Hickory Dickory Dock. My Pizza Cravings Won't Stop. I Tried Once Before. To Quit What I Adore. But Give Up On Pizza?? No More!! Lol, it's always a good time to stop by Hickory Tree for some of their uniquely tasty thin crust style Pizza. These are BIG Slices too that they serve here, which don't even fit on your plate. Toppings are plentiful with a flavorful Cheese and Sauce combination on a nice soft but still firm Crust which sorta reminds me of a traditional NY slice in it's own way. The perfect Slice for folding. I like this small but special spot with both indoor and outdoor seating options plus plenty of other shops to hangout at, I can't believe I haven't hit this place up before. But that was then and this is now, when I'm over this way I'll be here alot more. Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

Hickory Tree Pizza - Hickory Rewards Program - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Love the pasta in garlic sauce so much! Always the best! Just delicious! Great staff, too!

Pizza was ok. We got two plain slices and a small 20 oz bottle of soda. $9.38...seriously? I know all about inflation, but this is highway robbery. I went online when I got home to find out what a large pizza costs, and it is $16 and change. Then I see on their website that they have an every day special for 2 slices and a 16 oz soda for $5.16!!! Might want to get and keep more customers by actually posting that in your restaurant, or mentioning it to customers who are simply ordering a couple of slices. read more

We were picking up takeout from one of the restaurants next door and the smell coming from Hickory Pizzeria was just so alluring. We even witnessed another person picking up takeout telling his friend "do you smell how good the pizza is?" We came back the next day to try the pizza and a chicken parm sandwich and both were very good. Note: it's located in the shopping center with the ShopRite, but on the lower level read more

Hickory Tree Pizza - a cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Got a bunch of things delivered. Pictures are after they have been reheated in the oven (can't be too careful these days with covid) Potato pizza: if you like potato skins, this is the pizza to order. It's really good and definitely a repeat order. Philly cheese steak: this is why I was compelled to post this review. I got this cause I was craving a Philly cheese steak. I had seen the review from two years ago where someone complained their cheese steak was all bread and very little meat so it had me concerned but was still willing to give them a shot as I wanted a cheese steak even if it was going to be bad. Not sure if things have changed since but I'm happy to report the bread to meat ratio has flipped from that other reviewer. A lot more meat vs bread. Even more than what you'd typically get in Philly. I'd say their meat treatment is similar to Steve's in Philly but a lot more of it. If you're wondering why the cheese isn't yellow, it's because I got it with provolone wit onions (the classic Philly cheese). I feel they added butter inside the bread which is a departure from a classic Philly but I'm not mad at it. It's probably the best Philly cheese steak I've had outside of Philly besides the NY outposts of sister Philly restaurants (and I've had it in a lot of different places/states). Usually it ends up with "never again" but with Hickory's, it's a "definitely again". It ain't a true Philly but definitely tasty. Thanks guys!! read more

Hickory Tree Pizza - Half Cheese Steak cross section - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Their pizza is great with a nice thin crust. Dinners and hot subs are just as good. I especially like the sausage pizza and parmigiana subs. Staff is friendly and they remember their regular customers. read more

Pizza usually arrives with cheese sliding off half the pizza. They're good about sending a replacement when this happens, but kinda wish it didn't happen so much. read more

The food here is good and the prices are moderate. My coworkers ordered pizza and they said it was delicious. The chicken tenders I ordered were tasty. We placed an order for delivery (to Morristown) and it came in less than 30 minutes. This was our first time ordering from this place but it won't be our last. read more

Hickory Tree Pizza - Crispy fried chicken tenders w/ honey mustard! Delish :) - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

Surprisingly decent pizza located in a strip mall in Chatham, NJ. Plain slice hit the spot. Lunch deal of 2 slices and a soda for under $5 is unheard of these days. read more

I have lived in New Jersey all of my 43 years and I've never had such delicious pizza. I absolutely love their plain pie. The buffalo wings are the best in the area!! The people are super friendly, great service Hickory pizza is a hidden gem!! read more

Pizza is the best in the area. I used to go to Arminio's and Villa, but now I prefer this

Very good pizza, super friendly staff and newly designed interior with lots of seating options. There are about 8 choices for pizza within a 2-mile radius of our home and this one is becoming our favorite. Plus they're Jets fans! read more

I live 7 minutes away from this place. I ordered delivery several times last year and didn't have any problems. I also appreciate that they have an app so you can order without calling. But tonight I ordered a small plain pizza, no toppings, one soda, and they said it would take 55 minutes, which is a bit too long IMO for an extremely simple order. The bigger problem was when it actually took 75 minutes, and the pizza was cold. 75 minutes for a small plain pizza being delivered 3 miles!!! I had to re-heat it which I don't think I've ever done in my life before. Not cool at all. read more

**NY STYLE PIZZA HERE** stumbled across this place with my co-workers for a thursday afternoon lunch. if you're putting it in your GPS, just go directly where it tells you to go! its on the side of the shop rite mall strip. you can order by the slice (of what they have available) or order a personal size which is 12". please beware that the personal pies are HUGE!!! definitely greater than 12". they're about $9 each. they have a great lunch deal that's 2 cheese slices + coke for only $4. i would definitely do that one day! that day i wasn't particularly hungry and also craving a pepperoni pizza (look at how many pepperonis they put on my pizza! they also taste "more real" than the regular pepperonis you might get at pizza hut), so i got 1 single slice of pepperoni. they warm it up for you and it comes out NY STYLE BABY!!! love this place, love their pizza, love their service, love their prices. definitely come if you're looking for ny style pizza in this area! does get kinda crowded during work lunch hours, but you can order to go and they also deliver in the local area. read more

Hickory Tree Pizza - Pepperoni single slice -- look at the Amt of those pepperonis! - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

This review isn't about food...it's about trust and being a good business. I went to CVS while waiting for my pizza...walked into Hickory when it was ready, paid and left my bag from CVS in the pizza place (had gift card for Christmas). Hickory Pizza put it on the side and when I called the next day said come on down and pick it up. Made my day! read more

Had Chicken Parm and Caeser salad here for a midweek lunch. Would upload photos but that would mean I had enough self control to delay eating the sandwich. Guy preparing & cooking the pizzas was friendly and appeared an expert at his craft. check this place out. read more

My favorite local place. A very gracious staff - they continued to serve cstomers using candles and flashlights during the blizzard-caused black out in October '11. Even if they didn't have the best pizza in the area, which they do, I'd give them 5 stars for that alone. read more

The best pizza in the area that we have tried. I have found that it is the closest to NYC pizza which is a super thin crust and not too saucy. read more

This is a nice little spot to grab a few quick NY style slices. I stopped here for a quick lunch in February and I was very pleasantly surprised. The pizza was cheap and very, very tasty with just the right amount of grease and salt. I don't often shop around this area, but I would definitely stop in again if I'm in the area! read more

Two stars and ONLY because the food is good. Customer service Awful. I visit often and it's ALWAYS something new, mix your order up, screw up your request (And catch an attitude with you when you request a refund or it to be fixed! * the skinnier mean brother I never caught his name. Wish i took pictures of the order he gave me. Instead I got a refund. Then he slammed the food in the trash. Diva! read more

Simple, cheap and fast. What you want in your local pizza joint. Couple stools, couple tables; visit before grocery shopping so you don't go in hungry! read more

This was really, really bad. I'm usually a fan. But lately, what the heck is going on? Over cooked pizzas and mozz sticks like shoe rubber. And to call to give constructive feedback, the nasty owner could give a crap less. Go elsewhere...problem is no good pizza around. Worth the drive to go to Dominick's in Harding. read more

Our go-to pick up place for pizza. It super quick and quite tasty. Everyone who works there is beyond friendly. My husband and I are obsessed with their chicken fingers! My husband likes the garlic knots, too. I wish they had coupons in those mailed packets with all the other pizza places as it isn't super cheap :) read more

One of my favorite pizza's around. Always have a fresh pie there, pizza is solid. I've had the chicken fingers and they are great too. Always get the special!!!! read more

Love their pizza - so much I had it 2 nights in a row! Plain cheese was super tasty and hit the spot. White pizza with mushrooms came with big dollops of mozz and cooked just right. Not fancy Judy great NJ pizza. read more

Exhaust all other options before trying this place. The pizza is a 2 out of 10, the staff is either lazy or incompetent... maybe both. Forget about ordering delivery! We ordered 2 orders of buffalo fingers and fries.. simple right? Nope! We live about 60 seconds from the restaurant, 1 hour and 20 minutes later we called to find out where our food was.. "it should be there soon?" Ok, what does soon mean? "Maybe 5 minutes?" Ok thanks. 15 minutes later we called to cancel the order and let them know they had lost our business. Then we ordered Chinese and had it in less than 20 minutes. Prior to this incident we had boycotted the place for the same reasons, maybe 2 years earlier, but thought we would give it another shot... never again! Subsequent: After we finished eating our Chinese food, which was lovely, and 2 hours-20 minutes after we first ordered, the doorbell rings... it's the hickory tree delivery driver, had to laugh. The kid had no idea that we cancelled the order 45 minutes ago... way to go team! read more

Five stars for a pizza place. starting to become my "go to" weekly spot for a pie. very consistent each time. Sauce is great and they definitely hook it up when putting on the toppings. Out of town guests also have given strong reviews on the pizza from here. Sneaky, good wings as well. read more

Woman on the phone was rude, pizza was terrible. With other great options near by, won't be ordering again.

Just spent $70 on a delivery that never came. Owner told me it was delivered and never wasn't. Total rip-off, rude owner, never order here.

Stick to the Pizza only if you are stuck with the low blood sugar shakes. Everything else on the menu is junk made by the well-intended but clueless. I am being kind here. Don't believe me? Go order a Philly Cheese, all bread no meat, then, go out to dinner before your movie at Roberts' Cinema! read more

I've ate here for lunch a few times, but the funny part about it is I already forgot about it. That's the best way to describe the pizza. Decent enough for me to return, but forgettable enough for me to not go into much detail. 3 stars, that's the review. read more

I've been ordering pepperoni pizzas from this joint for years. The pies have consistently been well done. I haven't tried anything else on the menu but have heard good things. The staff is friendly and the regulars give the place a hangout vibe. read more

Love their grandmothers pizza. Great lunch specials and a variety of pizza styles. Staff are always friendly.

The best pizza around. Hands down. And I am an obnoxious pizza snob. The wings are amazing too. Little secret (order the potato pizza...I know it sounds weird, but it is legendary...shhhh) read more

This pizza restaurant is local, delivers, makes a great pie and more. Sometimes I'm am a bit less than happy with new staff. I'm sure the owner can feel the same way too These are our kids and they are working. There are no other short cuts on quality. They have been in business longer, at the Hickory Tree, than most. That says a good bit read more

Good food, large portions and great prices! Very nice staff!!! If I am ever back in town i would come back!

I lived on the daily special back in college...and now I miss it. Best Pizza Ever.

Very friendly staff, good pizza, and everything else I've tried has been good. They only take cash, but believe it or not, the first time I ordered and asked to use a credit card because I didn't have cash, they delivered anyway and just said I could pay them back next time! Awesome! Fri & Sat nights can be be busy, so don't expect a quick delivery, but I'm sure the delays are due to the popularity. And they're always accurate on how long it will take, even if it will be almost an hour. Try the buffalo cheese fries - an interesting and tasty take on jersey diner disco fries. One of the top delivery places in the chatham area. read more

You guys have lost my business for sure!! When the default lasagna is cheese only!! Give me a F..ng break!!

I went here today mostly because jersey mikes line was too long and I didn't feel like waiting for a sub so I decided to get two slices of pizza to go. I work about 5 mins from here. I ordered the two slices and they gave them to me at first on a paper plate, but then I pointed out that it was to go. The girl at the counter starts trying to shove my two slices of pizza into a paper bag, and when I ask for a box instead the guy in the back was like "we don't give boxes for only two slices". Ok? Like they would have fit well in a personal pizza box. How cheap can you be? So by the time I got back to work with my bagged pizza, the grease had leaked through the paper bag and onto my seat. The cheese had stuck to the inside of the bag. Why is it so hard to give someone a box? It sucks because the pizza wasn't bad. But I will never go back. What a bunch of cheapos. read more