Such a great experience ! Always starts with the server ... Catherine D was absolutely amazing for the whole evening . Such a pleasant person and gets totally connected with her patrons. Appetizers were fantastic .. we split crab cakes and shrimp cocktail . Over the top. Bread and butter were delish too. Lobster Mac and cheese was a special and it was amazing . My wife had the 6 Oz filet and it was perfectly cooked. I ordered the Iberico pork chop and it was amazing with all the flavors and accompaniments . We had a private booth so loved the quietness and the ability to talk . Great experience ! Did I mention that Catherine D was great ? We loved it and it was our second time back . It will be our special place for future intimate events . Love the dark wood and decor. Reminds us of another place but different read more

See all

So glad we tried this place. So my only complaint was it was a bit loud (music) and cold. But that aside the staff was great and our waiter was awesome. The wife was super happy with his suggestion and the seabass and the ribeye wasn't too shabby. I feel the sprouts were the better side but everything here was great. Hoping we can come back again soon! read more

See all

Speakeasy vibe. Definitely wouldn't of found this place if I wasn't specifically looking for it. You take stairs down to a basement. Loved the atmosphere of the chandeliers and the antique glassware on the shelves. Our waitress Naomi was amazing. She was so friendly and personable. The food was delicious. Definitely recommend the beef tartar, and key lime. read more

Hemingway - Key lime - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

5 stars for the food, but 6 stars for the staff. Professional, attentive, and expertly trained. They know the menu inside and out and make excellent recommendations. If you want to see what top-tier Tulsa hospitality looks like, this is the place. Special thanks to the team for making our night memorable! read more

Nice atmosphere, great service, average overpriced food. Small dining tables. $18 margaritas. Burned Brussels sprouts. Terrible beer battered onion rings (Sonic's are better). Pork belly was all fat (Roosevelt's much better). Shrimp cocktail 10 pieces for $30..... read more

Had my dinner here for my birthday the other night. Parking can be validated with the hostess/host (remember your license plate!). My first reaction after stepping into Hemingway was, wow, I love this speakeasy vibe. The main door is not obvious in an alley way, which led to a basement filled with beautiful wood and dark sexy vibes. 5/5 Wife had a cocktail that was strange, but pretty good! You could tell the bartender was talented. They started us off with bread and butter. My god, the butter was unexpectedly amazing. They mixed garlic and Parmigiano Reggiano into the butter and it was perfect with the bread! Note that if you are a ribeye kind of person like me, your only option is the tomahawk, which wasn't what I wanted so I ordered the dry-aged bone-in strip and shared a few different sides with the wife. The strip was on the smaller side but cooked perfectly. The seasoning was decent and overall a delicious piece of steak. The sides were served family-style and we ordered the corn, creamed spinach, and potatoes. The corn was a smash - fresh off the cobbs, the jalapenos offered a nice kick and the tangy tajin was the cherry on top. So good. The creamed spinach was good. Often times, restaurants can be heavy on the cheese, but not this one. Hemingway's tasted lighter and very nutmeg-forward so if you don't like nutmeg, I wouldn't order this dish. The potatoes were good. I don't have much to comment on it other than it goes well with steaks. Food 4.5/5 We had terrific service (thank you, Emily)! Our waters were always filled, and napkins were folded when we stepped away from the table. For a high-end steakhouse like this, I expected no less. Overall, we had a great time at Hemingway and would certainly dine here again. read more

Hemingway - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

we had gone a couple days ago and were served the most brilliant crab cakes. The missus quite enjoyed them. service was utterly divine. though, we may need to freshen some lettuce read more

Our first time! Love the atmosphere, service and food! Already planning our next trip! read more

Hemingway - NY strip Oscar , truffle mash, Blackberry Salmon - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Wonderful dining experience for my husbands birthday! Felt like a speakeasy upon entering with the entry being on the side of the building; dim lighting with elegant decor inside. The steak was cooked perfectly. All the sides were delicious. The staff was attentive and friendly. No special item (like dessert) for a birthday celebration here though. read more

See all

Very small venue in a basement. Beautiful setting and restaurant. The entrance is hard to find, and it is on the side of the building. The address is a suggestion. Parking is validated. The service was outstanding! We had a party of 7. They don't have many tables therefore you really need to make a reservation. They can only handle a maximum party of 12, and there are only a limited number of tables and booths. You also need to make a reservation early because they fill up quick. We had the seafood tower (outstanding) and a variety of fish and steak. Limited menu options on choices but everything was phenomenal. We had a bunch of sides which are shared with the table. Carrots, corn, potatoes, Mac & cheese. Drinks were good, nothing top shelf or special. Absolutely a must visit for any special occasion. Realizing that they are $$$$ pricy. It will be $200+ per person easy. read more

See all

Hemingway is a favorite of mine. The food is delicious everytime I've been. Service is impeccable. The atmosphere is gorgeous. I've been to a lot of restaurants and Hemingway is beautifully decorated, from the crystal chandeliers, the seating, the dark wood, it makes you feel as if you've been transported to a different time. Highly recommended! read more

For my birthday dinner, my husband took me to Hemingway. We had reservations and were greeted by the host upon entering. We gave him our license plate number for parking and were walked to our table. A waiter came by with water, then our waitress arrived with fresh baked bread and butter. She gave us a minute to look over the drink menu. My husband had one of their bourbon cocktails and I had a glass of Merlot. We ordered crab cakes for an appetizer and asked about specials. Shortly after finishing our appetizer, we ordered our entrees. I had the New York strip and my husband had the filet. Both were cooked perfectly! We shared the creamed spinach and the potatoes au gratin for sides. Very good! We couldn't finish it all so the waitress boxed it up for us. I will say that we had previously been to this establishment about a year and a half ago and had a different server (which really made a difference). Our waitress this time was good, but not outstanding like the previous one. It really makes a difference when you are in an upscale environment as this. (For example, this time we inquired about specials and the last time we were told the specials.) And even though on this visit the waitress asked if we were celebrating an occasion, in which I told her it was a birthday dinner. I think she forgot because she never mentioned "happy birthday" or made an acknowledgment before we paid the bill & left. We will still return because we love the food and atmosphere. read more

See all

The ambiance is perfect for a date. Love the upscale speakeasy vibe. Everything is well thought out and decorated. Definitely a 5 star experience- everything you expect from fine dining. The ribeye was great and I added the bone marrow butter escort. My husband had a filet with the gochujang butter and enjoyed it. The Mac and cheese was good- white cheddar and shells. The truffle mashed potatoes were excellent. For my husband's birthday we ordered a la petite mort and it came with a sparkler, which was very cool. The service was top-notch. Not a single complaint read more

For starters, I have been trying to make reservations here on and off for two years. Every time I call, I am always told that it is a 3 week waitlist. I don't know what I'm doing an hour from now so that always made it difficult. The other night I decided that I was going to go in and try and get a seat at the bar. Lo and behold, they had an open spot for me at a later time at 8:30 which I was cool with...and this happened on Mother's Day weekend, so I was shocked. I can't say enough how cool this place is. It has an awesome atmosphere; dimly lit tables surrounded by a wall of wines... it was really cool, not to mention it is downstairs in a speak easy style setting. For the atmosphere I would give 5 stars. The service was great and had no complaints there whatsoever. We were greeted in a timely manner et and started out with drinks and an appetizer. The service would be given 5 stars. Moving on to the food. As stated before, we started off with the Arancini. I knew that I was at a really nice restaurant and was expecting to drop some money, so that is what I did. The Arancini was $16!!! Now I will say this... it honestly was the best that I ever had. I couldn't ask for anything better, but the down side was that it only came with 3. In my opinion, 3 is an odd number to share, but regardless these were amazing! I ordered my self a dry aged 16oz ribeye while the wife ordered the 4 oz filet. With shared sides, we ordered the charred Brussels sprouts and the Mac and cheese. Breakdown of each item below. Bread and butter- you will receive bread and butter upon arrival...the butter is Awesome!!!!!! I even took some home with me. Charred Brussel Sprouts- probably my favorite part of the main course. They were extremely charred, buttered down, and seasoned nicely. Definitely a must if you go. Mac and cheese- it was good, but not my favorite. The Mac and cheese is done with a roux which was pretty good, but I was hoping for something a little better, this is just personal preference here. 4 oz filet- ordered and presented at the requested cooked level. Nice char on the outside, nice flavor, but not overly impressive. 16 oz dry aged ribeye- I was really hoping for this thing to blow me away, however it fell very short of my expectations. It had a nice outer char. It was ordered and presented at the same cook level, decently seasoned, but it was not a tender piece of meat that I was hoping for. I am a person that generally eats the entire steak fat and all, but I was unable to do so with this piece. Beer- I love beer and love almost all kinds. I ordered a special made beer from cabin boys that is exclusive to Hemingway. This beer was strong, but I wasn't crazy about the profile. If you're looking to spend a cool $25 on this large bottle of beer and get a nice buzz, this is it. Overall, I had a great experience, but I did not believe it was worth the hype that I was hoping. I may go back in the future, but this is not a place that I will be frequently attending. Enjoy the pics below. read more

See all

Loved everything about this place! Food was amazing. Great menu. Atmosphere- just fabulous- Beautiful, classy, eclectic... all of the things you want for a night out! read more

10/10! My sorority sisters and I had dinner here while we were in town for a conference. They accommodated less than 24hr reservation easily and used a system I was already familiar with. We were greeted promptly and sat. Our server was Arthur and he was everything. Personable, knowledgeable about the menu and attentive. We had the shrimp cocktail appetizer and then I ordered the filet and spilt mac and cheese and Brussel sprouts with LS. I asked for a French 95 and Arthur hooked it up. It was so freaking good. My steak was cooked perfectly and the sides were amazing as well. We took pictures afterwards and the staff actually recommended areas that would be best to take them in. If you have a chance, go! read more

See all

I heard about this place and had the bf make reservations in advance, as you need to. Parking and entry was simple. The entry is stairs so not mobility friendly (is an elevator but broke). The stairs are decorated beautifully though. At the end is the host and no seating while you wait. We were sat immediately and provided water and sourdough bread. We had a server in training who was the bartender. He was knowledgeable and provided excellent service. We ordered the devils on horseback appetizer. Think bacon wrapped dates but elevated. Highly recommend. My boyfriend got the filet mignon and really liked it. I took a bite and was a bit jealous. It came with an entire garlic in which we devoured. I ordered the braised beef. Think "not your mommas pot roast". Meat was incredibly flavorful and fell apart touching it with fork; no knife needed. The potato were yummy but favorite part was crunchy peas and broccolini. We opted for no dessert and no potatoes since we had a late lunch. *Friend raved about potatoes. We'll just have to come back for those items. Highly recommend for a date night. Oh! The drinks were on point! read more

See all

Best waiter we have ever had. So courteous and kind. Food was excellent and the atmosphere is very welcoming. We enjoyed our meal and will definitely return. read more

See all

The food was excellent but the price is quite high. The price factor inevitably correlates with how critical i will be on the review. No complaints on service! They are experts in their field. Very friendly, attentive, respectful and helpful. All things desired with service. The Ambiance is cozy with a splash of posh! It is not overly dark but has the right amount of ambient light to create an intimate dinner setting. The food is well above average, my favorite was the sea food tower. Everything about it was excellent! The lobster soup was great, I liked more than the French onion, which was also very good. If I had one complaint, I would offer, not to get the tomahawk steak. Rather, opt for a different steak, all of which were very good. The tomahawk just lacked a crust and flavor profile that should be desired with any steak. Being the most expensive listed item on the menu, order a different steak and you will be pleased. read more

See all

Best steak house in town, great service and really first class dinning. Get the wedge salad for sure. Loved the wait staff, this is my new fav. read more

Everything was top tier. Definitely worth the money! We went for our anniversary. Our server was very kind. The food was absolutely delicious! It is also a beautiful restaurant! read more

Hemingway - Steak, carrots, Chilean sea bass - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Food:10/10. Everything thing here is perfect The type of place i don't tell my friends about its very special. The service is always excellent and exceeds expectations ticket time is perfect for a place like this. The way Hemingway go's about things is next level and i enjoy that. Ambiance is dark ish and quite perfect for a date or something. All around perfect true 10/10 experience ( also has a skytop bar above the restaurant) Food: 10/10 Service: 10/10 Ambiance: 10/10 read more

My friend and I thought the food and ambiance were both great, service was good. However, we were very disappointed in management and restaurant owners response followed by their lack of response to an issue with an employee. She gave inaccurate advice regarding validated parking for the restaurant. Our car was towed and the restaurant refused to take any responsibility for what happened. read more

It's a beautiful restaurant but I was served the toughest filet and they didn't seem to care. A $300 dollar dinner and I'm taking my steak home to my dog read more

I went there tonight and I was blown away! The atmosphere, the bar service, the food.... All amazing! I sat at the bar and they were so attentive and remembered my name every time they addressed me! I ordered the devils on horseback as my appetizer. It did not disappoint. It was both unique and flavorful! For my main course I had the ribeye. It was cooked to perfection and was so tender. The chimichurri escort was so good...herbalicious!! I also tried the carrots, Brussels sprouts, and hasselback potatoes... all were perfection!! From the bar I had the sangria and it was one of the best I've ever had! All in all, it was a great experience all the way around I would without a doubt recommend this place without hesitation!! Great job Hemingway! Best dinning experience EVER!! read more

See all

This was such a wonderful birthday experience. The cocktails were delicious, steak was excellent, and the rest of the menu allowed for a lot of variety. The sides were family style, which was a fun way to try multiple things. I think this is an excellent place for a special dinner night, just make sure to make a reservation! read more

The ambiance is perfection and the wait staff is definitely on point, it was a great experience all around to include the butter for the table bread! The appetizers were great, salad was awesome and everything was expertly presented, including wine & spirit knowledge but, to my surprise, the filets we ordered (med rare) came out a little overcooked, very thin and looking like sirloins. I feel like, considering how perfect everything else was, the steaks were just a stumble for this trip and I will give them another chance but with HIGH end prices, I expect a perfect steak at the very least. read more

I really wanted to love this place, but it started out with such a weird experience. We were asked for ids to order drinks, which is totally fine (we are almost 40). We were told by the server she would need a manager's approval because our ids (Real ids) were expired by a couple of months. She came back to let us know she would "let it slide" and put our drinks in since we were "so far past 21", and then were lectured a bit about getting them renewed. All of that started out the night on a strange note. The ambience was really nice and the food ranged from good to great. The arancini and crab cake appetizers were great, we loved the scallops, filet and lobster were a bit overcooked, and the sides were good (potatoes au gratin, corn, and mac and cheese). Overall, we probably wouldn't go again, but it was worth a try. read more

Steak was sub par and overcooked Service was outstanding Overpriced for the quality Parking is difficult read more

Great food, great atmosphere definitely gives you more of a speakeasy feeling. I had the steak. It was very good great wine selection and you could also have a great burger there without breaking the bank. read more

The service was impeccable. From the beginning of calling to see if there was a spot at the bar, and being answered promptly , showing up and having the Young sweet Maitre de ask if I was the woman who called. He then asked me if I needed a validated parking. I informed him that I parked in the lot across the street behind Roosevelts but didn't know I had to pay. He asked for my rental car key and he went out to a kiosk and validated it. That's excellent service. Parker, the bartender was amazing. I asked for a non-alcohol cosmopolitan and he made me a delicious drink. I had the 6 ounce filet mignon that I thought was average, I thought it was not very tender. But I the foie gras on top was absolutely delicious. I would return for the service and the foie gras. read more

The atmosphere was perfect for our anniversary. We had our private both. The service was fantastic, Rebecca was our waitress tonight and we couldn't ask for better service. She was attentive to our needs, suggested other dishes along with what we ordered and for our first time here it was needed and delicious. The corn agratin. And the chocolate mousse dessert. The manager AK came to our table and spoke with us personally. Best experience in a long time read more

The Food is outstanding, especially the dry aged 16oz NY Strip, paired with an old fashion. Our waiter frequently checked in with us to ensure our needs were taken care of at all times. It's a wonderful spot to take a partner to from anything like a date night to a proposal! read more

I called several weeks out and got a reservation for our wedding anniversary. I had heard good things about it. It's a small little place down in the basement on Cherry St. Low lighting and awesome ambiance. Service was outstanding. Ordered an old fashioned, excellent. My wife had the moscato, which she also said was great. We split a wedge salad. Even split it was large enough for both of us. Fantastic salad, although strangely topped with an onion ring. As a side we had asparagus. It was perfectly cooked and outstandingly delicious. Then we both had the filet mignon (she had the 4 oz, I had the 8 oz). Both were cooked to perfection. The highlight were the scallops. I've had scallops all over the world and who would have ever thought the absolute best I've ever had would be in Tulsa, OK?! Ended the meal with a cheesecake. It was good although honestly not the best I've ever had. We never had an empty glass, outstanding service as said earlier. We've been to several other similar type restaurants in the area and without naming names, Hemingway tops them. Total bill with gratuity was $240. If you're looking for a special night and great food, then Hemingway is the place to go! read more

See all

It took awhile to get reservation but it was well worth the wait. The atmosphere was perfect for a high end date night. The food was cooked exactly as requested and the server was highly attentive. We ordered the crab cakes, Bone-In Ribeye Oscar Style, King Salmon, carrots, brussel sprouts, and cheesecake. We couldn't have asked for a better experience and we will return. read more

See all

Great job Bret. I met you 25 years ago right after you got bought out and went to Europe for a month. You were a visionary at the time Success, looking for new things that Tulsa could benefit from in the food industry. While you were in Europe, you saw a pub that you thought would look great in Tulsa... you called it Kilkenney's, and then after its success you opened Nola's. Love the voodoo chicken. And now you've hit it out of the park again with the Hemingway. The family and I loved the food and the great customer service. Can't wait to see what you have coming next to Tulsa, Oklahoma. You are truly blessed. read more

Been wanting to try this place for a while. Came for my birthday dinner and it did not disappoint. The staff was lovely and they even gave us tips on where to park so we wouldn't be ticketed. The food, the atmosphere, the people all were excellent! read more

See all

If they didn't include bleu cheese in so many main items, my review would be one star higher. The appetizer I wanted had bleu cheese in it (my family ordered it, and it was strong as I tried it), the only salad available had bleu cheese dressing, and the butter/main spread for all steaks had bleu cheese in it. I was told no on other cheese options. This changes the entire experience if you do not like bleu cheese! The brussel sprouts and asparagus were top notch, better than the other high-end steak restaurants around town. The sweet corn gratin was incredible as well, and I do not usually order corn, but our family ordered a lot to try everything. The tomahawk on special was delicious, but less meat than expected. The waitress told us 4 people could split it. Three of us split it, and each of us only received a couple of small pieces of meat. Everything else was fat. I need to go back and try the filet mignon. The atmosphere is dark and gorgeous with private restrooms. Recommendations are highly recommended. There are two 2-person tables next to the bar that are walk-in, and we were told they are often open if you do not want to wait for a reservation. It's worth trying! read more

I've been wanting to try Hemingway for a while now and decided to celebrate my birthday here this year. We could not have been happier with our experience! Having a birthday 2 days after Valentine's Day always makes reservations tricky but luckily we called far enough in advance to get a table for Saturday night. The staff was very friendly and helpful, our server was wonderful and great with recommendations and suggestions. The food (seafood tower, American Wagyu strip which was a special, corn and mushrooms) was all perfectly cooked/seasoned/presented, and same for the cocktails. The ambiance was perfect, a gorgeous, dimly lit intimate space. We will definitely be back for other special dinners in the future! read more

See all

Great steakhouse. I came in from out of town. I was underdressed in a hoodie and ball cap and I did not have a reservation, but the staff was still extremely friendly. The waitress and service staff were amazing. I shared the perfect tomahawk steak, mushrooms, and brussle sprouts with my son-in-law at the table. We had a couple of amazing artisan drinks. Overall it was a great experience. read more

Hemingway - Tomahawk steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma