Very busy restaurant! People waiting at the door, and I know why. There was one or two table left, and we was greeted by very nice server and showed us to our seat. But our server , Mathias- was "incredible " he gives us tips on what was good to eat, the deals to get and basically took great care of us. I had your basic Fish & chip, but not basic by any means. Rather a large piece of lightly battered fish with a great helping of fries, and I do believe the tartar sauce was homemade! My husband had the Stuffed Haddock, shrimp & scallop stuffing - to die for! Ambiance was the typical "by the sea" nevertheless packed them in! There is one thing tho I must criticize on... never , never vacuum in a space where people are eating! No no no! IDC if its a hypoallergenic vacuum- its is just not what you do! Its gross! Love the place, love Mathias- and we will be back next year to eat! read more

The Mayflower - FISH & CHIP SLAW, TARTAR SAUCE - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

See all

Old school, a little kitschy, and super cute My very first time having steamed clam bellies. Likely won't be my last. So glad they explained how to eat them cause I wouldn't have realized what that steamed cup of water was for. We also got the fried clam bellies, won't be my last time having those either. Absolutely delicious. Staff was great, especially loved the lady pouring water for everyone, she was a charm. Table turnover seemed pretty quick, but it does fill up fast in there read more

The Mayflower - Steamed clam bellies - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

Truly 'LOCAL' spot - generous portions of good food at fair prices in the middle of downtown Provincetown!

With the almost diner-type/ no-frills setup, the Mayflower has history and a classic Cape Cod charm. Located right on Commercial St buzzing with both locals and tourists, this spot served us two very satisfying meals. My husband and I are steamer fans, so coming to Ptown was like stepping into my pescatarian element. The Mayflower didn't disappoint on our 1st day. On the 2nd day, I went back specifically for their lobster roll. While it's smaller than some oversized versions I had in town, the flavor more than made up for it. The bread held up all the lobster meat and drawn butter beautifully. Hubs being the carnivore he is, settled on the broiled pork chops which he loved. The service matched the food: warm, efficient and never rushed, The seafood is fresh, portions are hearty and service was spot on. read more

See all

Old school restaurant with seafood favorites, Italian, Greek and Portuguese food. Everything here is great and reasonably priced. I had the seafood pasta and it was excellent. My wife had the baked stuffed haddock which was amazing. Fast service as well. read more

The hot lobster roll and potato salad were great, our server was attentive and kind, and the building is beautiful. Definitely check it out

Our last dinner in ptown was The Mayflower. Frankly I've never gone here and we decided to give it a shot. The Lobster Pot is always so crowded and has a long wait. Let me tell you, forget the lobster pot and hit this place up. All the servers are wonderful. The queer o meter is as all in ptown a 10+++++ and the food did not disappoint. I went the steamers and lobster route. The steamers were, I'd say about 1.5lbs and cooked to perfection. Seriously the best I've ever had, even ones I've made at home. No grit, no rubbery bits and no added flavors to the water. Steamers in their purest sense served with drawn butter. I could've eaten 5 more orders. The lobster was 1.25 lbs served with 1 side. I got rice pilaf. The rice was fine. Nothing to write home about but the lobster, again, cooked to perfection. My wife got the chicken cutlet "burger" and fries. She said they were delicious. I stole a fry and they were hot and tasty. The bloody was spot on too - I swear you can't get a bad bloody in ptown. Our waiter was the sweetest gentleman and we chatted with him a bit. Seating is spaced out nicely and comfortable. It's not fancy or glittery, but it's now going to be one of my go to spots. I can't believe it took me 25 years to finally dine at this gem. It's definitely undersold and should be a hot spot. The location is perfect too. Do yourself a favor and stop in here on your trip for fairly priced, good portions, great food and wonderful service. Cheers!! read more

See all

Great food and friendly service! Fast, efficient but not rushed. A P-town fav for the whole family

My family was ordering in tonight and my mom said that she loved the lobster casserole so we had to order from here. I ordered the 8 oz piece of chicken with vegetables and the peel shrimp appetizer. My whole family seemed to love their meals so I'm not entirely sure why my experience was different. The first mistake was that our orders were placed in the wrong to go bags and our meals were mixed up even though we said that it was important. The second mistake was that I ordered the vegetables with my chicken but they gave me the potato instead. It was the saddest and smallest piece of chicken next to a potato in foil. I seriously doubt it was 8 oz. I also didn't think it was possible for chicken to be damp unseasoned, and overcooked at the same time. It was so disappointing that I couldn't finish my food which was so unlike me. Moral of the story if you're too afraid to cook chicken, you should never cook chicken. Also a little bit of flavor never killed anyone. I am beyond happy that my shrimp was really good. It wasn't overcooked or undercooked. They also gave me a lot. I would say that next time I should just order more shrimp but we all know there isn't going to be a next time. I had to add some of my own vegetables. read more

See all

Sea food and more are great love the food and service was fantastic. Ambience makes you feel at home. Great restaurant for the whole family with different types of food from pizza, seafood, and comfort foods and don't forget their famous Portuguese kale soup. read more

See all

It's a fun diner-esque restaurant place with friendly staff and a great varied menu. Food is always really good. Not 5 stars because it's old and a little run-down and dingy. read more

The location is on the main strip in Provincetown. It's been serving seafood in PTown for a century. There was a 30 minute wait to be seated. Unfortunately, they did not offer a waiting area for patrons. There is a small bar that holds maybe 2 people. So we waited outside to be called. No texting or paging system to notify waiting patrons. Some tech upgrades would be nice. Once seated our waiter was very helpful with the menu. He got our water and beverages promptly. We ordered a lobster roll and pork chops. I really wanted to love this place but it missed the mark with the food. The lobster was over cooked and portion very small for the price. The twin pork chops were decent portion but over cooked as well. Probably will not return. read more

The Mayflower - Lobster roll - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

See all

Stopped in here for a quick bite while exploring Ptown! Our hotel recommended it to us for dinner. Service was excellent, Domanique was so nice. The food was ok but the restaurant itself seemed old. Try the clam chowder and the lobster tacos. Not important, but the bathrooms are tiny. I'm 5'6" and my knees were touching the wall. read more

The Mayflower - Lobster tacos - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

Food was good and hot. I had the manicotti it tasted like comfort food to me. My husband had the Hot lobster roll, he enjoyed it, the breading was good and the French fries too. We shared the warmed apple crumble with vanilla ice cream, it was delicious. The service was fast, staff friendly the ambience felt like you entered to a family house, the staff works very well together and they are always happy and laughing. The decor, seating, can be upgraded, is dark and the booth seat lack cushions. read more

See all

YES!! 'Just ask your helpful, most friendly waiter what to eat... My baked stuffed scallops were sweet, fresh, generous!! My friend's boneless fried chicken w/gravy was comfort and crave worthy. Attentive staff, good value. A Cape Cod staple for certain. 'Love it!! read more

The mayflower is a cute diner right on commercial street in Provincetown. I visited on a Sunday afternoon, albeit not at peak times, and there was ample seating available. The server was alacritous and eager to keep my Diet Coke filtered, which I appreciated. I ordered a beyond burger, which was well prepared and came with some delicious and crispy fries. My one small gripe is that most of the fish here is fried, and the selection seemed limited. I would have loved some baked fish or some tuna steak, but in could not find much of that on the menu. Perhaps I just missed it! Reading comprehension may not be my strong suit. read more

Food was 10/10 service by Emmett was fantastic.. he was constantly checking on water, replenishing sodas and attentive to insure a great experience!! Lucky that we sat in the backof the restaurant as it was extremely warm and diners out front had to deal with the doors opening and hot humid air coming in!!! Do stop in.. ask for Emmett and sit in the back for the most comfort!!! read more

Great food and service, always fresh! Window seats have great views of Commercial Street! read more

On a pouring rainy day, The Mayflower was accommodating and helpful to our large family. We arrived with my toddler nephews, soaking wet from the rain, and the staff was quick to help us put the stroller in a corner, grab high chairs and get the kids meals out fast! Thank you for the kindness and delicious lunch! read more

This was a wonderful place to eat for lunch. The menu has a large variety of options. I had the clam strips. They were breaded and fried perfectly. The batter was light and crunchy. The other 3 table mates got a different option on the menu. Looks like none of the options are bad options. Service was a little slow. Took a bit for the waitress to get the drink orders. And we waited a really long time (35 mins) to get the check and pay for our meals. When she took the last plate, we said we were ready to cash out. Waited... waited... waited.. it got to the point we were awkwardly sitting at the table with empty drinks and a group waiting for a table. Overall a great place to eat read more

See all

It's a good old school Ptown restaurant. Service is competent, the decor is traditional and the food is typical cape food. All that you would expect from a cape dinner out. And I mean this in a good way - we used to go with the family for many years when we would vacation in the outer cape. Always pleasant. read more

Quaint ptown restaurant. Step back in time to this family style restaurant with very reasonably priced menu ( i loved oyster tacos!) They serve their martinis in the shakers with the old fashioned martini glassesfashionedmartin read more

Classic Cape Cod comfort food. Where the local eat. Comfy diner atmospher and friendly service. Menu a New England mix of American and local comfort food, Portuguese and local seafood with some Italian thrown in. The quality was better than the casual surrounding suggest. Salad green very fresh, ice tea house brewed and my Mozomambqiue chicken deliciously home style. read more

The Mayflower - Macambique Chicken - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

Stopped in here June 19tg, 2024 after having completed our P2P 84 mile bicycle ride. Our waiter was engaging and very pleasant with a great sense of humor. I had a delicious club sandwich with fries and it was cooked perfectly. Nice clean bathrooms and well AC'd dine if area. Didn't see any outside sesting read more

Ate here twice while visiting Provincetown. The service is excellent. We had seafood for dinner: fried shrimp, fried scallops and chowder. Yum! Went back today for lunch, again had excellent service, enjoyed chicken Parmesan and Eggplant Parmesan with Apple Crisp for desert. Delicious! read more

See all

My family and I have come here for our annual trips for the last five years. Every time we are able to get seated pretty much right away. This year it was especially empty which was slightly sad to see. For our entrées we ordered a lasagna, chicken fingers and french fries, seafood casserole, eggplant Parmesan, kale soup, and Salisbury steak. As always the food comes out hot and fresh. Everyone loved their dishes. This was the first time I had a fresh as opposed to frozen Salisbury steak dinner, and let me say I will never be able to look at those the same anymore. The steak was cooked medium and was served with a thick flavorful gravy. I was happy I opted for the velvety mashed potatoes as opposed to French fries as the gravy elevated the dish. The chicken tenders were crispy and moist with the tasty French fries. Pickle was crisp and fresh. My mom loved her seafood casserole as well and my friends and their dishes. Staff is as friendly as ever. We loved our waiter Steve as he was hilarious and personable. Given the quality of food and the price we will always come back again. read more

See all

While in P-town, we stumbled across this GEM! Great selection of food, specials and prices were great. We had the honor of getting Martin as our server. He was awesome. Marin was friendly, knowledgeable on the menu, and was a pleasure to talk to as we had asked him for a locals perspective on the area. He offered great drink suggestions and checked over our order before he put it into the kitchen. Once our food arrived he was attentive, filled our water often and always had a smile on his face. Our food was fantastic. I had the lobster salad plate and my bf had the surf and turf with lobster. If we find ourselves back in town we will be sure to seek out The Mayflower once again! Thank you Martin! read more

Came on a Wednesday night with a group of friends and was mediocrely enthused. I ordered a bowl of the New England clam chowder and was disappointed overall. The flavor was missing overall, as were the clams, I could count with one hand how many were in the bowl. For dinner, I ordered a hot lobster roll which was incredibly dry. I had to request not one but two sides of melted butter to enhance the roll to expectation, however delicious the fries and coleslaw were. I would avoid this place moving forward with how much money I spent for a mediocre meal, however it was a staple based on Ptown recommendations. read more

The Mayflower - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

Good diner food. Fast and friendly service. Kept clean. Food was good. Recommend to anyone visiting. read more

See all

great fish tacos, great seafood in general, local institution, authentic vibe, great prices

Three of us popped in for lunch after church and we all enjoyed what we had: Portuguese sloppy joe, cubano and the cheeseburger club. A unique spot in the busy commercial street area with good service. read more

Solid 3-3 and 1/2 star experience last night. I've been walking by the Mayflower for years and just never made it in. Staff is great-friendly, efficient and funny. There were three of us and it was still pretty early...so we were told to sit wherever we'd like. The staff actually made the meal...we enjoyed all of our interactions with them. Appetizers: the steamers were very good with plenty to share. The baked clam was just ok...super thick and bready with not many clam pieces...but I was hungry and it was a solid portion. Dinner: my companions had the lobster special (1 and a quarter pound) served with a side of choice (baked potato); I had the baked seafood casserole. The lobsters were cooked well and the baked potatoes were just right. My seafood casserole (a few scallops, one shrimp and a nice serving of white fish...cod??...can't recall)...all served piping hot with a "ritz cracker" buttery crust. Decent...a little greasy for my taste and definitely had lots of sodium (based on how much water I retained overnight!). We stuck with soft drinks but there is a nice assortment of adult beverages to choose from. Desserts were tempting but no room this time. Casual, diner-ish atmosphere with a great location in the center of town. The menu is extensive and it's a great place to go with a group of folks that have different hankerings/tastes. read more

See all

This restaurant is a classic. If you are looking for a Provincetown restaurant with history and amazing seafood come here! The staff is so amazing and always helpful with recommendations or a little local story. I make this a must for my own and others trips! read more

Our wait was very short, our waiter was extremely friendly and very polite. Food was perfectly cooked and served hot. Bathrooms are clean but very tiny. I would love to return and try another one of their offerings. read more

Decided on this place after eating a little too many lobster rolls in town. We got the seafood bake casserole under the recommendation of a nice lady we meat on the street and the chicken Parm. While the chicken Parm was tasty aside from the bland spaghetti with tomatoes sauce on the side, I say the seafood bake casserole was to be missed. The casserole came with fish, two shrimps and 3 small scallops. read more

The Mayflower - Wall - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

The booths aren't big enough for six people to sit comfortably. For $4.99, I ordered garlic bread with cheese as an appetizer and it was a huge loaf---what a deal! It tasted excellent: toasted golden brown, buttery, garlicky, and gluteny, just the way I like it! A no-brainer if you want a filling appetizer good to share (I barely shared). For $11.99, I also ordered a grilled chicken sandwich on a bulkie roll (plain, boring sandwich bun), and the whole thing was bland as bland can be. The fries were unsalted, extremely plain, and tasteless. The only thing that had taste on that plate was the pickle. Seriously. Avoid. The service was fairly standard and satisfactory---nothing too memorable. If I returned, I would order the garlic bread again but a different entree. read more

The Mayflower - Garlic bread with cheese - New American Near Me - Provincetown, Massachusetts

See all

While I have had a good Italian meal there, I tried one of their Portuguese seafood specials. I was hoping for something special since the owners are Portuguese, nope! Nearly $30 for 5 severely overcooked shrimp, and it was their "Camarao Mocambique special". I don't think I've actually ever eaten more rubbery shrimp. And they charged me because I ate the rice and fries. Mentioned it to the waiter and sent back some of 2/5 shrimp... he didn't seem to care. read more

Definitely try the fish parmigiana! It's delicious and not something you can find at another establishment. The staff is so friendly and the decor is cute! Definitely not a place you'll want to overlook when you're in Provincetown. read more

Excellent service, food, atmosphere for multiple party sizes and families Great food portions and Portuguese recipes as well read more

We love to come to Provincetown every year on vacation, and we always make it a point to go to the Portuguese bakery across the street, and the Mayflower Café. Why? To be honest, the Mayflower Café in the Portuguese bakery are two of the more reasonably priced places in town where you can grab a meal... But the Mayflower café is more than that. They have a classic American diner style menu, the portions are good sized, the food is tasty and the wait staff is very very friendly. In fact, when I do odd requests, like I asked to add onions to a salad? they smile and comply very quickly and easily with no friction at all to strange orders. That's always a plus to people like me who like things just a little bit different. So overall after you feel like you've been spending too much money in other places in Provincetown, try this. We especially recommend their Portuguese kale soup! You may find that there are different kinds of Portuguese kale soup's in the town.... it's a local dish. Mayflower's is tasty, and more brothy; keep trying all of them as you wander about town. read more