Came to Buffalo Bill's with my family on a Monday to support a local restaurant, and I'm really glad we did. It was pretty dead when we arrived, but the service was great. The atmosphere definitely has more of a bar feel, which isn't a bad thing at all, and I loved the '90s playlist playing in the background. The food was excellent. I ordered the chicken wrap with grilled chicken and upgraded to the garlic fries. Everything tasted fresh and flavorful, and the garlic fries were definitely worth the upgrade. My wife had the buffalo burger and really enjoyed that as well. It's also surprisingly family friendly. They have a decent kids menu with things like chicken tenders and pizza, and they gave the kids crayons and an activity sheet to keep them occupied. They have the brewing tanks right there, and I tried the Buffalo Bill's Haystack Hazy IPA, which was really good. Overall, great food, great service, good beer, and a relaxed atmosphere. Really enjoyed supporting a local spot and would definitely come back. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Buffalo Bill's Burger - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Had a quick lunch here last week. Service was good, the young lady helping us was nice and friendly. She was patient and had good knowledge of the menu and recommendations. We opted for the smoked mozzarella sticks, the wings and 2 pizzas. Mozzarella sticks certainly had the smokiness to it. Very good and id buy again. Wings were just OK. Something in the Buffalo sauce wass different ans not my favorite...but still ok. I got the combo pizza and it was decent. I think I was thrown off by the fact there was no greenery on the pizza. Even the peppers and onions were red, so it was a different experience. read more

Absolutely horrible, compare to how they use to be. Everything taste out of a bottle or can, they were legendary for there Ceasar salad, OMG, taste out of a bag and the dressing is disappointing to say the least. Nachos were equivalent to a movie theaters . We drive 60 miles to what use to be our favorite place to only get sick after leaving Buffalo bills. We have both had stomach issues since eating there on Friday 9/11 and now it's Sunday and just getting better. Service is great and it's a great ambiance, sunny, fresh, clean and usually lively but first thing we noticed was it was very empty on a late Friday afternoon. We won't be back ever. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Disgusting Nachos, absolutely disgusting!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Stopped by here on an early afternoon on Sunday with some friends to grab some drinks. The place was about half packed, but service was pretty fast. We grabbed a few beers at the bar and decided we might want to grab a table to get food, and ended up doing so. Got some wings and nachos for the group, and garlic fries. Everything came out pretty quickly, and we ended up just talking and grabbing a few more drinks for a few hours. The place was nice, with sports playing on TV while patrons enjoyed their meals. We ended with a few shots of Hennessy and then called it a day. Overall, a nice place to enjoy a beer with friends if you're in the area! read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Their Pizza is bomb and the lemon pepper flavor wings are amazing too. Make sure you order extra lemon pepper seasoning on the side just in case you need to add a little more. It's depending on your preference. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Lemon Pepper wings and Combination pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Great date night last weekend. We both got entrees and then shared (burger and chicken sandwich). Starting out with the pretzel and beer cheese. Do NOT sleep on this appetizer- SO good! Onion rings (with $5 up charge- not the $3 the menu listed... ‍) VERY good! I got the Misty Pale Ale- superb! Hubs got the Taz and loved it too. (They use the Taz in the beer cheese.) read more

See all

Unfortunately, our experience this time was very disappointing. We are regular customers and have been coming here for a long time, so this is the first time we have ever had this kind of experience. The service was not good from the beginning. We were not given plates or napkins until we had to ask for them. The food was also disappointing because it had very little flavor. To make things worse, we were charged $4.50 for each glass of water, which was very surprising. Considering the service, the food, and the extra charges, this visit was extremely disappointing, especially because we have always enjoyed coming here before. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - 2 Soda Water -- $9.00 - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

This pub is a staple in Hayward. There were multiple televisions playing the World Cup. The person who greeted us at the door was very friendly. It was not very busy because it was a week night. We waited about twenty minutes before finally having to asking someone to wait on us. The lady who I flagged down was super nice. Even though I do not think that she was supposed to be our waiter, she continued to be attentive to our table. We really appreciated that. The food was pretty good bar food. I would give it 3.5 stars if I could. read more

See all

The vibe here is cool, pizza was decent, and I enjoyed the sweet potato fries. Nothing extraordinary but I would go back with more people if I was in the area. read more

Haven't been back here since the old ownership. I was surprised on how much I loved it! The beer tasted the same. The pizza was good (not pictured) and Id return for the burger alone. The sweet potato fries was a nice addition to the menu, will return. read more

See all

We came here for the first time in years last night and had a great experience! The service was truly phenomenal - we felt well taken care of. The food was also quite good - we enjoyed the clam chowder and a vegetarian pizza (we appreciated the fact they were generous with their toppings). The atmosphere was pleasant and kid-friendly (it was great that they had crayons and an activity sheet for my 8 year old!) Color me impressed. read more

It's been 6 years since we last visited BBills , We missed the place , so while we were close by we decided to give it a go. Surprisingly no crowds, and food was great (2) enormous pieces of fish with chips with a Taz . Brew master . Not easy to maintain that taste, well done . My significant other enjoyed the ribs . Prices were reasonable overall considering ,service was great too . It's always been a clean place and it still is. I'll be back. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Fish and chips with the Taz - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Local brewery with a selection on beers on tap. We got a variety of beers and everyone seemed to enjoy them. Wish they had some non alcoholic options as well others than the Corona low alcoholic version. Food was the typical bar menu, we got a salad, the jalapeno burger and some chicken sandwiches. They were flexible in making one of the wraps into a sourdough sandwich which we appreciated. The food tasted fresh and flavorful too! Service was prompt and friendly. read more

See all

Food is ok... Brew selection is unbelievably amazing w/great in house made brew of their own... 2nd date, 8yrs age so I'm little bias

We came here after a movie for a late Galentines celebration. Purple Haze was pretty and tasted pretty good We were seated immediately, and our server was sweet. Ordered the ceasar salad and added steak. Im torn because the salad itself was delicious, but was surprised the meat was so overcooked it seemed like beef jerky! They didnt ask how i wanted meat cooked, that should have been a sign. $29 for a salad was also some sticker shock. I wanted to give this place a chance, but likely would go elsewhere if I ever goto the movies in that space again. read more

Quality/Quantity - Guess my buddy is MORE of a regular than I am?!?! Yet I believe we always come together?!?! I guess he is just more memorable. Anyways, I just had dinner at your other restaurant, Casa Del Toro, and wanted just one more beer before going home. Got my usual red, while my buddy got his usual IPA. And I ordered the garlic fries as I still had the munchies. My buddy could not believe after eating a steak dinner (see Casa Del Toro review), that I could still eat. Well, the joke is on him as he ate more than 60% of my fries, lol. Atmosphere - Indoor/outdoor seating.150 indoor seats and 120 outdoors seats. Table, booth, bar, counter, heated patio, etc. Free wifi. Open kitchen. Plenty of mall parking; in the past when this place was crazy busy, parking was a challenge. Open 7 days a week from 11am to 9pm or 10pm. Service - Good. Well even better when the bartender knows my buddy. And the manager recognized me, lol. Anyways, we are both regulars. :) Price - $35 + generous tip. Owner Comment - Congrats on your success since 1983. I used to be a regular. Thanks for reopening on 8/7/23; Hayward needs more good businesses. Congrats to Alejandro Gamarra and all his restaurants and businesses. We just had dinner at your other restaurant, Casa Del Toro. read more

See all

Servers are first rate. Menu is abbreviated but meets all the needs of the diners. Venue is perfect for diners read more

Your basic brewery with typical bar food. Wings, fries, salads, sandwiches, pizza, and some other fried items from which to choose. They have 3-4 tvs and plenty of seating. Service was friendly. read more

See all

We came here on a weeknight and were seated right away. On Mondays it is happy hour from 2 pm until close. We ordered the ribs, pork sandwich, and the minestrone soup. We also ordered a side of crazy fries. The food was just okay. Folks thought their meat sandwiches were fine and there was nothing special. The minestrone was pretty good. I think where they fell through was the fries. The crazy fries were way too soggy with the sauce and the sauce was not great while the garlic was too much. My partner enjoyed the beer and thought that was good. It is sort of dark inside and there's plenty of seating. The service was pretty good as well. read more

See all

I been coming here for years Buffalo Bill's Brewery is one of the places you come because is honestly the best you can find in Hayward with good food, excellent prices, good service, welcoming and friendly. From good pizza to excellent jalapeño poppers. Great beer too, but it's so great that sometimes they ran out. The food some times can change a little and I see the difference. But I already know what are always great in the menu. Like the macaroni and cheese with steak or pork is one of my favorites. Wigs are great too especially if you wanna share with people. I know better locations with better wigs but 8pm everything is already close in Hayward but I can trust they Bill will be there with the same quality as always. Now talking about ambience is awesome! I like it because it feels like the example of how great Hayward is: at lots of background, at lots of different peoples but we all love our local beers and food. I can say this place is awesome for big families get together or even a first date. Of maybe you are alone and getting hungry after the gym and you are too lazy to cook at home and you feel like cheating the diet for a day well Bills is your restaurant. read more

See all

Overall experience was great. The host/server was amazing with great energy. Food was good. I'll definitely be coming back. But I'd say in order of like for the sliders, fried chicken slider #1, Beef Slider #2 and pulled pork #3. The server said the slider buns were different this time around and she wasn't sure why. Sliders were $5 each during Happy Hour. Dirty Fries are Garlic Parm fries with thousand island sauce is what makes it dirty $9 during happy hour. read more

I've been here before for a Yelp elite event, so it was great coming back for lunch with my coworkers! Or a great low key place to hang out with friends. I loved that the brewery has some of its equipment for display. Parking is super easy, there's a parking lot behind the restaurant. I ordered their fried chicken sandwich and it was super crispy and juicy. The fries were cooked perfectly. I didn't try any of their beers but it looked refreshing! read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Ivan was our Super Server for our second time in less than a week. We had the zucchini, it was so awesome. We had the Gorgonzola salad, my god you must have this! Lastly ordered the pepperoni pizza, so delicious, the crust was crispy and the dough very moist! The Salsa music and Bob Marley music hit the Community Vibe spot! Ivan was so attentive that we thought he owned the business. What an outstanding, beautiful fun experience today was! read more

See all

I had a lovely time her with my daughter before catching a movie. Service was great, food was great, and beer was great. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Buffalo Bills burger, sweet potato wake fries, Ricochet Red, ands a cheese burger patty and fries - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Their food is usually good, and the beer is good but the AMBIENCE, or lack of is due to the noise level, including the forced listening to THE EMPLOYEES or MANAGEMENT's (which is what they have told me, each time I asked if they could turn it down or OFF) choice of music, even on the outside patio. I stopped going there years ago because of the terrible noise levels, which apparently doesn't bother too many humans who love shouting and being inside with all the cacophony of SPORTS on FLAT SCREENS, loud music (?) and the people. Whatever happened to going out to eat and having a conversation? read more

Stopped by Buffalo Bills Brewery and ordered a pizza -- it was delicious! Crispy crust, melty cheese, and fresh toppings made it way better than I expected from a brewery. Solid food to go with the drinks. The atmosphere was super chill, and to top it off, there was a Love Island watch party going on while I was there. Totally unexpected but honestly made the visit even more entertaining. The crowd was into it, and it added a fun energy to the place. Service was friendly, though a little slow -- the only reason I'm not giving 5 stars. Still, between the great pizza, good beer, and unexpected TV drama, I had a great time. read more

See all

I did not really impressed with the quality of salad and steak. Steak was fatty and not really like the salad , it was a bit wilted. One of the good parts was the beer. Super fresh and yummy . We ordered hazy style which got me after 2 sip. Service is fast and attentive. Ambience also is warm and cozy . This location has patio for nights that are quiet and not warm to enjoy. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Steak Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Nice environment with indoor and outdoor seating. A decent sized menu and a full bar. I really like the pesto chicken sandwich. I like that I can sub the Swiss cheese for cheddar. The sweet potato fries are pretty good as well as the side salad. The prices are a bit high though. read more

See all

Whoa, my last review for this place was back in 2008, that's 17 years ago yo, WTF. Lol. Since then long tenured Buffalo Bills changed hands a little past the pandemic. Like many other owners, not many wanted to stick around in an already hard business. New blood had to enter the equation and good for Hayward, a local empire took over. Owners of the Metro Taquero chain and Casa Del Toro next door bought the business rights to this old time brew pub and Hayward classic. Much of the inside is the same, but honestly it's been so long since I've been in, I can't really tell. But the overall vibe is the same, very urban yet industrial vibe. The food and drink, albeit more expensive due to the times and inflation, is even better than what I remember so let's jot down an update. 4 beer Sampler ($12/4*) A little pricey for trying to find out what they have but at least their beers are pretty good. I hate paying for a sampling and the beers suck. Like any where else, they have multiple IPAs, but they are on the lighter side but still quite balanced. These aren't the thick and heavy ones like Fieldwork and Drake's. I really liked their Hazy (juicy and fresh) and their Double Standard which has a stern hop finish. I also liked their Blueberry Oatmeal Stout which was smooth with just a faint blueberry hint, not in your face or artificial tasting. Half Club/Half Soup Combo - lunch special ($16/4*) You can pick between like 5 sandwiches or so, and between 2 soups. The sandwich was really good but at 3 layers can be a bit tough to bite into. Good toasted sourdough, turkey, bacon and avo slices. And the kicker I liked which you don't see often was pickled jalapenos which made it zing. I could eat pickled jalapenos on any sandwich, you just don't see it enough. I chose minestrone soup and it was hearty with big chunks of veggies and swollen shell pasta. Loved the taste of the broth and seasoning, just thought it was a bit skimpy of a portion (like cup was only filled half way) and the soup wasn't hot, barely warm. Still delicious just an observation noted. Combo Pizza ($22/4*) In my original review I was amused at how the pricing for pizza or burger was around $11 bucks. Now they are both over $20, weeeee! About small pizza in size about 8 small slices, good for 2 peeps as an app. Crust nicely charred on the edges edges but reamins soft and droopy in the center. I think the amount of cheese and sauce they use keeps it from getting totally crisp. But there is a good meaty and melty bite. I actually liked the slices cold the next day, as everything was stuck as one. Service at the bar was good, spacing was kinda tight. But I'll definitely be back and won't hold off as long as I did for this return. I'm just glad a successful local group took over an old institution to keep it alive. It's a model I can root for and support. Cheers! read more

See all

Stopped in for a bite to eat after golfing nearby. Even though it was not busy it took a while to get service and since we weren't drinking beers, we waited a long time for waters. Maybe under staffed at the time. I had the PestoChicken wrap, which was pretty good. I saw some pizzas and wings that looked good too. Overall it's a good gathering place in downtown Hayward if you want a beer and some good food. read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Pesto Chicken Wrap with side salad - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

Here's a polished five-star review you can use: Ivan was an outstanding server--friendly, attentive, and incredibly efficient. He provided speedy service while still keeping us informed every step of the way. We felt well taken care of from start to finish. Highly recommend asking for Ivan! He has a great smile! read more

What a great place to enjoy delicious burgers (sliders) and beer! They brew their own beer which was very tasty. Came here for happy hour and the price of the sliders/burgers and beers was only $5 each! Definitely coming back when I'm Hayward. read more

See all

Awesome restaurant and bar, great atmosphere and fantastic service! Ivan the bartender had great suggestions for local spots and all around great vibes. Sendia was our waitress and she was fantastic! Loved everything about this place, great beer, great food, great service! read more

I'v been coming here for almost my whole life. It's not quite as good as it used to be but their food is great and the service is usually good too. The ambiance is a little lacking but for events and holidays they step it up. read more

Food quality went way down. They used to have decent pizza and now, it's super generic yet still costs a premium. Beer might be slightly improved but still doesn't justify the price. I won't be coming back. read more

I met a friend for lunch at Buffalo Bills Brewery. Second time here and I really only came back for the fried pickles because they are bomb! Their selection of beer Is pretty good. The house red was my favorite (I dont remember the name ) The food was meh. Ordered the pastrami and my friend ordered the chicken pesto sandwich with sweet potato waffle fries. The pastrami was greasy but decent. The massive amount of fries was fun at first but then it just felt wasteful. Server was nice but the service was slow to start. It wasn't busy at all so I was surprised that the service was a little slower than expected. All in all, not the worst place to come for A sandwich and beer. read more

See all

Thank you Buffalo Bills for being a Hayward and beer institution! Been going here for 2+ decades and am happy it's been reopened. Hayward folks go support our local spots! read more

I came to Buffalo Bills to catch up with some friends I haven't seen in a while! Buffalo Bills have both indoor and outdoor seating. We chose to sit offside because it was a nice sunny day. With the sun, we were concerned about one person getting hit by all those rays, but before we could ask, the hostess immediately asked if we wanted to move the sun umbrella. Very attentive! Our waiter was also super nice. He checked on us frequently and gave us recommendations for our drinks. 10/10 the peach cider (not pictured) was super good. I'm a bit sensitive to bitter taste, so this was a hit! They don't brew it there; they have it in a can. 10/10 their nachos are very filling. It definitely filled up a party of 3 with some leftovers still. If you're looking for protein, this has plenty chicken in it! 9/10 the wings were great. We did choose for a spicier sauce and there was definitely that kick in it. The ranch does help with that kick without affecting the taste too much. 9/10 chicken wrap was yummy. The sauce that comes with it reminds me of the sauce they use in gyros. Definitely come here if you're looking for a place to chill. They do play sports on their TVs and I hear people come there to watch. Though it's a bit pricey, your serving size makes up for it! read more

Buffalo Bill's Brewery - Nachos - Pizza Near Me - Hayward, California

See all

Love this place! It's my extended living room. It's a place where i go to for the Happy Hour and Pizza. But more than the happy hour, it's comfortable, cozy, good staff, good service. I like to come here and work on my laptop, food is always fresh and consistent. The staff who i interact with are my favorite part of the experience. Keep up the good! read more

My husband and I decided to check out Buffalo Bill's Brewery after I attended a Yelp event here not too long ago. It was our first date night in 4.5 months (since having our baby)! We came on Valentine's Day. We ordered beers, burgers, and garlic fries. The garlic fries were good and crispy. The alimony ale beer is delicious. My Buffalo Bill's burger wasn't very good. I asked for medium rare but it was beyond well done, making it very dry. I should have spoken up about it, but I really don't like food getting wasted. The side salad with vinaigrette was good. My husband got the bacon onion burger. His ended up actually being medium rare and it was a lot better than my burger. His sweet potato waffle fries were good, but super crispy. I like crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, but it was just crispy all around. Our server was welcoming and friendly. The pricing was a much more than I expected. It may be more worthwhile to come with a group to enjoy the shareables. read more

See all