Great food. Worth the risk of hitting a deer or getting carried off by giant mosquitos. The steer you just ate probably came from the field behind the restaurant. Nice folks, great service. Fun. Thank you. Who knew? read more

Very small dining area. Was told it was best to arrive 15min before doors open to be able get in and get a table. Heard many great things about this place, so the bar was set high. Girlfriend and I were about 10th in line or so. Not pleasant waiting in this heat, but was supposedly worth it. We finally got into the place like door-buster dash sale at the big box stores. We chose our table. Service was extremely slow as we got the initial excuse that they were short staffed in the kitchen. Took forever to get a drink and finally get our order in. Seeing that the bar was set high, I was practically drooling. After waiting for over an hour and watching others who were behind us in line already served, gone and new patrons sitting down with drinks in front of them, I was ready to get up and leave! Our steaks finally arrived, while they were good, I've had much better elsewhere and they definitely weren't worth the hour plus wait time. Make sure you don't forget your wallet. Not sure if it's post COVID price gouging or maybe they were always a bit pricey. Being new to the area, I'm not sure. Price was steep enough, but with a credit card penalty (My terminology) if you dont pay them cash, I'll never return. Tired of businesses forcing the extra 3.5% on a credit card customer. It used to be illegal for a reason. Price of that should already be built in. If you don't give up your pocket money, you pay the penalty. Absolutely ridiculous.I wont be back. read more

I had several people tell me about this place and finally got to try it out. It did not disappoint. We had the Rib eye shared with my husband because so big. It was great! Also tried the fried lobster . It was good but think I still prefer steamed lobster. Great service minimal wait , but it was packed and people kept coming in. read more

I don't think it was worth the wait, the price, or the time. They missed an appetizer for our group no big deal and they offered to comp it. Then they lost our order and took forever to bring even the salads. When the food does finally come, fish special was over cooked and dry, marinated chicken was burnt because they used a press to cook it faster., 2 burgers were not good enough for teenage boys to finish. The bright spot was the filet my wife thoroughly enjoyed. The fried green beans were not bad, but they were standard frozen stuff from a box, cheese toast was very good. Pricing is ok if you get what you pay for, but up charge $1 for 5 pieces of asparagus or sautéed spinach on a $29 entree not to mention the salad is $1.50 up charge to get bacon and cheese when they ask if you want it like it comes on it normally. There were a lot of excuses and apologies from the server when she came by, and they sent us home with free dessert, but the manager never came by, and the up charged items more than covered the pie. Overall cleanliness didn't really knock me off my feet either. Someday I might try again but not any time soon. read more

We were seated right inside the door in this tiny hole-in-the-wall place, but obviously the locals love it because the tables did not stay empty for long between parties. Good thing we got in before the dinner rush, otherwise our party of 8 would have been waiting for a while! Get the fried lobster tails. Seriously, I don't care if you don't really like lobster or you're not a fan of fried foods (liar). They are amazing, and the honey mustard dipping sauce brings them to another level. We took the leftover sauce and put it on everything. I recently stopped eating red meat, so I was a little concerned about what I'd be able to eat at this steak house. I was considering ordering another plate of lobster tails for myself when our friends that had been before recommended the swordfish special. I'm not sure what they do to keep the seafood so fresh around Columbus, but I hope they continue! The Jamaican cream sauce was flavorful and brought the swordfish together with the fried crab claws. The only disappointment I can really think of was the cheese grits, they were pretty bland in my opinion but I was so full from the swordfish and mashed potatoes that I didn't really miss them. Everyone was struggling to finish their plates, but when we heard "chocolate peanut butter pie" all of a sudden half of us still had room to spare for dessert. read more

The steaks are awesome. When we got there it was 6 pm and already a wait outside.any waiting in their vehicles and se lined in chairs out front. Was a little apprehensive because it is in the middle of nowhere, but when we saw that many people waiting we figured it had to be good. The staels were cool as ordered and did not need any extra sauce for dipping. Very tender and tasty. Will stop there again if going thru at the right time. read more

OMG!!! If we weren't told about this place, we would have totally missed out on an amazing meal!! We knew we were in for a treat when we pulled up as cars were lining the road for parking. One ordered the ribeye, one ordered the fillet. My fillet one of the best steaks I've ever eaten. I couldn't complete my meal...made me sad because it was sooo good!!!!! Service was fantastic and everyone spoke with a smile! read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

Had the ribeye steak and my wife had the chop sirloin steak. The meal was very tasty and the service was very good. Sides were very good also. Had a great time and will be back soon. read more

We found a good one in this hole in the wall. The fried lobster was a hit. The steak was fabulous with flavor. Everyone was welcoming to all ages. Get there early as the line forms at 5 pm even on a Wednesday read more

Lobster tail was to die for. They were out of what we wanted, chicken fried steak, so we both had to compromise but was still tasty and the peanut butter chocolate pie was yummm read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - Chocolate Peanut butter pie - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

See all

I meant to write a review a couple of months ago when I was first introduced to Hunter's Pub, but never got around to it. I have now eaten at Hunter's Pub three times...twice within the past week....if that says anything about the food! My first visit here I had the New York Strip (my favorite steak) and it was divine. Ask for the green beans instead of potatoes...while the mashed potatoes are great, the beans are even better. Second visit here I had to get the same thing, but the third visit I went for the seafood special (it changes nightly). Absolutely delicious Asian-inspired grouper, which tasted as fresh as I would have expected if we were on the Gulf Coast. Try the cheese toast for an appetizer. While it looks and sounds simple, it is fabulous. The salad is nothing special at all, but it comes fast and helps to tide you over while you wait for your steak! Portions are large too, each visit I've had plenty of leftovers for lunch the next day. Don't come here if you are looking for great ambiance...it doesn't exist. As others have mentioned, it is truly a hole in the wall. Converted from an old gas station as I understand it. Crowded, loud, and boisterous, always busy but with prompt efficient service and out of this world steaks. Come when they open at 5 pm if you don't want to wait. Overall, Hunter's Pub probably serves the best steak I've ever had, which more than makes up for the lack of "fine dining" atmosphere. I can't afford to keep eating here twice a week, but this is my "go to" place when I crave a great steak. read more

Ummm, wow! 8 of us came from a conference to this quaint little place. After devouring the fried lobster tail, I had one of the best ribeye steaks I've ever eaten. We shared homemade peanut butter pie and key lime for dessert. I cannot say enough positive things about this place. The service was great, the food was awesome, and the price was reasonable! read more

Great hole-in-the-wall place. Best steak place around Columbus area. I recommend their succulent filet and fried lobster tail (appetizer, comes in 3s). Despite it's isolated location, you will find yourself waiting for a table if you go around 7pm read more

Ok me and three co-workers went here last Thursday for a work dinner. I don't eat steak but I agreed to go anyway. If you don't eat steak you have few options; a fish option that changes (red snapper the night I was there) and grilled chicken breast. I think that's pretty much it. Of course all my co-workers ordered steaks while I went with the chicken. I can't personally speak to the steaks but I can tell you there was nothing left on anyone's plate so maybe that's all that needs to be said. With each meal you get two sides to pick from as well. I can honestly say that for a basic grilled chicken breast it was probably the best I've ever had. The grits were good maybe a little heavy and the salad was nothing special. For dessert apparently you MUST get the peanut butter pie. All mu co-workers did but I went with the key lime pie. I believe both are homemade. The place is in the middle of nowhere. On a Thursday evening the lot was full and cars were parked up and down the street. In other words the place was packed. But we only waited maybe 20 minutes to get a table; not too bad This place isn't inexpensive but not unreasonable either. If you can find it, this place is worth a visit especially if you like steak. Or even chicken. read more

I did a double take the first time I saw Hunters Pub, but when I sat down for a New York strip I was blown away. One of the best steaks I've ever had. read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - Lobster tail appetizers - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

They have some of the best steaks around. The only place I've personally been and had better was at Flemmings in downtown Austin, TX. Hunter's beats them for the price though. The location is out in the relatively middle of nowhere, and the place itself is rather small and packed, but a cool atmosphere at the same time. I'll definitely try to go back whenever I'm in Columbus. read more

Does not look like anything much from the outside but the food is pretty good. I had that nights special, grouper, and my husband had steak. My meal was fantastic, the steak didn't blow us away but it was still good and fairly priced. Worth checking out. We would go back. read more

Had the 16 oz ribeye. And it was legit!! Nice hole in the wall . Definitely coming back. They have homemade steak sauce which was hella good! read more

Great steak. Great service. Get over the price and the plasticware...it matches the ambiance and the food makes it worth it. You're going to a "hunters pub" and you should expect that ambiance. Ribeye was cooked great and tasted great. Mashed potatoes were great. Peanut butter pie was awesome. We got the fried lobster tails to start and they (and the salad) were the only part of the meal that was just ok. Worth the drive. read more

Way to go Hunter's . From start to finish you will not be disappointed. Food and service is great. A hidden gem.

Small place with great tasting food. The steak salad was mostly steak and cooked perfectly. The house sauce enhanced the flavor. If you are passing through then this is the place to eat. read more

Great dinner spot! The daily specials are always delicious but I don't think you could go wrong with anything here. It is out of the way but SO worth it! No matter what you order, make sure to save room for the peanut butter pie. read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - Peanut butter pie - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

The waitress was super nice, however the food was terrible. We spent $125 and ordered the ribeye, strip, kids chicken fingers, kids steak tips, cheese bread appetizers, and motz sticks appetizers. Hands down, the worst steaks I've had in the last couple years. The steaks were like 2/3rds fat. It was ridiculous and very gross. I really wanted to like this place and came because of the high reviews, but it was just straight up gross and very expensive. Avoid, avoid, avoid. read more

Nice service but it's over-priced and crowded. I've been twice. The first time I had the marinated grilled chicken breast ($12) and asparagus. It was good enough to make me return. The second trip was on a Friday night, we were warned about the crowds but thought, how long can it take? It took about thirty minutes for us to get a table and at least an hour for our food to arrive. I ordered the steak tips. The iceberg salad was small and forgettable. Worse yet, the server made it without gloves. Taking money and then adding tiny tomatoes to my salad with bare hands is a little scary. The bread was delicious but the sweet potato fries weren't anything to write home about. The steak tips were disappointing. There was a lot of meat, it was cut thick and it got cold and chewy fast. It's also smothered in overcooked mushrooms and onions (I had mine without onions). Even adding the sauce, it wasn't good. I'm not sure why anyone would rate this place five stars. They do have nice servers. I left my purse and no-one went through it or anything. The jukebox is cool. They fill it with money on Friday evenings so you don't have to pay. And I appreciate the semi-late hours. But the seating is uncomfortable, the atmosphere is noisy and the food only warrants three stars. Being generous, I'd give four stars for the chicken breast and two for the steak tips. I won't return. read more

Really, that's the best steak people have had? It was a pretty good rib eye, but don't understand the raving about it. Service was ok, and I guess the shock factor is that you don't expect that type of food in a place that, but there wasn't really nothing special about it. The panko crusted fish with some sauce, was rather small, and not all that interesting. And it wasn't cheap either read more

Angel was a great server. She was so kind and funny. The steak was amazing. I highly recommend it.

Great steaks. A little pricey, but worth it when you just want a good steak in a laid back atmosphere. Go early on a Friday or Saturday in the summer or you'll have a long wait. read more

Located in Hamilton GA in the middle of nowhere this local favorite was a genuine treat! Great steaks, creative appetizers, a jukebox you can pick the songs on, and peanut butter pie like you'venever tasted. Heather and the staff were an absolute delight. 10 out of 10 recommend (May want to leave grandma at home if she doesn't like a loud dinner environment!) read more

Going here tonight can't wait best steaks around! Small hole in the wall with a 5 star steak, yes even competes with Ruth's Chris, given it's 1/4 of the price.. read more

If you love "hole in the wall" restaurants you will LOVE Hunter's Pub. Fine dining in a beyond casual atmosphere. We were staying at Calloway Gardens and found this jewel. Try the fried lobster tails for sure! Between us we also had the filet mignon, fish of the day topped with shrimp and a cream sauce, sauteed brussel sprouts w/bacon, asparagus, sweet potato fries, green beans and salad. OKay, so we splurged, it was vacation. Do not forget the home made peanut butter pie! read more

Pretend it's your bday. They'll give you free pie. Try the peanut butter pie. I don't like anything peanut butter, but this pie is the best pie I've ever had! read more

I love this place. Fried lobster is the best. Always worth the wait. Our waitress is always great. Its easy to drop a bill but its worth every penny. read more

Who knew a concrete brick building, along the side of the road, in the middle of GA could have the best steak I've ever had. If you don't eat here, you are missing out. DELICIOUS read more

My husband and I drove out to Hunter's Pub on a Friday night, we got there a little after 8 and seemed like we just caught the tail end of their rush. The restaurant itself is small and completely no frills. The servers were very friendly and attentive throughout service. My husband ordered the jalapeno poppers to start which were just okay. Our steaks came out shortly after and were cooked perfectly, HOWEVER, definitely lacked salt. I find that like most other steakhouses that pride themselves in their sauce are less heavy handed with the salt. It is a personal preference but I am not a fan of steak sauce and the Pub sauce was no exception. The sides came in huge portions, the fried green beans were so good! I definitely would come back to try the lobster tails and pies that everyone raves about. Overall, the friendly service and atmosphere alone was worth the short drive and I would give Hunter's Pub another try. read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - Ribeye Medium Rare and Loaded Baked Potato - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

So good! Everyone recommended this place and I'm not disappointed. Ribeye and fried greens beans. Couldn't leave without trying the fried lobster tail. Everything was great and their steak is the best I've had. Atmosphere isn't very diverse so I definitely felt out of place but people were friendly and the food was fabulous! read more

See all

Great place to eat. Friendly staff and comfortable atmosphere. We enjoyed the ribeye, filet, sweet potato fries and loaded baked potato. All was great! BUT, whatever you do, don't leave there until you try the peanut butter pie! Oh my gosh! It's the best ever! read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

Delightful surprise! Order the fried lobster tails, steak entree and don't miss the peanut butter pie. Loved the service and the food. Also, the wine selection was surprisingly good (and so cheap!) read more

Hunter's Pub and Steakhouse - New American Near Me - Hamilton, Georgia

Ordered the ribeye and it was absolutely perfect paired with their homemade steak sauce. Also, the chocolate peanut butter pie was soooo yummy! Our server was super nice and played with my toddler. Excellent service and food! read more

I wish I could give Hunters Pub a 3.5. They do cook good food; good steaks. This is a once per year type of restaurant though because it is so expensive for what you get. We started with the combo appetizer and you can tell most of it comes frozen and they fry it. We thought fry to order but we were wrong as the jalapeño poppers and onion rings were hot but the chicken tenders and cheese sticks were not. We sent the chicken tenders back and were given hot, fresh ones but it was kind of a negative way to start my moms B Day dinner celebration! And-- it was over 10 dollars-- for an appetizer! The only other real negative was my husbands dressing came out really late after he got his salad so he was just sitting and looking at his salad for a while before he could eat it. The fish special was good but over 26.00 per entree. Waitress was nice. Place is loud and small. They gave my mom a free slice of Key lime pie for her birthday and sang to her which was cool. Overall, it's okay. Check out he receipt though because my heart still hurts a little. read more

See all

Wow. Let me tell you that this is a hidden GEM. The ribeye was top notch and the peanut butter chocolate cake is something that will make any Yankee fly to Georgia. The wait is well worth it. I recommend bringing a cooler with some drinks and enjoying the nice outdoor atmosphere. Will return 110%. read more