! My son got a piece too. Didn't ask for them to go but came out in a styrofoam container. They were TINY! My piece didn't even have crust on the bottom. I guess I was expecting the same size pieces of Cheesecake Factory like Barnes & Noble sells. read more

See all

First time to the new Spaghetti Warehouse in its new location. Went for lunch because I thought they might have a lunch menu (but no). First impression. Two waiters arguing in front at the hostess stand. Wow good start. Not the place for it in front of customers. Pasta dishes were just too expensive for lunch (and the portion sizes I saw on other tables looked a bit small) so I went with an appetizer (fried calamari $8), Caesar salad $9, Italian wedding soup $8, and sweet ice tea $3. Decent size Caesar salad plate with dressing and calamari was good. Wedding soup though. Broth was very thin and not much taste or seasoning. Would have been nice with more meatballs. Progresso wedding soup in a can has a better soup. As I said, would have been nice to have some lunch combos but just a thought. And despite the waiter/waitress argument in the beginning, my waitress was great with her attention and service. Not sure after looking at the menu that I want to go back. Missing some of my old menu favorites from the previous restaurant. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Fried calamari - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Delicious dinner last night at the Spaghetti Warehouse! Italian wedding soup: So good and I will say likely on the top of my list for Italian wedding soup offerings in Columbus; I love pouring Parmesan cheese on every scoop and I stand by this so kindly do not judge The salad could be beefed up a bit with more croutons and beefier tomatoes but my husband did his magic chopping it with the blue cheese dressing Lasagna: Solid and the red sauce is always delicious: in retrospect we should have ordered it independently Chicken Parmesan: Huge surprise as it was incredible. (The only reason I say surprised is because it was a game time decision to order this as it was included in the lasagna and chicken Parmesan combo which my husband and I split.) The chicken was also perfectly cooked and the melted cheese was incredible. The crisp on this was delicious. I would put this against any other I've ordered in Columbus. The wine and beer list was exactly what we wanted and affordable. My 14 Hands red wine mixed well with the red sauce. Service: Jordan was wonderful and so attentive as I noticed another server was flawless while patiently accommodating a nearby huge table who had issues with the parking validation. He didn't miss a beat in his professionalism. Made a point to tell anyone on staff that we loved our experience. As we live down the street, we will definitely be back as it was delicious and enjoyable with a staff who clearly cares. Only downside is that I didn't take pictures and that is on me. Additionally, we needed to order dessert. Didn't get a loaf of bread as it was more like pieces of bread but cmon, semantics. We should have ordered the garlic bread. Ambiance: It was loud with families and young children, but cmon, who cares?! Overall, we will be back and it is nice having you in the neighborhood! read more

My family and I wanted to come to the new location. This experience is truly sad and it's not the same. The restaurant is much smaller. We were told the wait will be 45min but ended up being 20min. When we got seated we noticed about 8 empty tables. I understand people are under staffed and it's hard to get people wanting to work. While waiting for our food it took so long just to get re fills on the drinks. Literally it took 15min to get re fills on water!! The spaghetti sauce is more sweeter and not what it used to be. It was nice to come see the place but we wouldn't come back. Also if you park at the Columbus Commons they will give you a ticket voucher. You just have to pay $2.00 in order to get the voucher. This experience all honesty 2 stars. Heads up!! The voucher they give you doesn't work at all. So we had to pay $6.00 for parking. read more

Spaghetti Warehouse - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

It is nice to have The Spaghetti Warehouse back in Downtown Columbus, but miss the historic West Broad Street location, but will make new memories at the new location. The food was excellent like the 15 Layer Lasagna, my friend has Spaghetti and Meatballs with Mushroom, another one had the Pasta carbonara, and the last one had a huge salad. Garfield would still eat the lasagna in 30-45 seconds. The service was good and the server who took care of my group was great, but most of them are new employees because the other workers lost their job because of the roof collapse at the old location. Give the new servers time and will be back making new memories at the new Spaghetti Warehouse at the Columbus Commons, but will retain the old feel of the other location. read more

See all