First off, I was greeted in a very friendly manner by a nice gentleman who may have been the owner. He patiently explained the entire menu to me and talked about the different fish they had that day. I ordered the lobster roll and a Pellegrino is a very good lobster roll with a unique lime taste to the mayo drizzle on top. Chips were fresh and just the right amount. Great view and upbeat music I'm glad I found this place on my way to the airport. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Such a cute place! We came in at 3pm for a late lunch. 3 adults 2 teenagers with 2 picky eaters. The owner (I assume) was so accommodating! And so nice! Everything was super fresh and tasty. We had 3 fish tacos, 1 chicken taco and fried calamari. We all enjoyed it immensely! It's also so nice to eat right next to the boats. Super calming read more

What The Fish Rolls - Calamari - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Our fish tacos and calamari were absolutely amazing. Top notch! Service was exceptional- seems like it was the owner who took the order and delivered the food. Was super helpful. Coming for late lunch it was quiet with some fun background music. We'll certainly come again next time we're in the Keys read more

Dockside eatery in a busy marina with standout seafood rolls. Delicious! We had the Casa del Mar fish roll (fresh mahi), fish tacos, and ceviche. Every bite tasted fresh and succulent, which is not always the case. The cashier/food runner was very welcoming and made the experience even more enjoyable. Good, fresh food for a reasonable price. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Ceviche - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

We stopped in because we were in the mood for some fish tacos. There are some parking spots out front. There was a super friendly young guy who worked here, I wish I got his name, but he was sweet and really provided great customer service and cared about ensuring our meal was good. We ordered a ceviche and an order of fish tacos. Both came with some tortilla chips. The ceviche was the best thing we got for sure, really thick pieces of fresh fish, freshly cut onion, some crunchy texture from the peruvian corn. All in all, delicious. The tacos were pretty good too and we enjoyed dipping them in the sauce leftover from the ceviche. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Fish tacos - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Absolutely fantastic lobster roll, packed with flavor! Bread was well toasted. Service was incredible and very fast. The restaurant is just off the highway and easy to access. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Best fish tacos in the keys! Friendly staff, highly recommended place. Will be back soon!

Stopped by this place based on the reviews. And it did not disappoint! Six of us each tried different rolls and devoured them. Only problem was it was extremely hot outside and there's no indoor dining. My suggestion would be to add some fans. The gentleman behind the service counter was friendly and informative. Keep up the good work, Guys. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Crab roll and Cape Cod chips - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

This was by far the best ceviche I have ever had outside of PERU! Great team and extremely helpful when it comes to making decisions for those second guessing options. I recommend the Shrimp roll, but next time I go I definitely want to try the lobster roll. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Ceviche - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Whenever I travel, I'm always looking to Yelp to find these tucked away hidden gem places. This was a great little spot, nothing fancy for sure but very comfortable setting on a sort of water canal ( so water and boats to look at). Extremely friendly owner turning out some really good food. We had a crab cake roll that was very good... and a Main lobster roll. The roll was right on point, a New England style roll that was perfect. I was reluctant to get Main Lobster while in the Keys, but I had already had Florida Lobster several times on this trip ... so I did it. I'm from FL so I'm just gonna say this .... Main lobster may be better read more

See all

Our go to every time we go out to the sandbar with Island Girls!!!! Fabulous hidden gem!!!

You don't want to leave the keys without checking this place out. If you're a first timer; Alex walks you through the menu like a breeze. Tells you what's what and what's the catch of the day. After ordering, Alex walks the dishes over. I had the Market fish entree and my boyfriend had the LobsterRoll, we shared the "Ceviche Del Mar". And we both agreed this was one of the best meals in FL. I'm VERY picky about Ceviche and this was so fresh and delicious. The ceviche alone could've been a meal. The market fish entree was cooked in olive oil and salt; appropriately seasoned for a fresh catch. And my boyfriend was just speechless on his lobster. He was in lobster bliss. These place is like a little shake shack, sitting inside a strip mall/dock area. I definitely recommend coming here before leaving FL. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster roll with house chips// ceviche with corn chips - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

This was by far the best meal we had in the Florida Keys. Most of the other restaurants we tried were unfortunately underwhelming--the food just didn't live up to the hype on social media or influencer reviews. I'm so glad we found this spot, thanks to its glowing Yelp reviews and convenient location right next to Paddle! Florida Keys, where we did a mangrove eco tour. We ordered the lobster roll, ceviche, and a side of fried calamari: Lobster Roll (M.P. $30 on the day we visited) Served on warm, buttery bread and packed with juicy, flavorful lobster meat. Way better than the ones in Key West, which used small, dry, broken pieces ( and claimed to be one of the top of the world's lobster roll) Ceviche ($17) Made with the fresh catch of the day. Zesty and incredibly fresh. Fried Calamari, Small Side ($8) Crispy, tender, and clearly just made. They also offer a nice selection of craft beers and sparkling drinks, including prosecco. The food came out quickly and everything tasted freshly prepared. We loved sitting on the deck by the ocean, with boats nearby and tarpons swimming right beneath us. read more

See all

Did someone say yummo ?! That food was what the clutch I was so hungry and we went kayaking before this at the place right next to it. The guy with the cowboy hat at the counter was quite friendly and the food was delish. We both got the fresh catch of the day fish rolls and they were awesome. The shrimp roll looked good as well side note. Overall great dining experience, sea breeze was hitting and the tables were nice. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

This restaurant was quaint outside dining right on the marina. The best lobster roll I have ever had $33. Fish tacos were amazing. Highly recommend this place. The owner was very informative. Great service. read more

See all

This jewel in the Florida Keys is exceptional! Everytime I visit I am delighted with the freshness and delicious cuisine. Lobster Roll, Fresh shrimp Tacos and yummy fish sandwich are among my favorite. Ambiance by the waterway dock serene. The owner cares and prepares your meal with love. read more

Nice ambiance, was a pretty view. Service was decent and food was okay. Would come back if someone else wanted to but I think there are better fish/lobster rolls. read more

The lobster rolls in this place are amazing. Easily the top in all of Florida. It's an easy place to eat with cold drinks and a nice view.

Really great shrimp rolls and fish tacos in an off the beaten path spot in the middle Keys. Love eating on the water and also seeing nurse sharks just off the dock. Very friendly manager/owner who takes pride in his business. We've been twice and love it. read more

Fresh local fish , never frozen. Fish was delicious. Had the catch of the day fish roll (Mangrove Snapper/ Gray Snapper) with potato chips. Service is good, you order at the counter, pay and they bring it to your table, then service is done. Tables out in the back on the water self seating. Tip to owner: you need to put a fan out there on the deck for a breeze and to keep the flies away. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Mangrove Snapper fish roll. Catch of the day - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Service was great (he even set expectations on the wait which was not long!) and gave good recommendations. We split a fish sandwich and the ceviche. We're light eaters, so this may not work for everyone! We sat outside on the water, drank a cold beer and enjoyed lunch. read more

See all

Everything was so delicious. The spice levels were amazing and the service was great. The prices were a bit high compared to the portion sizes but hey, in this economy... The restaurant was clean and the outside seating was chill. Overall, I loved this place! read more

See all

On our way up from Marathon, we were in the car discussing how unimpressed we were with food down in the Florida Keys, particularly the fish. We were looking for 2 things: freshness & flavor... And "wala" as the owner, Alex, commonly says, that's exactly what we found last minute driving up back home at What The Fish. This place is a true hidden gem as many describe in the reviews. The owner is a masterpiece of a host, he greets you upon entering with a grand introduction of his menu in which he explains so proudly! The view of the small marina behind his shop is perfect, beautiful homes and boats strolling by to look at while you eat. The food = outstanding. We got the Casa Mar rolls and they were incredibly tasteful. Make the stop to visit and support this local small business, you will not be disappointed. We are only sad we didn't find this place sooner, especially with the old prices... read more

What The Fish Rolls - inside - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

Mahi mahi roll by the marina. A cold Corona and a sunburn from the day. A nice breeze with birds chirping all over the place. No complaints, we will be back. Thanks! read more

YUM! Stopped in for lunch today ready for a good lobster roll. Extremely pleased with my roll. It was messy but aren't the best foods a little messy? The owner explained their menu and was very kind. A definite must stop in the Keys! read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster roll as it comes. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Yes. Lobster and shrimp rolls. Fish tacos are solid. Ceviche was great. Service is superb and personal. Back porch is nice and feels very much like a Keys hangout. read more

This place is a great break from the same themed shell tiki bar places. Clean quiet and on a nice little quiet bay its a needed break. The food is exceptional. read more

Absolutely incredible restaurant!! Best lobster roll EVER! Service and ambiance were also great! read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

We stopped in for some rolls after finding this place on yelp. We got a lobster roll that didn't have FL lobster. Instead, it had Maine lobster even though it was a few days into lobster season in the area. We also got the end of the embargo roll. The rolls were just rolls, nothing great and nothing bad. Parking is a pain. read more

See all

Holy cow! Best lobster roll ever, and I used to live in New England! Calamari was crisp and perfectly cooked. The casa mar fresh local fish was perfectly seasoned. The green dressing on the lobster roll was good enough to eat with a spoon. Single leaf of butter lettuce kept the butter toasted roll crisp. Worth the 5 star rating, will definitely be back next time we visit the keys. Charming host/owner explained the menu in detail so we knew what we were ordering. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Lobster roll, casa mar roll and calamari. - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

Wow, what a hidden gem in Tavernier! All I can say is, you can definitely taste how fresh the fish is. Both sandwiches and the calamari salad were superb. Cool spot to grab a fresh fish sandwich and a beer! Gentleman taking the orders was really nice too. Great vibes at this local spot. I see why it has great reviews. Will def. Be back. read more

See all

A group of us stopped into What the Fish Rolls for a quick lunch while playing in the area. Free parking can be found in the parking lot. Discover is an accepted form of payment. Orders are placed and paid for at the counter. Bottled beer and wine can be purchased to enjoy with one's meal. Outdoor seating can accommodate large parties. Shade is provided if direct sunshine is unwanted. I ordered a bottle of Elysian IPA for $5.50 and the Ceviche del Mar for $17: white fish of the day, red onions, Aji Limo, cilantro, toasted corn and tortilla chips. I was thrilled to find a beer from home (Seattle) and my lunch choice was light, tasty and satisfying. I savored everything about my lunch experience, from the enthusiastic and friendly staff, raw and delicate view, lovely view and friendly locals. Overall, I am thankful to have stumbled upon What the Fish Rolls. What a gem. read more

See all

The food was delicious but I felt they could have stuffed it more with more lobster on the lobster roll and calamari on the calamari roll. For the price they should've been more. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Calamari Roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all

A perfect spot for a quick lunch. They have delicious rolls that come with potato chips. I really enjoyed the shrimp roll, but the shrimps kept falling out. My friend had the Casa Mar Roll with the catch of the day (Mahi Mahi when we visited) and that was also delicious without the spillage. Right off the Overseas Hwy, there is usually plenty of parking in the center. The dining areas are in a hut and right by the waterfront. The restroom is shared between all the shops in the area and is located 2 stores over. read more

See all

Cute little restaurant off Hwy 1 tucked away right on the canal by a small marina. Order at the counter for delicious fresh fish rolls - we ordered the lobster roll, a chicken taco and the casa Del Mar roll at the counter and grabbed a seat outside on some high tops overlooking the water. They also had picnic tables around the other side. Food was amazing and came out quickly. Service was efficient and friendly. read more

See all

Excellent fish tacos! Corn tortilla prepared perfectly! First time visit and would definitely recommend. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Fish taco on corn tortilla - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

We've been wanting to try this place for a while. It has a great location and sits outside of a marina on the water. The employees were so friendly and accommodating, which made our visit even better. We shared the Castaway roll and some perfectly fried clams. We sat eating, overlooking the water on a gorgeous day. What more could you want? Beer and other beverages are for sale as well. The shrimp roll It was delicious, with fresh avocado, red onion, plenty of shrimp, and tossed in a light sauce. I did think the bread was a little chewy, and I was missing the toasted buttered bun you typically see with these types of rolls. It is still yummy, nonetheless. I can't wait to return. It makes for a great little day trip while visiting nearby attractions. read more

See all

Saw this on Yelp. Tricky to find, but the food is delicious. Outdoor seating only, but we had the benefit of watching 2 manatees in the marina from our table! The catch is fresh and tasted like it! Yum! read more

Fantastic place. Alex, the owner. served us and was so enthusiastic it was awesome. The lobster roll was hot and delicious. Great way to start the weekend sitting outside on the deck. Highly recommended read more

The restaurant is rustic and cool. I liked the shack feel to it. I wish I had tried a different roll, but it was tasty nonetheless (see pictures). I would give them a try next time you're in the area. read more

What The Fish Rolls - Casa mar roll - Seafood Near Me - Tavernier, Florida

See all