I wanted to give a shout-out to this diner and to Sofia, our waitress. I ordered a 10oz steak with mashed potatoes and a salad. Everything was great, the steak was done to my request, and the salad was large. It was the mashed potatoes that I really appreciated about this meal; the clumps of potato told me they were homemade. This diner will be on my regular stops. read more

This is what I expect a diner to be! Great service, Great food and a Great price! My wife and I were both impressed with our orders and both said if we lived close, we would eat here all the time! 5 Stars! read more

See all

We love this diner. Very clean. Great service. Reasonable prices. The wraps, chicken fingers, sweet potato fries and onion rings are great. The fries/onion ring portion is also HUGE. Well worth it. read more

I had a nice experience when going here the other day. I had mixed emotions because I heard a rumor that it was not so good. Well they were wrong. It was not too busy and very clean. The pancakes were really good.Some of the best I have had in a while. It was nice cozy and very modern looking. The waitress was very courteous and nice. Looking forward to going back soon. read more

See all

Food was good. Food quality was good. Service was good. Ambiance is amazing. I love how clean and inviting it is. Very sleek and modern. BUT the thing that stops me (and many people that I know) from making this place a regular spot is: it's too expensive. The prices are high to begin with and there's an up charge for almost anything. Most things you would expect to come with fries come with "chips" and you have to pay $3 extra on top of the high prices to get fries. (Also as someone who is extremely critical of French fry quality they weren't even that good. I'm very picky with French fries. It's not that anything was necessarily wrong with them. They were just "battered fries".) If your meal comes with soup and salad and you want to upgrade to French onion it's $3 extra and if you want a Caesar salad it's $2 extra. So if you get a chicken fingers basket for 19.99 and the 2 add ons for $5, that's $25. Travel less than a mile down the highway and there's 2 all you can eat places that range from 14.99-26.99 (depending on day and time) but for arguments sake let's say dinner time. So it would cost 1.99 more to go to an all you can eat. Guess which one I'm going to? The diner is very nice. But I don't wanna pay for your renovation! ‍ Someone had to say it. I'll drive to Easton for the better value. Bottom line: you'll enjoy the food, atmosphere and staff but you won't feel like your buck got you as far as it would anywhere else. I wouldn't mind the elevated prices if this were a fine dining experience but it's not. It's just a diner. read more

Key City Diner - Mini dinners chicken tenders and fries (2 tenders missing) - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Great food, friendly staff, quick service, cozy vibe. Highly recommend! Will definitely return soon!

Greg the owner, and staff run a great family diner the best in both new jersey and worth the drive from pa, you will keep coming back again and again, Homemade cooking at its best 5 STARS the menu has something for everyone should anyone be disappointed its probaly your fault What a great place! read more

Great friendly & clean diner with excellent food and portions at very fair prices. We will be coming back.

Jill and I went this morning for breakfast to the newly reopened and perfectly renovated Key City Diner. Greg the owner and his mother were there to greet all patrons The service was impeccable the food was outstanding and the renovation was over the top. We are looking forward to going back many times. And wish the family owners much success We highly recommend the Key City Diner read more

Brand new and renovated inside! Everything inside appeared fresh and clean. My grandma loves this place and they have something for everyone! All of the food was served fresh and piping hot. They have great deals! Their mini dinner meals come with a soup AND a salad.All the staff was friendly and accommodating. Would stop by this place on a future visit to Jersey. read more

See all

Food & service both very good. I got the chicken cordon bleu (it's not coated in flour, so a yes for a low carb lifestyle). It comes with side salad & soup - gave the soup (pepper pot) to my granddaughter (again.... Carbs) also came with a side salad was fresh & crispy. I only have a picture of my leftover chicken reheated in the air fryer at home, and I added some tomatoes & broccoli. Just as good reheated! Kids had burger, omelette & we all had a taste of Boston cream cake.... All delicious! read more

Key City Diner - Chicken cordon bleu (leftovers at home) I added the tomatoes! - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Ok but wouldn't go out of my way for this diner. I ordered an ice tea not realizing they only serve it from the fountain. To say ithe ice tea was gross would be an understatement. Once the waitress let me know it was a fountain drink and not brewed I asked for a Coke instead. That was just as nasty as the ice tea. Upon paying the bill I told them that both beverages were horrible and they let me know that they had someone come to fix the fountain a few days prior. If the fountain was not working correctly, did no one check to make sure it was ok before serving to anyone? The food was mediocre. The building appears to have been redone recently so it's quite nice actually but that's not gonna cut it. read more

Very pleasantly surprised. Got off the highway for a quick dinner while passing through. The menu has everything you could possibly want and more. I ordered Greek pork Souvlaki with pitas. It came with soup (creamy potato) and a fresh green salad and fries! It was more food than I could eat and I took more than half my meal to go. It was delicious but huge portions! My husband got stuffed peppers with mashed potatoes and mixed veggies along with soup (an excellent lentil soup) and salad. Two huge stuffed peppers! We easily could have split one entree but glad we didn't because we got another meal for the next day. Service was quick and friendly, our waitress was training a new staff and was super attentive. Highly recommend and future diner experiences will be compared to this one. read more

Food was okay, nothing special. Nice new decor and clean inside & out. Service was good and coffee quickly served. Prices were high for what you get. For breakfast two people should expect to pay $30.+ read more

Key City Diner - Omelette - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Good diner experience. Good service. The vintage exterior has been maintained nicely. read more

See all

Always loved this diner especially because it had the beauty of an original vintage diner inside and out. Even though I miss the aesthetic of the vintage diner, I have to say that the renovation and updates are very nice. Clean and comfy with the same great food! And of course the gorgeous vintage sign makes it even more fun. read more

Woke up early and craving potatoes, so, we headed to the post-fire renovation re-opening of the diner for breakfast this Sunday after Independence Day. The inside decor is not the same ole diner from our late night stops back in 1980's. The cityscape mural on the one wall, all new floors and all updated furnishings throughout. And with the economy since Covid, the food costs are super expensive. All over, double priced food with smaller portions. A shout out to Carla, a ROCKSTAR server, whose reasonto make customers happy, was on pointe with a personality to match. Great gal. Ok, 3 scrambled eggs, home fries and dry toast, $8.99. Meh. Chicken fried steak, eggs, & home fries, $13.99. I'm noticing restaurants are not only raising prices PLUS omitting a side. It's what's happening and I'm leaving hungry. We gave it a go and file it under: OAD (onceanddone). read more

Great place, so much more than a diner. Owner super nice and they hire the best people who really take care of you. Had the Goulash dinner special and it was delicious! With soup and salad it was a great meal. So happy they reopened!!! If in the area stop by, you won't be disappointed! read more

Best Diner Around! Food always hot and fresh! Waitress Alex is the Best since the twins Victoria and Valerie worked there! Alex is vey friendly, checked on us several times, she's the Bomb and easy on the eyes as well! read more

I waited a long time for Key City to reopen. Looks great inside, Food was good as were the staff, although my waitress might have been a little too new to solo. . A bit of sticker shock on the menu prices to be perfectly honest. Before the fire I knew the owner and the staff, so I miss the old staff. I know the economy has caused prices to rise dramatically, but I'm on a fixed budget I doubt I'll get there as often as I used too. read more

Service was very good. We were checked in several times during our meal to see if we needed anything. Healthy portions. Had corned beef rueben and other guest had a burger. read more

A very old school diner from the outside. I thought the coffee was very good. My breakfast was really good. The sausage Gray Benedict was full of flavor and completely action packed! My home fries were crisp, as requested. Unfortunately my pancakes were cold. My traveling associate explained to me his sausage gravy with biscuits and eggs was room temperature at best. Service also wasn't impressive. It took a long period of time to simply get coffee. They did seem short staffed. Food was great! Service fell short. I do recommend this place for a very good meal, and hopefully, service can get some help. read more

Key City Diner - Sausage Gravy Benedict - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

See all

The new decor is beautiful. Our server was absolutely lovely, and the food was fantastic! My husband, who considers himself a true connoisseur of country fried steak, gave theirs five stars! I had the steak and eggs, which were out of this world - both at breakfast and for dinner when I ate the second half of my enormous breakfast steak! We love this place. Hope you do, too! read more

When they reopened after the fire, the food was incredible! Generous portions, excellently prepared and delicious. Fast forward to Feb. 2025 and well, now, not so much. Its the exact opposite. Breakfast plates are served in very poor preparation, overcooked with scant ingredients. The table service is still excellent, but it's pretty clear that its now just overpriced food without regard for quality or serving size quantity. Most days I drive by, and the parking lot is more often than not empty, and I know why. Was just there, left very disappointed. I won't be going back any longer, just a waste of money. Too bad to, because they were really doing a great job. read more

Food was average , nothing spectacular. Service was just service lol nothing special, nice setup though everything is new and updated but nothing to really make the diner stand out read more

Really cool place Family owned, they make great pies and serve with a smile Open 24 hours a day, seven days a week. It definitely a trip down memory lane read more

Key City Diner - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

See all

Nice Diner. First time there. Breakfast was good. Went with a large group so waitress worked really hard and took care of us very well. Just your typical Diner. But they did change there times and are not open 24/7. read more

Key City Diner - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Great food and service. Brand new beautiful building. Glad they reopened. The staff was friendly, coffee fresh and supplied locally and I would definitely return here. read more

Decided to check out Key City Diner after the fire. Used to eat there often and enjoyed my favorite, chicken franchiaise. Nice renovation job, leaning much more modern. I ordered without consulting the menu, and sipped a raspberry iced tea while I waited. The waitress arrived with a dish that was anything but chicken franchaise. The breast was breaded as opposed to an egg coating and the sauce was bland. The pasta was mushy and not especially hot. Oh well. Then the bill arrived. $32 for this meal. I don't mind paying for good food, but this is a diner, not a fine Italian restaurant. The service was adequate and I left a tip. But I will not be returning with prices like that. Burned in P'burg. read more

Not worth the money. Took an hour to get our food. People came in 20 mins after us got there food 10 mins sooner than we did . $77.00 for 3 breakfast too much read more

Where do I start? The place, so beautiful!! couldn't have pictured such a beautiful diner! the food was amazing. I ordered the broiled seafood combo. it came with soup, salad, and twi sides. I was soo stuffed. The portions were a nice size. The desserts are a must!!! ordered a black out cake and a strawberry cheesecake. I'm still thinking about them. Everyone was so pleasant. highly recommended!! read more

The food is very good. But the pricing is very high. Felt like I was raped financially. For 2 cheeseburger deluxe, 2 sodas and 2 pieces of cake. It came to $52.00. Wow just wow. Won't be going there anymore. The service was really good. The ambiance is cold and sterile. New modern look. read more

Good food, good service, good people. A solid go to spot. Friendly atmosphere. I love the gyros and the burgers.. amazing French fries.

Don't order a cheeseburger and fries because it is terrible! They couldn't cook it right , but poor quality. Bad tasting.

I stopped here while passing through the area at 3:30 pm on a Monday, Halloween to be exact. Usually at Jersey diners, the staff is old and crotchety, which is part of the charm in my mind. To my mild surprise, the staff here at this time was pretty young, everyone was dressed in costume, and everyone was very friendly. Nice touch, gang! Plus, the sausage egg and cheese sandwich was incredibly good. It wasn't busy at that time, so I was able to hop back on the road in record time. Your experience may vary, but mine was excellent. read more

Key City Diner - Turkey sausage, egg, and cheese on a kaiser roll - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

Not really my part of NJ, but I was traveling through the area with a friend, he was feeling hungry and light-headed (diabetes? hypoglycemia? he should probably get that checked out with a doctor...but I digress...), and this place presented itself. It looked like an old-style diner, the kind of place that's been around forever and hasn't spent money on a "modernistic facelift," which is a point in its favor, as far as I'm concerned. I'm a sucker for breakfast food when I'm in a diner...which actually isn't very often...so I ordered 3 pancakes with a side of scrambled eggs, home fries and ham, along with a glass of orange juice. My friend ordered some kind of omelet, which seemed huge. The waitress was friendly enough and efficient, and the food came out with relative speed. My feelings about the food were mixed. I thought the eggs, home fries and ham were good, although the ham was a bit tough. The pancakes, however, were bland and tasteless and I had to use a lot of syrup. My friend complained that his omelet was also without much in the way of flavor, and he used a lot of ketchup. Prices were reasonable. Would I eat here again if I were in the area? Maybe. I wouldn't go out of my way, but if I were in the area again, and hungry, I could probably do worse. Next time, though, I think I'll try a cheeseburger or something along those lines rather than pancakes. read more

Live locally and have only been here once before. Parking lot is always filled. Came for breakfast and we all had breakfast dishes. Omelette were good and so were the waffles. I would just say average at best. Nothing terribly horrible and nothing that was good enough to come back for. Although the service could of been better our waitress did come by often to refill our coffee. read more

Key City Diner - Diners Near Me - Phillipsburg, New Jersey

I was a little apprehensive going in to this diner; however, the food and service exceeded my expectations. My waitress was extremely friendly, especially to us non-locals. The food we ordered was all very tasty, and the soup was also very good. I do recommend this diner! read more

Recently I went to the Key City Diner in Phillipsburg. It came highly recommended to me so when the opportunity presented itself, I drove a bit out of my way to go. I arrived around 5 pm. It wasn't too crowded and there was plenty of seating. Atmosphere: You can't miss the Key City Diner. When driving by, there is a giant Key Sign and it looks like a stereotypical diner. It's a big metallic, shiny, diner and is definitely everything you picture in a diner. The inside feels as if you stepped into a time machine when diners were created. Interestingly enough, there was also a decently sized salad bar too which is something many diners now lack. Service: The waitress was a bit awkward and either new or not comfortable. She did refill our beverages and the food came out quickly, but every interaction was awkward. When I ordered a gyro, the women quickly and wrongly corrected me in the pronunciation. Later, she pronounced it a different a wrong way. Not a big deal, but just one instance of interaction. Coffee: There was nothing unusual or unique about the coffee but it wasn't bad either. The waitress brewed it hot and kept it refilled. Food: The Key City Diner has everything you could picture in a diner. Breakfast all day, multiple dinner meals, salads, and seafood. As I mentioned, it also has a salad bar too. I opted for a beef Gyro with a Caesar salad. The gyro itself was good and had plenty of beef. It came with fries which they gave me an entire plate. The Caesar salad was filled and I appreciated they already added the dressing. Overall Summary/Would I come back? I enjoyed the Key City Diner and if I'm back in the area I would come back. It's in the middle of diners I've been too. read more

See all

We have tried for years to like this place. But it is consistently bad food and high prices. We just paid $42 for breakfast and it was not edible. Over cooked eggs, under cooked bacon. Don't send things back as they burn it instead of cooking it properly. The servers are lovely but the cooks are terrible. Save your time and money and go to Sullivans on Main for a way better breakfast at a better price point. read more