This was the best meal I've had in a long time. Mac's Shack is crazy popular in Wellfleet; so much so that we've been meaning to go for years but didn't make it until tonight because of the long waits/lack of reservations. But this evening we went early, girded ourselves for the wait, and were rewarded with creative and expertly prepared seafood dishes. Some of the standouts were appetizers, especially the fried oyster bao buns and the smoked bluefish croquettes. And some were mains, notably the sea scallop dish with sweet corn purée and farro which is probably the best restaurant meal I've had this year. A friend really enjoyed her salmon entrée as well and my daughters both loved their sushi. The fish and chips was a bit of a dud--mediocre fries and a pedestrian presentation that was more suited to Mac's takeout spot on the pier, as opposed to this more elevated location. But the fun, festive vibe, gorgeous salt marsh views, and the other amazing dishes make this a solid 5/5. Seriously, get the sea scallops. And those bluefish croquettes! read more

Nice atmosphere, fabulous staff, great views. The food is sub-par. The Ceasar salad was browning and without enough dressing to make it wet. They did a presentation of half a head of lettuce all gussied up, with the lack of dressing it just completely fell apart. The fresh anchovy was a nice touch. The fried oysters were decent though super small portion spread over way too many so-so fries. read more

We ate lunch here on a Sunday afternoon and it was lovely. My party of 7 sat out in the back porch area with a wonderful view of the water and wellfleet bridge. It was nice since it gets super crowded on weekends so the 11:45am lunch start was just right in terms of beating the Summer Crowds. We had a plethora of dishes: fried clams were excellent and super fresh, tuna sandwiche was grilled to perfection and not dry at all, fish tacos were excellent, Gonjang burger was very flavorful and the poke bowl was to die for The service was excellent and punctual and I would definitely recommend this restaurant. When on the Cape - Mac's in Wellfleet is a must! read more

See all

A local favorite so be prepared to wait and enjoy a drink before your table is ready. No reservations accepted. Fish is fresh and creatively prepared, drinks look pretty but are overly sweet with questionable inclusion of alcohol. The views of the pond are lovely, although you need to get there early as the "electric walls" come down once the mosquitoes come out. A summer outing that doesn't disappoint. read more

See all

What a delightful place to discover! First, make sure you are seated in the back room. The light pours in through the slatted ceiling, the floor is chipped stone (shells?), and the view glances from a pond up to wooded hills. Our waiter was charming, and the food was EXCELLENT! Far more than what we expected on a September weekday afternoon. read more

Had a great late lunch here during our visit to Wellfleet. Tide was out at the time, but we still enjoyed the view on the outdoor covered patio area. Service here was great as well. I went a little risky with the lobster fried rice -- was delicious! Lobster rolls were another hit at our table. Definitely worth a visit. read more

Undoubtedly the best in Wellfleet !! If you're a seafood fan / this is it !! It has a fantastic bar scene as well! Great for date night out - family and friend's. They have an amazing wine list. On the drink list try the El Mescalito or the Siesta!! read more

See all

I had a wonderful time at Mac's Shack. The food was well portioned and delicious. I do wish the vegan and vegetarian options were better labeled / noted on the menu, though I was very glad to find some excellent options that our server also helped point out. The fries made me feel like I was on vacation & the braised beet poke bowl was new-to-me and I'm so glad I ordered it. So beautifully plated as well, I might add. We came on a night Mac was present at this location in Wellfleet, and it was a pleasure to meet him and say hellos. The back patio seating was honestly the biggest highlight for me... I mean, can't beat these views! read more

See all

A very popular spot in Wellfleet. Great atmosphere with outdoor seating around the bar, as well as indoor. We came late on a Saturday night when the place was hopping but lucked out and found a high top and ordered at the bar. Great service all around. The food was very tasty and reasonable. We had seared tuna sandwiches and a drink each. The drinks; Brooklyn was tasty, the peach fuzz was so so, and the prosecco good. We will be back here soon. read more

We go to Mac's Shack each year on our annual visit to Wellfleet because it's so consistently good. This time the food was excellent as usually but my nephew had a scallop dish that was the best thing I've ever tasted there. The depth of flavors was amazing. read more

May take some time but well worth the wait! Lobster Mashed Potato and Lobster Fettuccini were the highlights!

I am 100% certain that the 'lobster' roll was imitation lobster. I've eaten lobster and lobster rolls my whole life. There's really nothing else to say, truly a disgusting disappointment and waste of money. read more

This restaurant has gluten free fryers. If you're gluten free you can get fried clams Fisk and chips. Lobster roll. It's a gluten free dream

Good food and always a big crowd. Love their fish and chips such light breading! Sushi is always a big hit with our crowd too.

We go here frequently and really enjoy the cocktails. They have great bartenders. My husband always order the oysters and they are so fresh and briney. He also really enjoys the hamburger. It's one of his top five places for a burger. I usually get the fish and chip which is cooked well and fresh. They have such a nice outdoor space. This is a fun spot! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Fish and chips - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

This is one of our local friends favorite places. No reservations so if you show up late, prepare for a wait. They have a new covered area out back which is perfect (in lieu of the prior tent). Service was tremendous, Nicholas was the best. Super attentive, helpful with menu items, and very experienced. Ambiance was fun, casual, and vibrant. The food was amazing. We started out with the cod cheeks and grilled octopus which were divine. We also had the shrimp and scallop dumplings which were the least favorite thing that we ordered - just ok. All the sushi and sashimi were so fresh, delicious, and beautifully presented. Miso soup the best we've ever had. Highly recommend this place. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

We had to wait for around an hour for a table of five but we were seated in the pergola area and it was so lovely! There were some bugs but it was ok. I recommend the pomegranate marg it was great and the kung pao cauliflower!! The burger was good and the fries were meh. I had a bite of the cucumber sushi as well which I really enjoyed. Super fun vibe and great for a nice dinner in wellfleet! read more

See all

Came here for lunch and it seemed to be a popular choice! Even with the poor weather this place has an impressive set up on the back of the building with a weather proof enclosed tent, that had heating, fans, the works! The chowder and Brussels sprouts were both a delicious appetizer! Followed by our entrees which we had a difficult time choosing for the amazing selection! I had the Harissa Salmon dish and it was divine and my friend had the Halibut with the Lobster mashed potatoes, both wonderful meals! Our server was friendly and attentive! If in Wellfleet this is a must! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Halibut with Lobster Mashed Potatoes - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

2 small mixed drinks with no booze for $29 then tip - boo. bad start switched to beer - it was warm fish and chips was fresh, but portion small and not the type of batter i liked even after a discussion with waitress beforehand great outside ambiance good sushi chowder was on the thinner side, but had lots of clams and potatoes - its a preference thing - i liked it i am not rushing back, did not live up to hype read more

What a diamond in the rough. Found Mac's shack by mistake, boy were we glad. Lily our bartender, made awesome drinks, we were sorry we didn't stay for food. Love the atmosphere, outdoor bar. We will be back. read more

The service was great only reason I'd give it one star. The food on the other hand was awful what should have been a good meal for 50 dollars was terrible. The fries have definitely been sitting in a fryer the clam chowder was a cup of water no thickness to it I don't think there was even a piece of clam in it. Even the kids meal that I grabbed for my son the grilled cheese was fried beyond belief and not even edible. Highly disappointed and would not return read more

Mac's was recommended to us by a friend but the experience was less than stellar. Service was adequate but we needed to ask for silverware, water etc.... Food was just ok- Fries had a big hair in them and needed to be returned and the tuna in the sushi was bad (mushy and inedible). One member of our party was gluten free yet the dish was served with panko bread crumbs. We probably wouldn't go back. read more

What I liked: Attentive and welcoming staff. Atmosphere is beachy nice. What I'm 50/50 on: The clam chowder had a great flavor but it's not the hearty sort of chowder most people expect (thick, more clam bits, potatoes). If you know Capt. Parker's, this is the opposite in texture. I need to sample it again. What I did not like: The fried chicken sandwich with barbeque sauce. It was a disaster, lol. The sauce was too spicy, even for someone like me who likes spicy food, and it just didn't taste all that great. The bun soaked up the sauce and basically turned to mush and the sandwich falls apart in your hands, so I used a knife/fork. What I loved: The waiter asked me how I liked the sandwich, and I said matter-of-factly that it was too spicy. I wasn't complaining -- after all, I ate the damn thing, lol. Before I knew it, the cook came out, apologized, the waiter apologized and said it was her fault for not telling me it was spicy etc. etc. The cook offered to cook something else (I declined) and took the meal off the bill. I didn't ask for anything and they fell over themselves to make it right anyway. That's how you get customers coming back, like my wife and I certainly will. read more

The food was fantastic; the atmosphere was great. Will be returning next year. Staff was great. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Fantastic whole belly clams - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

My one takeaway... don't waste your time. My grandparents and I came to eat here and we waited 15+ minutes for someone to come to our table even though we were one of four families and there were many servers .We ended up leaving before we could even order because of this. We weren't even able to get water before we left and when we left no one noticed or cared. As we left I also noticed the hostesses giving us the stink eye even though it was nothing against them.We just wanted to eat. read more

Oh this was a treat! Two California girls on a New England Road trip. We wanted a taste of seafood and we got the best of the best here. We got a table outside. Jole, our server, helped narrow down the choices. She was awesome! We ordered oysters, calamari, bellied fried clams and fish tacos. The calamari was not fried instead it was served in a rich tomato and garlicky sauce. It was delicious. The bellied fried clams were like fried calamari. The French fries were not the best. We ended with the fish tacos, the fish and the garnishes were amazing! I would definitely come back. Oh and all that for under $100. Make sure to arrived before 5pm to get quick service. It got filled up pretty quick after we arrived at 4:45pm. read more

See all

Went here when they opened, 430. Waited about 20ish minutes with my family of 11! While waiting we got some drinks at the bar which was nice. The outdoor area was fun and comfortable, I really enjoyed the vibe. The music was great. The service was great. Once we were seated as we were ordering at the table our second round of drinks were already being delivered to the table. The food was amazing. I had a lobster with steamers both were so fresh and amazing. The cod cheeks were amazing as well! The sushi was ehh. The rest clams were amazing and fresh. read more

See all

This was kind of a surprise because it seemed like literally the entire population of the cape was at this place when we walked up. Or maybe that should have been a warning. The place is nice, it has kind of chill outdoor seating with a low-key vibe and bathrooms that are basically portopotties. The only thing off theme were the prices, sheesh. We're talking $3.50 oysters (dude, you can just pick them up down the street) and $34 small-size lobster rolls (them's city prices). The oysters were very tasty. The lobster roll, being $34 and served basically everywhere in New England, has to be held to a high standard. A standard it does not meet - the meat was overcooked and chewy. The butter, rather than being drizzled atop the roll was in a giant blob at the bottom. The result was a mushy mess wrapped around rubbery meat. I make it sound worse than it was - it was not BAD, but again, if you're gonna make the same thing everyone else makes in the area, you gotta do better. I wouldn't come back here there's a ton of places in Wellfleet. Not bad, but not good either. read more

What a cute little place to eat in Wellfleet right near the water. Most of the restaurants was in a heated tent with string lights in the center. This place has all of the general New England seafood. We started with local oysters which were delicious and honestly some of the best I've had. Then I had the fish and chips which were perfect for dinner. The fish was perfectly cooked and only lightly breaded. I'll for sure come back the next time I'm in wellfleet! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Fish and chips - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

Good location a lot of parking nice view of the water. Lobster was good, steamed and reasonably priced because it's basically a self-serve place. Picnic tables to sit by. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Lobster - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

Not what I expected, the service was just ok the server only came by once. The shared 2 bathrooms is problematic when there is a line. The food looked better taste. The biggest issue was food temp. I had the clam chowder but it had no roux which made it more of a soup than chowder. The eel dynamite roll was good but the spicy tuna was just ok. The lazy lobster was not warm at all the corn risotto had elements of sweetness from the corn but the rice was slightly underdone so it was not as creamy as I would have liked. The lobster was tender but again just as warm for the overall dish. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Butter Poached "Lazy" Lobster - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Wellfleet oysters, best I've ever had. Salmon roll was good and Fish tacos were also very good! Our server, Nate was excellent Beautiful view to top it off. read more

My family and I have eaten at Mac's Shack in Wellfleet every summer for quite a few years and generally they have been decent every time, about a 4/5 at best. This visit on 10/12/25 went against that experience, unfortunately. Someone in my party has a severe dairy and tree nut allergy and they were extremely curt about having to deal with those allergies, clearly showing a lack of empathy and overall care despite being..in the...service industry????They also didn't supply condiments and when we went back to ask for them they deflected, not taking accountability for a simple mistake. On top of this, we found a hair in one of the sushi combo meals and there were clearly some bits of something that didn't belong in the California Rolls that were ordered, of all things. I assume it was crab shell, but I can't be sure. How does one mess up a California roll, it's literally 7 ingredients. Anyway, I'm sad to say this place seems to not be up to the caliber of the previous visits we've had and we will not be going back any time soon. Overpriced mediocre food. The miso soup was pretty solid, though. read more

One of my favorite restaurants on the cape - friendly service, casual ambiance, and FRESH food. There is no reservations so there may be a wait, but there is a nice outdoor area with a bar and some seating. Our food came out fast and was fresh and flavorful and the drinks were great. Best sushi I've had in a while!!! read more

See all

The best on the Cape, hands down. Amazingly consistent and in season, get there by 5 or prepare to wait. The new back dining area is delightful. Have a West Hollywood and a High Roller for me. read more

When I say I cannot express how amazing our experience was, I really mean it. Firstly, Mac's is a celiac safe establishment. Not just celiac "friendly", but seriously built around safety for people with gluten issues. The owner (Mac) has celiacs and so all the staff are knowledgeable and the menu is about 90% gf. Our waitress, Jolee, was a gem! She was so excited with how excited we were She took time explaining the menu, answering questions, and made sure to check on us often. We will be back on our next trip to Cape Cod, and Mac, if you are reading this, please bring a location to Georgia! read more

Absolutely fresh and delicious lunch at Mac's Shack in Wellfleet. Despite being a local "chain" this oyster shells underfoot bayside shack in Cape Cod's historic and foggy town of Wellfleet felt unique & was enjoyable. We waited about 20 minutes for a seat, but waited in the bar, so it went quickly. From fresh local oysters, tasty grilled hamachi collar with unagi sauce, to a flavored wasabi & sesame oil flavored ahi noodle dish to a picnic-tables-under-a-tarp setting, this location & seafood (seasonally local, but also flown in from outside the area, so ask) is excellent and not to be missed. Friendly and attentive service rounds out a good casual fresh seafood lunch in Cape Cod. read more

See all

Perfect outdoor rusticity in Wellfleet. Stumbled in by happenstance, incredible 6oz lobster roll (Cook's posts a competitive edge here). Also recommend their Chatham location. Hope to return soon! read more

There are several locations in the area, but they're all great! The original is Mac's Shack in Wellfleet near the pier (no reservations, but a big bar to hang out in while you wait for a table). Their sushi is really great, but there are plenty of other things on the menu too. My favorite dishes are the spicy tuna mango martini, bang bang cauliflower (tastes like a combo of sweet, spicy, and soy), and the ritz-crusted bluefish with garlic mashed and creamed spinach! (visited 10/29/11, 8/16/23, & 8/23/24) read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - pomegranate martini - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Excellent service from our server. Excellent food and variety. Fun outdoor eating experience. I'd recommend this place to anyone looking for good seafood that is moderately priced. The oysters were delicious and local! read more