I decided to order from this place. When I opened up the box I smelled something funny. Then saw how dark the sausages looked. I figured maybe it was overcooked but the sausages taste like they went bad. Stay away from this place. You tried calling them back nobody's answering the phone. read more

La Bella Pizza - I've never seen sausage look like this. Sausage taste like it went bad. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Pizza I got here was horrific. I came here to pickup two marinara slices and I've never seen such disgusting slices in my life. The guy doing the service was incredibly rude but what made it worse was the slices. Literally looked like pizza dough that had ketchup on it and smelled like toothpaste, almost no cheese on it too! The guy refused to make me another slice read more

I'm pretty surprised by how polarized the ratings are for La Bella. Most of my friends that have lived in Bensonhurst share the same consensus as me: La Bella is the best Brooklyn slice you'll ever have. Affordable and tasty New York pizza with a local staff that just emits warm vibes. The place is small but friendly and endearing in its own way. The regular customers that you'll undoubtedly see talking to the staff speak for themselves. You can never go wrong with the pepperoni or cheese slices. La Bella always has the perfect ratio of cheese and sauce and the ingredients taste fresh all the time. I've bought pizza at around ten at night and it's tasted wonderful. I recommend the buffalo chicken slice and they can also make a mean vodka pie on request. The vodka pie is some of the best I've ever had. The crust is always great too. You also usually get a free soda most of the time too when you spend a certain amount (which isn't a lot at all). Something that's unexpectedly fire is the buffalo wings. You'd never expect a random pizza joint's wings to taste so good, but in my opinion, the wings from La Bella are some of the best I've eaten in my life. They have the perfect orange creamy color and have the right kick to them. La Bella makes them completely fresh. Overall, this place is a hidden gem, but real ones know La Bella has always been good. read more

La Bella Pizza - Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza Slice Vodka Slice Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Horrible service. Person behind the counter became extremely mad at a kid for no reason, screamed at him loudly. He has no decency. The pizza was cold and very smaIl, almost the size of my palm. New York is all about pizza, but this is not the one to support. read more

Most DELICIOUS Eggplant Roll Everrrrr!! Soft well cooked eggplant, yummy homemade sauce, ricotta and cheesy cheese in a crispy Yummmmmmy crust that's not soggy like the rest ! Came with a homemade marinara sauce for dipping ! Omg Soooo Good!! read more

La Bella Pizza - Eggplant roll Deliciousssss - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The best pizza in Bensonhurst hands down!! Always fresh. Crust is always perfect. Chicken caesar slices and buffalo chicken slices are a must have! read more

La Bella Pizza - a whole pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Came by for a quick snack after hitting the gym. 2 slices and a soda for $5. I ordered a plain slice and sat in to eat. Sprinkled a bunch of stuff on it like garlic powder, red pepper, parsley. The slice was freshly made and delicious. Bottom and crust was crispy and hot. The cheese was hot (be careful as it slightly burned the roof of my mouth). The slice was extremely enjoyable. The garlic knots were not bad either It was flavored well, with lots of garlic and oil. Only problem was that it got can get soggy. I would come back again. read more

Best pizza and burek. Everyone is nice and always good treats you well. Been enjoying this place for many years and keep coming back every once in a while read more

This pizza is always fresh and taste like my grandmother made it just like back in the day. I'll recommend this place to everyone keep on going strong make that money read more

One of the best grandma pizzas in new york if not the best. Amazing chicken salad and wonderful service. This place is one of the reasons we go back to bensenhurst sometimes. If you are ever in the area, take the time to try this place, you will love it. read more

nice neighborhood pizza place that's been around for a while. It's right next to the 20th Ave train station, so it's very convenient. Only minus is that they refused to deliver a pie to my house :(. Eh, that's ok. I understand the margins are probably a bit thin. However, I probably wouldn't make this my go-to pizza place. read more

La Bella Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I am a little sad for not writing the reviews of all the nice eating places in my neighborhood. This is next door pizzeria for us and my husband used to frequent this place before our marriage. We absolutely love all the pies here. Highly recommended. read more

Wow, ew ew ew! Somebody call Gordon Ramsey. I have no words. I'm born and raised here and this is the WORST pizzeria I ever ate from. I ordered the eggplant parm. hero w/ linguine with fish/clam red sauce. It came LOADED- I mean loaded! With clam meat and only about 4 shells... This is such a hard and disgusting indicator this was frozen seafood.. sure enough even after removing 80% of it was so salty, I had to spit it out all over the pasta and throw it out. The eggplant parm hero was a complete mess. It wouldn't stay together and the cheese looked microwaved. So gross. A lot of grub hub businesses generate fake reviews. Always google a place before ordering. read more

My favorite from la Bella is the bbq chicken slice, buffalo chicken slice or the chicken cesar salad slice. They're pasta is decent as well. I think La Bella is better than Lenny's on 86th. But the last time I came here, the pizza dough was too think and chewy. It's not as good as the usual. But maybe it was just a fluke. The place is small, but they do have seatings inside and outdoor. I would recommend takeout though. read more

My favorite spot in New York to get Pizza. Been going here for over 15 years since my high school days. The buffalo slice/roll is a must have. The whole place and everyone there is like family. Jef Ded you are the best! faleminderit për të gjitha kujtimet e shkëlqyera që bëmë në picerinë tuaj! read more

A little away from the main avenue but this hidden pizzeria always hit the spot. Love the flavor of the sauce. Pizza is always on point. Their cheese ravioli are a hit... def recommend it read more

We were here because of the burek's place next door closed down. We got a slice of chicken salad pizza, a sicilian, & two meat byreks. They were all just decent. The food wasn't freshly made. The food isn't bad but just don't taste fresh. It's probably better if it was freshly made. The service was just okay. The guy wasn't rude or friendly. Overall this place is decent. We probably won't be back but if you live around this area, this place is worth a try. 1 slice of chicken salad pizza, 1 slice of sicilian, 2 meat byreks, & 1 can of soda, all total was $15 read more

See all

I love this place! Firstof all of pizzas i tried are delicious and they always have many different choices there. people who work there are so nice. It's like a fast food tho. People come and go. really fast service. Highly recommend read more

Stopped for supper before an event. Great experience. Owner was cheerful. Food was good. We'd recommend this place. Good price.

Well, you gotta think to yourself...Hey they haven't poisoned me. That's what I appreciate most about going out to eat nowadays, that they haven't given me food poisoning. I had a vegetable slice, It was surely appetizing. I enjoyed it very much so. I also had a bite of a white slice and that wasn't half bad either except that it burned me. I only gave it three stars because usually you're suppose to be informed of your food, but someone I was with had to go up there and ask if it was ready. Thus, it was ready so that was a star dropped. Speed matters when you're hungry. I don't have too much else to say except maybe you shouldn't use the restrooms here. People are kinda careless about hygiene, if that says a thing or two. read more

Gr8 quick stop, fresh n' pretty tasty foods, the grilled chicken hero tasted like an import from heaven period, so fresh. [Bon D.] I had my food delivered when i was just sitting across the oven, and have no input on the bathroom hygiene. Also i liked the 15min wait for my hero, it shows me that its 100% fresh. very efficient and friendly service. Watch out for the older red dude coming in screaming for coffee, he's after women... be aware.... read more

Delicious pizza and pasta dishes at great prices! This is our go-to pizza place! The garlic knots are very garlicky without that raw garlic taste at some other places. It's so yummy. They can make a vodka pie at request as well. Look for the specials. They make it easy to order and I love that the prices end in .00 or .50 making it easy to do the math!! Highly recommend this pizza joint. read more

Passed by here the other day and wanted to try it out since I haven't had pizza in a long time. The place was small but had tables indoors and outdoors for you to sit. They had a special "buy two slices and get a free can of soda". I ordered a pie, half margarita and half mushrooms. It cost $19.00 and took 20 minutes to make. The pizza was super oily ( they put olive oil on top of the margarita slice) and there weren't any signs of basil or garlic on the pizza. The mushroom slices had very little mushroom on it but tasted okay. I saw a lot of other goodies there so I'll give this place another try but for now, it's three stars! read more

These guys make the best Pizza around Bensonhurst hands down. As Chef Emeril says.. It's da saaaaauce! Thin crust, not over-cheezy (I invented the word). Apart from the fact they've been long time staple here, they're also accomodating if you want a say, a custom chicken roll with garlic and veggies..you just wait..as fresh food is always worth it. Check em out! read more

I went last week and they really amped up their dishes. I ordered the chicken penne vodka (doesn't contain any alcohol) and my friend ordered the Sunday special and they were amazing. The portions were huge and could easily be for 2 people. read more

La Bella Pizza - chicken penne vodka, Sunday special grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Never had an issue when we order pizza here but My Husband & I got severely sick after eating a pasta dish a few nights ago... still dealing with symptoms as I write this review. Definitely staying away from now on. read more

Our local pizzeria. Variety of food here: pizza, calzone, rice ball, to pasta dishes. Small own family pizzeria with few limited tables. Takes cash only. Pizza freshly made by staffs here wearing Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle logo. Cute. We had calamari linguini with white clam sauce. Not too bad. read more

See all

Good place for calzones, regular slices, and rice balls. Other than that, the new owners are terrible compared to the old ones. For one thing, the new owners have thick eastern european accents and they have absolutely no idea how to make pizza. The pan pizza that they have on display is pretty bad, I don't recommend it. Their spinach rolls/calzones are delicious. The one thing I like about La Bella is the fact that they close much later than the other local pizzerias around. Other than that, I would definitely go somewhere else during the day. Overall, a decent place. Not bad, but not great. read more

Yes, I ordered a pie from a while ago. All I remember is how dry it was. They really didn't put any sauce on it. This is not good pizza. I would be embarrassed to serve something like that to a customer. They need to get a new person to make it. They'll probably close down soon since Lenny's is right around the corner read more

It's a nice, cozy pizza spot that is located in a relatively busy area, providing a welcome reprieve from the loud surroundings. Their slices come with thin crust for the most part, which for me is certainly an upside, as you get less of a doughy flavor and more of a crunch to go with whatever the toppings are. When I ate recently, my slices of choice were the buffalo pizza, which packed a nice kick, and the Caesar salad slice. That must have been the only time I'd ever seen a salad slice heated in the oven. While it definitely improved the chicken, I can't say the same for the lettuce, dressing and croutons. I'm sure there are others who would prefer it in that style though, so it seems like this is certainly a place that caters to specific tastes. While I doubt I'll be getting the salad slice again, I can certainly see myself returning to try the other flavors they have on offer. read more

Please, if you see on google maps that this place is temporarily closed, it is NOT. It is open and in business and only takes takeout and delivery. Same if you order on SLICE, it says it does not take orders however it does, please do not be mistaken. read more

Ordered for delivery and after 45 min the food was still not here so I called them to see how much longer. It finally came about 10 min later and everything I ordered was cold. So cold that I had to microwave the pizza and everything else I ordered. The vegetable pizza did not taste good at all. Mozzarella sticks weren't good either. Not sure if the food tasted bad because everything had to be reheated in the microwave or because it was just bad. read more

Love, love, love this pizzeria. Pizza is always made fresh; my favorite is the whole wheat veggie square but I also think eggplant role is divine! Yum! One of the last authentic Italian eateries in the area. La Bella is in a great, convenient location - although the parking may sometimes be a little sucky. There is a small area to sit and eat outside. The place is quiet and friendly. They do not accept credit cards. If you ever need napkins, straws or utensils - just ask, they will be happy to supply you with anything you may need. read more

I've been here for years now and their pizza is okay. The only reason I come back is cause they're extremely hospitable

Today I ordered for home delivery 1 pie no oregano and half mushroom the pizza was horrible it was reheated they put the mushrooms on top it was not fresh from the oven it was reheated you could taste the after flavor like burnt pizza on the bottom maybe they're busy but it was a home delivery if I stood there and watch them do the job they would of gave me fresh pizza pie but not that they had one extra pie and just put mushrooms on it and reheat. This is the second time that's happened I'm not sure I'm going to try the third time sorry guys it is what it is. Sometimes I go in the next much fresh they look at me and tell me everything's fresh what I mean is what is hot not to reheat it of course everything is fresh but when it's reheated it it's not fresh from the oven I would recommend to make fresh pizza when it's a home delivery..... read more

The only way you will know if you try it your self for us Excellent and that's 5 out of 5. And service the guys are Excellent.

Nice neighborhood pizza. I love the chicken caesar pizza! Baked ziti with meatballs is delicious as well as their penne a la vodka! Meatball parm hero is great too! Appetizers are decent. read more

Ordered a mushroom pie. It was disgusting. It's not pizza, it was bread. I don't know if ordering a topping made them put less cheese, there was no sauce, it was SO dry. I don't know what else to say, it was one of the worst "pizzas" in my life (I don't know exactly where it sits compared with the frozen pizzas). It's cheaper than any pizzeria around the area but spend a couple of $$ more and get actual pizza. read more

Great place. The pies are ok but I think you can get the most out of their Italian dishes. Their pasta and baked dishes are well worth the money. I recommend the la Bella pasta and baked ziti. The food are fresh and always the right temperature. read more

La Bella isn't far from where I live and I order it whenever there's no time to cook and the family wants pizza. The crust is delish and you must, must, must try the grilled chicken pizza - to die for. Food is always hot when they deliver it and I always get a free soda with it. read more