I have tried quite a few lobster rolls around the hamptons over the years but this is still my favorite. This place gets pretty busy on the weekends and I wish they did ordering through the website because sometimes its hard to get an order on the phone during peak hours. Limited seating, but very cute and on the water. Tried the clam chowder as they won the contest in Sag Harbor and it did not disappoint. read more

I've now been here twice. Sag's town is by far my favorite and I think this is a wonderful component to it. The location is right on the dock down the water. There is minimal seating but it is easy to take their stuff to go. It's super casual but delicious. The lobster roll is one of the best I've had out in the Hamptons, a classic cold lobster roll. The fries are also great. I've tried the clam strips, they are good but nothing to run to. I don't know if I would get again I would definitely rather try something new. I've sent other people here off recommendation and would continue to. read more

The Dock House - Fries, clam chowder, lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

My usual lobster roll spot is closed on Wednesdays, so I tried the Dock House today and had a good experience. They serve cold lobster salad rolls, not hot buttered lobster rolls. Mine had plenty of lobster meat and tasted great. I really enjoyed it. This is a casual spot with a few tables. The harbor view is pretty from the windows inside. You order at the counter, then grab your food when ready and seat yourself. You can also take your order to go and find a place outside to sit if they get busy, but I didn't have that issue. My food came out quickly, and the cashier was friendly and efficient. This is not a fancy place, but it is convenient, quick, and has tasty seafood! read more

Delicious cold lobster rolls overflowing with a generous amount of lobster. Comes with a bag of chips. The clam strips are very good. Comes with waffle fries or a salad. The tarter sauce is very good. A very nice lady was at the register. You order and they call your number when the order is ready. We had 3 lobster rolls and 2 orders of clam strips. 5 drinks (iced teas). All in $200. We were lucky to grab a table for lunch. Great timing. read more

The Dock House - Clam strips with waffle fries - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

See all

This is not a place you go for the ambience, but you go there for great seafood! The Dock House is quite small, with only a few tables inside and outside. But it's on the dock where all the massive yachts park and there are plenty of benches on which to sit and eat. We got the lobster rolls, which were brimming with meat! Hardly any mayonnaise, just really great seafood. The New England Clam Chowder is excellent and creamy, not runny like some places. The shrimp cocktail is also good. You can't beat a place that serves seafood right from its own waters! You can also buy fresh fish to cook at home. read more

See all

A bunch of phony reviews giving this place 5 stars. Easily the worst lobster roll in the Hamptons. Old management a decade ago had this place in check. Overpriced and mediocre now. AVOID read more

Delicious lobster roll that hit the spot!! They don't do warm, only pre-mixed cold. And it's pricey but good seafood always is. read more

The Dock House - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Better food than Lunch. This place has the best clam strips I have ever had. There was so much meat inside. The lobster roll definitely ranks in the top 3 best lobster rolls in the hamptons. Just as good as Clam Bar and Bostwicks The ambiance is extremely casual. read more

Checking out the Long Island scene, we stopped at the Long Wharf... boats everywhere! We wanted to try a lobster roll and New England clam chowder, so went to the Dock House, ordered both and wow, so good! The lobster roll was packed with lobster, and very little filler, with the perfect amount of mayo! And the clam chowder did not disappoint! Definitely recommend stopping in! read more

See all

So promising based on the reviews and the big fresh-looking menu, but underwhelming in my experience. Clam chowder - watery and not a ton of flavor. Everyone from miles around has clam chowder and a 'special' recipe. IMO, it's not in evidence here. Not enough clams, and not enough body to the soup. Not sure how they were 'Voted Best'. The scallops sounded good in reviews. When I asked about them at Dock House, they mentioned the fried version, which is battered and fried. It ever there way to hide the flavor of scallops, I'd think that would be it. Instead, the Grilled Marinated Sea Scallops seemed a better fit. I ordered that but was disappointed. The scallops were a bit overcooked, for one thing. The marinade was like spicy brown sauce, sitting on top of the scallops, which themselves sat on a baguette. If you look at the menu online, it mentions the baguette very clearly. For the record, it is listed inside on their big menu, if not as prominently. I never touched the baguette as it struck me as hard to taste the scallops. The waffle fries are good, a bit greasy and have an engaging salty flavor. Was this dish horrible? No. Can I recommend? No. It's a charming place inside. Nice little view of the harbor, if you sit by the window. They're closed a couple days of the week. Would I ever try them again? Sure. But I'm not in a rush. read more

See all

I came to The Dock House to see if the lobster roll here is as good as everybody says it is. The lobster roll was packed with fresh lobster and was scrumptious, especially because I squeezed some fresh lemon juice from a lemon wedge that came on the side. Lemons and lobster are a winning combination because they have an affinity for one another. One brings out the flavor of the other. The lobster roll is served on a grilled hot dog potato bun. I did not care for the bun because the potato bread poorly counteracted the flavor of the lobster. I would have preferred a toasted New England-style (split top) hot dog bun. So I ate just the lobster salad. The lobster roll costs $35.79, but they added a "chkot fee" of $1.25 for paying with a debit or credit card. So my bill came out to $37.04. Thom explained that the surcharge "covers the transactions". I also purchased some corn mango salad. That costs $11.50 per pound, and it was made with fresh local corn and tropical mangoes. It was refreshing, and I liked it a lot. There are many spaces for vehicles to park on the wharf. They are in company with yachts that dock on the marina surrounding The Dock House. I can see how the popular seafood shack got its name. I highly recommend that foodies stop by here. The menu has plenty else to offer besides lobster rolls: fish tacos, steamers, fried calamari, chowder and more. Long-time Hampton residents tell me that they come to The Dock House for "the best lobster roll this side of Maine". Robin, the manager, told me that shipments of live freshly-caught lobster are delivered each week from Maine. Check out The Dock House's website, dockhouseny.com. They are open daily from May to October. I give it four stars because of the unnecessary transaction fee. read more

See all

Good golly -- this lobster roll was everything I imagined it would be. Incredible fresh and a ton of meat inside, you'll be dreaming about it for days. Ooo, don't forget to order a side of clam chowder as well! You won't regret it! The young lady working the register was a sweetheart as well. Great customer service, laid back atmosphere and fabulous seafood, be sure to check them out! read more

See all

They DO NOT serve a lobster roll. what they serve is a LOBSTER SALAD on a roll. Lobster rolls are lobster and butter and brioche bun. The Dock House uses mere crumbs of lobster, mixed with tons of chopped celery, some scallions, and gobs of mayonaise....NOT A LOBSTER ROLL. read more

Visited The Dock House this past weekend for perfection on a compostable plate! My Lobster Roll was delicious, perfectly everything with a squeeze of lemon. I removed the chips, as I had no interest in them. 10/10! The service was quick and friendly. Don't look to languish too long, as there are only two small tables and a bar inside for sitting and eating. Everything was excellent! read more

The Dock House - Lobster Roll! - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Quaint spot on Sag Harbors wharf, doesn't look like much from the outside but their food is great! This is a must try for your summer spots as it is now closed for the season. Quality seafood done right, the crab cakes were moist and some of the best I've ever had. The grilled tuna was a generous portion and cooked to perfect temperature. The menu is huge and has something for every seafood lover but if you don't like seafood don't worry they have a burger and even a beyond burger for our non-meat eaters! Check it out and don't forget to grab a South Fork Blondid for dessert. read more

See all

Came here for lunch. Super friendly staff. Great view. Small restaurant with a little seating inside. We order a lobster roll with was $35. It was okay. The soft shell crab was my favorite. It was so meaty! Their waffle fries taste great as well. The fried baby scallops was perfect. We also ordered a kids chicken fingers and the was okay. They have tons of fries but like two small pieces of chicken. For the price i wish the pieces of chicken was a tad bigger. read more

See all

3.5 stars, rounding up to 4 because the staff was very sweet and the restaurant is on the harbor with beautiful sunset views. Would recommend the lobster roll ($35), which was packed with lobster and had celery and red onions for a nice crunch and texture. The clam chowder was also quite good and had a lot of fresh seafood. I would not recommend the fish tacos, which were around $20 for 2 tacos with a small piece of fried fish - dry and cannot compare to fish tacos in NYC.. the seafood platters were also just okay, pretty average fried food and overpriced for what it is. read more

The Dock House - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

This place is AMAZING , Fried Clam sandwich by far the BEST one I had in years .... Shrimp tacos and fresh calamari, SO Good . , casual anytime of the day ! Just go ... I promise you will thank me later .... read more

Pros: fairly good selection of fresh sea food, cooked the way you like. Cons: completely insane lines at lunch time, and no place to eat the actual food (the few tables they do have fill up very quickly). Overall, this place is great for a quick snack by yourself but if you are with a group - you luck may vary. read more

Placed a pick up order on a weekend for a lobster, along with a couple dishes for some friends. Unfortunately the miserable weather during the Memorial Day weekend prevented us from being able to stay and enjoy the location, which seems to be the highlight of The Dock House. 1-1/4 lb lobster - 2.5/5. It was not horrible, but overcooked a bit to the point where the meat was fairy tough and chewy. Was expecting more for the reviews of this place. On the plus side, the ~$32 price seemed fair given the high lobster prices in NYC (not sure about the Sag Harbor area generally) Leaving a 3 star review because I would go back, if only to see all the hype about the location. Definitely would not order the same item however. Maybe try the lobster roll that seems to be all the craze read more

The Dock House - 1-1/2 lb lobster - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Food was amazing, great place to try top-notch seafood. The service was quick and friendly, they answered the couple questions I had about the menu and sent me in the direction of the lobster roll and it was amazing!! 100% worth the price, your getting good quality seafood, and you can tell!! Cute place located right on the water with welcoming staff, a great place to visit if you're in the area!! read more

The Dock House - lobster roll :) - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Amazing lobster rolls, probably the best I've ever had! Perfect ratio of lobster and mayo and will come back for sure! I flew all the way from South Korea just for these lobster rolls read more

The Dock House - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

I was in search of a great lobster roll, and I think I found the best one Long Island has to offer. The seafood in LI is decent but nowhere as good as you'll get in Maine. I tried the lobster rolls, shrimp tacos, and fish tacos. The fish tacos were my favorite of the three. The lobster roll was good enough but something about the flavor was lacking but portion was good and taste enjoyable. read more

Hands down the best lobster roll in all of the Hamptons. They have the meat to bun ratio done perfectly read more

The Dock House - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

This place is the good stuff... If you're looking for a real dock house seafood fish house lobster roll shrimp Poboy clams and knuckles taste of the sea chips on the side french fries indoors salty dog eared pages of a Captains log hot feet cold planks pirates in the bathroom cole slaw not whole slaw high tops low cost (this is actually pretty pricey but it's Sag Harbor in the summer) friend ships AND friend ships... This is not your spot. Just kidding. It's all this and more and I love nothing more than this and some Big Olaf's ice cream next door! T.J. the oyg read more

Wow the lobster roll was excellent. We definitely love our seafood and when we come to the East Coast we definitely like our lobster. The sandwich was on a toasted bun and there was about a pound of lobster salad included on the sandwich - very generous. We also had a bowl of clam chowder. So yummy! We had an amazing dining experience! read more

See all

We were really looking forward to having some great seafood out here. Considering the good reviews, we were pretty disappointed with this place. to be clear, we ordered for pickup. It was the first place we tried in the area so maybe our expectations were too high. There were a few of us so we ordered a few different items to share: 3 lobster rolls, a few pounds of mussels, and 2 soft-shell crabs. Lobster rolls: Priced at $38, this is the highest price I've ever paid for a lobster roll, including Manhattan, Maine, and Rhode Island, so I was expecting something spectacular. The bun itself was underwhelming, not toasted, not buttered, just a straight up hot dog bun. The lobster was decent, the bun was filled with plenty of lobster. The saddest part, I gotta say, is the bag of Lays potato chips that came alongside. For $38 I expected a better side item. Mussels: overcooked, chewy, dry. The best part of eating mussels is being able to enjoy the juices and how soft and tender the meat is. There was none to be had. Soft-shell crabs: It wasn't clear on their menu in the shop that this would come in a sandwich form. Nevertheless, the crab was battered and deep-fried really well and for the most part this was the best thing from what we ordered. Overall, we would never go back to this spot. It's overpriced and we found way better lobster rolls and other shellfish for much better prices in the same area. I know with many restaurants, dining in is a much better experience, but that probably only applies to the mussels in our case. read more

I loved this place for years. I was shocked by the poor quality of the fish. The flounder tasted frozen. I'm disappointed.

Customer service here is in the crapper. They gave us that feeling that while our money may have value to them our Time certainly didn't. The two stars are for the food alone and bless the hearts of the folks in the kitchen the front of house clearly have no respect for them. One short fiery women tried to snatch my friends plate from her mits because after the 45 minutes we waited for it. 45 minutes you read that right! It was still missing her side salad. No Deb you can't use her scallops to play show and tell in the kitchen only to return a cold plate and sour face. I'd never go back here for the human element alone. Pitty shits too because with a location like that they will get away with this weak behavior indefinitely! And who could forget the dead lobster left in the tank. After the charming encounter we had with the staff I am willing to bet they use dead lobsters in their chilled lobster rolls? And soups - that's a Barf! read more

The Dock House - Dead lobster see doing the back stroke stage center. - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

My sister and I came in for a quick dinner on our way home from work, we were not disappointed! The restaurant was very cute and casual with high tops outside to watch the boats go by. The staff was great. We had the pleasure of being helped by Chris who was so friendly and kind. The food was all fresh and delicious. We had the grilled tuna, shrimp tacos, baked clams and a cup of lobster bisque. Everything was delicious and made to order. I would definitely visit The Doc House again, 10/10. read more

Absolutely the best lobster roll in The Hampton's! My wife and I spent a week in The Hampton's and I tried lobster rolls everywhere. At The Dock House, you get lots of lobster, just enough mayo, celery, and seasoning on a perfectly grilled bun. Absolutely loved it and highly recommend it! read more

The Dock House is an absolute MUST when in the Hamptons!!! My boyfriend said that this is the best lobster roll he's ever had. I don't eat seafood, but the chicken tenders were seriously incredible. Probably the best I've ever had to be honest. Their homemade honey mustard is to die for. Met the owners - Andrea and her son Alec, and they're the sweetest people. The lobster roll, honey mustard, and so many more items are all Andrea's recipes! Very impressive. The inside is super cute too, and the location is even better. After we ate, we walked right outside to look at the gorgeous views of the water and the boats. Can't wait to go back soon!!! read more

See all

The Dock House is a casual spot right on the water in Sag Harbor. It's a quick and easy lunch while walking around the adorable town. A friend and I split the lobster roll last time I went in. It had lots of fresh lobster with crunchy, fresh veggies for texture. There was not too much mayo either. It was really tasty and hit the spot. The only reason I don't give 5 stars is because I do think I've had better lobster rolls. Also, my friend ordered the chicken fingers and fries, which were nothing to write home about. Seemed fried from frozen. read more

The Dock House - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York

Food was pretty cool, service was great. Nice place. I would definitely recommend. Good read more

I've been coming for a long time - over 10 years. But it's gone completely down hill. No clams in the chowder the fish and chips is like fish sticks at public school. AND - they charge you a fee to use your Credit Card!!! Don't go here ! Use their bathroom and if you happen to piss on the floor then good on you! read more

Overpriced lobster rolls. Baked clams were undercooked, sent back and was inedible. I do not recommend this place. What a waste of a meal.

Such a wonderful atmosphere, great wait staff and great food. Would highly recommend for others to try it out if you've never been there. Will for sure be going back again. read more

Good food and amazing service and atmosphere very good place to eat and I will definitely be back and highly recommend this wonderful restaurant read more

Wife & I stopped at Dock House for a quick lunch, late June 2021. Very cute inside, a basic fish shack on the water. These types of places don't care about the frou-frou (frou-frou in Sag Harbor?!?!), so you could miss Dock House in the shadows of multi-million dollar yachts. Excellent, fresh seafood. Delicious! Not a large place, but it was not crowded when we came (weekday). read more

See all

Just get the lobster roll with waffle fries please... I think it's the best lobster roll I've ever had on Long Island , and I was born and raised on Long Island. The seasoning on that lobster meat is fantastic! Their burgers are good too! read more

The Dock House - Seafood Near Me - Sag Harbor, New York