Great atmosphere. Food was amazing and presented well. Bid…read moremenu with lots of choices. Great dessert case, many options. Great wine list. Service was super.

Yikes. Not sure how this place gets reviewed so highly?!…read more On a positive note the arancini balls were good. All four meals were average at best. We had pomodoro and added meatballs. This was a $25 pasta dish. The noodles were overcooked and tasted like boxed noodles. The homemade tomato sauce was just ok. Meatballs were decent. My child had a pizza which was ok. It was Neapolitan style and soggy. Our family of four spent $177 with tip, which I have no problem spending on a good meal, but this fell very short. We went to Wahoo's the other night and spent half that and it was 1000x better. Save your money and go elsewhere.

One of my fav places to stop! We always get the lasagna with meat sauce. Consistent over the years…read more Today we also tried the spinach salad with balsamic, fresh bacon, egg and onion. Sipped on key lime cider. No complaints! Portions are big enough to split or save for leftovers. We will be back next year!

When I researched where to get the best grouper Rubin in the aisle, Maida area the Bayside Gourmet…read morewas the most common response I got. Went there for lunch and absolutely had to say that the blackened grouper Reuben WAS all that! It was nice large sandwich, the grouper was thick and fresh and the blackened seasoning flavored it perfectly. It was served with a side of very crispy kettle chips and with my cold iced tea it was a perfect meal. The service was excellent and I love the decor from the 80s! This is definitely a destination you need to try, especially if they're blackened grouper Reuben! I look forward to the opportunity to stop back in to try something else on their menu. Please make this a destination as it is very easy to drive by and not notice.

Dog Shit Horrible!!!!…read more Sprint out the door, don't walk, don't jog; effing sprint out of this hell hole. The service was the worst I have ever had in over 30 years of patronizing any service industry... BY FAR and AWAY THE WORST!!! Over a 75 minute wait for a pizza and close to 90 minutes for the two calzones. Did not see the worthless waiter after he took the first order. My wife had to go ask for a second glass of wine and refills. The bacon in the calzone was not even done.. On top of that the manager and someone on the staff were talking about screwing over DoorDash as well based on an order that was not picked up due to not being assigned a driver. The service in the Florida Keys is usually slow and casual, yet this takes the cake for blatant disdain for the customer and incomprehensible incompetence.

absolutely would recommend customer s was excellent the food was amazing and overall experience was…read moreexcellent

Thanks to Google we spotted this awesome pizza place.. rating was about 4.2 which gave us more…read moreconfidence to eat here.. nice location . Right on the highway going to Key West... there are some seats inside to sit and eat.. not too many seats but good enough for4-5 families . Service was good .. Maria was really helpful . They also have beers, just as any other restaurants in key west ! Slightly expensive than the regular pizza places but worth it . Parking facilities are good . Loveddddddd the garden veggie pizza . The cheese taste was ultimate ! Have never had a pizza this good . Cheese pizza was good too. Just melted in z salad was ok. Could have had more cheese .. garlic knots were awesome . Marinara sauce was just out of the world. Wanted to give a 4 star , but just for the garden veggie pizza , I'm eating it 5/5 ..

Food- this place is not good , everything is bland or extremely mediocre, the calzones have tiny…read morepieces of pepperoni and instead of cheese it's this gross creamy Alfredo sauce. The salad is bland and flavorless, and we also received the wrong order , when we addressed the staff and called , they did nothing about it. This place is a disappointment. ALSO NO NEED TO RESPOND SARAH C. ( business owner) as all your responses are copy paste or automated .

Amazing. Exactly what you want from a beach bar. Great drinks. Amazing bartenders. Fun…read morepatrons. And the fried pickles. Outrageously good. Some may call it a "dive". I call it paradise.

We stopped in here late night after it being recommended by the bartender at Florida Keys Brewery…read more Upon pulling up, you might think that it would be a little rough inside, but quite the opposite! When we walked in, we were greeted by a friendly bartender who got us our drinks right away - and then come to find out that they have a pizza menu!! It's late night of course, we're hungry, so we order a pizza - It was SOOOOO good and not at all expected! We ended up ordering another one lol! We played shuffleboard, while enjoying our pizza and drinks and overall had a pretty fun time!

Captain Craig's was amazing !!! Best staff ever very sweet…read moreand made sure the restaurant was clean too. Loved the food, especially Picatta style so yummy! Bonus the key lime pie is absolutely to DIE FOR!

All I can actually say is.... AMAZING!! I ordered Shrimp Scampi and the Key Lime pie. They both…read morewere hands down...the BEST I have ever had. Service was great and accommodating to a large group. The Atmosphere was inviting and relaxing.

Last night my coworker picked up a pizza from Enrico's and to say we were very happy is an…read moreunderstatement! They have different options for entrees such as seafood and pasta items for those that aren't feeling pizza but this is what you really want! The crust tastes homemade and thin so you don't feel too overwhelmingly full. We opted for spinach, mushroom, and pepperoni on this sucker. The cheese was extremely rich and juicy. The prices aren't breaking the bank like other pizza spots in the area either. It was ready within 15 minutes which was also a lovely surprise! Krust, Upper Crust, and the other pizza joints need take note to how this place operates for sure! Highly recommend!

Enrico's has a sign on the front of their storefront saying it's NY style pizza, and as that's my…read morefavorite type of pizza, I had high hopes. Their pizza is thin crust like NY style, but that's where the similarities end. I found the crust a bit flavorless and the sauce lacking in spices as well. The pepperoni and meatball pizzas were well topped, but the spinach garlic pizza we ordered had barely anything on it. For a large pizza, I'd say each slice had 2-3 small spinach leaves, tops. It was extremely sparse considering you pay around $3 for extra toppings. It's edible for sure but if you want a solid slice of NY pizza, I'd skip this spot.

We decide to go here for our anniversary dinner as we were in town and had been told they had…read moreamazing food. Our server was very attentive and offered dinner suggestions. We had the Islamorada shrimp, Ribeye steak and scallop potatoes. Everything was prepared perfectly and were huge portions. We have already started recommending this place to our friends we have met that are also staying at a resort close by. We will definitely be back next time we are in Islamorada. Maybe even again tonight!

In a word, overrated. There was a lot of hype around this restaurant from locals and others who…read morerecommended. When we arrived it was mostly disappointment. We arrived and it was an awkward welcome from the hostess and the staff; lots of rules where to park and how to order water and having the party together to sit down. Our server was friendly and welcomed us and took our cocktail orders. The bar is unimpressive, the cocktails were mediocre to below average and the orders were simple. Negronis and Old Fashioned should be well executed at a steakhouse, not the case here and the cherry in the old fashioned was neon pink like a dive bar. We switched to wine and the wine list is impressive and there are some values on the menu. Appetizers were mediocre at best. Lobster bisque, as others have shared was a miss. Shrimp Islamorada was average and the breading was soggy. Tomato basil was good. Entrees were good - fish, steak and lobster dishes were good. The sides were unimpressive and lacking in flavor. Dessert was a miss, house made key lime pie tasted store bought and the crème brûlée was inedible. The price for the meal was typical of a high end steak house, the experience and meal was something far different and can't recommend to others.

Very good fish. We almost got glutened by the chips, but one of the servers ran to the back to…read moreassist us. A must try restaurant in the keys.

Hard to find this place. Everything on the ground floor is abandoned. After searching we found the…read moreplace upstairs. A very long an steep handicapped ramp. Anyway, the offer outside dining. Too cold and windy for this day. A large dining room and the bar area has tables also. We thought we would try it. Dated and in need of refurbishing. But, clean as a pin. The place has been taken care of. A whole crew of older ladies came in and the place started to get loud. They were all catching up. Bartender was on the ball. Waitstaff also swift and efficient. We made a decision to have a two and done. Extensive wine list. Limited bottle beer. Nothing on tap.

Once again majority of the food was on point. The conch buns were a little dry. It was a little…read moredisappointing that the oysters went from $1 to $2 but everything has gone up in price. We'll be back again when we are in the area.

we really love this place!! The view, the servers, the…read moreoysters, the appetizers, the staff are just so special. Service with a smile every time we have been there big shout out last night to Peter and Emily highly recommend.