This was the best cheesecake I've ever tasted! Also the service was top-notch with aesthetic themed decor inside too. Cannot wait to try more soon! read more

See all

Excellent cheesecake and very pleasant staff. Great flavors and if is was in a more convenient place I'd try it again. The downside is it's not in Manhattan or another high rent district, so $11.50 for a small slice, plus 4% for using my debit card doesn't add up. It was really good though. read more

3.5 stars. Vanilla bean cheesecake was great. But there was no prices on menu nor was there labels for what cheesecake was what. I had to ask what each item was. When I go back ill update accordingly. Cheesecake was a 4.8/5 stars so definitely go for that. read more

Right from the moment you walk in Bella was a She's so sweet and personable asking how she can assist and if we have any questions please don't hesitate. Her smile is infectious and the way she shares details about the desserts is top tier. The experience and cheesecake was 10/10. I would most definitely recommend. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Photos of business and items - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

When in New York you must eat cheese cake, I tried the banana pudding cheesecake cupcake. I'm a southern belle and this cupcake was absolutely delicious. It was fluffy and quite delicious. When I say the cheesecake was a taste of heaven. I enjoyed that this establishment is a hidden jewel in a residential neighborhood. There is plenty of off street parking. There is a playground outside so you can enjoy your dessert outside and and run off that sugar. read more

See all

Absolutely amazing!! Banana Pudding cheesecake!! Was perfect!! Then the banana pudding cup! All served by a beautiful young lady who was super friendly & made sure I had a card & if I buy a certain amount of cheesecake, I'll get a slice free! Beautiful work Dana! read more

Warm inviting personable atmosphere service was great ambience is relaxing inviting right next-door is going to be a coffee shop. The cheesecake is delicious. There's a red velvet, homemade whipped cream cupcake. And a Oreo cheesecake cookie oh my goodness everything is homemade handmade done on the premises sumptuous simply mouthwatering cheesecake read more

See all

Popped in while in the area based on the reviews. Heads up that there is no branding on the building and it's in a residential/slightly run down part of town. That being said, the 2 young men working in there were very kind and hospitable. They were some of the kindest people I've encountered in recent memory. We got a slice of the Banana Pudding cheesecake and it was outstanding. Very tasty and almost not even cheesecake imo. So good. 4 stars because a tiny slice was $8.95, more than most nice restaurants. But the flavors were there. I would recommend posting small signs of what type of cheesecake each one is, as all 3 customers inside asked what they were, like we did. Posted prices wouldn't be the worst idea either, but glad we stopped in. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

I just bought a slice of the pumpkin cheesecake. It is beyond delicious.... Im glad I don't live too close to this place because I would be there everyday. And the vibe is awesome. read more

This place is a gem in Newburgh. She makes not only cheesecakes but tres leches, cupcakes and other treats. I used to buy from her when she was selling cheesecake out her house she's the real deal! I'm here every chance I can get I just love this place!!! Please check it out, you won't be disappointed! read more

I come here all the time and the cheesecake is amazing. The cupcakes and cookie sandwiches are original. The staff is very friendly

"Time to make the cheesecake!" If you read nothing else other than this first line...Do not go here unless you arrive immediately after they open! Dang it, I hate to be "that customer" but I'm going to be that customer that poops on this place because this place is NOT close to my home. I drove about 40 mins to this place because of friends sharing their experiences when it was in Kingston prior to moving to Newburgh so I was excited for it to have moved closer to me. Let me preface this review by saying I called ahead asking if they had products readily available that I was interested in OR if I should order ahead to ensure I was able to purchase what I wanted since I didn't live in the area. I was told to come down because they do have the items I was interested in readily available which is a traditional cheese cake. When I finally arrived to this bakery I was confused if I was even at the correct location because there was no signs out front indicating what business this might have been. Secondly when I got inside I thought for sure I was at the wrong place because while it smelled really good inside they had two massive sized display refrigerator units with ZERO product inside. I thought, "maybe it's SO fresh they just get what we want from the back right from the oven". Nope!! They had no products to sell except a few slices of some rainbow cheese cake I had no desire to taste. The staff was super nice despite my confusion of zero product available for sale. They politely told me, "Well it is two hours before closing and we've sold out of what we had for the day!" Gee, I guess if you have no more product you might as well close your doors immediately and update business hours to "11am while supplies last for the day" because why have business hours if you are essentially closed once you run out of product to sell. UGH! I was so dang disappointed BUT I was hopeful and asked if I could order for pick up the next day or day after and was told no. Either they don't take orders or the young man mis-informed me because I was willing to place an order only because I did not live in the area. I left shattered and so disappointed because I absolutely LOVE cheese cake. Photos on Yelp from 2022 that show their beautiful display case with tons of product in it was from their Kingston location prior to moving to Newburgh. I'm not even sure if they are ready for business and probably should just take phone orders for pickup until they are ready to be officially open at the new location. I wish them the best of luck but they really should change closing business hours to "while supplies last" this way customers know if you don't line up at the door before they open then don't bother visiting. read more

I was looking for a slice of cheesecake on my birthday. This was soooooo good it's so creamy and soft- I just wish the place had chairs and tables for me to enjoy it. They should open up more locations! Also service is really friendly. I paid $22 for two regular sized slices which is kinda pricey. However I find it to be better than grocery store cheesecake and Cheesecake Factory cheesecake (and I love Cheesecake Factory) read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Very good cheesecake. Enjoyed it very much. The thick part of the cheesecake, outer layer wasn't cooked all the way so it was very eggy but the first half, woah, great! Next time I'll come and try another one. Got the strawberry cheesecake read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

very cute spot with great cheesecakes and interesting flavors. I love how it's in an old house. enjoyed the other stuff as well

This is the best cheesecake in the HV. I would tell you which flavors are the best, but in reality, it is all of them. If it's your first time and they have the cookie crumble ones, try them. The service here is also wonderful. Highly recommend!! read more

We got a variety box to bring for dessert. We were visiting family in fishkill. Everything was delicious! We'll go back if we're in the area. Service was friendly and made recommendations. read more

Very unorganized and overpriced definitely not worth seventy dollars for a plain cheesecake ..! They have a nice coffee bar but no one making drinks and no seating...? read more

I went in yesterday and was instantly greeted by a warm and sweet staff . I pass this place all the time and finally decided to stop in. I got banana pudding cheesecake for myself and strawberry for someone else . The banana pudding one was absolutely delicious honestly one of the best slices I've ever had . I can't wait to go back and get another . It didn't even last long enough for me to take a picture lol read more

Oreo cheesecake was good , Oreo was soft which leads me to believe it wasn't made fresh. When I went there wasn't many selections on a Friday. Was heard great reviews about their cheesecake and wanted to try to rainbow one! Cannoli was filling and my son ate the cupcake. Reached out on fb but never responded. Only went one time. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Oreo cheesecake , cannoli filled with cheesecake and strawberry crunch cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

came here after eating lunch across the street at lolas. This is a pretty hidden spot, i only came across it on the map and looking at yelp. Tiny little shop up the stairs. the two people working there were very nice. We ordered a slice of the chunky monkey cheesecake. it was DELICIOUS. If i could, i would have ordered a slice of every flavor. the key lime flavor looked great. would definitely come back here again if i was in the new paltz area. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - chunky monkey cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Wow! Just wow! The variety of cheesecakes here is impressive. And every one I've tried has been lovely!

Radically high-quality cheesecake, bakery in the area. Apparently they were in new Paltz before but are a welcome addition to the city of Newburgh. I went in over the weekend and bought four slices for after dinner; banana, biscoff biscuit, red velvet, and cherry. It holds space among the best cheesecake I've had in my life. read more

A great place for a wide variety of cheesecakes. A bit pricey but it's quality, so worth it. Loved the rainbow cookie cheesecake. Creamy and light, chocolate Brahma cracker crust at bottom. Layer of jam and chocolate made it really taste like a rainbow cookie. Who would have thought that? Amazing. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Delicious rainbow cookie cheesecake. - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

was greeted warmly by the staff and she offered a though explanation of the menu. she offered suggestions and told me specials items. i ordered three slices of cheesecake, strawberry crunch, cannoli and rainbow cake. she boxed all cheesecake slices like I wanted and offered a fork with box to eat. she also answered my questions without issue. all in all very great service here. now to the cheesecake, very tasty and homemade with love, very easy to tell they made in house and not prepackage. also they very much live up to the name offering a wide variety of cheesecakes. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

Being a chef and restaurateur I have tasted tons of cheesecakes from some of the best chefs in this country , with that being said, Hudson Valley Cheesecake is some of the best cheesecake that I have ever tasted. The flavor tastes just like you picture them...That Butter pecan was crazy. If you get a chance run, don't walk to Hudson Valley Cheesecake read more

This cheesecake is delicious I recommend trying the strawberry crunch and the cookie butter cheesecake! read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

It is one of the best if not the best bakeries I have ever tried. Im not a huge cheesecake fan and it was absolutely divine and decadent! I also had their banana pudding cupcakes omg delicious!!! Service was amazing, the cashier was knowledgeable and nice. The atmosphere of the place was simplistic yet so clean. Great place! read more

I honestly believe this is the best cheesecake I have ever eaten. I consistently try different flavors and keep repeating and returning for The Chocolate Cheesecake, Strawberry Crunch, Oreo, Tiramisu, Cannoli, Banana Pudding, DunkARoo, Plain, Strawberry, and various Mini. Did I mention the little cheesecake sandwiches? This place is always worth a stop. The ingredients are always fresh and changing. read more

Please update your phone # on safari or yelp , idk , but my Girlfriend is going crazy with how many people call her daily asking for your delicious cheesecakes ( apperantly) ... read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

My wife and I met in New Paltz and we usually visit a few times a year. Each time, we look for a new local business to try. This place caught our eye while walking down Main Street. The first thing that caught our eyes were the 15 different varieties displayed. I'll admit I was a little overwhelmed, but the man behind the counter explained each flavor, including what the crust was made out of, and his recommendations. We went with the Italian Rainbow Cookie and Cannoli cheesecakes. The staff/family, told us how to properly transport and store the cake pieces for our trip home. Now, I am from New York. I have eaten A LOT of cheesecake. This is, by far, the best cheesecake I have ever had. My only disappointment is that they don't yet ship to NYC, but hopefully that changes soon. Try this out when you come to New Paltz! read more

We were greeted by friendly staff who took Covid very seriously. There was a sign outside with a bar code to view the menu, and even order online, reducing the physical contact. The staff were also cleaning the doors and handles, keeping everything clean. We were astounded by the wide variety of mouthwatering cheesecakes. A staff member described each cheesecake from the crust to the drizzle on top. We ended up choosing the rainbow cookie and Oreo cheesecake. Both were extremely smooth and rich, and were better than expected, being from New York. I highly recommend trying Hudson Valley Cheesecake if you're in the New Paltz area, or craving something sweet! read more

Amazing cheesecake and even more amazing staff! Everyone here was so friendly and we had such a great experience. We got the rainbow slice, banana pudding slice, strawberry cheesecake slice and the December flavor of the month. Our favorite was the banana pudding but it was honestly all so delicious! Highly reccomend this place if you're looking for some great dessert:) read more

Amazing service and great cheesecake, we forgot our oreos and the servers brought it to us! Truly amazing people who work there, no room for seating but truly amazing experience! read more

Well what can I say...this is by far the worst business owner I have ever talked with. Dana is so far up her own arz and that is where it gets the chocolate. Worst food poisoning EVER. read more

These cheesecake crumbles or sandwiches are amazing and nothing like I've had before. By the time we came back, they sold out! Don't just get one... you will regret that decision. read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - Cheesecake crumbles or sandwiches... they are AMAZING! - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York

SO GOOD!! cheesecake is delicious and the staff are sooo so soso so nice. 10/10 recommend

Amazing cheesecake. Go to spot after I eat anywhere in town. I check their Instagram to see what they have available everyday and have often made extra stops just because I see their crusties or strawberry cheesecake available. I will not lie, I've even called ahead and asked for them to save me a slice. Wonderful family that runs it! The showcasing of the desserts could use some improvement and there's no seating inside, so head to the park and grab grab a bench! Delicious. read more

Smoothest, creamiest cheesecake I've had. Absolutely delicious. So far I haven't tried a slice I didn't enjoy.

Wow! Just WOW! The best cheesecake you can find! She doesn't miss a beat when creating new flavors. Get the BIG BOX and try them all! Tiramisu, butter pecan, pistachio, and chocolate crunch are some of the best! read more

Hudson Valley Cheesecake - BIG BOX - Bakeries Near Me - Newburgh, New York