Ashley at The Cakery was amazing to work with. We opted for a dessert table and a small sweetheart cake for our wedding and it was all beyond delicious! We had the marble cake with raspberry & chocolate ganache filling. People couldn't stop talking about it. As well as the lemon bars, coconut macaroons, brownies, apple pie bites, mini cheesecakes, & the chocolate covered strawberries. Our whole dessert table was absolutely perfect. read more

Definitely will be back . This is my fifth order with them. Customer service is excellent. read more

See all

Whenever I have a special occasion or am charged with "bring a dessert" I love going to The Cakery. They have a wide variety of cakes, cupcakes, cookies, bars, cake pops, and cake balls. Their bakers are real artists who will work with you to create the perfect cake (cookie or traditional) that are as pretty to look at as they are to eat. It's tucked away in a shopping plaza so it can be easy to miss. It's worth the trip. My personal favorites: their bars (cheesecake, brookies) and cake balls (cookie dough is fabulous). Highly recommend if you want a sweet treat for yourself or a special event. read more

Splendid customer service! I did not have the chance to try them unfortunately- i got 2 dozen assorted sent to my friend who had a child. They took my order, wrote a note for the delivery and set up a drop off time. Superb organization skills! Literally called/messaged 7-10 bakeries in New Windsor, Newburgh, and Beacon and this was the only one that delivered to Newburgh. My friend and their family said the cupcakes were fantastic and they are going get another 2 dozens lol. My one complaint is the delivery fee was not cheap. 25 dollars for delivery which is even too expensive for this NYCer. read more

Thank you Ashley. The delicious presentation of all your cupcakes were beyond impressive. I purchased a carrot cupcake and a cannoli cupcake. Both of these were to go and they were packed beautifully. Both cupcakes were light, fresh and AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL AND DELICIOUS. Cannot wait to return. Thank you Ashley!! read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Carrot cake cupcake DEELEECIOUS!!!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

The cakery is my favorite place to stop and get sweets. This is the second time picking up cupcakes and they never disappoint. They constantly change and add fun flavors depending on the seasons. I also ordered a birthday cake for my boyfriend one year which came out great. I asked for an Amazon box designed cake and it was perfect. read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Outstanding bakery for those of us who have celiac disease or wheat/gluten allergies. They make delicious French macaroons filled with jam or cream. You do need to order ahead, however it is well worth the wait! read more

I had ordered a cake for my boyfriends birthday- I sent several pictures- and had noticed they did a car previously so I asked if they could do it. I was told they could. I realize there are quite a few details that were involved, however the cake looked like a joke. I had also asked that The cake have golf/grass/greens underneath it- clearly there is no greens. If they couldn't deliver what I had wanted they should have told me it couldn't be done. Not one response from the establishment, I guess they don't care if their customers are happy or not. I would steer clear of this bakery especially if you have a special occasion coming up. ** I had left the establishment w the cake because there was a young girl behind the counter and I honestly was just in shock at how bad the cake looked. I attempted to call the owner as soon as I got into the parkinf lot, yet she ignored my calls and blocked me on Facebook. read more

See all

I would do zero stars if I could. Been here a few times great experiences, though a few times I've felt sick after eating a treat from there, I figured it was just because everything is so rich. Today we bought a bunch of cake balls, and to my disgust it was covered in full Izzy green MOLD. I feel sick to my stomach. I normally don't write reviews but I don't want anyone else to eat mold like I just did. Praying I don't get food poisoning. Clearly this is an issue of hygiene. No mold develops over 3 days. How long was this shit sitting in the case rotting??? Save yourself time, money, and puking. DO NOT ORDER From HERE read more

The Cakery Fishkill - MOLD - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

The cake pops are incredible! I've had cake pops before and thought it was just a pricey gimmick. But not only were The Cakery's cake pops beautifully decorated, each one was absolutely delicious. They are slightly different than cake: dense but velvety, filling, and in a wide assortment of wonderful flavors. Even vanilla knocked our socks off. The cannoli and amaretto flavors were spot on, scrumptious, and so satisfying. Mint chocolate and red velvet were amazing too. There were totally worth the price! We're already planning to get them for our next celebration. read more

Cake was beautiful looking,,, but horrible taste. The cake was super stale and super sweet. I wonder how many days they had it out waiting for it to sell. I was so embarrassed having my guest eat this cake! Never again. read more

The Cakery Fishkill - a purple birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

These guys do beautiful and delicious work! We had them put together our cake and dessert bar for our baby bash. I sent Ashley a few Pinterest photos and she did a great job combining all into one custom cake! The dessert pastries all matched the theme of the cake - a beautiful spread the guests love. Must try the blueberry cake balls! Another favorite is the coconut cream filling for cakes! Thank you Ashley! read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Baby bash cake! Peter Rabbit theme! - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

I have ordered multiple times from them with great outcomes. This time was even better. I ordered cupcakes shaped into a rainbow for my daughters baby shower. It was beautiful and the colors were perfect. I also ordered rainbow cookies and not only did they match the cupcakes perfectly they were delicious as were the cupcakes. Thank you for always delivering such amazing deserts. read more

I had an appointment scheduled with another local bakery who upon arrival told me they couldn't accommodate me, after previously confirming. I reached out to Ashley in a panic and she fit me in no problem at a WAY better price than I was told by the other bakery. Not only was she incredibly sweet and professional, she made the most incredible replica of my husbands car for his birthday. On top of that, everyone said it was the best cake they'd ever tasted. Fancy cakes aren't always great tasting, but this was both beautiful and delicious. I HIGHLY recommend this business and will continue to use them for future events. read more

See all

My wife and I live in Monroe, Connecticut. The Cakery was recommended by my daughter who lives in Beacon, NY. Last year, I had a birthday party for my wife here in Connecticut and asked my daughter to pick-up cupcakes for the party. OMG they were out of this world delicious. This year my wife had a baby shower for her daughter. She asked my daughter to again bring the ordered Cakery cupcakes with an English Garden theme. Not only were the cupcakes delicious, but they were also so beautifully decorated that everyone raved about them. My wife and I give The Cakery Fishkill 10 Stars not just the 5stars Yelp uses. read more

They ruined my wedding cake. After I did the tasting - I sent them the photo of the cake we talked about along with color swatch I wanted my cake. When it arrived on my wedding day, it looked nothing like the photo. They never followed up before my wedding day - I realize now that I should have but I had a million things to do as most brides do right before their wedding. The cake showed up with WHITE flowers/roses instead of multi color pink Roses and it was like they didn't even try to match the color I wanted with the color swatch for the rest of the cake. They left with the cake to "fix it" and came back with the same cake after they spray painted the flowers (which looked terrible by the way) and they were now loose and falling off. One of my guests had to pick up one of the flowers and put it back on. Plus, Taste wise - it was just okay compared to what I remember from the tasting. Nothing memorable. I complained and received a $25 Credit but on a $400 wedding cake - that doesn't do much. Once a wedding cake is ruined and not as you imagine it - the day is over and there's really no fixing it. read more

The Cakery Fishkill - The cake I wanted - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

Don't trust these guys. I called at 4pm right when they were closing to reserve a cake for my wife birthday today. They asked for my name and said they would hold their last vanilla butter cream cake and to call back in the morning with my credit card and message to write on the cake. When I called at 10:15am they told me the cake was sold to someone else! I kept asking if it was me since I can't imagine they sold it to someone else. They won't have my business anymore. read more

I ordered a thanksgiving cake. Nicely decorated but when we cut a slice it was dry, old and the flavor was horrible. This is not the first time I had a product from them and it was horrible. I have no idea why people like this place but quality is absolutely under par. read more

I must say this is a real gem. The cupcakes are insanely good. Not over sweet just right. The cake park is moist not dry and heavy. The coconut macaroons are out if this world. The peacan bar is so good that i had to hide it from everybody. The prices are very good nothing over priced the flavors are on point. So much better than Adams. If you want good bake good go to this little place. Enjoy the flavors they have to offer read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Just stumble upon this little gem tonight. Had to buy a few things also have gf to order but they had some Macaroons. - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

This place NEEDSSSSS a professional marketing director because it is the best baked goods I've had from NYC to Rhinebeck. I live in Fishkill and didn't know they were even there until this glorious day! Phenomenal, phenomenal baking skills. Not overly sweet but sweet enough for my heavy sweet tooth. A perfect balance in every single thing I tried which was about 7 different items. If I literally had a gun to my head and was told you have to pick your favorite, I still couldn't. Everything top notch. Blowsssss any competition away in neighboring towns such as Beacon and Hopewell. I will be back anytime I need something for a party or to get my own fix. Any other dessert is a calorie waste. *I am not friends or family with the owners or anyone that works there. It's that impressive* read more

I got a cake for my boyfriends 30th birthday. When I went there, I wasn't entirely impressed with the attitude of the girl I was talking to. Didn't seem enthusiastic and made it seem like I was wasting her time. I really tried to let her take as much of her creative spin on the cake as she could, but it didn't seem like she was working with me much. I figured, she's the cake artist, not me, I'll tell her what I'm looking for and she can create the masterpiece! We came to a price of $140 which I thought was a bit much but I figured for the occasion and the piece I thought I would get, it would be more than worth it. The cake was 100% disappointing. I could've done a better job myself or maybe even a 5 year old. The cake looked very rushed and thrown together and not at ALL what I imagined. I was so disappointed in this establishment as I expected my expectations to be met beyond what I could imagine. The "30" they put on the cake looks like they colored it with crayons markers. Originally she tried to charge me $190 for this garbage also. Regardless of the taste, not worth it. Incredibly disappointing. No creativity what so ever and they completely half-assed it. read more

The Cakery Fishkill - a birthday cake in a box - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Horrible, $80.00 taste like cardboard.... my first & last time there..... I had them make a specialty cake, I seen all the reviews so I couldn't wait to try their cake. I didnt even mind paying the extra money , it was just overall nasty, it wasnt moist it was over baked, my child could have baked a better cake... read more

This place is a joke! I had ordered a cake for my 50th, sent a picture- I wanted it exactly the same except a red flower instead. The cake didn't look like what I had asked for- it looked like a half attempt, there was barely any filling. I had also ordered another cake prior to me getting my cake. It was for my boyfriends birthday. I had sent several pictures- and had noticed they did a car cake in the past, so I asked if they could do it, I was told they could. I realize there are quite a few details involved, however the cake looked like a joke. If they couldn't deliver what I had wanted they should have told me it couldn't be done. Not one response from the establishment, I guess they don't care if their customers are happy or not. I would steer clear of this cake shop/bakery especially if you have a special occasion coming up. read more

Loved my baby shower cake and cupcakes, it looked so good and was delicious. Thank you! read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Baby shower cake - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Excellent cupcakes. Had the cannoli cupcake and my son had the oreo cupcake. Both were delicious. Store is clean.

I ordered cake pops for my daughter's Winnie the Pooh themed baby shower. They created cake pops which looked like Hunny Pots to go along with the theme of the party. They turned out great! Both the vanilla and Oreo flavors were DELICIOUS and moist! My guests and I enjoyed them. I would highly recommend you use them if you are having an event. read more

Outstanding! I've ordered cupcakes for past events but this was a special request. A custom cake for our son's wedding and it was absolutely perfect. Worked with Ashley on what the couple was looking for and she made their vision a reality. Not only was it a beautiful tiered cake, but it was simply delicious. The guests actually asked for seconds. When was the last time you went to a wedding and actually ate the cake. LOL. I highly recommend you visit them for all your events. You will NOT be disappointed. read more

They made our daughters Baby Shower cake just the way we wanted! It was the perfect Lion cake matching the theme for the baby. It was so perfect! It was a lion face surrounded by 12 cupcakes as the mane. Everyone loved it!! It was delicious!!! When we picked up the cake we also got two of their pecan bars which were also very delicious!! Definitely recommend this bakery for cake for your next event!!! read more

We have been buying snacks at On-A-Stick since before they officially opened so when we were planning a party this summer, we knew where to go for delicious cupcakes. Our guests were absolutely thrilled by the beautiful cupcakes and how moist and delicious they tasted! Ashley goes above and beyond for her customers and we hope she has tremendous success! read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Two dozen cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

Our family has been using this bakery since they opened. There is nothing to say but THEY ARE THE BEST! Their designs have been spectacular; husbands 50th bourbon bottle, daughters bridal shower and wedding cake! read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

We had our wedding cake made here, and we were not disappointed! So moist and delicious and beautifully iced. Thank you!! read more

The Cakery Fishkill - Bakeries Near Me - Fishkill, New York

See all

I am super duper picky when it comes to cakes. My standards are so high. I want a moist cake, a flavorful filling, a perfect icing and a beautiful exterior. If it's buttercream, it shouldn't taste like crisco. If it's decorated, it shouldn't look like a mess. This place gets a 9 out of 10. I ordered 2 cakes, one chocolate with an amazing raspberry filling and one almond cake. The almond cake was aaaaamazing. The chocolate cake had too much buttercream icing and not enough raspberry filling. The ratio was off enough that we stopped eating leftovers. The almond cake though, that's worth the 3 hour drive to get some more. Super good! And the presentation of both was impressive read more

I found this shop on Yelp while visiting the area. Today is our grandson's fourth birthday, but his "big" party is not until Saturday. I purchased six cupcakes and six cake balls to celebrate his day. I mixed all the flavors and every one was absolutely delicious. Service was outstanding too. I will definitely return when in the area. The cookies and other baked goods were beautifully decorated and looked just as yummy! read more

These are the most amazing and creative cupcakes I've ever seen! They also make very tasty and adorable cookies. I agree with the other reviews, they need better marketing because they're awesome and I would have never gone there if I hadn't been eating next door! I think they need to be on SHARK TANK!! But then again, I don't want them to go nationwide and leave us! ;-) I haven't had any of their cakes, but everything in this bakery is gorgeous. VERY talented! And I mentioned DELICIOUS?! read more

AH-MAZE-BALLS! I've been going to on a stick since it was operated out of a house. The artwork is nothing short of amazing. Beautiful. They are so creative in how they can make your dream of a cake come true. OH - and its all so friggin delicious! You wouldn't think that a cool looking sugar cookie or 4 tier fondant cake could taste remotely yummy, but they do. Moist and flavorful. All things baked here are to DIE for. I have never been disappointed with their products look or taste. Ashley LOVES what she does, and that love is baked and decorated into everything that comes out of her oven. I would HIGHLY recommend this place for any baked good you'd ever need. read more

Got the lemon raspberry. Taste is on point but could be more fluffy. Need to come back for red velvet

One word to describe this place is PHENOMENAL! I went in there hoping to get Irish Soda Bread. Unfortunately they did not have that but I figured since I was there I would try a few of there baked goods.They were amazing ! We tried the Carmel salted cupcake, raspberry cheesecake bar, peanut butter bar, magic cookie, and the chocolate cherry cupcake. Everything was baked to perfection with just the right amount of sweetness! You will not be disappointed! read more

Both the cookies and the cake were delicious! I would DEFINITELY recommend this bakery and will use them in the future. Thanks Ashley!

Absolutely beautiful baked goods. Husband said it was the bedt cupcake he has ever had (chocolate salted caramel). My pecan pie bar with chocolate was amazing. Their chocolate cake pops were big and delicious! Beautiful cakes and adorable cookies. Original treats in the case. read more

Ashley is amazing! This is definitely my "go to" for the simple and the amazing. Last week I brought some of the cupcake balls to my friends at All Sport and they are hooked! Guess I need to keep that up!!! This week it is an amazing chocolate and caramel birthday cake. read more