Staying in Sag Harbor for a couple nights and had a craving for a burger. LT Burger was within walking distance. We walked in one door and it was completely empty, there was a little hallway to another part of the restaurant and a sign pointing to a hostess stand. There was no one at the hostess stand and a few patrons eating. We stood there for a while awkwardly not sure if we should seat ourselves or not. Finally, after no acknowledgment we left and went to our hotel room. We couldn't decide on any other option so we called and placed a pick up order. Went to pick it up and they forgot the milkshake. Nachos were really soggy. Burger was dry. The milkshake was really good. 2 burgers with fries, nachos, and a milk shake = $60. Perhaps the food would have been better at the restaurant but still can't get over the complete lack of acknowledgment. read more

Kills me to give one star. Sunday morning place half full. Service horrendous. Took 30 minutes for cup Of coffee served with no spoon, milk or sugar. Mimosa took 40 minutes Chai latte came after food came. Food was cold and was terrible. No reason for service Like this in a restaurant half full. No servers smiled bad experience and I am a local. What a shame. BRING BACK BAY BURGER. Ed's stinks as well read more

We have been LT fans for a decade, but something has gone awry in the last year and half -- maybe two years -- since their longstanding manager left. Even worse this fall/winter in the off season. Inattentive, slow service -- moldy burger buns!! -- just not the special place it was. I hope that this is just a lull and that the good ol LT, with first rate burgers, five start service and all the plusses that make the prices worth it comes back soon. I love LT and hope to see you again. read more

I don't get all they hype this place receives. After reading about it in an NY Times article, I figured we were in for some seriously great burgers. To me, it was just average and lacking just a bit of extra somethin'. The Mexican is very, very messy. Like get your Yelp bib out with a fork and knife messy. Unfortch, they forgot the avocado on it but I was so hungry I ate it without saying anything. (I would have spouted off angry expletives if they had taken it away from me!) My husband's LT burger was requested medium but hit the table well done. Again, we should have said something and requested it be redone, but he was just as hungry as I was. When shelling out $14 for a burger you want it right the first time. The fried pickles could be better - they had way too much breading on them. However, get extra ranch dressing. It's out of this world awesome. They're one of few places in town that stay open late. We were surprised to walk right in at 8:30pm on a Friday night. AND, we were sat immediately with no reservations... shocking for the Hamptons. read more

Wow, I was looking forward to eating at this restaurant but the staff or more so, who I think was the manager, was a real ... shall I say it.... d*ck head. 2 times I had this experience. I'm surprised the owner lets this person represent the restaurant. He really seems to be put out by customers and is very expressive when things aren't going right. Keep that stuff back-of-house buddy. He should get another job that he doesn't seem to hate. Breakfast was poor. Eggs had zero flavor and the potatoes were just plain weird in their texture. read more

Burger amazing. Great quality angus beef. 2.) I applaud young people working. Hats off to getting them off the couch and off their iPhones to actually work for the summer. BUT. It is and was chaos The kids need direct and focus. The ice cream girl the host but most important each girl should PRE shift have their hair tied up and in a bun or pulled back not while on their busy shift. read more

LT Burger is a new spot in Sag Harbor, which takes over the merry-go-round space formerly occupied by Mambo Jambo. Owned by the LT of BLT fame, this burger joint is located on Main Street in one of the prettiest towns in NY and I gave it a try last Saturday night. Here's the rundown: The PROS + 3: The burgers are freaking awesome. All are 7 ounces of certified Angus beef, a combo of sirloin, short rib, chuck and brisket. Served on a sesame seed bun, they are close to perfection. + 2: Spiked milkshakes! I think this is a new phenomenon. But anytime you mix Oreo ice cream and tequila it can't be a bad thing. + 1: The wraparound bar, big overhead wire fans and incandescent hanging lights give LT Burger a cool retro vibe, and the crowd is Hamptons, yes, but completely casual and both kid/adult friendly. + 1: Three Kinds of fries - thin, waffle and sweet potato (my personal recommendation). + 1: Ms Pac Man up front if you're waiting for a table.... The Cons - 1: Not a huge fan of the bartender. After grabbing a seat at the bar, I waited for at least 7 minutes before he even looked my way. Total pet peeve of mine. And then after ordering a beer, it took another 5 minutes for him to pour it. And then he snarled at me when I asked for the beer...WTH? Customer service... - 3: Christie Brinkley's autograph is on the wall near the front -- me thinks that's not too cool. Overall LT Burger is definitely a winner -- for the burgers alone -- and I'll be hitting it again sometime soon. Just hoping for a better seat at the bar. read more

Overpriced seems like a place tourists/ city people go to. It's in a great location and fun looking inside but definitely needs an improvement. read more

This place is terrible. I wish I could have an opinion of the food, but I've been sitting at my table in an uncrowded restaurant for about an hour food-less. They have nice drink selections, is that why they're making me wait? To get drunk off boozy lemonade and forget about wasting the day away? In what world does it take an hour to cook a burger? Sorry but this is the third time I've come here and I'm not coming back. Don't waste your time! read more

Lucky enough to have a friend in the Hamptons, but I now I am even luckier, I ate an LT Burger in Sag Harbor. We split a Seven Peppercorn and Mountain Blue burger. Angus beef. Madeira mushrooms, and cartelized onions and a bun that reminded me of challah. The burger was light and incredibly juicy. It was clear that no one had idiotically pressed it down with a spatula. The burger came with excellent skin-on fries and we ordered a side of slaw. The serving size was very ample. The slaw was slightly sweet with a dose of vinegar and a bit of "kick". The restaurant is very attractive- white tile with writing on the walls- subway chic. I would eat here again in a minute. Prices... NY style but worth every penny. Glad we shared. I am already dreaming of my return. read more

Phenomenal burgers and outrageously good milk shakes. They have "R-Rated" milk shakes, which are just another Long Island excuse to put booze in something. I was a little put off by the decor... The place seemed really hipster when we walked in... But I absolutely didn't care when my shake arrived. I wish the shakes were bigger, but they probably just saved me from myself. Our waiter was fantastic. The burgers are juicy and delicious. An absolute gem. read more

Revisited LT Burger on a slow night in the spring. It was crowded but the service was terrible. What I really want to talk about is that we were served SPOILED FOOD! Cole slaw was sour and the dairy had obviously expired, the meat in the chicken was cheap quality and was full of veins, sinew, and cartilage and most of all it had MSG in it. I broke out in a rash, and my husband and I vomited and went to the bathroom ALL NIGHT. Do not go! read more

I finally got around to checking this place out, and it was pretty good overall. With my timing being what it is, I arrived during the unfortunate period between breakfast and lunch. They only serve pastries, shakes, and coffee shop items during those dreaded 30 minutes, so I didn't get to try one of their aptly named burgers (the Dirty Chicken burger sounded particularly appetizing). After a solid 12 seconds of studying the menu, I settled on the French Toast shake. It's basically every kid's dream: a soupy blend of soggy Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal with vanilla ice cream and syrup. It really hit the spot, though I'll probably get it without the whipped cream on top next time. My only complaint is that the serving size was very small for a $10 shake. The young lady that helped me was very cheerful and friendly, and I'm hoping to have a similar experience with the staff during my next visit. I'm looking forward to updating this review after trying out a burger or three. read more

Only 2Stars for the politeness of the staff....the food has declined after a few more visits. My original visit was amazing but there is just not enough consistency here for the price... read more

Best burger and shake in the Hamptons! Bring the kids and relax. You'll be a regular in no time. read more

Came here for lunch during the off season, so there wasn't a wait at all for my girlfriend and I. The atmosphere is warm, light and inviting: wood floors, white tile walls and an open dining area. My girlfriend and I split the nut milkshake and an order of waffle fries. When we first try a burger place we tend to stick to the basic burger, so we both ordered the Standard which was cooked medium well for both of us - even though I ordered medium, not that big of a deal. The burgers are 7oz, just short of a half pound, and were enough food for the both of us, and combined with the milkshake - Nutella and almonds - we walked out full and happy. My only issue was the price, although it is the Hamptons and I expect to pay more, $11 for a standard burger without cheese is a little steep - it wasn't the best burger, but it was good and I would recommend it. The milkshakes are by far the most expensive, but like I said, could be split between two people - ours was $9. The full price of our meal was about $35 and I would recommend it for someone looking for a good burger and fries in the Hamptons, especially in the off season when so few businesses are open at all. read more

This is the quaint burger shack that everyone wants at the beach. Industrial fans hang from the ceilings and specials are written along the white plastic brick walls. The staff is very friendly and the prices are very REASONABLE for the hamptons. Best yet, they don't take reservations so just walk in on a night your bonfire gets rained out vs. not having a hot reservation to fall back on. The food is good. Predominantly burgers with some seafood mixed in (ie, lobster roll specials). The Backyard Burger is my go to and the Fried Pickles are a MUST (the smoked/spicy russian dressing makes it). Friend loved the veggie burger too. The New England Clam Chowder was not all they hyped it up to be (apparently voted #1 in the hamptons by some one). The shakes are good too, although very heavy. Had the Oreo one and it was essentially a meal. Definitely a casual meal winner for the hamptons, although may be expensive for take-out. read more

Too bad this review isn't completely on food. The food here is great (it deserves 5 stars), perfect for kids old and young. I'm gluten free and vegan-ish and I always am satisfied. Burgers for everyone, sweet potato fries, lettuce wraps for the sans-bun people and fabulous shakes that include R-rated choices for the 21 & over crowd. The service is without a doubt the worst service in Sag Harbor. When you order ask for your check at the same time because you won't see your waiter again. I've eaten here about ten times busy or (today at lunch) empty and it's always the same. Lots of workers, they all look happy, they smile a lot....don't know what the issue is. read more

I had high hopes, took a look inside in August, brought a menu home, decided to come back when the tourists went home. So, we went this weekend. Is the food bad? No, it's ok. Is the service bad? Yeah, not so good. The waiters were grouped behind the counter complaining about a no show manager. Our food took nearly 30 minutes to be served, just 2 burgers and chicken tenders. The kids shake was served in a glass to a toddler. We overheard that they only had 5 highchairs, so customers were waiting for highchairs to become available, even though there were plenty of tables open. My suggestions: you serve hamburgers, do it faster, do it with more imagination, how about some seasonal toppings, also families are attracted to burger places...... be ready for them. Buy 5 more highchairs, get some paper cups with tops for the kids, how about some crayons or other entertainment for the kids. And, oh yeah, please sweep the floor more regularly. If lunch for 3 is going to cost me $45 I don't want to see what the last diners ate on the floor around my table. read more

Burgers are great Shakes are great Seating not so so great You will be basically be shoulder to shoulder with strangers and the food is messy so you will 100% feel very uncomfortable eating here. So as good as the food and shakes are the seating arrangements just aren't worth it unless you are lucky enough to get the 2 seating areas in the corners where you don't have to eat dinner/lunch with your friends/family plus strangers. True Story: The seating area was so tight that the waitress started asking a complete stranger next to me their order until we awkwardly had to say that he wasn't with our party...So awkward. If you're going to go, go on a slow day..and only a slow day....aka never..so basically..don't go. read more

We tried LT burger early in the season very disorganized on a busy Sunday. I ordered the clam chowder, the menu stated it was the best in the area. When it was delivered to the table it was potato soup it had no clams in it. It took about 15 minutes to get the waitress she took it back to the kitchen and the chef did come out apologize saying they ad the clams after its made and they had forgotten to put the clams in. In the mean time the rest of the party had finished there lunch and my chowder had not made it back to the table. Just as we were leaving (this was my main course) they returned with the chowder it had been reheated in a microwave and was curdled. I paid and left. Yesterday we decided to give it another shot it was a Wednesday at about 2pm so we thought maybe they were just overwhelmed the first time. I ordered a hamburger to play it safe my husbands burger came out with a cockroach smashed against the french fry tin. We were absolutely shocked and sicken. The waitress took it to the back with attitude and basically wiped it off brought the same fries back with out an apology or" what can we do to make this right". We left and did pay but I will never set foot back in there again. read more

I've enjoyed eating at LT Burger many times as the food is usually tasty and doesn't break the bank quite as much as other options in Sag. I'm giving them one star for their lack of consideration in updating their hours. Some family and I stopped by after a movie yesterday (the day after Labor Day) and the restaurant was closed, despite being listed as open online. Nobody was there to answer the phone either and no hours were listed on a voicemail. Others walked by while we were there and they were equally as disappointed (we had chatted outside the building). Only crappy businesses can't even be bothered to updated their hours. It really can't be that difficult. read more

Usually it is not half bad, and deccent service, for the Hamptons. I was totally ignored in the cafe today, i was next in line, ordered an ice chai, then the lady decided fo serve the next guest and complete his transaction first...... while I stood there in much confusion, WHAT? I went elsewhere. read more

Oh yeah. Outstanding burgers brought to you by the 'LT' of 'BLT' fame. Incredible shakes (including with alcohol if you so desire). Classic fifties diner style but the food is updated to reflect today's trends (and portion sizes). Pricing is quite high, but the place is very good. read more

I went here to have lunch with a friend. The atmosphere is very nice and cozy. The service was friendly and attentive. The food was mediocre and the prices were INSANE (and that says something, because I'm from California where everything tends to be pricey). I got a burger. It was not bad, but it wasn't great either. Middle of the road. For FOURTEEN dollars, it should have come with a side. Yes, it was ONLY a burger on a plate with nothing else. To add insult to injury, the tomato was one of the most unripe I have seen in my entire life (pale pale pink) and the lettuce was iceberg. Iceberg, really? My friend had a falafel sandwich. It was also mediocre (You could do much better by spending a couple of bucks at a Mediterranean food truck. Seriously.) We also got onion rings which were good (but not outstanding, and I wouldn't be surprised if they were frozen from a bag). The milkshake was really yummy, but honestly, can you f-ck up a milkshake? I mean it's kind of hard not to like fat and sugar that tastes like chocolate. Beer and wine was also $$$$. $6.00 for an Amstel Light? Jesus Christ, I can get a pint of local microbrew beer back in California for $4.50! For the $40+ bill that we had (for LUNCH! with no alcohol!), I would expect the food to be a lot fresher, tastier, handmade, local and organic. It was identified as none of these. Honestly, I can get a better burger at IN-N-OUT for $4. If you are a millionaire who likes mediocre food, then by all means, go here and make the owners millionaires, too. If not, save your money and go somewhere nice in the city. read more

Disappointing on every level. We did take out and: the burgers and fries were almost cold when I arrived PRIOR to the time they said the order would be ready; the burgers were so undercooked that we had to deconstruct them and continue cooking them at home; and the order didn't include beverages and fries that we had paid for. So essentially, the fact is that this was an overpriced ripoff. read more

Came here for happy hour margaritas and... burgers! (duh). You know when you're just craving red meat? I just got the happy hour slider at the bar and it fulfilled the desire! When you walk in you are transported from Sag Harbor into a subway-tile-lined diner complete with booths, a fireplace, neon lights, great smells, and charm. They have a bar complete with taps, milkshakes with booze, and a menu with options! I'll definitely be back to try the array of burgers they offer (chicken/veggie etc). The bar area was packed for happy hour, and everything that came out of the kitchen looked fried and delicious. Margs were strong, bartender smiley, slider was larger than expected and cooked perfectly. Fries were crunchy on the outside, soft in the inside, and delicious! Lost a star for how hot it was in there... For some reason Yelp is not allowing me to post a photo at this time, I'll try later! read more

LT Burger - Happy hour slider... Pretty large patty for a slider!! - Burgers Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Service is slow as fuck, I got nachos before salad and waiters don't listen they brought the wrong food when asked for a specific directions for what to put on it. Overall wouldn't come here again read more

Came in late Sunday evening for a quick bite. Our server Tom was great! I was torn between the tuna or the standard burger. Tom suggested the tuna and by was I happy!!!! The tuna steak was prepared they way I asked and the fries were oh so good! The tuna steak though I must say all the components were spot on so as not to outshine the fish. My friend had the burger with bacon and the Gouda fries! He, like myself savored every bite. The only reason I gave them two stars- the kitchen apparently forgot our order and we waited for over an hour before being served. Again, if it wasn't for Tom, we would have just left. read more

Great burgers! Really great. Service is good. Loud enough to bring your whole loud family (which we have). There is an Oreo Shake that is pure sin. Then, there a deep fried Oreo dessert that tastes like a doughnut with a wonderful surprise inside. Good times. read more

I paid something in the vicinity of 15 bucks for a ceasar salad, I was working and got it to go . It was romaine lettuce with a shot glass sized cup of dressing and some Romano sprinkled on the floor of the styrofoam container. The tall lanky kid with wavy long hair at the to go counter was completely obnoxious and it looked all the servers were miserable as I was watching the body language of people being served on the patio . I am a year round customer on the east end and when February comes id gladly give my money to Bay Burger instead of this over priced pretentious dump !!! read more

Family friendly and in the center of town. Make a reservation while you are en route. Stay away on Friday and Saturday nights. This is a place worth several visits. read more

Great food and service but the prices are ABSURD. I understand it's the Hamptons but my burger was $16, which is about normal, and an extra $3 for two thin slices of avocado. Also, their shakes are $8-$18. $8 isn't bad but why are some $18? I don't care how fancy or tasty it is; that is just too much. If they can find a way to decrease their prices, especially $2 for a slice of cheese and $3 for bacon or avocado, then they will be five stars in my opinion. Nice job controlling Covid, though. They have distanced barriers between each table, which is very safe. read more

I was there on a weekend...it was so busy I took a spot at the bar and was glad I did. Great bartender and selection of burgers. This place has a mid-century diner vibe with a beach bar attitude. read more

LT Burger - The smoked stack! A perfectly cooked burger with just the right combination of smoky, spicy sweet savoriness - Burgers Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

As far as burger places go, this place is near the top of my list. I had the Mexican burger, which was bursting with flavor. The chili and the jalapenos really took it to the next level. I also had the waffle fries which tasted great but they could have given you more for the $4.75 price tag. The only knock i would have against this place is that the service was slow as a result of being overcrowded. And they should give you more fries for the price. read more

Wifey and me had two egg white omelets. Had to ask for everything twice. It was a Sunday morning and our first night in town. I will say the help was inattentive but still pleasant enough. Had to send back the maple syrup sausages as undercooked. Omelets were huge and the toast had loads of salty butter. I must say overall the breakfast was delicious! But 43 bucks for breakfast(for two). I left 7 dollars despite the suggestion at the bottom of the bill. read more

Great food, delicious shakes, decent staff. Sometimes you'll have a weird experience with the service, but whatever, it's a burger place. Fries are great. Shakes are really good but kind small. Food is always prepared well. Atmosphere is inviting and family friendly. Don't expect a nice quiet dinner here. read more

Not a bad burger but way over priced but hey, it's the Hamptons. I had the backyard burger, done rare. It came out medium rare, but close enough. The bacon added a nice smoky flavor. The shoestring fries were excellently done. Fun drinks selections and a decent house red of good value. Good service... pleasant surroundings... not a bad place. You can get just as good burger at Five Guys at half the price, but hey, as I've said....it's the Hamptons. Besides, you can't get a beer at Five Guys. read more

This is a follow up to my 9/15/2014 review. At that time my compalin was only about the annoying little brats at a restaurant where the bar is the focal point. Things, alas, have gotten worse. The prices have gone up and the portions have become miniscule. Ordered the heirloom tomato salad for $15 topped with a burger for $7. The salad barely filled 1/4 of the bowl. Beware bartender Sarah may not pour any liquor in your drink. We both ordered soda with lemon vodkas. But we could not taste any liquor. We asked Sarah and she said she would give us "more" and proceeded to open a brand new bottle. There was one bottle of lemon vodka and it was unopened.Thanks to the manager who reversed the charges but still it ruined a nice night dealing with this. read more

I had been to LT Burger twice before and as reviews on this site have indicated, service/management has been its weakness. But I live in the area and love a good burger so I gave it another try yesterday. I have to tell everyone that service has improved greatly. It was seamless. We went for a late lunch (well, I had lunch and my husband had brunch) and even at 3pm the restaurant was still very busy but we were sat immediately by the hostess. The room is very open, airy and fun. Our order was taken quickly, drinks arrived fast and the food appeared in less than 15 minutes. The operation was carefully supervised by the manager, who introduced himself as Daniel. He came to our table (and most other tables from what we could see) and asked if everything was satisfactory and could he do anything for us. He was very personably and talked with us leisurely for a few minutes about questions that we had. Other reviewers had commented that management was nasty but Daniel must be new because he was great and you could see that he had a dedication to the smooth operation of the restaurant. Congratulations on LT Burger hitting its stride and we look forward to coming again and bringing our friends. read more