I had the rainbow cookie and pignoli cookie and they were very delicious! Very fresh! They have a nice seating area as well with a nice wall of fame to look at. Very friendly staff as well. read more

The prices are low, the cakes are small so it's perfect to try a few things. I got the chocolate moose and the only part I enjoyed was the white frosted lining under the chocolate shell. The rest of the cake was stale read more

Fortunato Brothers - Chocolate Mousse Cake - 10-15 People - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

How have I never reviewed this gem of a bakery, they have everything & anything you need to satisfy a sweet tooth. An exhausting amount of Italian cookies & cakes, check, a whole gorgeous section of Gelato, check. Want some coffee or tea or cappuccino..check check check! Just go, you can't go wrong. And everyone is insanely helpful! read more

Fortunato Brothers - Cheese cake - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A true neighborhood spot in a quiet corner open late. After eating various pizza slices in Williamsburg, a lil sweet treat with some coffee was in order. Definitely neighborhood vibes...people inside have been coming here for years, grew up in the area or were like me, transplant wandering in for something sweet. We came specifically for cannolis and coffee. We threw in a rainbow cookie and a pastry filled with delicious cream. I have never been a huge fan of cannolis, however this one was good...I still wasn't a die-hard fan but it was a good cannoli. Loved the rainbow cookie and whatever that other pastry was that was crunch, had Nutella and strawberry with light cream. Delicious iced coffee and friendly service. read more

See all

I really enjoyed this Italian bakery in Brooklyn. One of the more interesting item I got here was their pistachio lobster tail! I don't think I've had that before so I really enjoyed trying out different flavors of classic Italian pastries! read more

Fortunato Brothers - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is my new favorite local spot. I just moved a few blocks away from here and will be coming here probably at least once a week. As a cannoli addict, this place has not disappointed... but the real stars of the show are the rainbow cookies and the lobster tail. I love that there's seating inside so opposed to a grab and go type spot. The service has been iffy at times but generally fine. Will be leaving many many more reviews... read more

See all

What can you say about this local timeless establishment? All Italian delicacies, gelato cookies, cakes, espresso, etc. it's such a treat. I used to come here more often, but I haven't been here in a long time. Parking might be an issue, double parked, and risk. It was worth the risk for the rainbow cookie and pistachio cookie. Yum just looking at the pictures I wanna go back. read more

See all

Delicious pastry, coffee and Italian classics like St. Joseph's pastry. Coffee is delicious as well. read more

We ordered twice through goldbelly. Shipped to florida. Both times the cookies traveled poorly. They were crumbled and were basically melted/disintegrated on arrival. The ones that were somewhat intact tasted very good and there was a nice variety in the box. But overall a waste of money. read more

Stopped in for a few treats on a Sunday afternoon and there was no line. Pistachio lobster tail and pignoli cookie were great. Rainbow cookie and chocolate dipped lace cookie were both sadly meh. You can do better for Italian bakeries in NYC, but it's def worth getting that pistachio lobster tail if you're in the area. 3.5 stars. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My 8 year old loves the cookies from here. we used to come a lot more often when. she was in school near by. I stopped today and hit 1/2 dozen cookies and a cup of chocolate ice cream. The cookies didn't taste as good as a few weeks ago. Maybe it just wasn't a great batch. we still come thou. it's nice inside lots of seats to sit down and a great selection read more

See all

I had passed Fortunato Brothers but never made it in for a visit. However, someone recently told me they had the best rainbow cookies so I had to check it out for myself because I am an avid fan (love me some rainbow cookies!!!). And were they the best? I have to say "YES!". Originally I had asked the sales rep how many cookies could I get for half a pound. When she responded with "6", my thoughts were: "What the...?!". But when I received my bag of cookies, I understood. They were like little monsters! The cookies are double what the size is usually sold in Italian bakeries. But God damn, Fortunato Brothers perfected the ratio of cookie to jam to chocolate! I am floored and I will absolutely be back for more! read more

Lovely family owned Italian bakery. We came here for late night treats and to buy souvenirs for family back home in California. Pros: Gorgeous displays of detailed marzipan sculptures!! Worth coming just to see these Wide variety of sweets / traditional classic cookies (rainbow, honey ball plates, cannolis, nougat cake) and all are beautifully done Cons: A bit pricey but not unexpected for the neighborhood or nyc in general. Have had better pastries elsewhere growing up in a high Italian population area but not complaining since this place was a pretty complete one stop shop read more

See all

We stopped in here after a scalp massage. We ordered at the counter and they brought it out to our table. The marzipan's were beautiful and tasted great, but it was a little bitter. The rainbow cookie lacked jam, but otherwise great texture. The experience here was typical of an Italian bakery. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Rainbow Cookie w/ Cannoli and Marzipan - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

typical old-school italian cafe with lots of goodies! we tried the pistachio lobster tail, pistachio cannoli, rum baba, and hot coffees. the highlight was definitely the lobster tail, so flakey and had lots of pistachio and a just-sweet-enough pastry cream. the cannoli was still pretty crispy and the ricotta filling was great! i've never been a huge fan of rum baba and this one was no exception. it was fine and more of a "me" problem for not liking them lol. overall, really happy to check this place off of my list and will return in the future! read more

See all

This place was amazing in 1996. Now it's awful. The service was unpleasant, the pastries are pretty but taste terrible and the decor has not been updated in past 30 years. I'm not sure how this place is rated any higher than a 1 star. read more

Fortunato Brothers, you rock! Years ago, my cousin packed up her family and moved to Virginia. I'm going to see everyone before heading to my timeshare. She tells me: Billy, can you bring some Italian cookies? And bread! Oh how we miss good New York bread. Now I'm on a mission, where can I zap in, grab the goods and zap out? Fortunato Brothers is my go to, grab the goods and hit the highway. I walk into an empty store. I see rows and rows of Italian baked goods. I'm going to order a few pounds of Italian cookies and I was told bread! They haven't has good Italian bread in years. The bread was still warm when they put it in the bag. The final product? C'mon, it's a Brooklyn Italian bakery! The Sfogliatel was fresh and had a nice crunch. How do I know? I was driving south on I95 and busted open the box of pastries! How could you not, the smell is intoxicating and calling me: Bill S... This is a bakery and not a sit down restaurant, you won't be on your laptop all day sippin' lattes. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Italian Mixed Cookies - 1 Pound - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I ordered a cake for a baptism and was shocked to find it made in red. I had to drive back from Queens after being told it would be corrected. When I got home again, the cake now read "Happy Birthday" with a cross on it, forcing me to make a third trip just to get the order done properly. At no point did anyone apologize or offer to make it right in any way. When I initially posted a review, the owner falsely claimed it wasn't his bakery, despite the fact that I had been a loyal customer for over 20 years. Due to the repeated errors, lack of accountability, and dishonesty, they have lost my business and that of everyone close to me. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Baptism cake - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Along with Veniero's, Fortunato is one of the few remaining classic Italian bakeries in the City outside of South Brooklyn and the Bronx. While I find Veniero's excels primarily at their cakes, like the torta di mandorle and their Italian cheesecake, Fortunato does best at cookies. In particular, their pignoli cookies are the best rendition I've had of this item anywhere, and they also offer a less traditional pistachio cookie that is even better. Note that the gelato is generally worth skipping. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We are big fans of FB. Why wouldn't we pick up additional treats for our baby's second birthday? It was a no brainer for us to grab some treats. We ordered an assortment of desserts that included pistachio cannolis, regular cannolis, rainbow cookies, pistachio cookies, and raspberry cookies. One of the employees gave our daughter a complimentary heart cookie for her birthday. Everything was delish. Especially my favorite pistachio cookies. read more

Fortunato Brothers - 12/16/23 - Assortment Of Deliciousness - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Late night Italian desert shop! Perfect place to grab a desert after a meal and the cannoli didn't disappoint! It didn't blow my mind but how big it was for the price of only $5 seemed really worth it to me. Had a lot of seating as well with a waiter if you wanted to sit down and chat for a bit! read more

Fortunato Brothers - Cannoli - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Their products are good quality but, has decreased in quality I have been a patron since they opened in 1976, but unfortunately has began to go down hill. From service to the products. If i am a client and sit at your establishment o should feel welcomed, but not that i am disturbing what ever you doing. This place was a excellent for aftter dinner place to have desert. Not anymore. read more

Best. Cannolis. Ever. Cream well balanced, not too rich or sweet. Just right. Shell to die for. Basic shell, rolled in delicious toppings. Despite all the calorie carnage on all the great pizza spots in NYC throughout the day, it was absolutely appropriate to finish the day with these amazing cannolis! read more

Fortunato Brothers - Cannolis: Pistachio and chocolate w peanuts - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

A neighborhood staple with a long history. They have maintained quality over the years and continue to keep things interesting. My go-to's are always a cannoli, rainbow cake, and pignoli cookies. Service is quick and kind. A reminder that most things are by the pound. read more

See all

Being an adult means realizing the power you have to not need a special occasion to eat cake! I was badly craving a slice of cake and I hate getting it at the store cause it's always too sweet. Luckily I saw this is in the neighborhood and raced over. I got a red velvet slice and lobster tail, which my friend and I loved. read more

See all

Their pastry and other desserts are delicious however, their service is horrible. The young ladies behind the counter looked miserable and acted as if you were bothering them if you asked a question. No hello, no smile, just annoyed that they were working. Staff clearly needs customer service training. Oh yeah, and my coffee could've been hotter.. read more

Absolutely stunning bakery. Since 1976 they have been churning out delicious baked goods. The store is modest but full of delicious goodies for your next event where treats are essential. Prices are a bit on the higher end ($18.50 per lb for their cookies) but the cookies are totally worth it. What really stands out is their incredible selection of shaped and painted marzipan. All edible but cut into absolutely shapes. I got two strawberries and little banana and it was $9 for the three (I forget what the price per pound was). Friendly staff and quaint ambiance. We will be back!! read more

Fortunato Brothers - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I AM THE FABULOUS BAKER BOY! A prelude to one of the best bakeries Brooklyn, let alone New York City, has to offer. Brilliantly located in Williamsburg, only a five minute walk from the Graham Ave stop on the L train, to stop here will force you to cough up a few pennies. Only you will be happy you did. The pastries are as perfect as they can be. Without me getting too loquacious, there is plenty of rhyme and reason to spend $80 here. There is something for everyone, which beckons the question, WHY DO THEY NOT SELL HAMANTASHEN? Every Italian bakery knows what these cookies are. They are associated with the Jewish holiday of Purim, but can be eaten year round. For those unfamiliar, they are a triangular cookie with a fruit or savory filling inside, usually apricot or raspberry jam, chocolate, or poppyseeds. The name derives from the villainous Haman, of the story of Purim. They taste delicious and can be served in any size. But to not sell these is a pretty big disappointment. At least they serve Linzer tarts and those are delicious. Soft cookie, lightly dusted with sugar, and a smooth raspberry or apricot jam in the middle. Now you know my favorite cookies. Or some of them anyhow. If it were not for a two train subway ride to get here, I would come here regularly and weigh 500 pounds. They also take credit cards, adding more plus to the poundage. If Cuccio's is my #1 bakery in the city, this is easily my #2. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I haven't been here for years since I left Brooklyn, but I wanted to buy my mother cheesecake and other pastries. I ordered strawberry cheesecake, and it wasn't the typical cake. The strawberry looked like it came out of can with sauce, not fresh-cut strawberries on top. The cheesecake didn't even taste like cheesecake. The texture was smooth, but it tasted like it was mixed with too much milk. It was very awful, and I was very surprised because I feel they make the best cheesecake. I had to throw out the other half of it because no one wanted it.The other pastries were cannolis, and they were okay, nothing to brag about. Anyway, next time, I'll buy the cheesecake in Queens instead. read more

Coming here is always a treat and brings me back to my childhood days of coming in here on a hot summer day to enjoy gelato on a brioche bun with my dad. I will never forget the memory of my father and I coming in one summer day to witness an older Italian man order some gelato on a brioche and give out a loud moan of intoxication. Moments later when it was our turn to order, we said we'll have what he is having. I remember like it was yesterday! Many moons later, I am bringing my daughters here to continue the tradition of enjoying good eats and memories together - 10/10 experience. This place will always have a special place in my heart. There is really no wrong choice in things to enjoy here... from gelato, lattes, cookies, and breads. All amazing. Wishing the business continued success! read more

Fortunato Brothers - Almond and coconut gelato within a croissant- absolutely delicious - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I was at this old school Italian Café and Pasticceria/Pastry Shop after going to a dinner a while ago. We ordered a bunch of things and shared a whole lot. To be honest I'm not sure where any of the poor reviews are coming from because everything I had was very good rivaling or exceeding the best Italian spots around me or the famous ones which are much more absurdly priced for similarly good or worse quality. Perhaps people should stick to their Italian/Italian-American offerings instead of the generic American stuff? To drink I had the/Caffè/Coffee Granita which is essentially coffee with very smooth ice. If you want a pick me up and it's in season, order this and you might as well get it in medium or large as the small size is quite tiny. The coffee flavor is strong and it's quite delicious. For pastries we tried a bunch. I got one of the Pignoli to try along with one of the Pistachio Pignoli as well as a Sfogliatella. Yes the general pignoli are just a bit worse than Ferrara's but the latter costs almost $50 a pound if not more compared to the $28 a pound here and it's not twice as good or even close. Very good quality and the pistachio one is a nice touch which isn't found there. I personally prefer the pistachio crusted version at my local spot Monteleone but this was very good. The Sfogliatella was also excellent. I saw another review on here complaining about people trying to pronounce this instead of saying lobster tail but there's actually a distinction. The long stuff you find in spots is said dessert and lobster tails tend to have a stronger sweeter filling instead of having citrus. Rant aside, it was outstanding. Not overly sweet of a filling with a good pastry which had a bit of a crisp and there was plenty of citron to add a bit of bitterness. Would heavily recommend as well and I know sfogliatella quite well. As I'm not commonly in the area, I bought some meringue cookies for the group. These were also outstanding with a good crispy texture and they weren't too sweet. Would heavily recommend the hazelnut one. Another person had the baba rhum which they liked and someone had a fruit tart which they liked as well. Not much to complain about here. The prices were reasonable and the quality of most of the pastries was either very good or outstanding. The staff could have been a bit friendlier but there were a bunch of us who went back to order more and it was pretty late so it was at least partially expected. Would go back if I was in the area. read more

See all

I came back after dinner tonight while in Williamsburg. Hoping to give it another chance... I purchased two of their new cannoli filled rainbow crumb cake. An idea, that they stole from Comfortland in Astoria... already a bad start, $7.50 for both. Not terrible for a little treat. They even gave us a sample of bread, which was generous, but it's end of day... so a great process. The staff are always friendly enough. Unfortunately the pastry is utter garbage. I mean it went straight to the trash. As a Sicilian, it's a-front to the very nature of my culture. Whatever is in this, it tastes like a fridge with heavy mold and fake almond flavoring. It's quite awful, even my partner couldn't stomach it. I really was hoping it was a fluke from my last visit, but I will really not be returning this time. It's unfortunate as there aren't many bakeries like this left in Willamsburg. Do better. read more

Solid 3 star for a local Italian bakery. The service at the counter wasn't really friendly or accommodating when we were asking questions - but the goods were decently flavored. When I asked if a sfogliatelle was pistachio flavored, she gave me a blank stare and said it was a lobster tail - not able to make the correlation that a sfogliatelle was the same word as a lobster tail... These pastries are usually best paired with a side of espresso, tea, or coffee on the side as a tea time goodie. One could also get a box of goodies to bring to a family gathering. Decent place - not the best, but decent. read more

What I like about this Italian bakery is that they have the mini version of the dessert. Perfect for a party or if you want to try a bit of everything without spending a lot of money and consuming a lot of calories. Everything looked very enticing. I had mini sfogliatelle, tiramisu, baba rum cake and a canolo. The sfogliatelle had a nice crunchy shell with nice amount of filling. Tiramisu was moist and soaked with espresso. The mini Baba rum was so adorable in a small container soaked with sweet syrup. They have several flavors of gelato. read more

See all

This is an absolute wonderful place. The cakes, cookies and coffee is a dream. The service is fantastic and I can't wait to visit again.

I enjoyed stopping at this bakery. They had a large selection of different items to order. I tried out three different pastries, and each one was delicious. My favorite was the rainbow coockie cake. But, the cannoli was pretty tasty as well. Overall, this was a nice spot for some late night desserts. read more

See all

The absolute best cakes, pastry and coffee. The owners and staff are great. I highly recommend this bakery.

If you like old fashioned authentic Italian Pastry, this place is the real deal! I love the pistachio cookies! read more

See all

This has been my go to bakery since I was a kid. And let me tell you, they've only gotten better! The pastries and cookies are a mix of old school Italian treats and new creations. The staff is always helpful. And the cafe has such an old school Brooklyn feel to it. read more

Fortunato Brothers - Cappuccino - Small 12 oz Rainbow Cookie w/ Cannoli - Desserts Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Lobster tail was really flavorful with amazing cream to croissant ratio! I wasn't a fan of the rainbow cookie with cannoli cream, but I've never been a rainbow cookie fan. I'm booking forward to coming back and trying their tiramisu! Lots of seating Indoors and outdoors read more

See all