I was returning home from some business on Shelter Island and I heard about this BBQ place in Riverhead. We had a condo in Baiting Hollow, just north of here, for many years and past through here many times but never noticed it. This day I read some Yelp reviews about Mapletree BBQ, and thought "I think I'd like some good BBQ today". First, parking is a little difficult, park on the street or across the street in a small parking lot. I was fortunate enough to get a spot on the street in front of the restaurant. So my inside is pretty small. Wooden tables with rolls of paper towels and some BBQ sauces. No menus, you order off a chalk board, which is OK with me. In fact a woman claiming to be an owner was very helpful and made some good suggestions. So we pick what we want, pay, sit at a table and wait. Just a few minutes and food is on our table, and food it was. I had the brisket and my wife had the baby back ribs. Both very juicy and sauces were excellent. I've been on a BBQ kick lately and Mapletree BBQ is just what the doctor ordered. Next time in Riverhead you'll find me there for lunch. The reason for 4 stars is, first as I said, the place is very small. Also, and this is just a pet pieve for me, food comes in cardboard boxes on a tray. Just don't care for that concept. Of yes, another plus, soft drinks have refills and before we left that lovely lady that helped us insisted we take refills for the ride home. Great customer service. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

*** Before I begin I'll state that I am originally from the south so I know good BBQ and my opinion on this place is going to be a little biased because of it. Much like a person from NY would be biased about pizza from the south. Just ate here for the first time today. Walking in everything looks nice and clean and the staff was friendly and helpful. But I noticed something missing that all BBQ restaurants should have... that awesome bbq smell. The place didnt smell bad, it smelled normal but just didnt smell like BBQ. Me and my wife decided to order a few things so we could try this place out and give an honest opinion. We got the beef brisket, ribs, Carolina style pulled pork, slaw, potato salad, corn bread, baked beans and collard greens (they have them labeled kallards). The pulled pork and the brisket were both dry and had little flavor. Overall they were just ok. The ribs were better but still nothing exceptional. Potato salad was good but not really what I think of when I think potato salad. The coleslaw was a little bland, needed salt, pepper, vinegar and sugar. The cornbread was more like cake than corn bread. The baked beans were kinda weird and gross. They were more like a sweet flavored chili with no meat, definitely not baked beans. I am writing a separate paragraph about the collard greens because they were just that bad. The collard greens were definitely not cooked correctly and you can tell they were made by a yankee because no southern cook would ever send those out and call them collards. Not to mention they called them "Kallards" so I'm not 100% sure that they were actually collard greens and not kale, which is gross. The last thing we need to discuss is the BBQ sauces. They have 3: spicy, sweet and Alabama sauce. The spicy and sweet sauces are a little backwards. The spicy sauce is a ketchup based and the sweet is a vinegar based... these sauces would improve if they switched this up. The Alabama sauce is not really a BBQ sauce because it is a creamy horseradish sauce but it was good on the brisket. The last thing I have to say about the sauces is, where is the mustard BBQ sauce? I know this is the north and yellow mustard ain't all that popular but no good BBQ restaurant can go without a mustard based BBQ sauce. Overall this place was ok but definitely not good BBQ. I was going to give this place 3 stars due to the friendly staff, but I had to take it back down to a 2 because of those collard greens. If you have never had BBQ then you might like this place because you dont know what to expect. But if you dont like it dont let this place turn you away from BBQ because this place is definitely not what BBQ is. read more

See all

My wife was a little leery to try a new spot in Riverhead, the last spot was an old greasy spoon. Not to fear, I have a new spot my dear. (Stink eye coming my way) When I look at any new spot, my first thought is how will I feed a family of four? It's a knee jerk reaction, both my boys are working and have girl friends. They aren't hanging out with us anymore. It doesn't matter, this place makes the grade. You can order a full chicken as well as a rack of ribs for under $60 dollars. Now you might say, Applebees or Chilis are the same price point, why do I need to come to Maple Tree BBQ at all? Let me begin my review of Maple Tree BBQ. First, this place is cute as hell. Tastefully decorated as a BBQ joint, it's looks like a converted house with nice size tables. There was a mom holding a new born, its not a Texas roadhouse but perfect for families. Secondly, Like BBQ? The folks at Maple Tree BBQ are serving meats that are antibiotic free. There are also gluten free items if you're gluten sensitive. It's Sunday night and came to Maple Tree BBQ after shopping at Tanger Outlets. My Yelp Elite bud said to get the beans. I walk in and scream BEANS! The owner behind the counter said, I'm very sorry but we're out of a lot of food like beans. Aw dang. Not a problem, May I have the pulled Pork shoulder platter and my wife will have the pulled pork tacos. Oh yeah, and one of those beers on tap. My wifes tacos? Bangin'. The taco shells were soft corn shells, the pork was juicy and succulent and the pickled onions pulled it all together. My pulled pork platter came with fresh tasting cole slaw. My pulled pork was the same as my wifes, tasty and juicy. A perfect ending to our day. Maple Tree, you lost a star for running out of food and giving us limited options. But trust me, your BBQ is top notch and we can't wait to come back. Maple Tree BBQ is very close to Tanger Outlets. If you're looking for a great lunch or dinner, come to Maple Tree BBQ, its not too far away! read more

See all

Great smoked wings. Enjoy their BBQ. GREAT quality! Price is a bit high, but the food is good!

The smoked brisket ends pulled chicken Mac n cheese and potatoes are to die for. Unreal how good it is

My boyfriend and I came here on a weekend afternoon. Place was decently crowded and parking is limited. There's a parking lot across the restaurant and street parking as well but be careful because it's a busy street. We decided to try 1/2 lb beef brisket, 1/2 lb burnt ends, sweet potatoes, and cole slaw. The meat was really good and came with a side of sauce. Sweet potatoes were also really good with the BBQ. Cole slaw could've used a bit more flavor, it was kind of plain. Total came around to $40 for everything. Overall good place if you're looking for some BBQ read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Beef brisket, burnt ends, sweet potatoes, cole slaw - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Only had takeout so I can't speak to a dine in experience. Our friends live near here and love it. When we come to visit, they often get it. I'm often left disappointed. So I've had their pulled pork- 2 styles- NC which is a more vinegar based sauce and another. Just way too greasy for me!! Maybe it's because it's in a to go container and it traps it all but that doesn't mean it's not there! In house maybe on a plate or bun, it would soak it up!? The pulled chicken is super tender and moist- I will give them that. It does appear they put some kind of white sauce in that, so I assume that's what keeps it moist. While it's not bad, I just can't get over the grease and mediocre flavor of the pork. If greasy isn't your thing, I'd go for the chicken! read more

Their sandwiches are very good and we returned to try their ribs. Ribs was not that good - meat was not falling off the bone at all. I will go back for the sandwiches not for the ribs. read more

Went for dinner after the aquarium, about a mile away. Great spot with parking in the back and across the street. Service and food were excellent and everything came out super quick! read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Peach sangria - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Got called for Jury Duty and decided it was time to revisit! Had an hour and half break and was starved. Place was very busy, long line, tables full! Good sign! Only problem was one very nice man taking orders and one hardworking gal running out orders!! Service was slow and I had to hustle to make it back to court! The food was great though, I grabbed a seat at the bar and ordered the Maple Reuben which was terrific along with fries which were fresh out of the fryer! Value is great as portions are huge! I would just recommend they put on a couple of extra hands during lunch hours! read more

This restaurant has amazing food! It Never disappoints it's always worth the trip going out East. I love the Korean Barbecue Wings and the Mac and cheese. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

So this is a small place with some tables out back. Th night we were there they could have used another server to get out the orders. We had smoked chicken, ribs, beans, cole slaw, a reuben and briscuit. Food was ok but not sensational. I had been there in the past and the food had more flavor. Will go back and try again. read more

Cute little quaint barbecue spot on the East End. Brisket was good, but kale type collard greens were banging. I also enjoyed the jalapeño pickles and peach sangria. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Cozy bbq place to eat out in Long Island- when you need some properly smoked no bs bbq! Portions looked small at first glance but was very surprised that we had left overs to take home. YAY. Just sad that The Peach Sangria didn't taste very peachy rather was more citrus flavors. Customer service was friendly, helpful , and attentive. Restaurant seemed Very environmentally conscious with plant starch produced plants-tic utensils. LOVE that! Will be back read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Peach Sangria - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Was turned on to this place by a customer. Such a cute place and the food is top notch. The best bbq I have had in Long Island. The Cubano is in the top10 best things I have ever eaten. They are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays unfortunately. Parking is across a busy road but when the food is that good who cares. read more

Came on a recommendation since I was on break from jury duty. This place is about 3 min from the court house. Had the two meat platter and I got ribs and brisket and they were amazing. So flavorful with a great smoke ring on the brisket. My aides I chose were ok. The mac & cheese and the sweet potatoes were standard. Next time I would try the beans and something else. This is def stop for me again. Amazing ribs and brisket! read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Ribs and brisket! - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Fantastic BBQ, great menu and beer selection. Staff is exceptionally pleasant. Smoked wings make a great appetizer. St Louis Ribs melt in your mouth. Save room for the Bread Pudding with Pralines. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Bread Pudding - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Very good BBQ In town for a wedding, ordered take out. Got Beef Brisket Burnt Ends - Awesome Also had Southwest Salad - very good Chicken Siders were good Topped off with chocolate brownies - delicious! Highly recommend!!!!! read more

The atmosphere and food is really nice here. The quality and price of the food is good. I got the meat combo with 2 small sides for $19. Brisket is soft - you don't need a knife to cut it, just use your fork. Ribs were a little dry for my liking, but that may just be the style from smoked ribs. They had 2 BBQ sauces on the table, and both were delicious. They really enhanced the flavor of the ribs and brisket (which were both a little bland on flavor without the BBQ sauce). I enjoyed my sides: Cole slaw was fresh and not overdone with mayo, and pickles were perfectly tart to cut the fattiness of the meats. I was also impressed with the quantity of food, since I thought the small sizes were a great amount for the price. $2 for each small side if you were to pay a la carte. The food didn't blow my mind! But it was comforting, and if I didn't live so far, this would probably be my regular BBQ spot. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Brisket, ribs, Cole slaw, pickles Meat combo platter $19 - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Food and service is always good there, I definitely recommend pastrami if it's your first time going.

Great food a lil pricey but a definite go to for that Smokey bbq flavor we always get the sandwich platters which are amazing.

5 stars for amazing friendly service and staff and pretty darn good food. We headed out to the outlets this weekend and were starving and needed to find somewhere to eat. Found Maple Tree on Yelp (Kudos to all you other yelpers out there) I had the tacos (smoked salmon and pulled chicken); they were both light and filling at the same time. Perfect amount of flavor. Loved their spicy BBQ sauce! Not too sweet with the perfect amount of heat read more

Don't have to go south to get some bbq, just go north of New York Long Island! Had to come back to get some more awesome BBQ. Pastrami is probably better than Katz deli in manhattan, burnt ends are soft moist. Everything is full of flavor and not overly salty. So glad theres a hidden gem like this so close to the tanger outlet. I will never eat outlet food court junk thanks to this place. read more

See all

Very good place for bbq on the east end. Stopped in here on a VERY slow Tuesday evening. It was just a bit too late in the day and too cool to sit out at one of the picnic tables on the river, which would be totally awesome to do during warmer weather. I had the two meat combo plate with brisket and ribs and sides of baked beans and roasted sweet potatoes. Everyone knows that you have to have brisket and ribs if you're going to attempt to judge a BBQ joint. The brisket was top notch. Tender, juicy, flavorful. Five stars. The ribs were good, not great. If anything, a bit undercooked, which is way better than overcooked. They had nice flavor but didn't stand out. 3.5 stars. Baked beans were pretty bland while the roasted sweet potatoes were excellent. Also sampled the cornbread which was above average. Counter service was good. The owner (at least I think he's the owner) came by to check on us and then ran out from behind the bar to take my dirty trays so I didn't have to do much cleanup. All in all, I'll definitely come back here. May swap out the burnt ends for ribs and will definitely do something other than the baked beans, but this place is very good on the verge of being great. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Brisket, ribs, baked beans, and roasted sweet potatoes. - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

See all

Came to this place for lunch after visiting the Long Island Aquarium down the road! They have plenty of outdoor seating so it was perfect to eat there and practice social distancing. We ordered two combo meat platters ($18 and $20 depending on the meat) so we could try a variety of their meats. We ordered texas beef brisket, north carolina pulled pork, salmon and the brisket burnt ends. For sides, we ordered cole slaw, herb crushed potatoes and mac and cheese. Our favorites were the pulled pork and the burnt ends! Both were filled with flavor and was delicious! The salmon was a tad dry and the beef brisket was alright. For sides, we recommend the herb crushed potatoes! The potatoes were soft and well cooked! There's also plenty of parking across the street and service was great. I would recommend this place because it's rare to see a good american bbq around the area :) read more

I had a pulled pork taco, which was very flavorful and tasty. The pork was prepared well. Unfortunately, the soft tortilla fell apart when I attempted to pick up the taco. And the amount of meat included in the taco was very underwhelming. I also had the Texas beef brisket sandwich. This was a fresh, tasty sandwich with a good amount of meat... however, it was just roast beef, this was not brisket, nevermind Texas style barbecue brisket. As such, this was disappointing. But, most New Yorkers have never been to Dayne's, Franklin Barbecue, Vaquero's, etc (famous barbecue places in Texas). If you want a decent sandwich on par with an average Long Island diner, give it a try. If you want real barbecue that was hickory or oak smoked at 240F for 16+ hours, I would look elsewhere. I appreciate the reply from the owner. Again, the food was fresh, tasty, and well prepared. I respect and appreciate that. However, I stand behind my original comment in regards to the "Texas Beef Brisket" sandwich. A nice sandwich with a generous serving of meat, however it's vastly different from Texas brisket that's been smoked 16+ hours at 240 or so degrees in an offset smoker. Be well! read more

My family and I travel in a large group with little children. From the moment we walked in, Alice the "BBQ Lady" was welcoming and a lot of fun. The food...everything we ordered exceed expectations. We are no stranger to BBQ but from the chicken to the AMAZING BURNT ENDS, the food was perfect. Well cooked, well flavored, not a single dry bite and sauced up just right. It was quite a journey for the family and myself to Riverhead. While the sunflower show was a letdown, Maple Tree BBQ was the real star of the trip. read more

They have the most bomb bbq ever! So good and def worth the try! I always order them on doordash & they never disappoint and the actual restaurant itself is so cute and has a great atmosphere! read more

1 star for friendliness, clean bathroom and convenient location after a North Fork day trip 1 star for food: - Burnt ends: BBQ sauce tasted like a cross between ketchup and tomato sauce. On top of that, I selected the spicy version - which was decidedly unspicy. Meat was cooked fine, but the sauce problems ruined the meal. - Pulled pork sandwich: literally unsauced meat on sourdough slices - no sauce, no nothing else Smoked beans side: super sweet, not smoky. Couldn't eat. - kallards: kale cooked with pork. Not great, but not bad. - Bread pudding: delicious! And the source of the single star. Maybe it was an off day. Other people on Yelp seemed to like the place, which is why we chose it. Unfortunately, we found the barbecue inedible (for one in our party) and deeply unsatisfying for the rest of us. read more

Decent clean but expensive. Ribs are hit and miss because of fatty and untrimmed. Sometimes no fat sometimes alot, but if you ask they will fix it and exchange them. Drinks are good but again expensive. The rest of the menu is very good. So food a 4. Cost a 2 so I gave it a 3 star. Oh and portion size a 3. You milage may vary. read more

Heard from friends food is awesome yet there was a table inside with customers w dogs. ( being petted & shedding). Its a restaurant!!! Gross!! Isn't this a health violation? read more

The inside of the restaurant is very rustic and simple. Portion sizes are more than fair. The meat is always very tender, but I wish they'd use less salt in their rub. read more

Wonderful spot with large outdoor seating. Food was amazing, price point was fantastic and service was excellent. Super accommodating. W 1 star off because there were sides that were not hot. More like room temperature Overall a great experience. Will be coming back. read more

This place was very impressive. Not only do they have delicious BBQ and drinks, but the service is also A+ The outdoor tables were so clean and well disinfected, I was truly impressed since many restaurants do not heavily prioritize disinfecting. I felt Safe and well socially distanced from the other guests. I have only great things to say about this place. read more

Food was amazing, we came with a large group an hour before close and accommodated. Great atmosphere and great food, couldn't ask for more!

I cannot say enough good things about this place. Wow. What an amazing meal. The pulled pork sliders are to die for- same with the smoked New England clam chowder and Mac. My boyfriend LOVED his platter as well. Brisket is amazing. Coleslaw and beans just a must. Great drinks too- recommend the jalapeño margarita and sangria. So nice to support a local business with such a hands-on owner. Will definitely be returning! Best bbq around. Looking forward to trying the potatoes and cornbread next. Looked great. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - 5 star all the Way!!!! - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

The environment was ok a bit crowded, while sitting ppl are hovering over you. The food LOOKED decent but when I got the Yexan sandwich it was cooked alright but had no taste and the chicken was under cooked and still bloody. I Hope you guys improve in the future good luck. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Chicken under cooked and has no taste - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

The owner really runs a good show! If you are a meat lover, this is your haven! Ribs that are so tender, pulled pork slathered ribs in BBQ sauce! Unique sauces that make your tastebuds ROAR! You might have to wait a bit.... So worth it!! read more

See all

I am sorry to said the only thing that is good is the ribs. If you want any other stuff, I wouldn't recommend coming here. It is a really hidden location but not a gem. This is a walk up to the counter and order then pay and grab any seats that you like. They will give you a small stand with number on it and bring the food to you afterward. The price here, it is really reasonable but comparing the quality of food, I am disappointed. The food is about the equivalent to price here. I got the combination of two meats (burnt end beef and pastrami) with two small sides cost 15 dollars. The pastrami was really dry and way too salty. If it was on a bun or a sandwich, it would be better but still too dry. The brunt end beef comes in the tomato like sauce and that tasted okay. The potato was really good and the coleslaw was basically flavorless. Then we also order half rack of ribs. The meat was fall off the bone which was prefect but the flavor is not strong enough. Overall it was alright experience. read more

Maple Tree BBQ - Barbeque Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Who knew you'd find good southern BBQ in the middle of Riverhead, LI of all places! Very good brisket and super tender ribs, it was hard to choose just a few things from their menu! Mac n cheese, stewed greens and their addictive corn bread were our sides for the night and all were delicious. Staff was really helpful and warm plus made sure to keep all the tables clean and ready to go for the next round of customers. We will definitely be back. read more