Holy cow! Now it may have been a minute since I've indulged in a nice slice of pizza but did I hit…read morethe jackpot when my boss ordered a few different kinds form this establishment. I mean, wow! From the garlic buttery crust to the perfect amount of grease that would make a true New Yorker grin, this place did phenomenal on all the different pizzas that were ordered last week. My coworkers and I partook in the pesto swirl, vegetarian, hot honey pepperoni, cheese, and traditional pepperoni. I can't say enough good things about this place and love how it located in Islamorada to really give the competition a need to step it up in the keys. I was told the staff was also quite nice and efficient despite the large number of pies ordered last minute on a Friday morning. I cannot wait to try some more here soon!

Food- this place is not good , everything is bland or extremely mediocre, the calzones have tiny…read morepieces of pepperoni and instead of cheese it's this gross creamy Alfredo sauce. The salad is bland and flavorless, and we also received the wrong order , when we addressed the staff and called , they did nothing about it. This place is a disappointment. ALSO NO NEED TO RESPOND SARAH C. ( business owner) as all your responses are copy paste or automated .

Bayside Gourmet is seriously the BEST!! I lived across the street for 8 months and wow wow wow. The…read morepasta is just incredible. I'm obsessed with their massive chicken parm, there's soo much melted cheese it's amazing. Also the tortellini is from another world!! So fresh, amazing cheese, and the parmesan cream sauce is so rich and delicious. My husband had the grouper sandwich once, that was also very good. They have good beer selections. Just come here, you won't regret it!! PS, sometimes the service is slow when they're slammed during busy hours, but who cares you're in the keys and good food is worth the wait. Love the food here!

Very friendly service and attentive. Food was delicious…read morebut really loved the key lime pie We ate outside on the patio and nice ambiance Yes, recommend this for everyone

We were lucky... this place was very close to where we stayed in Key Largo. The place was nice ,…read moreclean and friendly owners that were working / running the restaurant. The hot honey pepperoni was great and plenty to split for 2 with a couple slices leftover. The Caesar salad was also very good. It's similar to Detroit style ( square, thicker ,made in a pan) Was not disappointed and I eat a lot of pizza all over

Small little pizza stop. Chill atmosphere. You order at the counter. They were accommodating and I…read morewas able to get no cheese on my half of our pizza. Prices are a little high. Pizza was good.

Enrico's has a sign on the front of their storefront saying it's NY style pizza, and as that's my…read morefavorite type of pizza, I had high hopes. Their pizza is thin crust like NY style, but that's where the similarities end. I found the crust a bit flavorless and the sauce lacking in spices as well. The pepperoni and meatball pizzas were well topped, but the spinach garlic pizza we ordered had barely anything on it. For a large pizza, I'd say each slice had 2-3 small spinach leaves, tops. It was extremely sparse considering you pay around $3 for extra toppings. It's edible for sure but if you want a solid slice of NY pizza, I'd skip this spot.

I visited Enrico's five years ago and had such a great experience. The food was great, as well as…read moreservice. I always wanted to visit again and finally did. I could say this has been the worst dining experience I've had in a long time. Not only was the service horrible, but they hardly had any of the items on the menu. I remember the meatballs, pizza and rolls being amazing so we ordered that. The meatballs had potential but they must have been frozen and were warm on the outside but the middle was cold. There was no way of getting the waiter to tell him since we waited about 25 minutes to get our order in. Mind you we were the only ones in the restaurant. The rolls were not edible. The pizza was ok, but the crust had no salt whatsoever so you couldn't eat it. I was going to try the dessert but opted not to since it would have taken half hour more. It's such a shame because they were so good. Never again. I usually do not leave bad reviews, but this was just total neglect of a once good establishment.

Just had a great time and a great dinner at the Italian Food Company. The key lime pie was top…read morenotch.

Nice alternative if you're looking for something not seafood…read more The meat lovers pizza was exceptional. It's traditional Italian- super thin crust, crispy edges, really tasty. The chicken parm with spaghetti was good enough. The chicken was fried perfectly- crispy coating, not soggy as so often can be. The spaghetti was cooked perfectly, al dente. We sat at the bar- best chairs are there. Ozzi at the bar was great. This place has an authentic Italian feel to it. Real pasta, fresh made desserts and some imported from Italy. All the way around- a great experience.

We stopped in here late night after it being recommended by the bartender at Florida Keys Brewery…read more Upon pulling up, you might think that it would be a little rough inside, but quite the opposite! When we walked in, we were greeted by a friendly bartender who got us our drinks right away - and then come to find out that they have a pizza menu!! It's late night of course, we're hungry, so we order a pizza - It was SOOOOO good and not at all expected! We ended up ordering another one lol! We played shuffleboard, while enjoying our pizza and drinks and overall had a pretty fun time!

Fun divey,townie place. Super friendly bar tender took time to explain and talk pizza with us. We…read morewished we would have ordered just cheese pizza and not sausage. The crust was light with good under carriage. The sausage was not great. If you like sweet sauce you will the pizza sauce here. I like a a little more tang to mine personally but it was not bad. One bite gave it 6.8.. i would drop to 6.3.

Beer was amazing and on site food truck was delicious!!! Beer Garden out back was the perfect place…read moreto relax for the afternoon.

Staff are always wonderful and fit the vibe. Get yourself a spiny hopster. The classic west coast…read moreIPA you don't see a lot of any more. I crave this beer garden when we're on the mainland and the on-premises Taco Jalisco food truck always hits the spot.

Wow. Great atmosphere. It seems everyone knew everyone else. An incredible menu, smoked bacon…read morefried green tomatoes BLT, brisket burgers, chicken salad, wonderful shakes, terrific fries. Great beers on tap and those prices are just perfect. I like a fancy meal once in a while but it's just too much when your down in the Keys. We're looking for a simple place that is reasonable and great. This is it. Service is terrific, menu is unique.

Stopped in with our family when on vacation. We had read the rave reviews, seen the restaurant…read morefeatured on triple D, and read the "Best Burger in Florida." The place is small and we sat at the bar. It's a cool, dive bar vibe with memorabilia on the wall. There were only a handful of others there, but the service was slow, especially considering it wasn't very crowded. It seems like the waitress was distracted and forgot about us. Eventually, we were taken care of. We all got one of their sodas and thought h they tasted good. We tried to order their award-winning fish dip, listed on the specials board, but the waitress said they were out of chips. Ok, fine -- we said "forget it" and moved onto the main course. We all ordered some variation of the Fancy Nancy, their namesake burger. It was a good burger but not the best in Florida. Not even close. The fries were frozen and nothing to write home about. Others in our party ordered the "award-winning" potato salad, which tasted pretty good. As an aside, I ordered my burger medium well, and it was cooked as desired. Everyone else ordered their burger medium and two were very pink, more like medium rare or rare. It seems like most of their awards and accolades were earned pre-COVID. We wanted to like this local spot but I have to imagine it's not what it once was.

Such a cute place! We came in at 3pm for a late lunch. 3 adults 2 teenagers with 2 picky eaters…read more The owner (I assume) was so accommodating! And so nice! Everything was super fresh and tasty. We had 3 fish tacos, 1 chicken taco and fried calamari. We all enjoyed it immensely! It's also so nice to eat right next to the boats. Super calming

Our fish tacos and calamari were absolutely amazing. Top notch!…read more Service was exceptional- seems like it was the owner who took the order and delivered the food. Was super helpful. Coming for late lunch it was quiet with some fun background music. We'll certainly come again next time we're in the Keys

Beautiful ocean views and wonderful service from Alana at Hog Heaven. Casual, beach vibes with an…read moreoutdoor dining and bar area, a short walk to the tiki bar, and inside dining for those looking for AC and shelter from any storms. I highly recommend the blackened shrimp tacos. We also ordered the 3-sliders (the Turkey bacon was delicious) and the pulled pork on Texas toast which was good and a hefty portion.

What a big place, with lots of seating inside and outside. On a Sunday at 1:00pm it was super sunny…read moreout and the only tables outside were just in the hot sun so we went inside, also to watch the Bills game. They have a few big TV screens inside, and had labels indicating which football games they were showing. Inside is was super cold as they had the a/c down pretty low. Our server was very friendly and we went with the master bbq plate with three meats and two side. The brisket was super tender. The St. Louis ribs were meaty and very delicious, but not fall off the bone. The pulled pork was good. We also ordered 6 wings and they were nicely smoked, but bit tough and chewy.