It was a bit dark inside and we had to use the lights on our phones to read the menu. The food was excellent. Our waiter was new, his first day "alone" and he did ok. We absolutely love Harry & Izzy's. read more

Our first time at this restaurant was nothing short of impressive. The ambience and the menu offer an upscale experience, without being stuffy. The seating was comfy. The lighting was relaxing. And the food was prepared to perfection. However...the most notable part of the experience, was the service. Upon informing the server of my allergies, she and the manager AND the chef, all worked together to prepare for me a one-of-a-kind meal. The attention to detail for my protection was above and beyond what I have EVER experienced in any other restaurant. Definitely worth the generous tip we left. We will be back again and again...even though it is 3.5 hours from our residence. To the staff, I offer a sincere THANK YOU!!! Bravo!!! read more

We had dinner at Harry & Izzy's on East 82nd Street with some friends. We opted to sit in the outdoor patio to enjoy the great evening. Our waitress was very attentive and paced our meal perfectly. We all had the famous shrimp cocktail with that killer horseradish cocktail sauce and it didn't disappoint. I chose the 14 oz ribeye - well marbled and seasoned to perfection. Everyone enjoyed the setting and food - can't wait to return . read more

See all

Visited Harry & Izzy's during Devour Indy week. It's a great value. For $58 you can get shrimp cocktail, Caesar salad, and a 6 ounce fillet with mashed potatoes If you go on a Monday through Wednesday, you get an additional $10 off your meal. The service was wonderful. Very attentive and our food arrived quickly. It was hot and fresh. The steaks were served to perfection. The dress is upscale casual. You will see men dressed from suits, to business casual, to jeans with a nice pullover. The restaurant is warm and inviting. St. Elmo's, its downtown Sister restaurant, has a dark, moody, old world environment. Harry & Izzys, however, is light and bright. A definite contrast in atmosphere between the two. We love coming here during Devour week. We recommend this restaurant and will definitely be returning again. read more

See all

Nice ambiance, staff were great. I ordered a medium rare by strip, I got a well done. It was good, but it could have been better. At this price point ordering by temperature should not be a novelty. Again, staff were great.... Just disappointed in the main event so to speak. read more

Appointment through Open Table and had lunch with my best friend outside on the covered patio! The weather was great, light breeze, chilled glass of wine and we both ordered the LEGACY lunch special. 2 sliders, filet mignon medium rare, cooked to perfection and so yummy and tender. Heaven!! A salad with ranch dressing, and French fries hot from the fryer( mixed sweet potato & russet) so tasty. I asked for more fresh grated horseradish to add to my creamy sauce! Service was spot on, food served hot, carafe of cold water refilled & center table! Waiter present to our needs but not overly attentive. read more

Had a great time here for NYE. We sat at the bar and watched Ohio State lose to Miami. Up first I had a $16 Espresso Martini. It was made how I like it and would recommend it. Also tried a $15 lemon drop $16 Old Fashioned, and a martini. All of the drinks were very good and made correctly. I started with a $12 French Onion Soup. Very good. Then, I had a $26 Prime Rib sandwich. I enjoyed it a lot. The place cleared out as we got closer to midnight. The food and drinks here seem pretty much exactly the same as St. Elmo in downtown Indy. read more

See all

Came in for dinner with my fiancee and Dad on a Saturday night. The place was fairly busy and we were seated in the back room. Pros - Food was tasty as always. Flavorful, plentiful, and nice size servings - Speed- Our bread (table), soup, and mains were quick and well spread out, so no rushing, but not a lot of waiting - Service was good and friendly. Efficient and timely. - Parking availability was great, as we were able to find plenty of parking at 6p on a Saturday night. - Our Brussels sprouts for the table (shareable side) were AMAZING! Cons - Per usual with other customers, prices were a bit high on certain things, but food was good. (Worth noting- we all got different things to share i.e. pizza, steak, and salmon, and all were cooked/prepped to order.) read more

Harry & Izzy's - Shareable Brussel Sprouts - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Here for St Nick's lodge! This event feels up fast!! It's cute and festive for sure! The experiences just ok. I wasn't wow'd at all. The drinks was just ok and I didn't even finish mine. I tried the Grandma got hangover by a reindeer which I basically boozy hot chocolate. It was mid. Not a fan. My friend ordered the ski lift and was disappointed and ended up sending it back. Overall it's cute but missed the mark on drinks. I loved that they had nice Sherpa blankets on each chair!! It wasn't too cold at all! It's a cute spot to go take some instagram worthy photos! Service is great!! read more

See all

Had such a great experience at Harry & Izzy's! I ordered the pizza and wanted to make a few changes -- and they didn't just accommodate, they were so kind about it. The manager came by personally and made sure everything was exactly how I wanted it, which honestly meant a lot. The pizza came out perfect -- fresh, flavorful, and exactly how I asked for it (rare these days!). The service was top-notch all around -- everyone was friendly, professional, and made me feel genuinely welcomed. It's so nice when a restaurant goes above and beyond to make sure you're happy. Definitely earned a permanent spot on my favorites list! read more

Harry & Izzy's - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Went here for the pop up and dinner and the didn't disappoint. The pop up bar was nicely decorated and the drinks were good. Stephanie was our server for dinner and she didn't disappoint. She was hands down amazing and we will request her every time we go. Although I don't have many pictures because I was amazed with everything it was all chef's kiss hunty! I got the pasta with double shrimp and I thought i was at an Italian restaurant versus a steakhouse. Delicious read more

See all

My daughter loved celebrating her birthday last year at this location that she requested to go again this year. From the moment we walked inside, all of the staff were friendly and made us feel welcomed. We went at 6pm and it wasn't busy yet. The lighting and decorations really set a cozy and inviting mood. Our server Sha'Quia was amazing! She was attentive and so sweet. She even noticed when the potatoes that came out were not the right kind and quickly corrected it. The food and drinks were all so good and it just made my daughter's birthday even more special. It's pricey but it is worth it! read more

See all

My husband and I had an impromptu date night this past Saturday. So, after attending an event in Downtown Indianapolis, we were looking for a place to dine, but we didn't have reservations, and the wait times were over 30 minutes. I checked online and saw that we could get in at this location. I put in a reservation and requested a booth. The weather was mild and slightly rainy, but I noticed the covered patio area and decided that it would be a nice idea to dine outside. While checking in, the hostess greeted us warmly and I noticed someone who appeared to be management on the telephone. I asked about changing our preference to the patio and the hostess assured us that they could make that happen. A ticket printed and the hostess grabbed it, at which time the manager promptly snatched it out of her hand as another ticket printed. I thought that was very rude and unnecessary, but the hostess didn't miss a beat. She lead us to our table and chatted with us on the way, all while maintaining her smile. We were sat and Paul, our server, greeted us and offered us a wine and cocktail menu. We opted for a bottle of Moscato and ordered the famous (or infamous) St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail to share as an appetizer. I swear, the horseradish gets spicier every time. I could only eat one! Then, I ordered the Prime Beef Meatballs as my entree and my husband ordered the Penne Alfredo with lobster meat and sauteed shrimp. The first plate of pasta came out "loosey goosey", like the sauce was super soupy. When Paul came to check on us, we inquired about that and he didn't seem sure as to whether or not that was how it should be served. He went and made the manager aware. The same manager that I'd seen snatching the ticket from the hostess came over and apologized, stating that she'd love to have that remade for him. She somewhat redeemed herself, although I hope that she apologized to the hostess. She also offered him a soup or salad while he waited, which he declined. A few minutes later, a new plate of pasta was presented with a thicker, cheesier sauce. It was garnished with additional parmesan cheese, herbs and lemon zest, something that the first plate had include, but went unnoticed due to the watery river of sauce stealing the show. My meatballs were an appetizer, meant to be shared...and they are massive. I only ate one there and had one each for the next two days as well. We ordered cheesecake to go. We love Harry & Izzy's and normally frequent the downtown location, but this one is much closer to our home, and we will likely return soon. read more

See all

I just stopped in here for a quick happy hour drink while waiting to meet someone nearby. Went straight to the bar and was served right away. Not much else to say since it was a short visit. read more

See all

The famous shrimp cocktail was served buried in the sauce no shrimp showed. One was not deveined. The seafood dish was terrible. The calamari, shrimp and clams were all over cooked. Calamari like rubber bands. Sauce and noodles made it ok. My blue sapphire martini with blue cheese stuffed olives was a mess. The olives were the size of grapes and the blue cheese was smeared all over the olives very unappetizing. Service only ok. We had to spell Ceviche for him, and that was on the special card. Not going back ! read more

My party of four met here for a little annual holiday meet up. This is our second time meeting at H&I. We like the food, service, ambiance, and quality of food. We met on a Sunday after Christmas. The restaurant was still nicely decorated for the holidays. This visit I tried the Legacy lunch combo. It comes with sliders or salmon, soup du jour or salad, and fries or chips. I opted for the chili, salmon filet, and fries. I was warned the chili had a spicy kick, and I was not disappointed. The salmon was seasoned well. It was a nice lunch and I'm sure I'll return again soon. read more

See all

I was at dinner with a colleague, and the whole atmosphere and service were simply outstanding. Harry & Izzy's offers a dining experience that blends classic steakhouse elements with a lively neighborhood atmosphere. The interior is warm and inviting, with dark wood accents, comfortable seating, and soft lighting that creates a relaxed yet energetic ambiance. I enjoyed our servers, and they were knowledgeable about the menu and offered clear recommendations without being pushy. Timing between courses was paced well for conversation, and the team handled special requests courteously. In conclusion, this restaurant stands out as an exceptional choice for both family occasions and business meetings. It's warm, welcoming atmosphere and thoughtfully arranged seating accommodates intimate family gatherings and larger celebrations with equal ease, ensuring guests feel comfortable and engaged. The menu offers a diverse range of dishes that cater to varied tastes and dietary preferences, with high-quality ingredients and consistent presentation that elevate every meal into a memorable experience. For families, attentive service, a relaxed environment, and options for children make celebrations effortless and enjoyable. For business meetings, the restaurant provides a professional ambiance, discreet service, and the flexibility to host private or semi-private tables, enabling focused conversations without interruption. Additionally, the staff's professionalism and ability to manage timing and special requests make event coordination seamless, whether organizing a birthday, anniversary, corporate lunch, or formal dinner. Overall, the combination of excellent cuisine, reliable service, and adaptable spaces positions this restaurant as an outstanding venue that successfully balances the conviviality of family events with the formality required for business gatherings, delivering consistently positive experiences for all types of guests. read more

I really love it here. Top-notch service every time, and the food is always consistent. It's a great spot for lunch or dinner! Huge covered patio. They also have newly revamped lunch combos, which is a nice touch. I came here for lunch recently and tried one of their specials for that day--fresh tomatoes and mozzarella with basil. Yum. Tomato season is my favorite! I completed my lunch with two steak sliders and a Caesar salad. Perfection! read more

See all

Nice restaurant for a casual date with friends, a romantic date, a meet up with family, or just an all around great place to grab a bite to eat. I had dinner with friends for an early birthday celebration and my meal was delicious. I had the shrimp Alfredo add salmon. The Alfredo sauce was creamy and full of flavor and the salmon was cooked to perfection. Our server was attentive and patient dealing with 5 women who kept changing their minds on what they wanted for dinner asking lots of questions. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My husband and I came here twice. The first time I ordered filet mignon sliders on gluten free buns. I ate the filet mignon without the dry buns. The second time, I really enjoyed my Caesar salad, clam chowder and pomegranate sorbet. I asked for no croutons but I found two croutons in my salad and oyster crackers in my soup, which I picked out. We would come here again. read more

Visited this location for a work event (company holiday party). The event held in the covered patio area, which is an "L" shaped patio with a bar at one end. They had about 8-10 beers to choose from, and a list of cocktails available. The food was served buffet style and was a collection of many of their more popular dishes. Obviously the shrimp cocktail was great, but the steak sliders and pizza were very good as well. I had a couple of beers, and an Old Fashioned and all were very good. The waitstaff was friendly and attentive I have been to this location a few times, and I always enjoy the experience and the food. read more

Special occasion dinner, couldn't have gone better. The food was delicious and plated beautifully. Our waiter was attentive, and friendly. The restaurant is top notch without being stuffy. Best filet mignon I have ever had. Cooked perfectly and seasoned deliciously. My first time here and I will be back! read more

See all

St Nicks Lodge holiday pop up bar - a must visit!! The decoration immediately puts you into the Christmas spirit and there's a bunch of drinks to choose from. We had 7 of the different drinks and they were all great!! Chad was an amazing server with great recommendations. read more

See all

THE BIG: Located in the Northside of Indianapolis. Two stories with an outdoor patio. Plenty of parking in the parking lot outside. THE BLACK AND WHITE: I came here for a happy hour event and it did not disappoint. We were seated in the backroom and service was great. Foodwise, you have to try the World Famous St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail. It's an Indy thing and apparently it's just pure horseradish. It did make my eyes water when I had a shrimp. The filet was cooked nice and medium rare with some green beans and mashed potatoes as garnish. The creme brulee had a nice crystallized shell with a creamy sweet interior. THE FINAL BAMBOO: Overall, the restaurant was great. Total damage was around $170 for the filet mignon, shrimp cocktail, glass of wine, soup, and a creme brulee. I'd definitely come back and try some more menu items. read more

See all

Food was good, Service not so much 1st brought my Steak out with soup appetizer they took steak back. Food service was really really slow once it got going. My server although very nice wasn't sure what he was doing. Will I go back , Doubtful Very expensive for what you get. read more

This review pains me just a bit... I was here for a networking book club event. We were placed in a separate room, which was nice. What was odd was that the hostess wouldn't seat us until we had more people, so for a bit we had 6-7 people congregating in the small waiting area between the bar and regular seating. We had 2 servers for a party of 12-14. It was also devour indy. Drinks came out fairly quickly. I strayed from my normal Moscow Mule and tried the liquid love affair (which was delightful). I had initial plans of ordering from devour until salads came out and I just couldn't pass it up. I ordered the burrata and brussel salad adding sirloin. This is where the decline in stars comes. Two of us who got salads (one without any add ons) were the last to get our meals. When I say last, I literally mean everyone had finished their meals. Someone delivering meals apologized for the hold up stating the toaster wasn't working. We had salads. Those who had sandwiches were already finished with their meals at this time. At that point one patron was told that they took 20% off her bill due to the wait. Actually, the 20% was the added gratuity due to the guaranteed tip. Food was great. Overall our service was good, as the servers can't control the speed of the kitchen, but the way the lingering meals were handled was a bit disappointing for a higher end restaurant. read more

This restaurant was one of the best and classiest restaurants I've been to in awhile. I made reservations for this restaurant for my Anniversary and requested a booth. All accommodations was complied with an Anniversary card with the staff signatures. That was the coolest thing ever. I wish I knew the name of the waitress I had because she was very attentive and on point with recommendations. I ended up getting the New York strip steak while my wife got the ribeye. Both pieces of meat was tender with a little bit of pink and well seasoned. After restaurant gave us a slice of cheesecake that my wife and I enjoyed. I plan on visiting this place upon my visit back to Indy. read more

See all

Everything we ate was delicious (shrimp cocktail, tomato soup, grilled salmon with green beans, and scallops with succotash), and the service was efficient and quick. This location is in a strip mall but has the feel of an old-school steakhouse. I didn't take as many photos as usual because I was launched into another sensory dimension after piling way too much of their powerful cocktail sauce onto my first bite of shrimp. (It was excellent but I probably won't do an inter-dimensional travel invoking bite next time.) read more

Harry & Izzy's - Tomato soup - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Harry and Izzy's is always consistently delicious and our last meal was no different. Everyone is so welcoming. From the hostesses, greeters to the waiter. You are always treated as a high value guest and the ambiance just adds to that. Cost is almost exactly what you'd expect. It's a fancy steakhouse and the cost matches that. Nothing abnormal there. However, the food. SO PHENOMENAL! Every dish we had was so good. I really had no complaints. This is our go to date night spot and it should be yours too! read more

See all

The service and food were excellent. It was our anniversary and they had an Anniversary card on the table for us. That was very sweet. We both had the filet mignon and it was so tender and delicious. The green beans and crispy potatoes were wonderful too. The bread they brought out beforehand was so delicious too. And they treated us to dessert which we had the creme brûlée. read more

See all

Came here for our anniversary dinner on one of the less than 5 times my husband and I have been out to dinner without our 15 month old. I booked on open table and indicated that we were celebrating. I heard the waitress who had tables around us asking and offering desserts for celebrations, so I figured ours probably saw that on our reservation since she never asked. I also started hearing the other waitress asking guests if they wanted bread, which ours also never asked, but we did eventually get bread before our main dish. Fast forward, we started out with the calamari. Mediocre but nothing special. The bread we got while we were waiting for our steaks would have been good enough for me; it was very good! I got the ribeye filet and my husband got the ribeye. We were both very disappointed. My filet was cooked to temperature as asked, but it had 0 flavor. It tasted like a Kroger steak that I didn't season. I could taste the occasional char flavor but that was it. My husband's steak was unevenly cooked; part of it cooked correctly, part not but also 0 flavor. For the sides we got Brussel sprouts and the macaroni and cheese. The Brussels were very firm (underdone) and tasted old. The sauce was very vinegar forward and didn't have a pleasant flavor profile. Wouldn't recommend. The macaroni and cheese was the very best part of the meal. cheesy and rich. Yum. Ultimately, we weren't offered a dessert for our anniversary, but asking for it felt wrong. Then when the waitress took our food to box it she stuck her thumb into the macaroni dish instead of grabbing the plate underneath. After receiving the check it was about $175 and neither of us even had a drink. Woof. I don't feel my food was anywhere close to being worth that much. I really wanted to love it and be wowed, but it was lackluster. There are other places around the area at comparable prices that I'd choose to go before visiting again. read more

I was looking forward to enjoying my birthday here recently. My family and I gathered for the discounted three-course weekend menu. I made my reservation, confirmed that the menu still existed, then also sent screenshots to the family of what menu would also be available to choose from directly from this location's website. We were seated promptly but not waited on promptly. While our waitress was kind, our entire night was extremely slow (3.5 hour dinner - yikes - I would have never gone here had I known this). Just getting ice water took over 30 minutes. I asked for the menu I confirmed existed when I previously called in and was told it no longer existed but she would ask the manager since she was told it was my birthday. One manager said no, she asked another, they said yes (which took another 30 minutes). We placed our orders and very nicely said not to rush her or anyone but we had plans to get to after and needed to be out in 90 minutes. She said that was no problem, we'd be out well before then. After ordering, a middle aged women came out and said she was a manager. She accused me of being a liar regarding the menu. I told her when I called and also showed her the website. She accused me of not pulling up the real website then took my cell phone to try to see where I was lying. She made me go step by step over where I found this and kept making nasty comments about me trying to work one over on the restaurant, manipulating the web address (what?!). This encounter lasted about 5 minutes or so and I was absolutely mortified in front of my family. She just stood over me at this table and went on and on and on. It was disgusting. Our food took forever. Honestly everything did. Our nice, older waitress was probably doing her best, she said she was exhausted, and clearly needed help/to not be spread thin. We got our salads but it took another hour for our dinner entrees, which we had to track our waitress down to check on. The manager brought everything out and was still in a very bad mood because we were treated like we should not be there. We ate what we could but the food was so, SO bad. For example, steaks were either raw or well done when we ordered medium rare. Despite trying to eat quickly, we still couldn't get out when we needed to for our next plans. Again we didn't want to rush anyone but never expected to be there more than 2.5 hours with a reservation on an afternoon! Our waitress never checked on our food, never refilled our drinks during entrees, and after asking for our check, she took another 30 minutes to bring it. Upon returning, we were made aware that I should not expect anything free for my birthday (I didn't ask for, expect, or even want anything but yes, you do give free dessert, which is why we heard the table nearby get a birthday dessert and I've been here for birthdays before - always a free dessert). I will never come here again and honestly, this "establishment" should be ashamed for how incredibly downhill they have gone. Clearly I'm not alone in this thinking - check the Indy Foodies FB page - there's been garbage food lately so save your money and go literally anywhere else! read more

Harry & Izzy's - Raw, cold filet slider... - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I wasn't in the mood to cook and we had a gift card to use up. The food and service were really great. Salads were huge. Toasted ravioli portion was a bit small, 3 ravioli. Salmon was cooked well on my salad. Our server did an excellent job keeping tea filled. We even ran into a wonderful server that worked for another company years ago. She was always great. Only complaint or criticism would be the lights just inside hanging above the entry were covered in spider webs and a spider living his best life. Someone may want to take a swiffer duster to those and and relocate him outside. I know when you work in a building you don't notice things other people will like burnt out bulbs and spider webs. But small things can make you wonder what other things go unnoticed. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

First thing I'll say is this place is not cheap, but kinda worth it. This was another recommendation from a coworker I was visiting in Indianapolis. He said we had to try the shrimp cocktail. Apparently everyone else heard the same recommendation because almost every table had it. There is nothing special about the shrimp, but the cocktail part if super good. You'll swear it is 4 parts wasabi to one part cocktail sauce. It's very very good. Definitely try it. I don't remember the name, but I got the steak covered in Pepper. When you see it, it looks like too much pepper, but honest it isn't. The flavor was superb. I sat at the bar and our bartender / waitress was Jenn. She was awesome. Funny, smart, witty, helpful, attentive. I was impressed with her honesty about the menu as well as her knowledge of the menus ( food and drink ). I will say I felt underdressed in my jeans and T-shirt. This place was a level or two classier than I am use to. :) read more

See all

Harry & Izzy's is consistently classy, tasty, friendly, and attractive. The Ahi Tuna on rice noddles was different and good. The French Onion soup is authentic (almost as good as mine). Offering brunch is a great idea. read more

I had to get my fix... the shrimp cocktail! Other high-end steakhouses across the country claim to have "atomic" cocktail sauce, and they are posers serving bland ketchup. Harry & Izzy's and St. Elmo's is the real deal. Excellent service from the bar team of Zach and Caitlyn. Although happy hour is brief, I was able to catch the tail end with a Manhattan. I opted for the meatloaf this eve. It was good with mashed and green beans, but heavy heavy on the salt. I ended up slamming water thru the night. (You could scale back the sodium and still have worthy flavor). See you one more time for another shrimp cocktail before I bail my former home turf of Indy. read more

Harry & Izzy's - Meatloaf. Over-salted. - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Wonderful experience at Harry & Izzy's! We wanted a chill, more casual experience than the full restaurant vibe, so we ate in the bar area! I love that the seating in the bar area is all fair game for walk up (not just the bar top)! The best value on the menu are the filet sliders! At just $6/ea, this is the deal of deals and a great way to experience the wonderment of the quality meat at Harry & Izzy's in a more casual presentation! Pair with the world famous shrimp cocktail, some half wedge salads and a glass of wine and it's a perfect Friday night casual date! As always, the service was top notch, even in the bar area. Ambience was great and this is a more casual and relaxed experience we will replicate several times in the future! read more

See all

My family dined at Harry & Izzy's on the Northside of Indianapolis on Easter Sunday, April 4, 2026. Our server was Michael! He was a true professional and still had time to relate to us and really figure out our likes and dislikes. Great service and great food! Thank you, Harry & Izzy's read more

I had the prime rib sliders very nice Good service attentive Say at the bar had a whiskey from the private selection reasonably priced tasted good it was the wheaten red label read more

Always top shelf at the Northside location. Stopped in for lunch n discovered the have "the best" French onion soup in Indy!! Wow. Ordered the lunch special w 2 super good shrimp cocktail, French onion soup, 2 filet sliders, fries and a Saphire up!!! Excellent as always but I've always ordered the salad instead of the soup. The soup is outstanding! Highly recommend it! read more

Harry & Izzy's - Lunch special - Steakhouses Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana