This pizzeria is now open by new owners. The classic pan pizza is fantastic. You need to give this place a try. You will love it! read more

My partner grew up going to Florham Park Pizza, so when were in the area around Christmas time, we had to stop by! They've been under new ownership for the last few years, so it's not the same as what he grew up with, but it's a classic, casual, nostalgic, NJ pizzeria and it totally hit the spot for us. The manager who assisted was was cheerful and patient...with us and with all of the other customers that walked in. Keep her around! They offer a ton of pizza options. We ended up ordering: -slice of drunk grandma (thinner, crisper crust) -slice of traditional grandma -chicken cheese roll We dined in so our items were reheated in the oven, and then brought to our table...we enjoyed all the warm, melty, cheesy goodness. Loved every bite! If we find ourselves in the area again, we'll definitely get pizza from them again. Thanks! read more

See all

I was on way home other day and was starving and craving pizza so i figured i would stop by FP pizza since i am local and its been a while since i had their pizza I just went with a regular Sicilian and cheese slice bc thats how i like my pizza. Nothing fancy It did the job! Regular jersey pizza read more

Florham Park Pizza - Shrimp Marinara. shrimp parmigiana and eggplant Parmesan - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

See all

Would be nice if they had a website and menu.. wanted to see what they had! Ended up going to Nonna's! Always great!

I popped in and was pleasantly surprised by the variety of slices offered. You want chicken marsala on a slice? They've got it. You want ham and pineapple? They've got it. You want mushroom, caviar, sushi roll with onions? They don't have it and you should probably reevaluate some of your life decisions. I was greeted as soon as I walked in the door and the woman behind the counter was available to answer any of my questions. The Chicken Parm slice was well cooked and a good sized sample. It wasn't too thin or crispy and definitely hit the spot. It was $4.80 which is the going rate in the area. The dining area has a full booth, two partial booths and two tables with four chairs apiece. There was soft music playing in the background and it wasn't too loud. The next time I need a slice with 4-5 different kind of vegetables, I'm coming here. read more

Florham Park Pizza - Chicken parm slice - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

My family ordered tonight for the 2nd time from the new owners. Unfortunately we were once again disappointed. While the staff was very friendly and nice, the food was not up to Florham Park Pizza's usual standards. We ordered a Sicilian pie. It was huge, which is great, but it was so big the cheese was touching the top of the box and when we opened it, a lot of the cheese came off. We also ordered the chicken and eggplant rolls. The bottoms were burnt. I hope they are able to improve in the future. read more

See all

Ordered a cheese pizza this week. Wasn't very good. We prefer Italian Village in Madison. We will not order from FP Pizza again. read more

We aren't from the area but made a stop here while in town. Walked in about an hour before closing. Staff was awesome as we were hungry and looking for some good pizza and garlic knots. We placed our order and they kindly threw in a few other things to try. Stop in and support this biz if you are in the area. You won't be disappointed! read more

Florham Park Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

Weekly staple in our house. Grandma's drunken pie and chicken Caesar salad are the best around. Service is great, super friendly and they offer delivery as well. read more

Very good and typical NJ pizza. If you're from the area, the pizza is a cross between Godfather and Nonna. It's got the crust of Godfather (just not as dense), but the tomato sauce is a little brighter like Nonna. So, less filling and tastes great. But the big draw for us is the wings. They do Buffalo chicken wings like the way they used to be in the 90s. Remember how originally Buffalo wings in New Jersey were just the chicken wings with the skin and the Buffalo sauce, without all that stupid heavy flower batter and breading like they do at Godfather and Nonna? I don't know why restaurants use all that heavy flour and batter and breading on the wings. This place does wings the way they used to be, which for us is a huge selling point. The Caesar salad sucks, however. The dressing is awful. And the lettuce is not really restaurant quality, more like high school cafeteria quality. Maybe middle school. The dressing doesn't even taste like Caesar. I don't know what it tastes like actually. I've never licked mayonnaise off the floor and Stop & Shop but that could be it. That's okay because we just order dressing on the side and then throw it out when it gets here and replace it with bottled dressing from the refrigerator. Chicks. read more

Talk about a family-run business. While I waited for my slice to heat, an older Italian-speaking gentleman shouted back and forth with the pizzaiolo, with a well-worn tone. The vibe in here is almost excessively casual. I wouldn't mind a refreshed, less drab interior. That said, the Buffalo chicken pizza was one of the best examples I've ever had. Instead of veering into overly hot, it had a lengthy and satisfying profile. The pizza was served hot enough that I initially couldn't hold it, but it was worth the wait. You could do worse than to stop here. read more

See all

I was there last time 2 years ago, however, I came back and it is a completely new and delicious menu the delivery option is very convenient for the days when you don't want to go out read more

Amazing slices of pieces and unbelievably priced. $8.50 for two slices of pizza, you can't go wrong. I'm so happy I found this place by accident, the pizza definitely hit the spot. read more

See all

There are lots of choices for pizza in the Florham Park area and I've been to most of them. To me, Florham Park Pizza is the best in town. Is it a big place with a fancy dining room? No...it's a small old school place which just makes awesome pizza! It's been a couple of years since I'd been here, and not only hasn't it changed, but the pizza was better than I even remembered. I ordered a delicious slice of the square grandma. The crust and the taste was perfect. Really enjoyed sitting here eating pizza with a Coke! read more

Florham Park Pizza - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

See all

The new owners have some big shoes to fill as FP Pizza had a very loyal following for literally decades. I finally made my first order and they knocked it out of the park ! The location has been known for its amazing Grandma Pie. The best I've had having tried it at at least 20 places over the years. I was a little nervous to see how'd they would do with it. We ordered one of those plus a chicken parm sub. The Grandma was awesome! Tremendous flavor from the sauce and fresh basil. Just enough cheese . That will continue to be a "go to" for me. Chicken parm hero was excellent as well too. People say it's a hard item to screw up. Believe me - I've had some abysmal versions! It was "just right" in ingredient proportions. Loved that the bread was soft enough . Good luck to the new owners. You're off to a great start ! read more

Stopped in after the 4th of July parade. Great slices, great service, and great pricing! Will come back

On the plus side, the pizza is good. On the minus side, no one cooking wears either hats (ie., hair covering) or gloves. Also, the tables are only infrequently wiped down. Usually, a customer would have to make a request to have their table wiped before sitting down. This is true even when they're not busy and just standing around. Plenty of Spanish music playing in the background if that's your thing. This makes the ambiance interesting. read more

Great NJ style pizza. My nephew was visiting from Chicago and wanted some New Jersey pizza. He really liked Florham Park pizzeria. Very friendly service. read more

Was overcharged...told Id be refunded via credit that night as they could not refund me on the spot. 3 weeks later and several phone calls and false promises, still have not been refunded... read more

The Buffalo chicken pizza was very good. You have to ask for ranch to be put on it though. Attached is a picture. It was pretty busy with pickup orders for a Thursday night. I think they are known for their grandma slice so I want to try that next. read more

Florham Park Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

Great pizza with on time delivery and friendly staff. I would recommend this pace!!! Love the grandmas pie

At Florham Park Pizza they're dishing out some of the best Pizza A-round. With a crispy crust that's slightly thin but still hearty enough to hold everything together and topped with a very tasty flavorful blend of cheese. But to Me it's all about this dynamically outstanding old world style sauce, Bravissimo!!             We sometimes order from FPP for work functions, get togethers, and pizza parties and they always leave a lasting impression on everyone's satisfaction level as well as our bellies. I'll stop in for lunch whenever I get the chance to grab a slice or two and I can never say enough good things.    It's always interesting to see how different places adapt [or don't] to all this Covid Craziness and here they got it all down pat. Masks on everyone. Sanitizer at the ready. Nobody gets within 8 feet of the counter and they have a guy behind a set of tables where customers order and pick up from. You give the guy the money he hands You the Pizza and Baddabing Baddaboom You're on Your Way!! Come And Get Your Munch On!! read more

Florham Park Pizza - Delicious Margherita Slice, Named After Queen Margherita, She Must've Really ROCKED!! ;D - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

See all

We were so sad to hear the original owners of FP pizza sold. However we tried the "new" FP pizza tonight and it was fantastic! So many yummy kinds of pizza and the staff is happy to explain them all. We loved it. Yummy!!! read more

One certainty about life is that change is inevitable. Lived in town for 25-30 years and looks to be an end of an era. Everything points to the fact that there has been an ownership change at Florham Park Pizza. Thanks to Mussolino family for the great food and passion they brought to the community. They cared about the town and their customers. From a food perspective, I saw a massive drop in the taste and quality of the sandwich I ordered. Want to be fair as could be learning curve. Different bread...tasteless. Eggplant parm had no sauce. Why change the food so fast as shock customers? I wasn't aware I was ordering a completely different sandwich. Can't you say "Heads up, we changed it up?" Good luck to new owners. There's a high bar that was established on many levels at FP Pizza. Wish you success with your new business. read more

Pizza was good, and the folks behind the counter were very nice! The slice pies were a little old looking, but the sicilian slice reheated well. The fresh pies coming out of the oven looked very good. read more

Florham Park Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

See all

We stopped in here on Saturday for a couple of meatball parm subs to go. They told us we could sit outside and they would bring them out to us. While we didn't eat there, the patio area is a nice place to eat outdoors. I highly recommend this place - food is excellent and service is with a smile. Everyone was masked!!! read more

The pizza here is absolutely delicious, with a perfect crust and generous toppings. The staff are friendly and the service is quick. Very clean . The cozy atmosphere makes you to feel comfortable. You must try this place. read more

The Pizza is perfect it tasted so good! I have tried so many things from there everything tested so good/fresh. I especially recommend trying the different slices of pizza that they make every day fresh.HUGE SLICES, BEST PRICES.... If you're looking for fresh, delicious food go to Florham Park Pizza. read more

Outstanding pizza. Good balance of superb sauce, top rate cheeses, and thin (but not too thin) crust, like the best of the best Rays in NYC. Absolutely delicious (photogenic too)! Have had the cheese and the white pizzas. Friendly, prompt service. Ample parking: is part of a very attractive strip mall. Has outdoor tables with chairs and umbrellas for shade. (Don't know if this will continue during the winter.) My waistline permitting and when I'm in the area, I'll partake again and again. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas for take out tonight - the Margherita pizza was very good but the Veggie pizza was awful! The veggies were cut up so small it almost looked like they were pureed and the entire pizza was very soggy. This was the first time here after the change in ownership and we were disappointed. I will more than likely give it another chance but with veggie pizzas being one of our favorites, we can only hope this was a "one off". read more

Friendly staff. Can get a little busy at Lunch Time so best to order ahead. The Sicilian pizza is really great.

A standard in Florham Park. Good, consistent food, and ur bound to run into someone from town while in there. :)

we used to order from FP Pizza often. The last time they got our order completely wrong (wanted a cheese pizza with broccoli and a turkey sub dry (no mayo, no oil, no vinegar, no onions). we got a white ricotta cheese pizza with broccoli and a turkey sub with mayo, oil, vinegar and onions. I called back and they said they would send a new pizza and sub right away, which they did. when it came, all the cheese from the pizza was in the corner of the box not on the pizza. I sent it back as well as the first sub and pizza. they said they would credit my Visa card. I never got a credit. I don't know what's going on with this place, it used to be good. the past three times, not so much and this last event put an end to them for us. I also asked my friends and they agreed, they're not going to FP pizza any more. What a shame. Time to sell or step up your game! read more

Fast, safe and courteous. Ordered a few slices for lunch. It was delicious. Plenty of parking and nice outdoor seating. Try it out. You won't be disappointed. read more

Florham Park Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

Stumbled upon this place one afternoon, and I have to say it's probably the best pizza I've ever had. Let me tell you, I've had a lot of pizza! I usually get the barbecue chicken although I've also gotten the buffalo chicken which is equally great. I would definitely recommend this place and I make sure to stop by every time I'm in the area. read more

Stop here on my lunch break and ordered 2 grandma's slices, can't believe this whole time I was missing out, this place has the best pizza in the area!!! and I've tried almost all of them, it may not be as big and fancy as some of the pizzerias in the area but they have the tastiest pizza, good quality ingredients, with the most pleasant ppl behind the counter. read more

A small shop in the strip mall, they were voted at once point the best pizza in the area (on their chalkboard), and they served up a delicious ranch chicken bacon slice and a pretty decent mushroom pepperoni (the mushrooms weren't the plain kind, either, they tasted like they'd added some pepper and marinade). Quick and simple place to grab a slice to get in and out. They are, as Chow C. noted, a bit more pricey than some of the other local joints, though. Credit card accepted if over $10. read more

I love their penne pasta with vodka sauce. Great service every time. Great outdoor. read more

Florham Park Pizza - Is the bomb. - Pizza Near Me - Florham Park, New Jersey

Come here for pizza every Friday! They always have great pizza and great service! My personal favorite pies are margarita and bbq chicken but their plain pies are still the best around. Highly recommend! read more

Ordered for our office for lunch. Picked up order and realized when we got to the office that one salad ($10.50) was missing but we had an extra entree ($15.50). Called and they agreed it was their mistake and they charged us for the more expensive entree, tried to get us to just keep the entree instead of our ordered salad. Finally agreed to send the salad and they insisted that they needed to take back the other entree, fine. They dropped off the salad and never picked up the other entree. Amount charged to our card in no way matches prices on line or prices in print menu. Looks like we were overcharged almost $20. Called back again , they say the print menu prices are wrong on line is correct but still does not add up to what we were charged. Finally got my extremely soggy Caesar salad with bone dry grilled chicken. read more