This place makes some top tier sauce! I won some of their sauce in a raffle and had a $100 gift certificate to try them. I was trying to find a way to go there without having to drive so far just for food. I live an hour away from them, so the travel time is what makes going there a deal breaker consistently. It's worth going to East Hampton generally, but it should be a day thing. Not just to go eat. The person who helped us was very knowledgable and asked good questions in terms of what you'd like for your platter. The food was top quality. Our platters were worth every bit of that gift certificate and I'd love to come around this place again! I also had to buy their sauce on the way back home because we use it for some dinners. My only critiques is regarding the mac and cheese. I wish it was more of a homemade baked mac and cheese with the toasted top. But definitely good mac and cheese nonetheless. The mashed sweet potatoes were definitely too seasoned with all spice. It gave it too much of a kick than I was expecting. I liked the seating inside and outside. If we didn't have bad allergies, would've probably sat outside and enjoyed our meal. Also, this place has their own parking area. So that's definitely a plus! read more

Smokin' Wolf - Three meet and two meet platters. - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

This place is so good! I'm generally not a big fan of BBQ because a lot of times meat is the meat is dry because it was sitting around for a while, not cooked right, not good quality, etc. I for the 3 meat platter that comes with 2 small sides and a piece of cornbread. I got ribs, brisket, BBQ chicken, mac and cheese, and mashed potatoes. I also got an order of the little gem salad. The ribs were some of the best I've had in years. Very juicy, excellent smoky flavor. Tender, perfectly cooked. Brisket was okay when it was warm, but after cooling off a little bit, it got very dry. I'm not a big fan of brisket in general because of how dry and hard the texture can get, but this is okay while fresh. The BBQ sauce on the side helped, but I probably wouldn't get it again here. The BBQ chicken was the most disappointing - just shredded chicken smothered in a ton of sauce. It was very dry, like sticks of matches drowning in sauce. Mashed potatoes were very buttery and delicious, but also retained some chunkiness and skin too, which I really liked. Very flavorful and decadent. Mac and cheese was very good as well, but not the toasty top kind. Still very cheesy and good, like they used real cheese. Cornbread was a surprise hit - very moist and soft, denser than most cornbreads, and a lot sweeter than most cornbreads I've had at BBQ places. It tasted more like a dessert corn cake, which I didn't mind at all. The little gem salad tasted very fresh. Dressing was just okay, and the salmon we got on top was very stinky and did not taste fresh. The skin had a nice crunch to it though. I wish the fish had been fresher. The greens were great, so I might just get it with chicken next time, or something else if they would allow that. Overall, really great food! I would definitely go back here again. It's been a while since I've been to a BBQ place that has really good smokey char flavor without tasting burnt, while still retaining juiciness (in the ribs anyway). I'd highly recommend the ribs, mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, salad, and cornbread. I want to try some other items as well. Very friendly service too. read more

The food is good, a little on the expensive side. Great for take out. Their corn bread is delicious

It's located right on the corner, you can park in the side or the back. Has outdoor seating and you can smell the delicious BBQ before you even walk in. The food was delicious, the brisket melts in your mouth and the ribs were tender and the Bbq sauce has the perfect mix of spice and sweetness. We felt a bit confused at first since no one greeted us or explained the process. It took asking at the counter before we knew how to order. read more

See all

I was so ready to like this place because of the raving reviews but unfortunately I was a little underwhelming! I ordered the bbq chicken salad which came highly recommended by the waitress. She said it was the best thing on the menu and super hearty. So figured I'd give it a try. The bbq chicken was probably the only thing I liked and even then it was just chicken drenched in bbq sauce. Perhaps there just aren't too many options here in the Hamptons but it wasn't 5 star that's forsure! read more

See all

The brisket was fantastic - some of the best I've had in NY. Extremely friendly service. Highly recommend!

Best fried chicken in the area! The service and attention to detail is incredible - and the food is consistently delicious. Great potato salad and corn as well. I have used them for several different catering events from bbq to holiday parties and will continue to. read more

Delicious food and owners are super nice! Great lunch or dinner spot. Perfect for catering too! Order ahead for family meals.

Pricey, but amazing. The meat was perfectly tender and flavored, and the sides were to die for. The ladies at the front were super helpful when it came to the process of ordering and the food came out in under 10 minutes. The inside had a feel of traditional barbecue joints in the southwest and the outside tables were clean n' serene. One of the best barbecues I've had in a long time. read more

We drove by this place so many times over the years but stopped in for the first time recently given its convenient location on Montauk Hwy. This is decent BBQ and is quite reasonably priced even the area and the other types of restaurants which are a bit more prevalent in the neighborhood. We took out for lunch here, getting the BBQ platter which included an assortment of meats with Mac n' Cheese and Cole Slaw. The meats were all good and tender. I think the sides could use a bit more seasoning but they still complemented the meats well with some additional BBQ sauce. During the warmer months, the outdoor seating makes a nice setting for eating. I think this is a place which we will return to visit. read more

This BBQ spot is so fire! Everything tasted great, so glad we found it! When you first walk in, the smell of bbq welcomes you in (which is always a great sign!). Also, staff is very friendly to all and knows their regulars by name. The meat was so tender and you can't go wrong with the sides. We loved the Mac and cheese and cornbread, can't wait to come back and try more! read more

See all

Being from the South, we know BBQ...but let me say that the Brisket here is a winner ! The Mr. had the fried cod fish tacos which were also delicious. Topped it with a Montauk summer ale. read more

Smokin' Wolf - beer on a picnic table - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Not a lot of affordable options with this level of quality on the east end. Excellent BBQ and big portions. Tried the ribs, pulled pork, cole slaw, and baked beans it was all delicious. Nice accommodating staff, small family owned and operated restaurant. They care and want you to have a great experience. I would recommend calling your order in a head of time if you're in a rush. Will be back in the summer for ribs and beers in the outdoor seating area. read more

This place is yummy. I've had the fried chicken lunch combo with mashed sweet potatoes. So good! I just wish they gave a little more sweet potato. I've also had the Thai chicken wrap, one of their weekly special items. That was very tasty. The staff is pretty nice too. They say everything is made to order ;) read more

I do take out often. The bbq ribs are excellent. They are my favorite. I'm not a big fan of chicken generally. But my better half loves the BBF chicken here. read more

First of all I get how busy they are for superbowl but we always order from here. We placed an order for 50 chicken wings and 24 cheeseburger sliders. My mom repeated to the person on the phone literally x3 because she could not get it right. Then I get to the establishment and they "never" wrote my cheeseburger sliders. Plus we wait so long while everyone else walks past us. Wait 25 minutes for my order I placed for 4:45pm. Then we come home and our wings are burnt....I always support small businesses but this is clearly for regulars and townies. Which I am a townie; my family has lived here all my life but overall not worth it anymore. If I could place a 0 I would. But couldn't. read more

Smokin' Wolf - Burnt wing - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I've eaten a lot of bbq and this has to be one of the best pulled pork sandwiches I've ever had. Also Michelle is amazing! Thank you I will absolutely be back soon read more

Should have 5 stars hands down! I stopped buying and i usually bring lunch (for work) but this is a place that changed my mind, AWESOME food, great service for take out as well. I walked and ordered waited no more than 15 minutes. The prices were very reasonable! read more

Awesome place all around! Excellent food and really friendly staff. The brisket and spicy pickles are particularly awesome.

The food is fresh and superb. Servive is consistently good. Everyone who works there is friendly. One of my favorite spots for takeout food in the Hamptons. read more

This place's name is "smokin' wolf BBQ and more". You'd think their bbq should be their selling point. Nope. It's by far the worst bbq I've ever had. When you walk in, it looks like a normal sandwich shop where you order from the counter and they bring food to your table. There's no smoker in sight, nor was there anyone carving meat real time. That should've been the warning sign to us. Unfortunately we were too hungry and figured maybe someone was doing it in the back. We decided to order some ribs, brisket, and some sides. Ribs tasted like they reheated it in the oven. The outside was completely dry and I couldn't even chew on it - it tasted like some beef jerky gone very bad. The inside was also dry, not at horrendous as the outside but pretty inedible in my opinion. Now comes to brisket, very below average, not dry, but not juicy, and no seasoning. Oh and did I mention the corn bread, tasted like they made it three days ago. It's a shame a place can put BBQ in their name but couldn't do bbq right. Unfortunately there's practically no competition around and limited choices for food. I guess that's why they are still in business. read more

We ordered the pulled chicken sandwich and ribs... smelled great.. all was good until I had a chicken bone in my sandwich and the tendons in the ribs were inedible.. a lot more care needs to take place. This is not the first time we have had bones in our food. Chew carefully read more

Smokin' Wolf - person's hand holding a piece of food - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

The baked beans was the only good product in this meal, NOTE to the management, if your menu has pulled meat product on it then that is what the customer is requesting when they say "please give me a pulled chicken dinner" which is what was ordered on the day I stopped in there, what was served to me is surprising, an overcooked boneless chicken breast that the cook took a cleaver to and then poured barbeque sauce on it and sent it out the kitchen, pulled meat is supposed to be Pulled, not hacked up with a cleaver. Signed Customer you lost thru dishonorable service read more

oh my I was craving some good BBQ, and We came to the right place. Started off with a large serving of delicious cornbread, yummy. My husband had the brisket sandwich and baked beans, he loved it, actually said it was perfect. I had the pulled pork sandwich with baked beans. Delicious, as a matter of fact one of the best pulled pork sandwich. The beans were perfectly season. We are on vacation so we also had the Mexican corn, it was fresh and tasty. The corn was locally grown and so fresh. We got a slice of pecan pie to share. Everyone was so friendly and food was great. read more

Stopped by for a quick lunch and was not disappointed in the least. Great service, friendly staff, and great outdoor seating for a summer day. Food was great as well. The BBQ chicken basket + sweet potato fries were awesome and very flavorful! Also extremely affordable for being in the East Hampton area! read more

Food is good. Service is not so great, just unacceptable. Could be much better. Will try again read more

Amazing takeout BBQ. Great ribs and awesome Mac and cheese. Cornbread is a definite winner.

After and extremely long ride from Brooklyn this place saved us. We stopped on our way to Montauk in a rainstorm and they were 20 min to closing. They could have turned us away but said they have everything. We ordered the brisket nachos and hush puppies to start, meanwhile were family size for a party of 6 we were only 3. Then we tried the pulled pork sandwich and Mac n cheese, lawd have mercy. My coworker ordered the crab cake sandwich and potato salad and said it was great!! Top this is all off with some Montauk Brews. The service was incredible and Michelle was also a great host, thanks all for turning our evening around!! read more

Smokin' Wolf - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

The fries are AMAZING! The veggie burger is okay a bit sloppy and the mango BBQ sauce is different, so overall I kinda preferred with the sauce on the side. read more

No misses on the menu. I know exactly what to expect. And fantastic service is included as an added bonus!!! Yum.

Wow... this place has the best quesadillas ever! I ordered the vegetarian quesadilla and I added the mango salsa in it with guac on the side. I asked for my quesadilla to be extra toasty... the result was a delicious crispy and cheesy quesadilla with corn bits and mango and red peppers. Goey cheese and goat cheese too. It was honestly amazing. PLUS, the portion was HUGE! It was the size of a small pizza. I also ordered the corn on the cob; it was great too.:) Restaurant itself has a couple of tables inside and outside. Very clean and organized place. Plus they serve ice cream too. Great spot for a casual meal:) read more

Smokin' Wolf - Vegetarian quesadilla and a corn on the cob - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Didn't expect to find a good bbq spot here out east but gave it a try and was pleasantly surprised! Brisket was moist, ribs were cooked perfectly and the quesadilla/cornbread were bomb as well! Definitely recommend! read more

Smokin' Wolf - Brisket, BBQ Quesadilla, Ribs - American Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Absolutely the best food in East Hampton! Try the brisket chili or the ribs, you won't be disappointed. Great staff also. It is our favorite eatery in the Hamptons. read more

THE BEST brisket on the east end. We had a great meal with that, roast chicken and their famous grilled broccoli.

Found this place on our way home from Montauk. Lobster Roll was to packed and we were hungry! So I know it's covid times and I like that they take it serious with no inside dining, call to order and pick it up at the window. BUT that being said...we waited over 30 minutes for our meal- pork sandwich, veggie burger and a (tiny) slice of pie. Our whole time waiting only one family got their meal. The place was empty! Even when someone else who came to pick up their meal went to the window the nice lady said to us "it's coming we make it from scratch" (she knew it was taking to long) Long story short the food wasn't worth the wait at all. The made from scratch was wasted on us...it was nothing special. If we didn't wait so long it would of all been fine, but wouldn't go back unfortunately. read more

See all

Excellent food at a fair price for the area. Very friendly service. I'll definitely be back!

Great bbq meats and reasonable prices. The 3 of us went for the 2 meat combo + 1/2 rib order. The amount of food was just right since the combo order comes with 2 sides and 1 cornbread. The brisket was tender and ribs was the best part - charred and moist. Nothing crazy about the sausage but still makes a good addition. There are bbq sauces and condiments on the side which we used religiously. The cornbread is not good, I would skip it but it came with the meal. read more

See all

Was surised how good the meats were. I had bbq chicken, brisket, and ribs. All three were yummy. I especially liked the way the brisket was served -- thinly sliced like pastrami. Carrot cake also got rave reviews, though it was gone before I could try it. read more

Best BBQ in East Hampton Smoking Wolf has been a local favorite for generations and is the oldest BBQ Restsuraunt in the Area. read more

Great food, friendly service in a super casual setting. Great for a post-beach pop-in.