Very nice seafood restaurant in Chatham, and we easily found parking on Main Street as well as getting a table and were seated almost immediately on Juneteenth Day '26 at 1:00 Pm. Main Street was nuts, insane, busy, etc. with the holiday, vacationers, visitors, soccer fans for FIFA, etc. It's the Cape! Very nice place... looks like it could have been a church, VFW Hall, or something or another. Found out it was actually a clothier back in the day, and the stained glass and pews were rescues from a church up in Maine. Nice decor, comfortable. Both lunch and dinner menu served in the early afternoon. High volume, but a few empty tables on a long holiday weekend - Friday. A little off of the beaten path, by that I mean it is not directly on Main Street, but located on Chatham Bars Avenue and down the short street a hundred feet or so and on your left. Cold, bottled San Pellegrino with lime and lemon. Started with the raw bar, well worth the short wait! 18 fat, cold, and briney oysters that were shucked to perfection. The Shrimp Cocktail was great too. She had the Floey's Tuna Sandwich, along with the pasta salad; the tuna had capers mixed in which was a very nice touch! I had the broiled scallops and asparagus; an incredible butter/lemon sauce. Both done exceptionally well. Clean facility, plenty of room, and a wicked nice staff too! Truly, a hidden gem and a must visit! No negatives whatsoever! read more

See all

Small local restaurant in Chatham with really delicious food - Asian or Spanish flavors. Definitely great seafood - sole, oysters, scallops, and lobster. They are a small restaurant so make reservations well in advance! Like a month in advance! Noise level is pretty high because it's such a small restaurant. Hard for seniors to hear each other. Not ADA friendly - no ramp and somewhat uneasy terrain for elderly. read more

See all

My sister and I wanted to grab a quick bite before we left the area. Since we didn't have a huge appetite we just ordered a half dozen oysters, little necks, and a side of fries. The oysters were delightfully sweet and buttery. The little necks here do not compare at all to common west coast clams. They pack such a good flavor we enjoyed every bite. The seafood paired very well with a glass of Sancerre. As for the service, even though it was lunch time, we did wait about 15 minutes to order. We didn't receive any top ups of water or were checked in on much. We had to flag our waitress down to get some condiments before we dug in. The seats were packed a little tight to each other but for quality seafood, we'd do it again. read more

Impudent Oyster - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Called about a month in advance to make a dinner reservation. Their dining room is beautiful, but small, so make sure you plan ahead or try to snag a seat at the bar. Service is always pleasant. Their bread and butter basket has been consistently delicious since I started coming here. I tried the soup special, a shrimp and corn chowder. It was flavorful, creamy, and full of meat and veggies! Every time I come, the Devil's on Horseback is a must-order. If you like scallops, this is the appetizer for you- wrapped in bacon and bathed in hollandaise. For my entree, I also tried another special - the seafood arrabbiata. It was a delicious pasta with veggies, scallops, lobster, and shrimp! For dessert - the creme brulee special was a coconut cranberry flavor. The coconut was subtle, and there was a sweet cranberry puree under the custard. Overall, a delightful meal! read more

See all

My husband was really wanting to try this place and we both really enjoyed it! We went for dinner and got oysters and a crab cake to start. Both were fresh! Then we split a Caesar salad and the swordfish. The swordfish was really delicious. We were happy to stop in and hope to come back again soon! read more

See all

Service is good Food has gone downhill And is overpriced Cosy warm relaxed ambience read more

4.5/5 We've been to The Impudent Oyster many times, but this was our first visit for lunch. It's the off-season, and while the service was very friendly, it was a little spotty--they definitely seemed understaffed. Food-wise, everything was great. The calamari appetizer was especially excellent: a generous portion, and I loved the addition of artichokes and banana peppers. We ordered the "famous" scallop roll for our main. It was good, but not amazing, in my opinion. We also got the burger, which was very tasty and super filling. Overall, another solid meal! read more

Impudent Oyster - Calamari - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Great service. Super friendly host and staff. It's such a cute old building. Love their signage and menu illustration. They said people come here for the scallop bacon sandwich so that's what we got! Wow it was a hit. We upgraded to the truffle parm garlic fries -- they were some of the best fries I've ever had. I can't stop thinking about them. They were just the right size and not too soft and not too crunchy. Just the right amount of cheese. Goldilocks French fries. They said their seafood is fresh and local! It did taste like it. We tried waking in for the dinner the night before on a Sunday but they were booked and it was 1hr or more wait for bar seating. It was packed. But for lunch it was semi-empty and we just walked in. It's on the Main Street in Chatham near a bunch of shops, businesses, restaurants, gift shops, and a park. Highly recommend if on the Cape! read more

See all

Me and wifey are away for the weekend to Cape Cod. She's been browsing the google recommendation for best seafood in Chatam as we were strolling the city by walking. Called in to see if we can make a reservation for 2... only to be told they were fully booked for the night. However, the hostess let us know that they accept walk ins as long as you dont mind sitting at the bar section. Lucky enough for us when we arrive, a couple just got up and left, so there we sat down. Upon receiving the food and drink menu, one of the bartenders asked if we want a welcome bread, I said sure why not. Off to a great start, as we were too hungry we dont waste no time, wifey said they are well known for their Pesca fra diablo [ mixed seafood consists of lobster claw, clams, white fish and prawns] and I ordered steak au poivre [ medium rare]. Welcome bread is warm and fresh, generous heaps of butter in a cup, easy bite and tasty. About 15 mins in, our food arrived. We were amazed by the size of it. Generous portions and super tasty! Hands down we said to each other, we would definitely come here again to dine and hopefully get a table reservation. Geezussss, steak is cooked right to perfection. Great temperature, texture was there, easy to swallow. Sauce is on point and so is all the roasted vegs. The carrot, oh my... looks might be deceiving... sliced it and as soon as it enters my mouth, softtt and sweet. Steak wedges is AMAZEBALL, no exaggeration. I would rate this spot higher thhan Keens or Hawksmoor. My wife linguini cooked in marinara sauce [said its the town's specialty] doesnt disappoint either. Seafood is super fresh, no fishy smell or taste, clams are disgustingly delicious [no sand bites], clean thoroughly, fish pieces are also melt and soft... they DO NOT skimp on the toppings. We cant praise this place enough, totally recommended. They are fully booked for a reason and 90% were all attended by locals. The quality and ingredients they use is definitely up there.. Great atmosphere, food and service... will definitely make me a generous tipper!!!! read more

Impudent Oyster - Pesca fra diablo - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Birthday dinner. We have been going to the Impudent Oyster for 20+ years. Food is always very good, especially the seafood Service is good. Nice dining room. Just off Main Street in Chatham. read more

Impudent Oyster - Rigatoni with shrimp and lobster - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Excellent food and attentive ,very professional wait staff ! This is our "Go To" restaurant on Cape Cod !

Very poor service and bad attitudes from the hostess and manager. Not worth going here. Other great local restaurants to choose from. read more

My fiance and I came here for a romantic dinner. The vibes were perfect and the service was top tier, everything came out so quickly but wasn't rushed and the servers were so so kind. He got the swordfish and I got the sole and they were both phenomenal. Would recommend read more

After 40+ years of visiting the Cape, this is definitely my favorite restaurant. We visited on a rainy, cold, cloudy Saturday in May and sat at the bar for lunch. The atmosphere is cozy and the service friendly. We started with Wellfleet Oysters and they were excellent. The house-made chips are terrific -- thick and crunchy, with no oily taste. The appetizer calamari was enough for a meal; crispy coating and a very nice greens and tomato salad. Lobster roll was also really good and at a reasonable price . Best part of the meal was the rye Manhattan! read more

See all

Highly reccomended if you're staying in Chatham. Seems like reservations go pretty quick so if you're planning ahead (or have more than two people) definitely try to make a reservation. We walked in (bar seating only for walk ins) and put our name down. We were told about 45 minutes. By the time we parked the car at our hotel and walked back we waited about 15 minutes. So worth the wait. We shared an app from the specials - Thai crab cake. It combined interesting elements (crab cake, coleslaw, thai curry, and shoestring fries) that went so well together. I got the lobster ravioli from the specials. One of the best seafood pasta dishes I've ever had. The vodka sauce was creamy and they don't skimp on the scallops, shrimp, and big pieces of juicy lobster. Husband had the first dish on the main entree menu (something Diablo) he loved it. The drinks (husband got a dirty martini and an espresso martini) and mocktail (not too sweet - refreshing) were also spot on. The ambiance of the restaurant is very nice. I actually really liked the vibe at the bar. Again would definitely recommend. read more

See all

Food was tasty enough if a bit salty, and took a very very long time to come out. Oysters nothing special for their namesake and locale. A friend has celiac's and was personally assured the fish tacos (from the gluten free menu) would be made safely and she missed half the day vomiting. read more

Food and service were amazing! The ambiance is great. Such an amazing dine. I'd come back.

Food was great. I had the cape cod Reuben and it was very good and plenty of it. Lucy was our server, very efficient and friendly. The ambiance was relaxed and very neat and clean. read more

Amazing time! First time visiting Cape Cod and was recommended this place for the "locals only" atmosphere. Didn't make a reservation but the bar was first come first serve and only a 30 min wait. The shoppes around were very cute to visit while we waited. Food for 2 was the raw bar sampler - oysters clams and shrimp (all large and incredibly flavorful), clams casino and the broiled cod with the potato and goats cheese cake, green beans, capers, and beure blanc sauce. All delicious! Service was well timed and attentive to our pace and when we split a main, they plated the dish in half beautifully which was very nice and made each dish look special! The company at the bar were all locals and had great conversation - 10/10. read more

Impudent Oyster - Clams casino and raw bar sampler - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

One fine night on the cape my friend and I drifted along the coast like dreary travelers looking for a comforting meal and ambiance. A quick yelp search brought us to Impudent Oyster - a classy, mahogany themed restaurant nestled to the side of main street Chatham. We walked in to a buzzing scene. Dimly lit, classy decor and busy. This is a great place for a classy dinner with friends or a date. We promptly seated ourselves at the bar after a small 15 min wait. The bartender quickly served us drinks. The oysters Rockefeller were calling my name and I immediately ordered those, and am I glad that I did. These are some of the best charbroiled oysters I've ever had. The filling was generous, buttery and delicious with chunks of seafood. They are served on a bed of hot rock salt which I believe only helps their savoriness. An absolute dream. I was on the fence about what to get for my entree and on the bartender's recommendation went for the braised short rib. This dish was ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL. The beef was braised so beautifully, in a red wine reduction on a bed of potatoes with perfectly charred winter vegetables like carrots and parsnip, but the real magical element were the onion rings adding sweetness and crunch to the whole dish. We also met some old timers and learned this restaurant is nothing short of a Chatham institution. If you are in the cape, please come here and have some wonderful food! read more

Impudent Oyster - Braised Short Rib - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Food and service was excellent as always. I had the Filet and lobster half tail. Only problem was the size of the half tail of lobster. This had to come from a very small lobster. No bigger than a good sized shrimp. I know we are seeing shrink inflation but would be better to just have the filet by itself. At a lower price of course read more

Excellent all the way around. We arrived early on a recent Saturday night without a reservation. Tables were full, but we were told the full menu was served at the bar. Thankfully we got there early enough to grab a spot at the bar and not have to wait. Everything was soooo good. I got a pasta special chocked full of shellfish. Hubby got the surf and turf and was very pleased. Drinks were strong. Service at the bar was attentive and fun. Fellow customers at the bar were friendly and chatty, making the evening very enjoyable. I would return in a heartbeat! read more

We stopped in here after searching, high and low for the best clam chowder in the Cape. This place was highly recommended, and it did not disappoint. The clam chowder was some of the best we had while visiting the Cape. All the staff was friendly enough, the restaurant could definitely use some updates. It's extremely old with creaky old chairs and booths. I got the scallop sandwich and the daily side dish. The sandwich was fantastic! I ended up eating the inside and leaving the bread because I felt like it was too much. The pasta side dish was average and I probably wouldn't get it again. We will definitely come back for the chowder! read more

Impudent Oyster - Scallop sandwich and daily side dish - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

AMAZING FOOD! Service and ambiance at the bar was exceptional. Prices reasonable too. Go for the seafood- it's off the charts fantastic. read more

Impudent Oyster - Sole, topped with crab, over jasmine rice and asparagus - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Great food, great staff and lovely decor. Very accommodating in spite of busy weekend. Loved the local oysters

I used to like this restaurant more but the last few meals there have been a disappointment. We ate here this week and my seafood carbonara fell short. It was suppose to include lobster but there was only one small piece and the rest was scallops and shrimp. My wife's breaded sole was soggy, and they forgot to include a lemon. Another member dining with us had the shrimp and chicken piccata, and the jumbo shrimp were not jumbo. The chicken was dried out, they couldn't bite through part of it. Another member of out party had the halibut and it was overcook. I can't recommend this restaurant at this point, there are better ones in the area. read more

This was our first time at this restaurant. We came here for a late lunch based on the reviews from Yelp. The ambience is really quaint, bright and upscale casual. The wait staff was very attentive and accommodating. We had the Brussels sprouts as an appetizer. Nothing special, other than fried, with a sauce on the side. The mussels were harvested locally and came with white wine sauce, topped with onions. A large hunk of garlic bread accompanied the mussels. A very large portion as an appetizer and it was my main meal. My wife had the scallop sandwich, which was excellent-scallops cooked to perfection with a bacon/cheese sauce on a buttered brioche bun. It also came with a side of sweet potato fries. Highly recommend to come and enjoy a lunch while visiting Chatham MA. read more

Always exceptional. The varied fish are unique and so fresh. We enjoy sitting at the bar. Bartenders are very friendly and accommodating.

Always great Specials daily Comfortable Great service A+ expected and very much our experience. Kathleen Lockyer read more

Been a regular here for years. Now I open the menu and--boom--everything's "Asian-fusion." Swordfish Picatta? Gone. Fishwitch? Gone. And $9 for a side of broccoli...really? Feels like you're chasing tourists with deep pockets instead of the locals who kept you busy all these years. Keep the classics, keep your roots, and I'll stick around. Looks like I'm headed to Del Mar more often. read more

This is an old-school institution in Chatham! My mom and I came here since Mary Higgins Clark wrote about it in some of her novels. It is small, quaint, and full of charm! Even though the vibe is classic, the menu is full of lots of different types of food and interesting choices. To start, we shared the queso burrata. I have never had burrata warmed, but it was incredible. I loved the addition of the different veggies, especially the eggplant, and the balsamic. The textures were great and I loved the crispy crostini served with it. For my entree, I had the cod that comes on a salad. It was so light, but full of flavor! It is just what you need on a summer night. I would ask for extra blue cheese next time because I loved it so much! My mom had the surf and turf and raved about it. She even said it was the best fillet she has ever had! Our server was fantastic and we had such a lovely dinner here. I look forward to coming back next time I'm in Chatham! Maybe I'll save room for dessert next time :) read more

Impudent Oyster - Cod Dinner - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

See all

Outstanding food quality and service and the best seafood restaurant on the cape. Reservation a must for dinner they are always booked but walking are OK for lunch. Mussels Isabella a favorite but everything on menu is fantastic. read more

Stopped in by happenstance, so glad we did. They stop serving lunch at 2:45 , we walked in at 2:46 and they still seated us , thankfully . The staff was extremely pleasant . My lady had a full bodied Cabernet and I opted for the Pilsner on tap. Tasty, cold and refreshing. We both opted for the Nantucket Scallop sandwich and in truth , one of the top 3 sandwiches I have ever had. Scallops, bacon and Monterey cheese sandwich on the best tasting roll served hot . Outstanding!! The ambience was inviting, calm and serene with great tunes piped in, Dylan, the Beatles, Van Morrison.Stones. Highly recommended . I'd give it 10 stars if I could read more

We've had lunch here several times now over the past few years, and we enjoy this somewhat odd restaurant in downtown Chatham. First, the decor, very old school and perhaps this building used to be a church. Stained glass in places, and some seating that looks like old pews! The vibe is very old New England. While not dirty, there is nothing polished about the interior. Service here has always been friendly and very efficient, and the menu serves up all the classics you might expect, along with some eclectic options as well. Whether you are looking for fried fish, to more refined dishes, or raw bar, I' m sure you will fins something you and your party will enjoy. Cocktails are also a hit here with some specialty offerings, as well as a full bar. The fried calamari plate was a hit at our table, with perfectly fried calamari that also included fried peppers and artichoke hearts. A nice surprise was a big heaping of greens that made us feel like we made a healthy choice. This place is usually packed, so plan accordingly. read more

Impudent Oyster - Perfectly cooked fried calamari - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

Is a gem of a place The food was absolutely delicious. The service was fantastic Highly recommend The menu was very interesting and what we had was really good read more

Absolutely incredible. My husband and I came here for dinner and got very lucky snagging seats at the bar. We had the most delicious meal and best experience from start to finish. The staff are all very friendly and knowledgeable. Mussels were some of the best I have ever had and HUGE ! My meal was the prosciutto wrapped cod. My husband had the swordfish. Both were just insanely good!! We cannot wait to go back we've been dreaming about it ever since !! read more

See all

I love Cape Cod and in particular Chatham. Friends have a home close the water and we were invited up for a week. It was suggested we go to the Impudent Oyster for dinner the first night. Upon waking in there was no way if thinking this was anything but a New England bar/restaurant. The wood everywhere and the decorations screams Mid 1800s, Great everything! We went back for lunch twice and another dinner. read more

Very nice upscale dining experience in the heart of Chatham. Pre game at the Squire and head over to this restaurant for an excellent meal. The clam chowder is probably the best in Chatham, having tried many places in town. Also had a striped bass and lobster dish over rice that was sublime. read more

Impudent Oyster - Excellent!!! - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

The IO is a quirky location that serves out a lot of well done food. It appears to be a church or some previously relevant building that is now a fusion of seafood and English pub. It may not be what I expected, but it exceeded my first impression when I walked out the door. The decor is very unique and quirky as I mentioned before. It has stained-glass windows throughout the building along with a coat of arms. It has a lot of old, sturdy, stained wood to accompany that vibe which makes me think of a church or the pubs I visited in Ireland and England when I traveled abroad. The service was amazing as well. Prompt attention, able to handle a group of 8 (including 2 children), and pleasant throughout some of the ridiculous requests that my family inevitably had. The menu offers a variety of styles and cuisines. As I said, my family is not the easiest to please and everyone was able to find something they were happy with having for dinner. I think the highlights of the menu were the seafood pasta (see my photos) and the daily/fresh catch specials. The kids menu is your typical offerings but a little fancier in terms of how the items are done. They tend to be a bit picky, but gobbled up everything they were served. My parents are more meat-and-potatoes kinda people and they even ventured out of their comfort zone because of the poetic descriptions on the menu. It's a very thoughtful and passionate menu that weaves typical types of fare with local, seasonal ingredients. There was not a single dish (app, salad, main, or dessert) that inadequately executed, and most of them were visually spectacular. If I had one complaint, it's the price point or the value for the experience. It's Cape Cod, Boston, etc... I get it, things are expensive. But, honestly for the price point I didn't feel cheated or ripped off but I also didn't walk out thinking I got the full dollar's worth. Even my wife made a comment that the food was good, but not price point kind of value. However, that's not enough to really knock more than a star off, because if you want seafood that isn't from a shack on the water or fried this is the price point you will pay in the area (or Boston). They have to make rent and keep the lights on, which I totally understand and why I'm not making more of a stink about. The Impudent Oyster was a bit of a roller-coaster experience from the surprise of the first impression to the excellent service to the good food to the paying the check. It's a great local place to experience and like I said there isn't anything wrong with any of the food, but if you're a value-based diner (like my wife) this may leave you a little underwhelmed. However, if you are okay with the price point and what you expect to pay at the end of the night then it's a really neat local joint that really proves first impressions aren't everything. read more

Impudent Oyster - Seafood Pasta - Seafood Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

My daughters and daughter in law and I were looking for a place for Mother's Day lunch in Chatham and decided to try the Impudent Oyster . So glad we made that decision! A really cool place - cozy and seems very friendly. Our waitress Linda was a gem . She steered us right at every turn - was pleasant and knowledgeable. We started with a bottle of Rose that was very good. I got a cocktail that was lovely. My daughter got an order of clam chowder that was really delicious. I got butternut squash bisque which was lovely ;perfectly smooth. , hot and tasty . From there , I ordered the Nantucket scallop roll - omg - it was awesome! Lightly fried scallops packed in a roll topped with bacon and cheese. I was one happy camper. Daughter in law got the Pork Ban Mi which she loved . They even provided us with extra pickles!! One daughter got a Caesar and another chicken noodle soup. If I ever return to this area I will definitely go back!! read more

See all