Cluckman&#x27;s

Late-night cravings = satisfied! I stopped by Buddhaberry…read morefor a late night treat and wow this place did not disappoint at all. The frozen yogurt was insanely delicious...probably the best I've had in a long time. Super creamy, rich flavors, and all the toppings your heart could want. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, even that late in the evening, and the shop itself was nice and spotless which says a lot. I'm was just visiting the area, and I so wish we had one of these in Jersey. I'd be a regular for sure. Can't wait for my next trip back just for this place. Highly recommend if you're anywhere nearby. Total gem!

Always go here after dinner, food is great got a big selection of froyo. Right in the middle of…read moretown. Not much service needed but they r usually fast. Sometimes there is a line. The ambiance is fine, music is a bit loud but overall decent.

FroYo Bar

See all

Ending the night with a treat!

Yummylicious!

3.2(28 reviews)

•$

Salted caramel pretzel frozen yoghurt here is still so satisfying! Perfectly balanced, smooth and…read morecreamy. Worth a trip to the Hamptons! We usually go during the day when it's not busy.

My husband liked his ice cream, but my frozen yogurt tasted "off," and I did not feel well later…read morethat night. My fault, I shouldn't have eaten it! Of course, can't be certain my not feeling well was from the frozen yogurt - could be from anything, but it's certainly possible. At any rate, tasted bad, so I wouldn't return.

Go get them!

See all

Weeeeiiiii!

Big Olaf

4.0(82 reviews)

Big Olaf has been in Sag Harbor for decades now. I have gone since I have been a child & it never…read moredisappoints. They have a variety of ice cream flavors, toppings, & different ways you can have the ice cream. I ended up getting a milkshake & it was delicious. Was exactly what I needed!

If you're in Sag Harbor in the off month, this is a must do a repeat. I must do, however, if it's…read moreduring the summer, you will see a mob scene in front of this store and you know why it's fabulous. Never mind the fact that they have gluten-free sugar cones and gluten-free waffle cones. That's right you love gluten-free you want gluten-free ice cream with cones don't miss this spot.

Gluten Free Cones

See all

Cookie and Cream in a waffle cone

BonBon

4.0(1 review)

0.2 mi

Bougie candy store with some great gummy candy sold for way too much money. But they did have a…read moreblack licorice option in addition to the rainbow colored gummies my kiddos gravitate to. The pretty pink bags they have you dump your candy into are also pretty cute too. Gah, this place is a money pit.

From the owner: The magical world of BonBon was founded in 2017 by friends Bobby, Leo and Selim to sweeten and…read morerevolutionize the US candy world; through a love for their homeland and its sweet and savory treats. On our journey since launching our Lower East Side retail location, community events and online efforts; we have become the bona fide destination for anyone with a sweet or savory tooth for Scandinavian treats. We import all products ourselves from Sweden, this way we can always ensure quality and the highest standards as set by real-life Oompa Loompas on site in Sweden and New York. We believe that everyone should be able to enjoy BonBon candy and we therefore strive to have as many of our products as possible be vegan, gluten free and made with natural colorants. In the fall of 2020 our first very own produced candy - Sour Wild Strawberry Fish were made to be made as such and were followed by our Sweet Wild Strawberry Fish, Sour Blackberry Fish, Sour Elderflower Fish and Sour Peach Fish. Hope to see you in the shop soon! Love, BonBon

See all

Grindstone Coffee & Donuts

4.3(255 reviews)

Loved this coffee place!! Went back twice since it was so good! The workers were very friendly &…read morehelped me order my drink. Both of my drinks were delicious! This place also has donuts that look amazing, I would try them as well.

There are no prices listed anywhere. Living out here has become so surreal. Is it that hard to add…read morea price to the huge board that lists doughnut flavors? I guess I'm the first person to actually ask how much the doughnuts cost. They're 5$ a pop, btw. That said, not a bad doughnut.

Apple cider cake donuts

Classic (classy) Glazed

See all

Brioche "apple pie" donuts

The Corner Bar

3.5(132 reviews)

Local American restaurant located in Sag Harbor. We came as a large group on a Wednesday evening a…read morethe ambiance was bustling. I ordered the flounder which lasted a bit lacking in flavor, but maybe that more on me for trying to be healthy. The cod bites were good, calamari not bad. I personally didn't order it but the fish and chips portion looked massive and yummy. Food also took a while to come out but again we were a large group.

Decent place, nice local crowd & the bar tender was friendly. Best thing about this place is the…read moreinside/location. Old school east end feel with a great view. The wings are much like Elbow II in Laurel. The breaded food service delivery brand, just add your own sauce. I didn't have a chance to try a burger or any of their other specials, I'll feel that might bump them up to four stars.

See all

Menu

Doubles

3.3(6 reviews)

0.2 mi

I had the jerk chicken bowl, and it was good and flavorful. My order was ready relatively quickly,…read morewhich was nice. It's a very small place, so I'd say it's more suited for takeout. They do have a few seats, but it's not really ideal if you're with a group or looking to sit down and have a relaxed meal. For me, this is more of a place to grab something to go or have a quick meal when I don't want to sit around, chat, and spend a lot of time eating.

Quick and easy order and turn around time…read more I got an island blue smoothie , a double smash burger and fries very delightful all around. Cashier was kind NOTE : Not accepting cash at the moment... I'm not sure that's legal in NY... Also, I believe no "doubles" are sold here, only at the Amaganset location... bold to have that name without them as your staple.

Cute sandwich shop in Sag harbor

Entrance

See all

Cashier counter / open kitchen

Sagtown Coffee

3.8(123 reviews)

Awesome place to grab a coffee and hang out, but the food leaves a lot to be desired for…read more I've had some great items, notably, the chia seed pudding and açaí bowls. Where Sag falls short is the cooked items. The breakfast burrito is terrible - eggs are very overcooked and no real flavor profile. The bowls are mostly rice. They even have a poke bowl with no fish (???) for...$24? Go for the good vibes, friendly staff and drinks. Not for food.

I ordered the oat milk draft latte for $7+ and basically got a cup of ice. At 75% of the cup was…read moreice. There was so much ice I could barely get straw in cup. Disappointing.

Iced matcha with almond milk - yummy!

Apres afternoon menu. Absolutely amazing food!

See all

Gelato

LT Burger

2.8(346 reviews)

Yelp gets it right with the 3 stars. I think, I would even…read moresay 2 stars, but I don't like to go low. We ordered a medium cheese burger with bacon $30! The smashburger was $24, fried pickles $12. Iced tea was $5. My guy cannot eat mayo. Asked for no sauce on burger & no cheese. We got it to go. So, we didn't have time to go back when we realized it had both mayo and cheese. The fried pickles were 6 extremely greasy pickle chips. terrible!! waste of $12 for sure. Super disappointed. It took a very long time to get our food. There really wasn't a lot of customers there. It doesn't make sense that it took so long to get our order and they couldn't get it right at all. I would definitely not come here again.

Picking up someone in town, we figured LT Burger was a convenient place to have a quick bite…read more Turned out it wasn't so. The service was slow. The cocktails pricey, as was the food which was just ok. My water glass had a chip on the top. At least it's clean, with a variety of seating arrangements.

"Le Frenchie" Burger

See all

Exterior / street pov

Bee Bee's Fried Chicken

5.0(2 reviews)

32.9 mi

This place is just amazing. The food is just super tasty and exquisite. The service is professional…read moreand respectful. The ambiance is pretty chill and cool. 5 stars.

Food is great always bursting with many different flavors definitely worth every penny and prices…read moreare even greater me and my family love chef beebee

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

1 review that is not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Joey S.

147

19

30

2 years ago

Cluckman's, the new fast-casual takeout spot, offers a much-needed reprieve in the local restaurant market. Sag Harbor has desperately needed a place like this, something fast, affordable, and inviting. Cluckman's vibrant atmosphere is poised to make it one of the most popular hangout spots for the younger crowd. Its affordable prices and prime location near the old 7-Eleven should attract plenty of foot traffic. On my first visit, I ordered the classic chicken sandwich and fries. Unfortunately, the chicken sandwich uses a breast instead of a thigh, which typically offers more flavor. The breast was dry and underseasoned, lacking the necessary salt needed. The sandwich was generous with condiments--bacon, Swiss cheese, avocado, lettuce, pickle, and a signature "Sag sauce." However, the condiments seemed to mask the chicken rather than complement it. The chicken was also lukewarm. The hand-cut fries, while appreciated, were clumped together and soggy due to excess oil and were also undersalted. They too were lukewarm and not hot, which was disappointing. A heat lamp or some method to keep the sides hot would greatly improve this. On a positive note, the Sag sauce and garlic aioli were superb, with the Sag sauce being reminiscent of a classic Mac sauce from McDonald's, and the garlic aioli enhanced by fresh herbs. During my second visit, I tried the double smash burger and sweet potato fries. The burger was juicy but didn't quite meet the traditional "smash" expectations. Smash burgers are usually pressed thin and cooked longer on the griddle to develop a crust. This burger felt more like a thin patty rather than a true smash burger. It tasted good but again lacked sufficient seasoning. The bun, branded with "Sag," added a nice touch of presentation, but it wasn't toasted, which would have provided a better texture and prevented sogginess. The sweet potato fries were better seasoned than the regular fries but still clumped together and were lukewarm. I just want hot fries. On my final visit, I had the Nashville chicken sandwich along with onion rings. The chicken was similar to the classic sandwich--lukewarm, slightly cold, and dry. While the seasoning was improved, the chicken still didn't deliver the expected Nashville hot chicken flavor, tasting more like Frank's RedHot than the traditional Nashville spices. Traditionally, Nashville hot chicken is dipped in hot oil and then seasoned liberally with a spice mixture. This method not only infuses the chicken with heat but also ensures it remains crispy without introducing moisture that could make it soggy. Unfortunately, this crucial step seemed to be missing. The chicken was tender due to the buttermilk, but the lack of heat and proper seasoning was disappointing. The slaw and pickles provided a nice balance, but the overall flavor profile still needed improvement. The onion rings were light and flavorful but had issues with the coating not sticking well to the onions, leaving some pieces almost bare. Those with a full coating had a satisfying crunch and good flavor. Overall, I believe Cluckman's has great potential. It has positioned itself perfectly to fill a void in Sag Harbor's dining scene, offering a fast-casual alternative to the high-end tacos and tequila bars that dominate the area. With some adjustments to their recipes, cooking processes, and methods to keep the food hot, Cluckman's could easily become a beloved staple in Sag Harbor. The food needs improvement, particularly in seasoning and maintaining the heat of the sides, but I believe Cluckman's has the potential to excel. read more

Cluckman's - chickenshop - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Restaurants near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Things to Do near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Coffee near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Desserts near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Fast Food near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Pizza near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Takeout near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Thrift Stores near Cluckman's

BEST of Sag Harbor, New York Shopping near Cluckman's

Best of Sag Harbor

Things to do in Sag Harbor

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Cluckman's also viewed

Local Burger - Southampton

4.1

(23 reviews)

Stopped by Local Burger in Southampton with the family after a trip to the Montauk Lighthouse. The…read morefood was delicious. My nephew had the kids cheeseburger meal and a milkshake. I had my reliable grilled chicken without a bun. The hangover burgers were delicious per the rest of the party. There is a golf course on the premises that I want to come back for so my nephew can experience it. It was too chilly and rainy to try it today. The ambience and service were great.

Awesome golf amenities, but the head cook likes to save parking space for his friends I guess, with…read moreconstruction cones he keeps in his trunk. Ooh and don't try to move it! He'll give you the finger wag!

Sean's Place

3.7

(52 reviews)

Sean's place is the only place i go to for sandwiches when i am in town. The place is small and…read morealways packed with lines out the door. That's a sign of a wonderful place. There are a variety of items to choose from to make that perfect breakfast, or lunch sandwich. The food is always fresh and if you want the sandwich made a certain way ( i don't eat eggs) just tell them. The staff are very pleasant and always give service with a smile. I come in from Babylon and it's 100% worth the stop !!! Karen WC

Decent deli, but nothing to write home about!…read more Ambiance & Service: The interior is small with no seating, though there are a few outdoor tables. Our order took a while, but they were busy, so it was understandable. Food: - Breakfast Burrito with Avocado: The salsa and jalapeños added great flavor, but the salsa made the burrito very soggy. If you're getting it to-go, ask for the salsa on the side! TL;DR: Fine deli with good flavors. If ordering the Breakfast Burrito, get the salsa on the side!

Country Heroes

4.1

(49 reviews)

•$

A must when you're in the area. They've been here forever. Incredibly diverse and creative sandwich…read moremenu. They can make you anything. Old school vibes, and very welcoming, friendly staff. People might complain about the price increase, and I can understand that, but you get a massive meal and I'd much rather give them my money than any of the bougie places in the area.

Well I'm very excited to gain Yelp! Elite Gold status! I figured I would do a home run review to…read morecelebrate, that's why I picked Country Heroes. You just can't go wrong with this place they have every kind of hero you can think of as well as breakfast. Clean, friendly & huge heroes! You ought to go there!

Cruust

4.2

(6 reviews)

Yooooooooooo! Get ready because I'm about to GUSH. I went…read moreto this place the week it opened with little expectations- it always takes time for a new place to get it right. Right? I had The Italian Job and it was incredible. So much so, that I have been craving it since. So I went back last week and they talked me into The Hawaiian- it was incredible. Still craving The Italian Job I went back yesterday and got TWO sandwiches- lunch and dinner, player. It's how we do. Had The Italian Job for lunch and it lived up to the hype in my mind. Just a great sandwich. I mean - who craves sandwiches? This guy does now. For Dinner? The Miami Vice. I had half for dinner and am eating the other half now. Again, incredible. These are such well balanced sandwiches - not too dry, not so sauce heavy that the bread gets weird. Even after a night in the fridge The Miami Vice holds its own. For the Hamptons, the price is right. They made the sandwich while I waited - only took five minutes and the kids at the counter seem to love their jobs. Good vibes all the way around -

Cruust is Sag Harbors most essential newest addition. There truly isn't anything like it in town! I…read moream obsessed with the "Crust" sandwich, the shrimp salad sandwich, the Italian job and the angry fries! I also love ordering regular fries with a side of vodka parm sauce! The cute storefront is also so fun and is packed with delicious sauces and sodas to try. The service was also so quick and efficient. Melissa was the sweetest and made sure my order came out perfectly! Thank you cruust for the new addition to town.

Doubles

3.3

(6 reviews)

I had the jerk chicken bowl, and it was good and flavorful. My order was ready relatively quickly,…read morewhich was nice. It's a very small place, so I'd say it's more suited for takeout. They do have a few seats, but it's not really ideal if you're with a group or looking to sit down and have a relaxed meal. For me, this is more of a place to grab something to go or have a quick meal when I don't want to sit around, chat, and spend a lot of time eating.

Quick and easy order and turn around time…read more I got an island blue smoothie , a double smash burger and fries very delightful all around. Cashier was kind NOTE : Not accepting cash at the moment... I'm not sure that's legal in NY... Also, I believe no "doubles" are sold here, only at the Amaganset location... bold to have that name without them as your staple.

Smokin' Wolf

4.1

(152 reviews)

Every thing we ate was incredible. The food was great. Ambience perfect. Everyone friendly and…read moreeverything on time. Highly recommended.

This place makes some top tier sauce! I won some of their sauce in a raffle and had a $100 gift…read morecertificate to try them. I was trying to find a way to go there without having to drive so far just for food. I live an hour away from them, so the travel time is what makes going there a deal breaker consistently. It's worth going to East Hampton generally, but it should be a day thing. Not just to go eat. The person who helped us was very knowledgable and asked good questions in terms of what you'd like for your platter. The food was top quality. Our platters were worth every bit of that gift certificate and I'd love to come around this place again! I also had to buy their sauce on the way back home because we use it for some dinners. My only critiques is regarding the mac and cheese. I wish it was more of a homemade baked mac and cheese with the toasted top. But definitely good mac and cheese nonetheless. The mashed sweet potatoes were definitely too seasoned with all spice. It gave it too much of a kick than I was expecting. I liked the seating inside and outside. If we didn't have bad allergies, would've probably sat outside and enjoyed our meal. Also, this place has their own parking area. So that's definitely a plus!

M and R Deli

3.1

(12 reviews)

Great BEC!! (for $6.50) Good amount of eggs. Nice and fluffy…read more I was also excited to learn they have Dreesen's donuts which are the best ($1.50).

I schlepped my fat arse all the way out to East Hampton to get some Dreesen's doughnuts here. I…read moredidn't realize they only make them fresh in the mornings. Bought a bunch and nuked them for 15 seconds. Next time I will come earlier, but this technique worked in a pinch.

Sam's Restaurant

3.7

(180 reviews)