We visited Local Pie while visiting the shops in Bluffton. Overall, it was a positive experience. They have a nice lunch deal ($10 "wedge" sandwich or pizza and a soda) and a good kids menu. We enjoyed our food -- the spinach salad was good (though I wish had more spinach as there were a lot of toppings). The pizza was tasty, and I really loved the macaroni and cheese. Service was okay - I felt like we were annoying our server at times for asking for anything. Overall a nice spot with good food. read more

Went there for supper tonight, Cranberry spinach salad, nice flavors, Yummy! Pizza, crust was like a piece of soggy white bread, awful.. read more

Service was AWFUL! The bartender was rude and messed are order twice. That the most I'm going to say. Go to another location. The food is good, not going to lie. I won't come back here just because of the manager and bartender attitude. read more

Went to the new location at Riverside. Same great pizza and the staff were all very friendly, efficient and welcoming. Place was reasonably full given it's a weekday and after lunch. Noise was not an issue. Will definitely return! read more

Passed by their Old Town location many times. I love pizza, but not a fan of eating pizza outside. Called me weird. But I wish I had! The Old Town location looked fun, but our first visit to the new location on New Riverside has us sold that it's our new favorite place! read more

Went to the new location at New Riverside on a weekday. Drinks, salad and pizza were very good. Service was good. Its 1/2 bar 1/2 restaurant and kind of small. The worst part however, was the noise level. I couldn't hear people at my own table! Acoustics are bad- they need to install sound absorption panels. I may return, but I'm eating outside! read more

What a great experience and Carson service was outstanding. We went for happy hour and stayed (thanks to Carson's recommendation). He suggested the delicious wood fired pizza. We got the "suped up " 16 inch which was great for four to share. The ambiance has a local friendly vibe and Carson really added to that. ASK for him as your server and tell him Irish sent you. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Carson! Great on service! - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

First off the pizzas were cold and SALTY. The service was in between as I got a nasty attitude from the employee at location saying that new location which opened today "does NOT" take out orders until next "sometime" next week. I felt rushed and it just wasnt worth it. Better pizza at Dominos... read more

We have been to local pie a few times. One time for pizza and another time just for snacks. They definitely have a happy hour so hit that up from 4-6! The pizza is nice and crispy. The wings were delicious as well. Deez knots and the Mac n cheese were both phenomenal. We left nothing in the plate! The service was quick and efficient! We sat inside and the vibe was casual and comfortable. We would definitely go back! read more

See all

Ordered the local pepperoni pie a few times and it's consistently a great pie. I've tried them all in the area coming from NJ where they have great pies, and these folks equal as great can't go wrong read more

If you are in Bluffton, this has to be a must stop. Pizza was outstanding and service was even better. Sit at the bar and make sure Madison waits on you. She makes a killer old-fashioned and she's got the greatest personality ever. We ordered a Sicilian pizza and it was spectacular. Afterwards, make sure you walk around this quaint little town. Tons of nice little shops. read more

Curts and the food were excellent- the host Dana was not - she was all over the place and didn't pay attention to anything that was going on - we asked several times about people going in front of us and when we first came in she told us 30 minutes and we waited an hour and 30 minutes for our table.. she was not professional at all and needs to learn to not talk about customers to her other hosts.. she needs to learn to run a front of house for a location this busy... read more

They have THE BEST pizza! The hardest part is deciding which one to have which is why I go often. They also serve a very generous salad. Excellent customer service. Friendliest staff! read more

Overpriced trash pizza. Little Caesars is lousy but at least they put toppings on their pizza. It explains why they were empty at lunch time. This is terrible, even by Bluffton standards. read more

June 28,2024 Friday night Just moved to the area and after trying every pizza in the area we found a winner. My new hair dresser nearby told me about this place. So a Friday night in Downtown Bluffton and we got a great table outside even live music! Spoiler alert I dove into eating and missed taking pictures of the main event the pizza! Started with a Coca Cola and hubby had a beer. Next an order of fried green tomatoes, tomatoes with fresh mozzarella and lastly a large pizza with meatballs subbed the tomatoes on the pie for onions. Well needless to say we ordered too much and took half home which we gladly ate the next day. The food is fresh and delicious. The service was ridiculously great! Best of all the owners come from NJ like me! No wonder why the food is out of this world. Definitely will be back. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all

Pretty pretty good. Not bad for Bluffton tbh. Most places are closed on Sunday so we looked for options open and this popped up. We frequent many of the restaurants in downtown Bluffton but somehow missed this (maybe because pizza isn't a strength here in SC). HOWEVER, I was pleasantly surprised with my Baller pizza. I even added mushrooms because they were fresh and not canned. The crust was pretty good and didn't taste like cardboard or frozen pizza crust like some other places down here. Three people in our party ordered calzones....one had the dreaded cold center mentioned by other reviewers. Maybe stick with the pizza. Service was great - they just need to kick up the a/c a bit. It's just as hot as sitting outside but louder. I'd give pizza and service a 4 but ambience a 3. read more

See all

Extremely disappointed. Pizza was cold, undercooked and without flavor. Embarrassing for how expensive they charge for a pizza. I think you will be better off purchasing a frozen pizza as you will have a more enjoyable eating experience than this pizza. Not sure why they put micro greens on a Margherita pizza, did they run out of basil? I'm more convinced this pizza was steamed instead of wood fired. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

See all

I literally just walked in there was zero tables outside. No one outside seating. Inside like 3-4 tables with people seating inside. We walked in and asked for a large party they told us it was an hour 1/2 wait. For pizza? There's literally no one there and we asked to be divided and nothing as well just rudely stated "we can't do that". We just left 0/10 no wonder no one was there. read more

I've been to Local Pie quite a few times over the years and it's high time I give them a proper review! I've always thought it was a nice place to grab pizza & a beer, since we moved back to the low country this year, Kat & I have made this our after church spot on more than a couple of Sundays. The staff is very friendly and most days the ticket times aren't too bad at all. We usually get a pint and a 10 inch pie each, which with tip runs us about $50. Sundays there's usually a musician playing, but not in a loud annoying way. If you're local to Bluffton or just passing through, I'd recommend Local Pie to anyone looking for a unique pizza experience! 5/5 will keep coming back. read more

See all

Our Service was outstanding from Alyssa and Angela! Would definitely come back. Definitely need more shots too lol.

We went there last Friday and were totally unimpressed. We ordered the classic margherita pizza and it was just plain awful. The sauce was terrible, they had done weird micro green instead of real basil and the cheese was tasteless and frankly barely there at all. They are more concerned with to go orders going out fast than their dining in customers. I felt that we were an after thought to the to go business and it showed in the pizza. How in the world people rate this highly can only be explained by the area. This area must simply not have any good pizza. I am new here and enjoy dining in Old Town but will not be going back to Local Pie. read more

First time here, but we'll be back! Got there at peak time, so waitstaff were busy, but once they got to us it went smoothly. Pizzas are wood fired and they're delicious. Had plenty to take home. There is indoor and outdoor seating. They give kids a little pizza dough to play with cookie cutters. read more

The best pizza since I've moved here, seriously it's good. It's a little dark inside. Should be cleaner, service was ok, had to wait for the hostess and the waitress was really busy. I'll be back though. read more

Local Pie - Bluffton - Pizza Near Me - Bluffton, South Carolina

Pizzas very good, my husbands loves a thin crust and these fit the bill I do know they have regular also Service always great, the place is awesome inside but not very big read more

Had a nice lunch at Local Pie, they had both outdoor patio and indoor seating available plus bar top service. I loved the area it was in among shopping and other restaurants. We went to local because they had a gluten free option available, and it was DELICIOUS. Their wood fired oven gives a nice crispy crust and adds a ton of flavor to the pizza. The Costello had a combination of salty and sweet flavors and was salty and rich, the buffalo pizza had a bit of a kick and the local margarita pizza was like a typical margarita but with a bit of pesto on it instead, making it super savory! The sandwich was a crispy 10" sub with tons of flavor. We had a great time in the restaurant as well, as you can actually see the pizza being made, and our server Amanda treated us well, and was knowledgeable about the menu. The restaurant was small but not terribly, plus the patio doubled the table quantity. Loved the vibe and the food is so worth the trip! read more

See all

As a local who frequents local pie, I was very upset when I heard they let the general manager go. She was the heart and soul of local pie and ran it flawlessly. I'm not sure who is running it now but my experience there the other night was not good to say the least. The new general manager or who ever it is looks lost and doesn't look capable of running the place like Jena did. I'm not sure if I'll ever come back if these changes continue read more

Long time customer of this establishment , such a great place! Seems as some staff changes have been made, or different people are in charge ? I witnessed a nasty interaction with the on staff manager accusing some locals of stealing a wallet, later being located in the parking lot for the record. Just not handled well, and I believe his name was jimmy, older gentlemen , and not Gabe or Jenna 100% never seen this "manager" before . read more

Best pizza in Bluffton. Neil makes a great thin pizza and Madison was a joy behind the bar!

Chef Coffee is the best ever authentic italian pizza maker at Local Pie, Bluffton, SC. After frequenting an Italian family owned restaurant in CA for 28 years, Chef Coffee is closest to being there and makes a fantastic garlic pizza with parmesan cheese that will fill your senses so that you can't wait to enjoy it; simply mouth watering. Recommend you try as he makes a great pizza, especially with that oven baked crust. Yummy, enjoy! read more

I was very unimpressed with the pizza. I ordered pizza from them based on reviews I read. Over 25% of the crust had no sauce or toppings the sauce was tasteless, although the crust did not taste too bad. Definitely would not recommend. We ordered the Margarita and a white pizza and my reactions are for both. read more

Definitely go here! The food and service was amazing. I suggest getting the monkey pie, it's awesome. And our server Taylor M. was an awesome server, so nice and funny. PS Go birds! read more

This place is phenomenal from the music playlist to the waitstaff and chef to the fantastic food! You will be so fortunate if you have Madison as a waitress and Cofey as the pizza baker; so nice and accommodating!! We started with Deez Knots, a fluffy version of garlic knots(great sauce) and a good preview of the pizza dough to come. It is wood fired Neapolitan but so good amidst the light char. We had the Monkey , a white pizza- the best!! We have had Neapolitan before and this ranks as the best ever. If you have a food allergy including dairy they are accommodating and will even use your dairy less cheese. Highly recommend (and we had a pizza aficionado in our group of four). read more

Pizza was excellent. Great service and atmosphere. Maddison the bartender / server is 11 out of 10..charming, friendly, efficient, and welcoming! read more

Takeout Pizza - salty and less than impressive. For the price, I would try another spot. HHI Local Pie is much better. read more

New to the area and came across this pizza spot as we toured Old Town Bluffton on a beautiful day. We had the Buffalo Chicken Dip - delish warm and cheesy. Also had the Suped Up pizza - over all was good, but nothing special about it I would have like more sauce and cheese. We had a couple drinks Bloody Mary was spot on. Service was great friendly and attentive. Overall good place I will definitely be back to try something new. read more

See all

Very comfortable outdoor seating Excellent, efficient and friendly wait staff Delicious wood fired pizza, however toppings were minimal read more

Another wonderful dinner and great time at this gem in OTB! I had a delicious personal sized pizza and my husband enjoyed one of the wonderful calzones. The staff is top notch ! Alyssa was our bartender and server as we ate at the bar . But we met Angela today - and saw Madison again! They are all great and good at their jobs! So nice! And we shared a laugh about a show that we have a mutual admiration for! Love this place! read more

First time trying local pie and we were disappointed. Wife and I ordered 2 calzones , a veggie and A 3 meat. Got 2 veggies . Simple mistake. Brought out a 3 meat minutes later and the inside was cold and cheese unmelted Sent it back and was told they'd have to make a new one because we cut into it.( Can't heat food that's been messed with. ) Second 3 meat came out , same thing Wife's veggie was supposed to have spinach, mushrooms, none of which were in it. Onions and peppers were tho Just a mess all in all. Will not be going back read more

Great happy hour specials and Madi making it even more enjoyable with her energetic personality

This was our first experience at Local Pie. The beer was ice cold and the food was fantastic. The prices were great and Madison, the bartender, was Exceptional! We will absolutely be back again. read more