Holy cow! Now it may have been a minute since I've indulged in a nice slice of pizza but did I hit the jackpot when my boss ordered a few different kinds form this establishment. I mean, wow! From the garlic buttery crust to the perfect amount of grease that would make a true New Yorker grin, this place did phenomenal on all the different pizzas that were ordered last week. My coworkers and I partook in the pesto swirl, vegetarian, hot honey pepperoni, cheese, and traditional pepperoni. I can't say enough good things about this place and love how it located in Islamorada to really give the competition a need to step it up in the keys. I was told the staff was also quite nice and efficient despite the large number of pies ordered last minute on a Friday morning. I cannot wait to try some more here soon! read more

See all

Food- this place is not good , everything is bland or extremely mediocre, the calzones have tiny pieces of pepperoni and instead of cheese it's this gross creamy Alfredo sauce. The salad is bland and flavorless, and we also received the wrong order , when we addressed the staff and called , they did nothing about it. This place is a disappointment. ALSO NO NEED TO RESPOND SARAH C. ( business owner) as all your responses are copy paste or automated . read more

Ordered online to bring pizza back to our room. When you online order there is no pickup time given so we just guessed. Service was prompt and friendly. The pizza was good but probably the greasiest pizza I've had in a long time. There was so much grease it stained our shirt carrying it back to the room leaking out of the box and was dripping down our arms eating. Pepperoni can get greasy but this was too much. You can tell the dough is a good base so maybe go with something with less toppings. We also go the Caesar which was big but for $15 pretty lack luster. Edible for resort food but with so many options around nothing to write home about. read more

Fast delivery and great pizza Delivered to our Hotel room. Under 45 min. Uber Eats. read more

We were in the mood for pizza. And looking this place up we spotted our fave pepperoni! Upon arriving we also noted that it is served with hot honey-bonus! Things got even better when Gus let us know that they had just baked one to use for slices - so we could have that. It went perfectly with light peroni beer; all was so good. Interesting touch were the plates - looked like paper, but not. Also appreciated the extras, honey, Parmesan, oregano, red pepper. read more

See all

This was just ok. The cheese bread had an odd taste to it and the buffalo chicken calzone wasn't good. It appeared to be cream cheese and a little buffalo sauce mixed with chicken. Super goopy and not much flavor. We had also ordered a cheese pizza, but our order got messed up and we didn't receive it. read more

Amazing service! It's clean and smells great inside. There's WiFi and Stubborn cola which is delicious my favourite is Pineapple. Beware pizza by the slice it's only before 3pm. The staff is nice and very knowledgeable about the menu. read more

Islamorada Pizza - Calzone nadas - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

We picked up our pizzas while staying at the Three Waters Resort, and they were DELICIOUS !!! We ordered a large sausage and mushroom and a green pepper and onion with extra sauce. We didn't expect much but the crust was thin and crispy, the mushrooms and sausage were fresh and we all loved it. I usually love the sausage and mushroom the best, but the green pepper and onion was AMAZING! We could not have asked for a better pizza and only wish we didn't live 2 1/2 hours away. The service was quick and efficient and the ambiance was nice as you eat there or take out. We ate the pizza on our balcony in balmy weather while listening to a live singer. It couldn't have been better. Definitely recommend!!! read more

Great pizza! I wasn't expecting much, but was pleasantly surprised by how good our pie was (and that's coming from a CT pizza fan). We decided on the "Pepe" pizza. The ratio of sauce to cheese was perfect and there was plenty of toppings! The dough was fluffy and light and the hot honey was the perfect touch. The service was great and the interior was very cute. Not too much seating, but what they have is perfect as most people take their pie's to go. I'd definitely recommend this spot if you're staying at the resort or nearby! read more

Islamorada Pizza - Pepe - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

We fed a big crowd and everyone loved it! The crust was a 10. Sauce a 10. Toppings - perfect.

I was in town for a fishing trip and wanted a pizza. They created a custom pizza for me that I really enjoyed. The service was friendly and fast. The inside has nice seating and was very clean. I will visit them again. read more

Its a clean and cool looking pizzaria but the pies are on par with Dominos and store frozen. They don't put enough sauce on as another review here stated . The slices are stiff and wont fold . They make everything in the back room so you cant see what they are doing. I don't think they make the pies by hand but in a dough press so unskilled can make the pies .All pies are the same round shape indicating pie press/ The young pizza maker was walking around in a hoodie. I thought he was the return of Travon Martin . Managment, don't they have polo company uniform shirts ?? read more

I was craving a cheesy pizza.... I saw like the pics of the all cheese pizza here, but there were only a few reviews, so I was nervous, but I went for it and OMG it was sooooo delicious. The spot is small inside (1 eight top, 1 six top, and 4 two seaters, plus a few outdoor spaces) but I was ordering to go. I ordered in store and they said about a 20 min wait, so I decided to order a glass of wine while I waited (they have a few beers and wines available). Staff were friendly. There were a few others dining inside and a couple To-go orders when I arrived. The pizza was AMAZING. Super cheesy with a wonderful chewy crust. Reminded me of if a new York style pizza merged with a high quality Naples (Italy) style pizza. I am pretty sure they put garlic butter on the crust as well. It was a good size and I could only eat 2 slices for dinner. I did eat a cold slice for breakfast and lunch and it was still delicious. If you like a high quality and cheesy pizza, this place is for you! read more

Islamorada Pizza - All the cheese pizza (to go). - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

This is a brand new place, right down the street from us, in the Keys. I was concerned that it would be any good at all, but I was in for a surprise..... absolutely great !! Very tasty , crispy, light crust !! Excellent flavor, of the Red and White Pizza we had with Sauce and Pesto ! Very good , unique flavors!! Friendly staff, just getting business going !! I'm happy; we have an excellent Pizzeria right down the street!! Enjoy ! read more

Islamorada Pizza - Great Pie! - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

See all

Flew into Miami staying at 3 Waters Resort and had to check out this pizza place people kept raving about. Very good pizza, hit the spot. Cute little place in the resort. read more

Islamorada Pizza - Half hot honey pepperoni and Italian sausage pizza with Caesar salad. - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Loved the pizza st this place! We are from New York so are a bit fussy!! Check it out. Nice owners too!

Watch this place. They will overcharge you and not apologize. In fact they will try to justify it. The pizza is ok but we ordered a plain pepperoni pizza with half mushroom. They charged us almost $30. Called and the manager was trying to justify how I got "a good deal". Baloney! If I ordered online I couldn't even make it get to $30. Check your bill. It might not be right - but they didn't appear to care. read more

Great pizza! The taste was wonderful and we like thin crust! We were hoping for stone crab, but the carnivorous was excellent!!!

Review for Islamorada Pizza Co - A Must-Try Spot in the Keys! We had the pleasure of trying Islamorada Pizza Co, the new pizza spot just outside of 3 Waters Resort in Islamorada, and it absolutely exceeded our expectations! We ordered the Carnivore Pizza, and it was phenomenal--crispy crust, high-quality meats, and perfectly portioned to feed four people comfortably. Every bite was packed with flavor, and it's clear they use only the best ingredients. The sodas were another highlight--no high fructose corn syrup, just clean, refreshing flavors that complemented the meal perfectly. The atmosphere is laid-back and inviting, making it a great spot to kick back and enjoy good food with family and friends. Bonus for locals--they offer a discount with your ID, which makes supporting this fantastic local business even better. If you're in Islamorada, do yourself a favor and check out Islamorada Pizza Co--you won't be disappointed! read more

See all

All flop, no sauce, cheap pizza over hyped. It is over priced while being accompanied by the taste of whole sale pizza from places like Walmart read more

It was a good experience, enjoyed the pizza. The garlic knots were a bit undercooked but fine. Also, it seemed like too much smoke in the dining area because of the kitchen. read more

The location is very trendy and inviting. I food was so good and the crispy pepperoni was addicting! read more

Islamorada Pizza - Fresh hot and tasty kid and adult approved pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

The seating and layout of the place was like a cafeteria. The pizza was decent. Pepperoni pizza was greasy but tasted good. We also had the pittmaster. Really enjoyed it. 2 stars because the soda machine was broken and we had already been charged for 3 sodas. This would have been a 5 if I was offered my money back. Paid in cash so no credit card fees. read more

Islamorada Pizza - Pitmaster Crispy Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Islamorada, Florida

Jeff and Alexandria are the best! Love the spot! Very welcoming! good quality restaurant and people!

The food was so-so. That being the pizza. We also tried a salad. I was not very impressed with the salad as far as freshness would be considered. The lettuce was soft and limp and too much dressing. Overall mediocre at best. read more

It took an hour and a half for our pizzas?? We ordered 2, got charged for 3, and then after sorting that out they only made the one pizza and we had to wait 25 minutes again for the second one. Service could definitely use improvement. Pizza was fye though. read more

I wasn't expecting much from a hotel pizza restaurant but we were blown away. The space is small and unassuming but the food is amazing. It's counter service only but I'll happily refill my own drink for food this good. read more

I was expecting overpriced small pizzas and was pleasantly surprised to see full size, affordably priced pizzas. We went by boat and aren't totally sure we were allowed to dock in the marina but were able to keep an eye on the boat while dining on the outdoor patio which had a nice ambiance. Service was beyond friendly and made it a nice experience for our family with kids. It of course has less "keys character" than the old bait shop it replaced and more "resort vibe" but that's life. Overall, the pizza was delicious and I recommend any pizza lovers give it a try. We got a cheese and the vegetarian pesto one, both a hit. It's much closer to us than empire/boardwalk pizza and this will be our new go-to pizza place when in the area. read more

We got a pizza while staying at the resort and it was phenomenal! Quite possibly the best pizza we've ever had. We got 1/2 carnivore and 1/2 red white and green. Loved them both but surprised by how much I loved the red white and green. The crust was bubbly and crisp and the flavors were just delicious. I only wish they had smaller sizes as we were in a hotel room with a small fridge and no way to heat it up the next day. We tried setting it in the sun....lol...but it just wasn't the same. Just get one, you'll love it! read more

My boyfriend and I stumbled in here on a long drive, needing something fast and not wanting fast food. We were not expecting much but we were pleasantly surprised!! We got the cheesy bread and pepperoni apps and both were delicious :) definitely recommend read more

Arrived at the nearby Three Waters resort and after checking in was looking for a slice (it was just me) only to find that they weren't selling slices. What kind of pizza place doesn't sell slices? read more

kind and respectful staff, messed up our order but gave us both pizzas and both were incredible. We got one four cheese pizza and one with just mozzarella, so good read more

I know this is a small family owned business and they're working hard to make it successful.....but, the pizza was awful and the atmosphere was just as bad. read more

Food, Service, Ambiance was amazing, Glad the Florida keys is getting some new good spots!