Just had a great time and a great dinner at the Italian Food Company. The key lime pie was top…read morenotch.

Nice alternative if you're looking for something not seafood…read more The meat lovers pizza was exceptional. It's traditional Italian- super thin crust, crispy edges, really tasty. The chicken parm with spaghetti was good enough. The chicken was fried perfectly- crispy coating, not soggy as so often can be. The spaghetti was cooked perfectly, al dente. We sat at the bar- best chairs are there. Ozzi at the bar was great. This place has an authentic Italian feel to it. Real pasta, fresh made desserts and some imported from Italy. All the way around- a great experience.

Bayside Gourmet is seriously the BEST!! I lived across the street for 8 months and wow wow wow. The…read morepasta is just incredible. I'm obsessed with their massive chicken parm, there's soo much melted cheese it's amazing. Also the tortellini is from another world!! So fresh, amazing cheese, and the parmesan cream sauce is so rich and delicious. My husband had the grouper sandwich once, that was also very good. They have good beer selections. Just come here, you won't regret it!! PS, sometimes the service is slow when they're slammed during busy hours, but who cares you're in the keys and good food is worth the wait. Love the food here!

Very friendly service and attentive. Food was delicious…read morebut really loved the key lime pie We ate outside on the patio and nice ambiance Yes, recommend this for everyone

Dog Shit Horrible!!!!…read more Sprint out the door, don't walk, don't jog; effing sprint out of this hell hole. The service was the worst I have ever had in over 30 years of patronizing any service industry... BY FAR and AWAY THE WORST!!! Over a 75 minute wait for a pizza and close to 90 minutes for the two calzones. Did not see the worthless waiter after he took the first order. My wife had to go ask for a second glass of wine and refills. The bacon in the calzone was not even done.. On top of that the manager and someone on the staff were talking about screwing over DoorDash as well based on an order that was not picked up due to not being assigned a driver. The service in the Florida Keys is usually slow and casual, yet this takes the cake for blatant disdain for the customer and incomprehensible incompetence.

Pizza was great! We had the Margharita and Philly Cheese pizza. Slight sweetness to the crust but…read moredamn good. And btw...don't sleep on their wings. Add them to your order and thank me later. Don't judge by the outside and you can wait at the attached bar next door while you wait on your pie and wings.

Holy cow! Now it may have been a minute since I've indulged in a nice slice of pizza but did I hit…read morethe jackpot when my boss ordered a few different kinds form this establishment. I mean, wow! From the garlic buttery crust to the perfect amount of grease that would make a true New Yorker grin, this place did phenomenal on all the different pizzas that were ordered last week. My coworkers and I partook in the pesto swirl, vegetarian, hot honey pepperoni, cheese, and traditional pepperoni. I can't say enough good things about this place and love how it located in Islamorada to really give the competition a need to step it up in the keys. I was told the staff was also quite nice and efficient despite the large number of pies ordered last minute on a Friday morning. I cannot wait to try some more here soon!

Food- this place is not good , everything is bland or extremely mediocre, the calzones have tiny…read morepieces of pepperoni and instead of cheese it's this gross creamy Alfredo sauce. The salad is bland and flavorless, and we also received the wrong order , when we addressed the staff and called , they did nothing about it. This place is a disappointment. ALSO NO NEED TO RESPOND SARAH C. ( business owner) as all your responses are copy paste or automated .

We stopped in here late night after it being recommended by the bartender at Florida Keys Brewery…read more Upon pulling up, you might think that it would be a little rough inside, but quite the opposite! When we walked in, we were greeted by a friendly bartender who got us our drinks right away - and then come to find out that they have a pizza menu!! It's late night of course, we're hungry, so we order a pizza - It was SOOOOO good and not at all expected! We ended up ordering another one lol! We played shuffleboard, while enjoying our pizza and drinks and overall had a pretty fun time!

Fun divey,townie place. Super friendly bar tender took time to explain and talk pizza with us. We…read morewished we would have ordered just cheese pizza and not sausage. The crust was light with good under carriage. The sausage was not great. If you like sweet sauce you will the pizza sauce here. I like a a little more tang to mine personally but it was not bad. One bite gave it 6.8.. i would drop to 6.3.

By far our favorite meal during our 7 day trip in the Florida keys. We enjoyed it so much that we…read morewent back a second time for our last dinner. The highlights were the captains style mahi, the jalapeño encrusted mahi and the key lime pie. It was the best key lime pie we had on our trip!

Best meal of our vacation, hands down!…read more We started with the smoked fish dip. This fish dip is a bit more mayo-forward than others we've have but it was sure delicious and beautifully presented. All of us got some type of fresh fish. I tried the coconut encrusted hogfish in key lime butter. Whoa! So delicious, fresh, and not too heavy. The mashed potatoes were really good too! My wife also enjoyed her jalapeño encrusted grouper as well; the perfect blend of green, charred spicy notes without being overpowering. We loved the charred green beans, something we'd not had before. The menu here was refreshingly original and a fun take of fresh seafood. It's a cool spot and the service was good too.

Enrico's has a sign on the front of their storefront saying it's NY style pizza, and as that's my…read morefavorite type of pizza, I had high hopes. Their pizza is thin crust like NY style, but that's where the similarities end. I found the crust a bit flavorless and the sauce lacking in spices as well. The pepperoni and meatball pizzas were well topped, but the spinach garlic pizza we ordered had barely anything on it. For a large pizza, I'd say each slice had 2-3 small spinach leaves, tops. It was extremely sparse considering you pay around $3 for extra toppings. It's edible for sure but if you want a solid slice of NY pizza, I'd skip this spot.

I visited Enrico's five years ago and had such a great experience. The food was great, as well as…read moreservice. I always wanted to visit again and finally did. I could say this has been the worst dining experience I've had in a long time. Not only was the service horrible, but they hardly had any of the items on the menu. I remember the meatballs, pizza and rolls being amazing so we ordered that. The meatballs had potential but they must have been frozen and were warm on the outside but the middle was cold. There was no way of getting the waiter to tell him since we waited about 25 minutes to get our order in. Mind you we were the only ones in the restaurant. The rolls were not edible. The pizza was ok, but the crust had no salt whatsoever so you couldn't eat it. I was going to try the dessert but opted not to since it would have taken half hour more. It's such a shame because they were so good. Never again. I usually do not leave bad reviews, but this was just total neglect of a once good establishment.

I have heard only good things about Ziggie & Mad Dog's and my experience with them was great. I…read morewent early on a Sunday evening, sat at the bar and quickly joined by 10 other locals. They knew where to come. I ordered hog fish, onion rings, and a chopped salad. All were great. Service at the bar was enjoyable. The bartender was cute, and funny. The burgers and steaks looked fantastic. I do not feel you could go wrong with any order. Until next time.

As a Keys resident, all my friends would rave about their meals here. I had the opportunity to try…read moreZiggie's (it's quite the drive for me) recently. It was crowded but not crazy. I sat at the bar with Kevin, who was excellent at taking care of a full bar. I had the filet mignon which was really tender. It wasn't as flavorful as I had expected & wish I would have chosen the peppercorn sauce. The Old Fashioned was good, but not great. For $18, I had expected to be 'wowed.' Sitting at the bar was fine for me. Had I come here on a date, I would definitely prefer a table.

The food, ambiance, service and food were great. It's costly to eat there, but the quality of the…read morefood was very good!

Hard to find this place. Everything on the ground floor is abandoned. After searching we found the…read moreplace upstairs. A very long an steep handicapped ramp. Anyway, the offer outside dining. Too cold and windy for this day. A large dining room and the bar area has tables also. We thought we would try it. Dated and in need of refurbishing. But, clean as a pin. The place has been taken care of. A whole crew of older ladies came in and the place started to get loud. They were all catching up. Bartender was on the ball. Waitstaff also swift and efficient. We made a decision to have a two and done. Extensive wine list. Limited bottle beer. Nothing on tap.

We stopped in for their Happy Hour. Jeffrey greeted us and asked what kind of cocktails we…read moreenjoyed. He offered to surprise us. Both cocktails he made us were outstanding. We ordered a few small plates to share. Everything was absolutely delicious. The bar is situated on the 3rd floor above the Square Grouper restaurant. Lots of windows and spacious enough so you don't feel like you're too close to other people.

What a hidden gem! We spent two nights in a row here during our visit because it was just that…read moregood! We had the pleasure of having Natalie as our server both nights who went above and beyond her knowledge on the raw bar helped guide us to loving everything we had & she found us one of the last slices of tiramisu from the night before because we loved it so much! This place is a Foodie's dream!! The specials change daily to keep a vibrant and fresh menu. This is a perfect date night for you & your loved ones or girls night the vibe is a dim but warmly lit atmosphere which makes it easy to spend hours here. This will 100% be on our list to always come back to when we are in the Keys.