Great happy hour specials and Madi making it even more enjoyable with her energetic personality

This was our first experience at Local Pie. The beer was ice cold and the food was fantastic. The prices were great and Madison, the bartender, was Exceptional! We will absolutely be back again. read more

Just moved to the Bluffton area, so stopped in this cute spot for pizza. Not the best first impression. Several young guys were working hard to keep up, without any leadership. Service pretty bad. They were out of the local meatballs, unfortunately. Singer was awful - didn't know the words to songs so would sing "wha wha wha"or "something something something." But when our food arrived, it was very good - good crust and fillings in calzone and sandwich. Both very large - enough to share or for someone really hungry. Will come back sometime sometime sometime, but probably not soon soon soon. read more

The pizza was dry, very little sauce and cheese, the sausage and meatball ingredients were dry as well. The toppings were ultra thin, the crust flavor was ok way too thin , pliable not a single crunch to it, not what I expected from a wood fired pizza. Over rated, over priced... Real Disappointment. read more

See all

Ordered at bar - lunch special two 10" pies with cokes. While at the bar the a/c ducts began leaking on us....ok!? Grabbed a table, server tried to delivery orders for others - twice. No Biggie. Others began receiving their food even though they arrived later than us. After 45min - we timed out and had enough. Dropped a couple bucks for the fountain drinks and left 50 mins after ordering. Pizza cook dropped the pizza peel on the ground and continued like it was no big deal! Wow! Talking loud to the side kitchen like he was at a family BBQ. Place desperately needs direct leadership- no manager insight. Complacency is a terrible thing in a service business. It's a hard pass for me. read more

Had garlic knots which were like pillows of perfection with just enough butter and garlic. The marinara was great for dipping! The pizza was fantastic. Also the buffalo chicken dip was amazing! read more

We loved the fried green tomatoes, the cranberry salad, the wings and the pizza. Our server, MADISON, refilled our drinks the second they were empty, gave us great recommendations and brought our food right when it was hot. She was very attentive and everyone in our party of 7 remarked on her service. Ps when she wasn't busy she was folding pizza boxes, never sat still. She's a keeper! read more

During the pandemic it's tough to know where to eat that is going to feel safe. We had just come from the beach & were famished & wanted something quick. The outdoor open patio at Woody's was full, so we opted for pizza. There was a large party in the and a couple of people sitting at the bar, but we had plenty of open table area around us. We started out with a meatball (local ball $11). This Texan wasn't impressed, but my Italian friend from Jersey loves it, so it must be good, lol. I had the monkey pizza, which was pretty good. The server got our tickets mixed up, made me question whether I was charged correctly, but she was attentive and friendly. Very casual, I would return here. read more

See all

Worst pie i ever had sausage tasted like chocolate. 42.oo thrown in the garbage. Never again.

This was a nice lunch spot on a beautiful day. We sat outside, and there was live music which was fun. It was cute little place. We ordered the classic Margherita pizza. It was pretty good, but nothing special. The crust was nice and crisp and the sauce and cheese were pretty good. The basil didn't really have any taste though. But overall, it was a decent lunch. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

As new residents , wanted and was excited to try. Bartender was awesome. However, after 40 mins with no pizza, we chose to leave. Tender went to mgr , who never came to us personally , we Tabbed out, tipped the bartender and left. Poor mgmt is my thoughts with time there. But hope, if I try again, it's better. read more

The pizza was delicious, atmosphere was wonderful & the service was good! We went on a Tuesday & ordered 2 large bogo 1/2 off( Mr. Mittake & the Baller). Fresh ingredients & the crust was amazing with the perfect amount of char. Would've given 5 stars, however the draft beers were a bit pricey at $8 & $9. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Beautiful delicious pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

Madi was fun and knowledgeable, and attentive the whole time we were there. She seemed to be the only server there and she crushed it!

What a nice little pizza shop in cute downtown Bluffton. With so many choices around, we were really craving pizza so we ended up here. We ordered their specialty pizza of the day, which had a ton of veggies on it. It was good but not spectacular - I think we just weren't big on having potatoes on our pizza tbh. Kinda a wild choice of topping. We also had the garlic bread (yum!) and the wings (also yum!) with their bbq sauce, which has a mustard base. I would normally hate that because mustard makes me gag but there's soooo much extra flavor to these wings I didn't mind. I mostly ate those. Our waitress wasn't the most attentive because she doubled as the bartender and spent a lot of time talking with a VERY loud group of people at the bar who I assume must have been regulars because she was very familiar with them. Kind of irritating, but it didn't ruin the overall experience for us. We'd totally come again to try a less unusual pizza. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - BBQ wings and garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

The menu and bar provide consistent offerings. The enhancement on each of our visits is the genuine and capable service of our waiter Madison N. Her pleasant, customer focus stands above other servers in the area. Easily, an enjoyable spot for pizza! read more

We went there for my son's 13th birthday last night because he loved their margharita pizza so much. We had 13 people in our party on a Saturday night so we were concerned about any restaurant being able to accommodate us . They put us in a private room upstairs with plenty of room to spread out. Our waitress Taylor ,was so sweet and she even brought my son a special dessert for his bday and sang happy birthday to him with us! The food was great- best Buffalo wings we have ever had! I highly recommend this place! Taylor, you rock! read more

Great service & food. Great spot in bluffton to hangout with friends. Good happy hour and ask for Madi.

First, it was Madison who made our experience an exceptional one. Her bubbly personality and her pure joy for her job, her customers and just serving people really came through. Second, the food was awesome! My hubby and I enjoyed two starters, fried mozzarella, buffalo chicken dip and then we built our own pie. What was great about this part is we didn't know it was "happy hour" because it was our 1st time here. (We just relocated from Daytona Beach.) It was Madison who let us know and gave us her recommendations. My husband and I have worked in hospitality and Madison is a true asset to this restaurant. She should work every Friday and should always be behind that bar. She was working her butt off. Oh, and if you want to know more about the food, though we could not eat it all, and brought half home, it did not disappoint. It was so fresh, and better than we have had in a while. Lastly, total shock was the cost, we have been right next door and it was double the cost, but keep in mind we did come to Local Pie by accident during happy hour. Either way, happy hour or not, it is a must try. read more

My wife and I shared a calzone on a Sunday afternoon recently. The kitchen helpfully cut the calzone in half for us and placed the halves on separate plates for us. Unfortunately, the meat inside the calzone was cold; not tepid, not cool, but cold. We declined the initial offer just to heat it up because the outside was heavily charred. We like heavily charred, but heating it further would have rendered it burned. The new calzone was better but the meat this time was just barely warmed. We received the calzone directly from the oven. The chef explained to us that the wood-fired oven was too hot and therefore threatened to burn the outer layers whilst leaving the inside cold. I get it but it's the restaurant and not the customer who should 1) recognize the problem and, 2) do something about it. If they could jot properly cook our calzone, they should have steered us toward something that would cook well and evenly in their wood-fired oven. Despite the temperature of the meat, the calzone was tasty. I'd love to try again when the oven is at the proper temperature to cook a calzone. My only quibble with the taste -- it could have used a little more ricotta. The staff was nice about the situation and gave us an unsolicited discount for the trouble. I appreciate their candor and their taking responsibility for it and (hopefully I suppose) not marking us as unreasonable guests. I do not send food back lightly. It ultimately screws up the meal when the other guest's food is fine. But I think it was appropriate in this instance. Will we return to try it again? Probably not unless they post a sign saying, "Oven regulated to make a proper and evenly cooked calzones." With dozens of nearby alternatives, I would not put myself in a position to be disappointed once again. read more

We had heard the pizza is great at Local Pie, and the rumor mill is 100% correct. My wide ordered the 10" white pizza, also called The Monkey. I ordered the 10" Little Bear which had mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs. We loved them. And for the first time in quite a while we couldn't finish the ample servings and took home some great leftovers for later on in the day. The waitress was excellent, and kept our sodas filled. To top it off, we discovered they don't charge for sodas during lunch. I don't know if this is always the case, but it was a first for us. Definitely on our "will return" list read more

Great location on the Promenade. Big bar. Good pie. Nice menu. Bartenders are great. Chill time. Not expensive. Pizza good the next day still. Is a local hangout spot which we like as locals. read more

Near the park we frequent daily so we tried it. Hard to write a review since we want to encourage local businesses, and so much good to say BUT, cannot YET commend the food itself. Not bad, but not at all "substaintial" so, better luck next time. If you think of a pizza as 2slices then $10 seems fair. I'm definitely going back, and revise my review afterwards. Clean, super friendly endless buut May YBB the staff has a ways to go yet in their training on how to guide first time diners. It's a confusing set up, they ought to go outside and enter eachh door as aa new to "Pie", novice, and think about if people like to be confused or confidentt at a new food joint. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Pizza heaven - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

I'll keep this short and quick unlike their service. Waited a long time for our food, got fed up waiting, paid the bill and left. Terrible service. When we complained to the lady (not sure what her role was but she had the phone clipped to her and was upfront) and not one of the employees reported the issue to management. The lady did not know how to handle the situation at all. Literally a deer in headlights reaction to our dissatisfaction and complaints. As we were leaving one of the cooks said "we don't need your business" to my aunt when she informed them of the bad service we received tonight. So not only was the service terrible but the fact that the cook had the audacity to say "we don't need your business" goes to show that the restaurant employees do not care. What a shame. read more

Fantastic pies and huge wings. Hit it during Happy Hour so actually got some value for my money. Would have been perfect if not for the Clemson watch party going on. O-H...;) read more

I heard a lot of good things about Local Pie so I thought I'd check it out. I ordered the Buffalo Bacon Pie. I was so disappointed. It was apparent that it was made haphazardly. Only 3 slices of the pie actually had chicken!! The few caramelized onions on the pie were in a few lumps and the crust had huge bubbles and was tasteless. Maybe I was just unlucky as to who made my pie but consistency matters. On the plus side service was good especially considering how busy it was. I will not return. read more

Had not had a decent slice of pizza since we got here six seeks ago. Figured this was another lost cause - but was pleasantly surprised. Although it's tucked in the tourist section of Bluffton, got a table without much fuss and really enjoyed the food. Service was good, but my one pet peeve: Luke cool beer. That's one thing I must have when I go out is COLD beer. We may return, but I think I'll call ahead and have them put two or three on ice before I show up. read more

Pizzas were excellent. Perfect crust and flavorful toppings. The Buffalo chicken pizza was the best of that variety we have ever had.

Disgusting!!! Had I known I needed to ask for shredded cheese I would have! I did specifically ask for HALF grilled onions and they definitely dumped onions all over it. The crust was burnt and the bottom soggy. Sauce is store bought tasting. The Cinna bites were over cooked and super chewy. Best thing we got was caramel sauce! So glad I don't ever have to order from here again. Leaving early tomorrow morning and they were closing when we got there so we couldn't call to complain. Worst pizza I have had in a LONG time and we eat pizza often! read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - In a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

Trying to review a pizza place fairly is impossible, because it is so subjective. New Yorker's don't like Chicago Style. Coal fired enthusiast don't like wood fired. The Margarita purist don't like the pineapple pizza and on and on. That being said, I'll give you my thoughts on the Pizza at Local Pie. We tried 2 pizzas, the Little Bear (tomato sauce, pepperoni, sausage and sliced meatball) and the Mr. Mittake (garlic spread base, blistered tomatoes, shiitake mushrooms, shaved onion, mozzarella, truffle oil). I will start with the crust, both pizza crusts were very good and baked just right (not burnt or over cooked), probably one of the best crusts I've had in South Carolina. This crust is very similar in style to a Naples, Italy crust (the Naples crust has bigger air bubbles and their flour has a different texture). The pizza toppings on the Little Bear were very salty and the sausage was bland. The Mr. Mittake definitely had the better toppings. The blistered tomatoes were very tasty and complimented the mushrooms and truffle oil. Speaking of the truffle oil, I think they could really enhance this pizza if they spread the oil out towards the edge of the crust (the toppings and truffle oil stopped about 2 inches, from the crust). We had no wait on a Saturday evening and they offer indoor/outdoor seating. The service was good, the prices were really good and it's worth the trip just to try the crust. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Little Bear - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all

I am throughly impressed! A party of 6 of us from New York really enjoyed this meal! The pizza is thin and well done; just how we like it. They make the pizza fresh and it came out quick! We ordered a bottle of wine because vacation ... wine not?! And the selection of wines were pretty good, the only thing is that the glasses were freshly washed, normally a great thing but the scent of the soap was rough and kind of ruined the taste of the yummy wine ! Other than that, we really enjoyed our meal, the beer selection was good too and we had the aloha beaches pineapple beer and it was delicious ! The pizzas we chose were the monkey and the Buffalo chicken pie and both are worth trying! Service was top notch!!!! read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all

If you're a fan of New York style pizza or Trenton tomato pies, you know finding something like that in Lowcountry could be challenging. We've tried most pizza places in the Bluffton and Hilton Head area and have only found a couple which even come close. While I've had Local Pie slices at some of the street festivals, I never had a pie from their downtown location. For Mother's Day, we decided to get some pies. I even had a discount card from one of the festivals which we used to call in the order. Unfortunately my wife called the Hilton Head location and not the one in Bluffton. We ordered a large onion and large mushroom pie--- thin and standard crust. They also offer Sicilian style and thicker crust pizza. When we arrived in Bluffton to pick up the pies, there was obviously a disconnect. The girl at the shop immediately called over to the Hilton Head store to cancel and rushed to make our pies---- brick oven can be very fast and handy. The crust is very tasty as well as the sauce, cheese and toppings. Although the crust could be a tad crispier. With South Carolina opening again from the pandemic, there were many people sitting outside eating. They offered a very clean and sanitary environment offering sanitizer and wiping down tables feverishly. The folks there were busy and very attentive. Great service. read more

My friends and I ordered take out. We figured since it was a busy Friday and wanted to stay away from the crowd. Food was great. The pizza was still hot when we picked it up. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Deez Knots 16" Classic Margarita Pie 10" Suped Up Pie - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

best pizza in Bluffton! really hit the spot. The staff is really nice. they think of everything. the place it's self is nice too nice decor! my fav pizza place by far! read more

Fabulous pizza! I also recommend Deez Knots - super yummy garlic knots served with a San Marzano sauce that is perfect! Service was outstanding as well. read more

We had the best pizza and the most fun over the course of a week during our stay in Bluffton. Our bartender/server and now, friend, Madi was such an energetic, enthusiastic person with just the best personality. She was a big reason we went back multiple times. The first night that we met everyone it was closer to closing time and not as busy so the atmosphere was lively and we had a blast! Thanks Madi, and the rest of the group, for such a good time. We wish you the best!! read more

Best Staff. Best Pizza and More. I love the atmosphere. Great place to take friends. You will be happy you went there. Also: Local Pie has always supported the community. Thank you Local Pie for Supporting Sun City Womens Golf Charity for years. We love you. read more

I probably would have been better off making my own pizza, as someone who has eaten pizza all over the world, I found myself disappointed walking out of here with a burnt pizza! Save your money and make your own at home!!! They could have at least taken the burnt basil off and put fresh basil on! It's not like I had high expectations but I definitely won't be giving them my business or reccomendations. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Terrible hosts, they were unwelcoming. Pizza was cold asked for it to be reheated and they gave it to us burnt! Burnt basil, eww! - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all

My gluten free pizza crust was good but I ordered with shiitake and they threw on regular mushrooms on top raw/uncooked. Super gross and ruined the pizza. My hubby had a meatball sub and the meatballs were super dry. Server was nice but I wouldn't go back for the food read more

We just made our first and last order. Pizza sent out completely incorrectly and half the size ordered. Quality about what I'd buy in the grocery freezer section. Apps (meatball and spinach artichoke dip) too spicy and not good. We threw them out. And they don't answer their phone. Put this place on your no list. read more

Woohoo! Delicious pizza in the Lowcountry! If you have an appreciation for real pizza, you must patronize Local Pie. Two sizes of pies, low prices, fresh ingredients, and dough so crispy and soft you'll think it's fried. (In a really good way, it's not fried, it's just done properly in a wood oven...). Thank you Local Pie. We will do our best to keep coming back so your adorable windows by the outside bar stay open! Buy local. Eat local. Keep small business alive y'all. (PS I'm going to dream about Deez Knots. That's all I'm saying. Y'all need to try them for yourselves. And if you're clever, you might be able to get yourself an order of them for free). read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Deez Knots y'all. Get there. - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all