They've finally reopened, and we're glad they did. We ate here a few months ago and really enjoyed the wraps, so this time we came back specifically for the burgers. The space is nice--plenty of tables, good for groups, and lots of parking. It's located near Hobby Lobby at Southland Mall, in the old Hang 10 Boiler space. Today we tried the brisket burgers: * One Undercover style (classic cheeseburger) * One Streets style with cheese and mushrooms, and I added bacon The burgers are a bit messy, but in the best way. Very juicy, great flavor, and a solid size. Everything tasted fresh and made to order. My only knock on the burger itself is the bun--I'd love to see a higher-quality bun to really match the patty. Need to be a bit more sturdy. They offer a wide variety of meats and burger styles, from Stinky Mama (garlic-forward) to Islander (with pineapple). According to their website, all meats are HALAL, which is a nice bonus. The reason for the 4-star rating comes down to the fries. They were just okay and a little overcooked. I'd love to see chips as an option, and please--add pickles with the burgers. Overall, the experience was great, and we're happy they've reopened. We'll definitely be back. This is a local Hayward business, and it deserves support over big-box chains. Eat local. read more

Illegal Burgers - Brisket Burger THE Streets (Mushroom & Swiss Brisket Cheeseburger) added bacon - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

100% halal menu for those with dietary restrictions. Burgers are fire! Highly recommend the brisket burger and getting it Snitch style, it was delicious. I would say the fries are very average and they could be better. I also tasted the tenders and they are very average. They have menu other menu items but I would stick to the burgers. The regular is pretty filling with the two patties. This place is overall a burger gem. It's a perfect location because it's essentially attached to the mall with plenty to do if you're bringing others. The food was made fresh and was pretty quickly served. The staff were all very nice and helpful. A ton of seating inside and massive parking lot outside. I need to go here a few more times and try some of the other burgers too. read more

Illegal Burgers - The Snitch Brisket Burger - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

This is a new spot at Southland Mall, located right next to Hobby Lobby -- it's outside the mall, not inside. Parking is super easy with plenty of space available. I tried the falafel wrap and really enjoyed it. The person at the counter was friendly and welcoming. There is indoor seating, though it's not a large space -- just the right size for a casual bite. I noticed they had CBD fries on the menu, which I didn't get to try this time -- but I'm definitely curious and looking forward to trying them next visit! read more

See all

This the most ridiculous place try to eat at. Their hours are so inconsistent. I tried going months ago twice and they had a sign they would be back another day. I checked their hours yesterday and it showed they would be open today and tomorrow. Now it shows again closed until Friday and Saturday. How can a restaurant only be open two days a week? But each time I check they are closed. I guess I will never try it read more

Illegal Burgers opened where Hang Ten once was. Mostly inside seating. Outside seating available but not setup. Wall decored with pics of edibles. Illegal's marketing means non traditional meats: Lamb, wagyu beef, CBO, brisket with non traditional styles: hot dog, garlic, mushrooms.... Offerings (halal): vegetarian, greek salad, burgers, gyro, shawarma wraps, Philly steak, rice plates, afghan kabab plates, desserts, drinks, sides & dips. Bites: lamb burger (15.99) undercover style. -ordered medium rare, pd, ready in 10ish minutes. -looked medium, no pink meat. Very tender, semi-juicy. -lamb meat grounded fresh daily on site. -thick piece of tomato, mucho lettuce added moisture. Red onions adds tartness. House aioli added savoriness. Generous ingredients makes burger 5 star worthy. Not sure of rest of menu. *small convenience fee for CC use. read more

Illegal Burgers - Lamb burger (15.99) - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

This place delivers where it counts--flavor, service, and atmosphere. While prices are slightly on the higher are the restaurants here the experience justifies the cost. I'd definitely return and recommend it to anyone looking for a reliable and enjoyable dining experience! read more

Solid new burger joint at the Southland Mall in Hayward - we stopped by before attending a dance performance at Chabot College nearby. We stopped by around 5:30 pm before they got busy, and ordered an assortment of burgers and gyros. They're so new their fountain drink machine was not yet operational, and they didn't have bottled water (!!), so we settled on canned sodas as our beverage of last resort. The food took longer to prepare than expected, but boy was it delish! My illegal burger (lamb and beef patties) was juicy, tasty and humungous! I stole some curly fries from the missus, who was so busy enjoying her island burger (beef with pineapple), she didn't notice! Another hit!! The place is well organized and there are plenty of tables, all covered with a black and white "chessboard" checkered pattern. Bathrooms were clean. Parking was plentiful. Looking forward to my next visit - there are plenty of other delicious burgers I want to bite into! read more

Illegal Burgers - Entrance - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Excellent service and ambiance. Freshly made rice plates and burgers. Lots of parking and restaurant is spacious and clean. Delicious and nutritious! read more

See all

I'm saddened to say that I no longer recommend Illegal Burgers. After 3 failed attempts of trying to return to the establishment, during the posted hours of operations, the doors were locked and a sign was posted on the door stating they were sold out for the day, I was able to finally find the place up and running. The joy was short luved when the nice lady at the register could not figure out how to input our order on the tablet. After about 10 minutes the "cook" was called for help as it was just them two working. He was able to show her how to use the tablet while still wearing the gloves he was cooking with, and without changing out the gloves he proceeded to grab fries with the same hand by sticking the whole hand in the bag of frozen fries. He deopped a fry on the floor and pucked it up with the same hand again. He dis throw away the fallen fry in the trash but he never washed his hands or changed into new gloves. He kept cooking and touching the raw meat and buns with the contaminated gloves. We ended up canceling the order, since the lady was still trying to figure out how to charge my card, and I was fearful for my family to eat here. I hope this gets to the owner and they can correct this behavior. The restaurant was empty and I know they are struggling but you still have to abid by food safety regulations and keep clean. read more

People had been hyping me up about this spot and it was a bit of a let down. It was a decent burger but nothing special. It was also pretty messy and fell apart half way through. I don't know if I'll try it again. read more

Illegal Burgers - Angus burger with cheese - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

Saw this lil burger place on a fluke at Southland mall. Much to my satisfaction they had multiple burger options not just plain beef. I'm a sucker for a lamb burger which is why I stopped in. You never find lamb options in most normal Burger joints, and this one was all Halal. Prices were pretty standard for various burger options, they also had shwarma plates, gyros and Philly cheese option sandwiches. Everything was super fresh and very delicious. The quality of the burgers exceeded expectations. My fiancé and I were very pleased with our meal. It wasn't too heavy, considering the regular burger consisted of two patties! Not overly greasy or sapored with the flavor of beef what so ever. The shoe string fries were pretty good and we will be returning for more lamb option meals. read more

See all

Easily the best burgers in the area, here's why- Variety- just look at the menu! Not only do they have a variety of fixings, they have a variety of patties! Quality- the food is GOOD. I almost skipped this place because a negative review said the burgers were "un-flavorful" until I saw the other negative review where the person said they drove AN HOUR to eat here because they used to eat at their Fremont location and were mad that the restaurant was closed... I figured that if someone was willing to drive an hour, I could drive ten minutes. My husband and I ordered their regular sized burger and fries, we were very happy with the portion! The fries and the bacon on our burgers were cooked PERFECTLY. The patties were FRESH, MOIST AND FLAVORFUL. The aioli dip was DELICIOUS. Value- their price is on par with the local spots and probably cheaper than the nearby specialty burger places. Service- the person who took our order, who I assume was the manager was very polite. He told us our food would be out in about ten minutes and in about ten minutes he brought our order to our table. After our meal, I approached him and told him how much my husband and I enjoyed the food, I also asked him what was up with him closing earlier than his posted hours. He kindly explained that he closes early when they sell out of meat. It would probably be a good idea to add "or until we sell out" to their posted hours. This business is currently in its "soft opening" phase, I hope the neighborhood can give them enough support to stay! I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Undercover Burger: hefty burger for the price with double patty Onion rings: basic good onion rings, not overly battered Fries: i prefer thin cut fries so not too excited about them Kebab plate: quite disappointing. The platter was $20 where -meat was dry -rice was not seasoned / flavorful -advertised salad was couple sprigs of cut lettuce read more

Illegal Burgers - $20 kebab plate: -meat was dry -rice was not seasoned or flavorful -the sprigs of lettuce does not equal a salad - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Gourmet burgers at a reasonable price! Excellent variety of toppings options. Each style is included in the base price. We got their junior bacon cheese burger ($9) and their illegal burger regular ($13). The illegal burger had lamb gyros in addition to 2x 1/3lb patties. They hand grind their own meat. They have a CBD section of their menu with infused burger patties and sides. In addition to burgers, they have gyros, shawarmas, and plates. Service was great. Nice vibe and clean interiors. Support local businesses! read more

See all

Excellent burger. I had the Brisket Burger and it came with 2 large patties. Very flavorful. My 7 year old had the Angus and he loved it too. I was disappointed when they closed the Fremont location and glad they've opened again. Service was friendly and the restaurant ambiance was nice. read more

Good service and very juicy burgers. Reminds of of Beeps burgers when they were still in Hayward/Danville. Give them a try and enjoy :) read more

Illegal Burgers - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

Pros: 1. I received excellent customer service. 2. The food tasted clean. 3. Meat is halal 4. The layout of the restaurant has good feng shei to me. Cons: 1. I ordered a wagyu burger and wondered if the meat was actually wagyu. It seemed to be regular 'ol ground beef. 2. The food is overpriced. Burgers that START at $20 and don't come with fries and a drink? Is crazy! 3. They force you to buy two burger patties. I was told all burgers start with two patties for $20; my receipt showed one burger for $14.99 and an additional $5 for an extra burger patty. 4. The size of the burger is good for my waistline, but it is terrible value for the money in my wallet. 5. 1 Small piece of lettuce and tomato was put on the burger, again $20 bucks? 6. The menu board could use better descriptions of food items, toppings, and included condiments. read more

This is what we needed in the area! Super tasty burger and fries! We've been here twice and both times have been so good! Tonight was the first time actually going in and the decor is a Bay Area vibe for sure and the staff were super nice and friendly! So far we've tried their pineapple burger and bacon burger as well as curly fries and regular fries. All have been super tasty! We also got some of their garlic sauce, it's soooo tasty. Definitely come thru and try them out. Next time I hope to try some of their CBD burgers or different meats. But their pineapple burger keeps calling read more

Cheap Fries, Cheap Bun, Cheap Burger, it feels like a college cafeteria. Been there twice first time close sign in the door. read more

Great tasting burger and fries for reasonable price. I had the garlic burger. I'll try something new next time. read more

See all

If you're on the hunt for the ultimate burger experience in Hayward, look no further than Illegal Burgers. This local gem delivers juicy, flavorful creations that might just ruin all other burgers for you. Whether you're a burger purist or someone who loves adventurous toppings, Illegal Burgers has something for everyone--and yes, it's totally kid-friendly too! The Burgers (Where Illegal Becomes Deliciously Legal): Let's get to the main event: the burgers. Illegal Burgers doesn't just serve food--they craft edible masterpieces that demand your full attention. Each burger is made to order, using high-quality ingredients and cooked to perfection. From the first bite, you can tell this isn't your average fast-food joint. I started with their signature "Outlaw Burger", stacked with a thick, juicy beef patty, melted cheese, crispy bacon, and a tangy house-made sauce that tied everything together. The bun was soft yet sturdy, perfectly hugging the juicy goodness without falling apart--a small detail, but one I deeply appreciate. The flavor combination was off the charts, and I found myself debating whether to savor it slowly or inhale it all in one go. For my second visit (yes, I had to come back), I tried their "Western Fugitive", which came with BBQ sauce, onion rings, cheddar cheese, and a spicy kick that had me reaching for my drink but loving every bite. Their vegetarian options are equally impressive, with a black bean burger that even meat lovers would happily devour. The Sides and Drinks: No burger meal is complete without sides, and Illegal Burgers doesn't disappoint. The garlic fries were crispy, perfectly seasoned, and borderline addictive. Their sweet potato fries had that ideal balance of sweet and salty, and their dipping sauces elevated the experience. They've also got hand-spun milkshakes that are rich, creamy, and the perfect way to cool down after tackling one of their spicier burgers. Kid-Friendly Vibes: One of the standout features of Illegal Burgers is how kid-friendly it is. The menu has options for picky eaters, and the atmosphere is casual and welcoming--perfect for families. On my visit, I noticed several families enjoying their meals, with kids happily munching away on sliders and fries. There's even a little corner with crayons and coloring sheets to keep the little ones entertained while the adults dive into their burgers. The Service (A+ All Around): The service at Illegal Burgers deserves its own round of applause. The staff here are incredibly friendly, patient, and genuinely excited to make your meal special. On my visit, the cashier went out of their way to explain the menu, offer recommendations, and even suggest a few off-menu combinations (pro tip: ask about their secret sauce upgrades). The food arrived quickly, hot and fresh, and the servers checked in just the right amount to make sure everything was perfect. The Vibe: The atmosphere at Illegal Burgers strikes that perfect balance between casual and cool. The interior has a fun, modern design with quirky burger-themed art on the walls, and the music is upbeat without being too loud. It's the kind of place where you can grab a quick lunch, have a relaxed dinner with the family, or even swing by for a casual date night. Final Thoughts: Illegal Burgers isn't just a place to grab a meal--it's an experience. The burgers are consistently excellent, the sides are drool-worthy, and the service makes you feel right at home. Whether you're a Hayward local or just passing through, this spot is worth a visit (or several). It's a burger joint that lives up to the hype, serving up meals that are anything but "illegal"--unless being absolutely delicious is a crime. read more

My friend and I have been trying to get to this place for a while. Our schedules finally aligned last night, Friday. Got there at 5:40pm. Closed. No sign indicating why. No answer on phone or a message indicating why. Website stated open. Confused. We were disappointed . Hoping for a redo. We ended up at Sizzler for quite possibly the worst burger I have ever had. Still holding out for my Illegal Burger. read more

I love this new burger spot! It is right outside of Southland mall next to hobby lobby. We have a friend who only eats halal when we go out so it was nice to find a burger joint that was completely halal. I have tried a few things there including the Illegal Burger and Stinky Mama Garlic burger. They were both juicy, flavorful and huge! Their garlic sauce is so good too. I like the options of choosing the type of meat for your burgers and different sizes available. It's like you can always try something new there. Staff is very friendly and helpful, the atmosphere is clean and spacious, and the prices are reasonable considering the quality of the ingredients. There are also other options like Shwarmas, rice plates etc. (see menu items in pictures) definitely recommend this local business. read more

See all

Beef patty was over cooked and I found a hair in my food . Hopefully they can switch up

I recently visited Illegal Burgers, and I have to say, the experience was amazing! We ordered a regular burger, a garlic burger, and some chicken shawarma, and everything was absolutely delicious. The flavors were on point, and the quality of the food really stood out. The service was equally impressive. The staff were incredibly friendly and attentive, making us feel right at home. The atmosphere added to the overall experience--it was fantastic! Great vibes, good music playing, and just an all-around welcoming spot to enjoy a meal. If you're looking for a place with incredible food and great service, I highly recommend Illegal Burgers. We'll definitely be back! read more

The burgers here were super fire! I heard they ground their own beef into the burgers, super juicy, and the sauce was super good. The pastrami on the burger was super fire. Next time I'll try the bacon one. read more

It says open clear as day I checked on Google and on yelp as well as the Apple Map. drove all the way here super hungry just to see this closed sign. I'm so disappointed. read more

Illegal Burgers - 1pm on a Monday - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

Amazing great service, delicious food, super clean restaurant. Fun place, great location at The Southland Mall read more

Illegal burgers. I was recommended this by a friend who said it is a fairly new restaurant that opened in Southland Mall. However, the burger was un flavorful. There was no one inside the establishment, but the food was just OK. The fries were really good and the shake tasted like milk and flavor And that's it. read more

Waited 40 minutes for my food while i was 1 of 3 people in the building. When i finally got my food i saw they got my fries order wrong and my burger was wrapped without a bun. Noticed when i walked in that they made a mistake on another customers order for in dine and not to go. That should've been an omen that they weren't locked in today. Food was good and the cashier was nice. Probably just a bad day. I'll give this place another chance but not during my lunch break when i'm short on time read more

Food was terrible and I definitely won't be going back. I should have just went to Burger King.

I had the Illegal burger and it was delicious. I had previously found this restaurant near Kaiser in Fremont and liked it so I was disappointed to see it closed. The Illegal burger is a thick, hand formed beef patty with thin slices of lamb swarma. The lamb was crispy carmelized on the outside which really gave the sandwich a great texure and a deep delicious flavor. read more

Food and service were good. Prices were reasonable. Have gone back since and was equally pleased.

This my favorite fucking place bro food so damn good I even brought my younger brother here and he is soo picky and he tried their food and he text me at 2am and ask can I take him here every other day lmfaoooooooo read more

We tried 3 different burgers each was great. Meat was flavorful, fries were spot on, so long 5 guys we're coming here

It's only a matter of time before people realize this place is hear and is probably one of the best burgers in Hayward. If somebody does a YouTube review on this place, it's game over. read more

the burger is so juicy and my whole family love it. We will definitely go back when we crave for burgers. read more

Illegal Burgers - Japanese Wagyu burger with pineapple - New American Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

The bacon cheese burger was great, I don't eat pork so the beef bacon was really nice to have

Weird atmosphere. The cheeseburger I ordered was mediocre and dry. They use Hunts Ketchup which I am not a big fan of. And the fountain soda machine was out of service. So bring your own cans or they will rip you off on a can of soda. Very dissapointed and I am predicting that this strange restaurant will be closed by December. read more

Crazy good angus hamburgers. Expensive, but huge so you won't go away hungry. Drinks limited to bottled water and some canned soda flavors; would've preferred a self-serve fountain drink arrangement. read more