Everything we had was excellent. From the salad, [[HIGHLIGHT]]the family atmosphere and the best pizza I think I've ever had; and I'm 70 years old, so I've downed a few pizzas.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I'm diabetic and pizza is one of my worst foods to eat. My blood sugar didn't increase as much as it normally does. The crust, the fresh ingredients ....everything and I wish we had something like this in Western Pa. I want to add; I'm not one to tell the owners how good it was and I took the time to tell them. read more

Last time we were in town we loved this place. Went back again tonight Fri night for dinner. Didn't realize they close at 6. I guess it's not really a dinner place. Will come back again another time for lunch read more

See all

Krust is the real deal. The second I saw our pizza come out of the oven, I knew it was going to be good, the owner sliced it, and you could hear the crunch from across the counter. That's when I knew we were in for something special. We ordered the Pepperoni with Hot Honey and the Burrata pizza. Both were absolute standouts. The pepperoni had that perfect balance of salty and sweet with just the right amount of heat from the honey, while the burrata was rich, creamy, and fresh without being heavy. Every bite was loaded with flavor, and the square-style crust was crisp on the outside yet soft and chewy inside. [[HIGHLIGHT]]On top of the food, the atmosphere made it even better...it's family owned and run, and you can feel the pride they put into their place.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They were genuinely kind and welcoming, which makes the whole experience even more memorable. If you're a pizza lover, this spot is a must-try. Square pies, big flavor, and that perfect crunch. Can't wait to go back. read more

Krust - Pepperoni with Hot Honey - Desserts Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Small little pizza stop.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Chill atmosphere.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] You order at the counter. They were accommodating and I was able to get no cheese on my half of our pizza. Prices are a little high. Pizza was good. read more

Krust - Pizza with onions (no cheese) - Desserts Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Yes, it is that good. Opted to creat our own. Sausage, mushroom, and olive. It was excellent, subtle, fresh sauce, plenty of great cheese, and the crust was outstanding. The house made desserts are on a different level as well. The owners were friendly and gracious. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Plenty of seating in a nice open space.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

I had very high expectations coming here and I still was pleasantly surprised. This is by far the best Detroit style pizza I've ever had. I had the pepperoni hot honey and it was the perfect balance of savory and sweet, I also had the vodka sauce one which had onions, sweet tomatoes, and bacon and it was unbelievable. Even had a great cheese pull. I tried a variety of their desserts, I had the key lime pie, the Reese's pie, banana cream pie, coconut pie, and churro dulce de leche pastry. All were delicious! The service was great and pizza came out at a good time. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The inside of the place is nice and the pizza is made pretty much in front of you.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] And lots of parking. Overall I have zero complaints and would absolutely come again. read more

See all

I am so glad we went to Krust. It's the highlight of this vacation. The husband and wife duo are awesome. Very friendly and welcoming and the service was excellent. You can tell they love what they do and are very proud of their products. My husband was craving pizza and we followed our instincts. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I can talk about how clean the restaurant was, how easy it was to park, and service, but let me tell you about the food.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The CeasarSalad was amazing. The portion was huge and it was fresh. No brown lettuce at all and the perfect balance of dressing to lettuce. Enough for my husband and me to split with leftovers. We ordered the #6 veggie and added pepperoni and sausage. The pizzas are square, pan-pizzas with 6 slices that are huge. You can taste the quality of the ingredients in every bite. The sauce-fantastic. The marinated tomatoes were the star of the show. I really enjoyed them. Lastly, don't leave without trying the homage desserts. It was hard to choose, but we selected the Banana Cream Pie and the Cherry Cheesecake. Both were amazing. I am so glad we went to Krust. read more

The pizza here was sooooo good! My kids got pepperoni, my husband and I tried to hot honey pepperoni with sausage and we both said it was the best pizza we have had in quite a while. It was light and very fresh. The best part was how crispy the bottom of the crust was. The staff were really nice. Also the banana pudding and key lime pie were really good too! read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Krust pizza is a nice little place in the keys.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Service is fast and the food is good If you haven't tried pepperoni pizza with honey on top, you're in for a unique experience that you absolutely must explore. The combination of pepperoni paired with the sweet drizzle of honey creates a unique flavor. It's a delightful contrast to the traditional pizza experience. Additionally, don't miss out on the banana pie cake. It's incredibly delicious. The rich, creamy texture and the sweetness of the bananas make it a fantastic dessert choice. Together, these two dishes create a great meal that you won't want to miss.Treat yourself and give them a try--you won't regret it! read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Extremely clean and tastefully decorated space.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We ordered half pepperoni and half mushroom and it was absolutely delicious! Love a Detroit style pie and we weren't disappointed; crispy crust, airy dough, and lots of cheese. I couldn't resist getting a piece of banana cream pie (with nilla wafer pieces) to go. It was perfect. Highly recommend Krust! Can't wait to come back to this area so we can try a different "pie" and pie! read more

Krust - Pepperoni and mushroom pizza - Desserts Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

The pizza there is very good. They put a lot of Cheese and tomato sauce. I will definitely repeat.

We had a wonderful lunch. The greek salad and our pizza was delicious! The banana pie was fantastic. The service was excellent. read more

See all

AMAZING! Great service by warm people (owners). Awesome spot, very spacious and clean. Now for the pizza, I'll probably say this is the best deep dish I've had in Miami/Keys. Why? Bc it's just the right amount of thickness. Some others are too filling. Krust hits it right on the spot and the flavors are delicious! Can't wait to go back and try their wings, salad, and another pie! Will definitely be back. (Sorry, ate half the home made dessert before I took the pic) read more

See all

you will love this pizza. If you are in the keys try this place out!!! Good prices and fresh ingredient!

Run don't walk or rather don't nap! This is the Best Pizza if ever had in my Life! The cheesy crust, the cheese and the sauce is spectacular! This husband and wife show is amazing! They close Monday & Tuesday because they are making the fermented dough! [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is clean and beautifully decorated with an artist mural and simple table decor.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] They are friendly and everything is fresh, made on hand in a clean kitchen. Do not miss this stop while in Key Largo or on your way to Key West! read more

See all

Pizza is fresh and made authentically. The Caesar salad This is our second year eating here. My Scilian boyfriend and son rave about the Detroit style pizza. Go early or call so you don't get a "sold out" sign on the door. read more

Great pizza shop, modern , very clean and wholly owned and operated by a very appreciative husband and wife team - the staff of only two would explain the limited operating hours 12 PM - 6 PM although if you add in the prep time and clean up time and everything else required to run a business it's a long day I'm sure. We arrived a few minutes before noon and there were already people waiting to go inside. The menu is simple which allows for an extraordinarily focus on everything that is plated here - one size pizza definitely is plenty for two, the chef brings a unique perspective to each dish I thought the pepperoni honey pizza was amazing the airy but crispy crust topped with fresh quality ingredients and plenty of them and the attention to detail raises the bar here in the Keys. I loved the small diameter pepperoni, the hand torn basil leaves and the low moisture mozzarella which gives that stretch that so many pizza houses miss. We also shared a Caesar Salad which was also was plenty for two to share so simple and fresh. I'd be remised if I didn't mention a few oddities, I have no issue ordering at the counter and prepaying including the gratuity if I was a local I'd know that the food and service will exceed my expectation - for people passing through the area I think it's a bit more challenging and the owners my be leaving some money on the table but for a two person operation it is the most efficient way to operate. Being the drinks are individual servings if I want a second or third one I have to pay again and if I decide on pie as an afterthought I have to pay again not very efficient for the customer. I loved this place and definitely would return when I'm back in the area... read more

See all

[[HIGHLIGHT]]Its a good-looking restaurant[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] . The owners are working hard side by side, but the pizza wasn't good . No flavor, unlike the three best in this area , Italian Food Company , Tower and C&C Pizzas. They will probably gross a million this year, and they certainly deserve to , but I was expecting a close to a Detroit pizza. If they were to sprinkle dry oregano on the sauce, it would be a good Sicilian pie, but they dont. The sauce has no flavor and my pie wasn't light and fluffy as Detroit pies are known as. They probably will have a small chain in a couple of years because Keys people think the other gas oven pizzas in the Keys tasre good ! read more

My friends & I had lunch at Krust. The menu is pretty small. There are half a dozen pizzas that are 10x10". They have wings. They have meatballs. They have a few salads. You order at the counter & pay when you order. I find this a bit strange if you are eating there, especially the part of tipping before you have eaten anything. When your dish is ready, they bring it to the table. We all had different items and everything was really good. Portions are generous. Not inexpensive at $25 with tip for meatballs and bottled water. Inside is bright and open with lots of windows, widely spaced tables and wood flooring. I would definitely return. read more

Krust - The meatballs. - Desserts Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Delicious. Exceptionally good pizza and pie. Would definitely recommend 10/10 and come back. The pizza was full of flavor and the burnt top cheesecake, the keylime pie, and the kitkat pie were delicious. Not too sweet or heavy. read more

I ordered take out with Krust the other day and think the pizza was delicious. The crust itself is almost a ciabatta texture with an air-y dough that is prepared, cooked, and cut in a square shape for a non-traditional style pizza. I love how there are 5 pies that you can order and anything else can still be custom made. While the pizza was delicious I was hoping it would include a side sauce, pepperoncini, or some other spice but am still quite content with the mouth watery taste. The prices I feel are a bit high for a more medium size pie but once again, as far as flavor is concerned, they knocked it outta the park! read more

See all

Drove 1.5 hours to give this pizza shop a try. Worth every minute, mile and, dollar. I had the top seller with pepperoni and brought back cheese pie plus a slice of an oreo pie. It was lovely to meet you all and take pictures . I will return along with my friends but first, I will call to make sure you don't run out. Love you guys! read more

See all

After all this time it finally happened! I am Not sure what was better the amazing food for the conversation with the owners! I am so glad that the wait was worth it all. Food is prepared perfectly and fresh to order . Smaller menu admitted by Chef but he said he cooks what he likes and likes what he cooks. Honestly they could have 1 thing on the menu and I would return time and time again. We opted to have a salad and share a pizza pie. The crust at Kristen is certainly different level, in my honest opinion it's the best crispiest and flavorful crust I ever had. I love the smaller sized pepperoni slices . It assures you a perfect bite every time. Thanks for allowing us to share and fry your passion. Can't wait to try other dishes . Live laugh and that's amore!! read more

See all

Fantastic pizza spot in Tavernier! Krust is a family-owned pizza joint that looks and tastes authentically so. The menu is small and simple, but the flavors are anything but! I had the #3 Pepperoni and Hot Honey pizza, which was heavy on the toppings, flavor, and crisp. The pizza is almost Detroit-style, with a square cut and edge-to-edge cheese and topping coverage, but it's not unreasonably thick the way some other pizzas of that style tend to be. The owners were super kind and friendly, and I enjoyed a lovely afternoon eating my pizza and watching The Karate Kid on the tv in the dining area (to the owners: please turn on subtitles!). I dined solo so I didn't have enough room for dessert, but I'm already planning my next day trip to the Keys so I can try one of their delicious-looking pies! read more

Krust - Pepperoni with Hot Honey Pizza - Desserts Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Love love love! The pizza crust was perfection. The pepperoni was the small cups. And the flavor was spot on with sweet and spice! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Quiet and lovely atmosphere.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Best pizza I ever had. My husband and I decided to stop by and have lunch. We have heard several friends state that they love the food here. They were right! It was absolutely delicious. We had the hot honey pizza, wings and also dessert (Tiramisu and Dulce de leche)! The owners were so sweet and you can tell the passion they have for their business and food. I highly recommend stopping by! read more

See all

This is a pizza & pie heaven!! Detroit style pizza with a light and fluffy Krust with fresh toppings too! Hours of operation are limited but well worth the effort to go when they are open! The white pizza with spinach is amazing!! We add pineapple for that extra little sweet! The pepperoni with the hot honey is awesome and my personal favorite. If you're a dessert lover the pies here are all homemade by the owner and the flavor types is spectacular! The burnt cheesecake and Nutella are certainly a must try! Owners are always on site and the service is just as good as all the delicious yumminess they create!! Traveling to the Keys this is a must stop in Tavernier!! read more

Scoring this on a non-traditional pizza side of things... This spot is a must try! Detroit style pizza with great flavor. They earned the title "Krust". Epic crunch and flavor on the crust. Great flavor overall on cheese, dough, and sauce. Must try kind of place if your passing through the Florida Keys. You can't get by the slice. Must order a pie. Can eat between 2-3 people. My own preference if the undercarriage had a little more crisp i would have given it a few points higher... none the less I'm definitely stopping here again when passing through the Florida Keys. read more

Krust - Pepperoni hot honey pizza - Desserts Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Delicious pizza. We ordered cheese for the kids, a hot honey pepperoni and a burrata. Absolutely delish. The pizzas have a crunchy, soft, airy crust. Pies are also homemade and the perfect amount. The owners are extremely nice and will let you know customer picks. A definite must go to. We will be back for sure! read more

Ok just came back again & another 10!!!! We tried the wings ! They were amazing!! Also tried the burnt cheese cake !! Seriously best cheesecake I've ever had !!!! This place is the real deal & owners take pride in the food !! read more

We had the hot honey pepperoni pizza and it did not disappoint. The pizza was baked to order right at the moment we ordered. It was so fresh. The banana pudding pie is also a must. Everything was delicious! read more

Nice couple running the joint all by themselves. Called in for takeout and was prepared just in time while they were getting the last hit for the night since they close kind of early, 6pm. But understandable, they want their quality of life to enjoy too. Maybe they will stay open later for that late pizza lover crowds in the future. This location used to be Cafe Moka but they just reopened down the street. Inside is cute but the outside needs some work done. Decent pizza but it is on the thicker dough side, pepperoni and cheese wasn't as flavored enough to my liking but the Krust on the outside is where it's at. I think I read somewhat that it's cheese that makes that happen. Joe gave me some hot honey to try on my pizza, I guess that's a thing here now. It was okay but I like my buttermilk ranch better. Take out was maybe not the best choice for this pizza because the bottom started to get soggy. It would be great to reheat in an air fryer though. Wish I could have had their meatballs on my pizza but they don't do that here. read more

See all

Banana crème pie... on point as well as the pizza. Banana crème pie... on point as well as the pizza.

Best pizza I've ever had in Florida. Comparable to the pies I can get back home in Chicago (even if it's Detroit style). Had the hot honey pepperoni. Tons of pepperoni on top and very fresh tasting. Phenomenal buttery crust. Super friendly staff. Will definitely be going back. read more

Honey pepperoni pizza is one of the best pizzas I've ever tried. Staff is very friendly and plenty of parking in the back. Highly recommended. read more

We stopped on our way out of the keys, am so glad we were finally able to stop by for lunch. Super cute family business. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Great atmosphere, customer service, the best Chicago style pizza.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Definitely coming back soon again read more

See all

Some of the best (if not the best ) pizza I've been graced to enjoy! It's one of those meals that leaves an impression and makes a memory Ordered the #1 The Classic and #3 Pepperoni with Hot Honey + key lime pie and pistachio pie. Imagine all the pizzas ever depicted in cinema as desirable- that's KRUST Bottom line- I am eager to return Some other notes. We were in the area for diving and were on the way home to North Florida when we came across the stellar reviews on yelp. However , I'd like to point out as we were leaving there was a photograph of Dave Portnoy- a man known for his pizza critiques. Later I found his review and he assessed KRUST with a 7.7! By his standards that is a significant praise. I'd also like to express my deep respect for the owners. In our short interaction , we found out they have no employees. It is just the husband and wife duo. [[HIGHLIGHT]]They maintain a lovely , bright and crisp ambiance while delivering piping hot pizza pies and decadent dessert pies.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Thank you for the experience! read more

See all

It's fair for the area. The pizza was like a 7 out of 10, the wings were a 10 out of 10.

Good pizza but the desserts are amazing. Oreo pie and banana pudding is delicious, a hidden dessert gem.

Delicious pizza made with high quality ingredients. My husband and I shared the hot honey pepperoni and it was perfect for the two of us. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Cute and inviting atmosphere with a parking lot and entry at the rear.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Great service, they were so kind! Will definitely visit again on our next visit to the keys! read more