Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Old Mill Restaurant

    5.0 (1 review)

    Old Mill Restaurant Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Old Mill Restaurant

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for New American 169 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Oak House - Peanut Butter Pie

    Oak House

    4.8(144 reviews)
    34.8 mi

    We have spent our last 3 anniversaries at Oak House. It has never disappoints. Our most recent…read moretrip there might have been the best. This place is tiny. I have never tried to eat there without a reservation. It is always packed. I did not take a single pic but we had the gulf crab claws in lemon butter sauce. These were the most amazing crab claws i have ever had. It came with 2 pieces of bread thank goodness bc i needed it to get all the lemon sauce. Pricey- yes. Worth every penny-yes! We shared an entree short rib entree and added a side of mac and cheese and scalloped potatoes. There was not even a crumb left. I didn't even need a knife for the short ribs. My tip is to go early. I'm sure the other food is good too, but the best stuff sells out.

    Boy do I love Oak house. Really. One of the best restaurants in Birmingham. No question. All…read morethree of us got chicken piccata. OUTSTANDING. NOW let's talk about the service. Let me set this up. My wife and I are on the diet shot. We share meals and still can't finish them. Both my wife and I at the beginning of our life together 47 years ago, both worked for restaurants. We know how hard folks in the business work. Even though it would affect his income negatively, our server was a real professional. I notice things like that. I tipped 35%+. WHY, he deserved it and we enjoyed his service. The Ambiance of the restaurant was calm, friendly and inviting. We will absolutely go again. Bravo.

    Photos
    Oak House - A portion of the dining area

    A portion of the dining area

    Oak House - Salmon Oscar

    Salmon Oscar

    Oak House - Whiskey Sour

    See all

    Whiskey Sour

    Big Whiskey - 6oz sirloin

    Big Whiskey

    3.4(24 reviews)
    37.0 mi
    $$

    I decided to come here on a Friday afternoon before six to finally catch a happy hour here. They…read morehave happy hour Monday through Friday from 3 PM to 6 PM. They also have some half-price appetizers during that time. We were promptly seated, didn't have a weight. This is my first time at this location. I had been to the one in Alabaster and Hoover location, but not this location. Our server's name is Shellee. She said it was her second shift. I never would've known unless she told me she was extremely attentive and friendly. We both started off with the perfect margarita on the rocks. We each had two of them. They were so delicious. I believe she said the bartender's name was Kasey. She definitely did a great job on those drink. We had a pretzel and beer cheese appetizer to start with which was very delicious and was recommended by the server. For dinner, I have the buffalo chicken wrap and my partner had the ribs. We were both happy with our meals. I did visit the bathroom and it was very clean. It definitely is one of the bigger locations I will definitely be back here again

    This place matches the review. Excellent customer service, good food and nice atmosphere. Place can…read morebe for game day or fine dining. My youngest and I ordered the following: Southwest egg rolls: 8/10 very good 6oz sirloin: 8/10 very good Rickhouse Ribeye (cowboy style): 10/10 very good quality steak and flavor. The cowboy still just enhanced things even more. Highly recommend Potato salad: 7/10 not bad at all. My ribeye medium was so good my daughter no longer wants her steaks well done... I almost a shed a tear to this news. Amen.

    Photos
    Big Whiskey - Whiskey flight! (Run Forest Run)

    Whiskey flight! (Run Forest Run)

    Big Whiskey - Pretzels and beer cheese

    Pretzels and beer cheese

    Big Whiskey - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Bama Bucks - Brisket French dip with sweet potato fries

    Bama Bucks

    3.8(95 reviews)
    54.7 mi

    The 35 day dry ages split bone ribeye was melt in your mouth amazing! The garlic mashed potatoes…read morewere mouth watering, bursting with flavor! The asparagus was cooked to perfection, with that crisp first bite and seasoned to perfection! The onion rings were superb and the baked beans... they were the best I have ever tasted! The New York Cheesecake with the blueberry sauce and peanut butter pie were the absolute best I have ever tasted!! I give Bama Bucks a 10/10 for the food! The presentation of the food was breathtakingly beautiful! The service was a little slow seating (Valentine's Day so that's expected) but so well worth the wait! Tables set nicely with a single rose at every table! Very well decorated inside and out! Even though they were slam packed our waitress was very attentive to our table, made sure we had everything we needed and was not overbearing but so kind and courteous! Best date night I've had with my husband in a good while! We plan to go back soon to try more of their exotic food experiences soon! If you have never eaten here it's A+, 10/10, an absolute perfect experience!

    Bama Bucks in Boaz, AL is a destination! Located about an hour outside of Birmingham, Bama Bucks is…read morea wildlife and wild game outdoor zoo with a restaurant featuring wild game, as well as the usual fare (steak, chicken, and beef). If you're into funny taxidermy, bison burgers, and seeing a lot of animals you hope to never encounter face to face, this is your place. It's really a nice, clean, well-done facility. There's a gift shop with some crazy items, a bourbon bar, fire pit, and beautiful grounds and landscaping. Worth the trip on a lovely fall day. I especially think kids would love to spend some time here. The food service was slow, but the quality, ambiance, and service were actually fantastic. They routinely bring out a baby raccoon (collective "aww"). Wood-burning fireplaces add to the charm.

    Photos
    Bama Bucks - Bama Bucks Gift Shop Honey Bees

    Bama Bucks Gift Shop Honey Bees

    Bama Bucks - Pecan bread pudding

    Pecan bread pudding

    Bama Bucks

    See all

    Old Mill Restaurant - newamerican - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...