Fay's is one of our favorites. Wonderful welcoming staff, good affordable food, and a great diner atmosphere. They are always busy, so be prepared to wait, especially on Sundays, but we'll worth it. Also, they are cash only, so take that into account...but they have an on-site ATM if you forget. read more

Cozy corner diner specializes in breakfast. We enjoyed our bacon and eggs and I had pancakes too. Parking is on the street and you need to know it's cash only. No cards! read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Cozy corner cafe in a downtown setting. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Always a great spot ... PROS - menu options and super creative pancakes and French toast PLUS order 1,2,or3 - prices for each. Food is tasty and comes out fast. Service is great ... helpful and speedy. Place was hopping on a Sunday AM and they kept is moving. CONS- cash only. All the add-ons ... doubled our bill by adding onions, cheese, whipped cream etc.I would rather have a menu price that leaves room for me to add little things like onions ... and include cheese on my western omelet. That is a turnoff for me ... and will cause me pause before choosing to eat here again ... to be clear though, I'll be back, give me a reason! read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Great place for breakfast just off 81 South. Large variety of breakfast items on the menu and affordable. You know it's gotta be good when there's a waiting line on Sunday morning! Much better option than a fast food breakfast as you travel down the interstate. read more

Had the eggs and potatoes and toast with a pancake nice restaurant in Carlisle Pa and had the corned beef hash

Amazing bfast and lunch spot with hefty portions. The ambiance is old school dinner vibes. The service was swift and attentive. The food was delicious and looking forward to going back. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Great food, good service, and a nice old-school diner feel. This place is very popular and gets packed. We enjoyed our food, standard breakfast fare. I enjoyed my sunny-side eggs, pancakes, bacon, and toast. Their cappuccino is delicious! I highly recommend this local business. read more

The GREAT diner with nostalgic decor. The food offers typical diner food with some extra twists.The pancakes are so yummy. Never had a bad omelet yet. Solid breakfast meals and friendly service. We are New Yorkers and love our diners, so it's nice when we come through PA knowing FAYS won't disappoint and will serve up a great meal. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Dining - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

I'm upgrading my rating based on our last three visits. The French ghost debacle is a thing of the past and I shan't get them again ... our meals have consistently been hot and delicious and served by friendly, smiling gals. The chocolate chip pancakes are loaded with sweet chips and the coffee is good and topped-off frequently. Yum !! read more

See all

A great breakfast and lunch spot in Carlisle. The breakfast skillets are really good, as are the fresh muffins.

Omelets are amazing. Don't get the French toast; it's just bread dipped in pancake batter :b

Great place to eat friendly atmosphere. Will go again. Nice price Will go the next time I am in town read more

I recall my food being very tasty. The french toast was amazing! The Hawaiian Coconut with Pineapple French Toast was worthy of a trip back again and again. read more

Classic breakfast/lunch restaurant. Lots of Coca Cola decals and bottles decorate this place. Cash only. Very friendly staff. Typical breakfast diner foods. Good coffee. Service was fast and very professional. Was here late morning, but i heard about the line that forms earlier in the morning, and on weekends. I would very much recommend Fay's. read more

See all

Our family's favorite breakfast. Scrapple and bacon were perfect. Everything else was really yummy. Thank you Sally and Missy and all the team for a great family outing. read more

We're visiting my son at Dickinson College and tried Fay's Country Kitchen for breakfast. Although there was a line when we arrived, it moved quickly. The people were very friendly and attentive. Sally took great care of us. I had the skillet with bacon and cheese. They both had bacon egg and cheese on bagels with hash browns on the side. They have Coke products and have even decorated in a Coke motif. They take cash or check and have an ATM on site. Really great and highly recommend for delicious food and friendly people. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Special item - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Enjoyed this spot, loved the fact that they have breakfast skillets and their pancakes are very soft and fluffy, we will definitely be back at some point, it does seem very busy during the weekend so i enjoy going on weekdays, again very happy with the food and the service read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Chili eggs and potatoes on a skillet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Always wanted to try this cute little restaurant, and was finally able to a bit ago. Told the waitress our 1st time and she recommended we get the grilled LA cinnamon bread, and it was very good. I went with the meat lovers skillet, which was a great portion and didn't skip on the meat. My boyfriend got the chocolate chip pancakes three nice size pancakes. Can't wait to go back read more

See all

IDK what those negative reviews were about. Great food at low prices. I'd come to Fay's any time I wanted a hearty breakfast.

Place is great! Food is delicious, comes out quick, service is wonderful. Would absolutely go back!

Really good food and nice staff, I have eating in and dashed food from here. The wife gets the BLT and I get the cream chip read more

The breakfast was top quality, splendid service. We love the home town feel of this restaurant. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Decor - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Delicious breakfasts. Everything from standard bacon and eggs to great scrambles and perfect pancakes. Best baked oatmeal! Excellent service in a friendly downtown atmosphere. read more

6 of us stopped by here on Sunday for brunch. It was packed and we waited about 10 minutes. Which wasn't bad considering the crowd. I started with a nice cup of coffee and waters were given. I went with the old world omelette. It has mushrooms, bacon, feta cheese topped with a flavorful red sauce. I also had a side order of Canadian bacon. The serving sizes where big and you could almost split a meal. The food was hot, flavorful and left all of us full. If you find yourself in Carlisle, PA give it a try. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Old World omelette with a side of Canadian bacon. - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

Small Americana restaurant which has good comfort food. The service and ambiance were relaxing and pleasant. We would go back.

First time here finally I got to stop in for a work breakfast, I ordered sausage egg and cheese sandwich with home fries, the place is decorated with a Coca Cola theme very nice. Our server did a awesome job didn't have to wait long to get refills, and food was delivered fast. read more

See all

We were in for the Sprint Car races from out of town and found this spot on Yelp. It did not disappoint! It exceeded my expectations for a diner breakfast... everything we had was tasty. Prices were moderate. If you need a good breakfast plate stop here. read more

Food is excellent. Service is excellent. Atmosphere is excellent. If you like Coca-Cola decor this is a place you will like to see. Bring your cash! They do not take cards. There is an ATM on site. read more

The food is absolutely amazing (highly recommend the pancakes), fast service, and very nice people! 100/10 recommend.

1 minute wait with nice people the people and food couldn't be better. Prices were average read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Western skillet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

if your going to be a cash only business 1)ADVERTISE IT BETTER 2)HAVE A WORKING ATM. just moved to Carlisle and decided to try local businesses around me. ended up being the worst experience would not recommend or come back. read more

Found this place when I was looking to meet a friend for brunch. It had good reviews, so we decided to try it out. It was not far from the highway and had street parking out front. We walked in around 11:00am on a Sunday morning and while it was crowded, we were able to get seated right away. The skillets on the menu are what caught my eye ahead of time. I ordered the Fiesta Skillet (with no mushrooms, pictured below) and it was delicious! It came out in a very hot skillet, as the menu described. We also tried the Bananas Foster French Toast (also pictures below). It was just okay - nothing special. Fay's Country Kitchen allowed us to enjoy a nice meal together before going separate ways! read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Bananas Foster French Toast - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Food is good and prices are great. No problems there. The issue is if you can't do take out right, then don't do it at all. Today is the 2nd time I've called for a take out order. I swore I wouldn't spend my money here again after having the exact same experience about 11/2 years ago. Both times I was told how many minutes until it would be ready. I go there when they said my order would be ready. The first time I stood in the restaurant for 25 additional minutes before getting my order. This time I stood about 10 minutes before getting my order. The point of take out is NOT to wait. Food is ready to go when they told you. Not sure what the issue is, but it won't happen to me again. There are too many other options locally to tolerate this. read more

Every time my family and I visit Carlisle, we make it a point to experience at least one breakfast at Fay's Country Kitchen. There is a lot to love about this little place. Fay's has an extensive list of breakfast items that they serve. From eggs to oatmeal to toast to waffles to breakfast meats and potatoes, if you like it in the morning, Fay's probably serves it. For all of the items on their menu, the most impressive section has to be the pancakes. Fay's offers an amazing array of pancakes. They have their mainstay versions, like blueberry, chocolate chip or banana nut, as well as seasonal varities. As with most things on Fay's menu, a little money goes a long way when we're talking about pancakes. For just a couple dollars you can get two pancakes that are gigantic. About the only thing that will set you back at Fay's is the orange juice. You want orange juice, you are going to pay a lot for a little. Just keep that in mind. Also be aware it is cash only. So why only four stars? Well, my only issue with Fay's is that they don't offer much in the way of vegan food. But, if I'm being honest, what breakfast place in Carlisle does? When it comes to breakfast in Carlisle, there is no place my family and I would rather visit than Fay's. read more

Onion option with your tatos is offered right off the bat, yes, please and thank you. Our waitress was friendly, attentive refilling our beverages and offering hot sauce. A custom order was reframed as the meat lovers skillet which was enjoyed. I had the chipped beef on toast which was a smooth not too thick consistency. The potatoes were not seemingly seasoned but joyful with the griddled onions. Portions were well sized for the price. Sadly they don't make their own corned beef hash. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Meat lovers skillet - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all

Simple food, good wait staff, reminds me of an old diner. Don't forget to bring cash they do not accept plastic

I stopped by Dickinson College last April on my way to Penn State to say hi to friends and enjoy dinner in Carlisle. The next morning, I needed breakfast to energize me for the drive to State College. Everyone recommended Fay's and I didn't have a hard time finding it. I parked, walked in, was seated. Servers (Leilani and Emily) were great to deal with. I ordered one of Fay's breakfast specials (see photos) which had a robust slice of ham from Martin's Meats (from Lancaster, Pennsylvania), eggs, hash browns, and buttery, buttery toast. Not sure if it energized me (I must have had a food coma) but it was ridiculously good. Look at my photos to see how THICK the ham slice was. Highly recommended. read more

See all

Out of town friends wanted to go to Fay's for buckwheat pancakes. They only used to serve corn syrup for pancakes but now can pay an extra $1 for real maple syrup. Menu has not changed much in 20 years. The food is standard diner breakfast. read more

I absolutely LOVE this little place. If you ever are just driving through and want a place to get some breakfast or even a quick lunch, this is the place!! I love the small town feel of it. It's not trying to be fancy or "modern" or anything it's not. It's just a simple restaurant with genuine staff. It does help that I happen to go there every time with my friend who is from Carlisle, so the people are especially nice because they know her. But you get the sense that these people are nice whether or not they know your name. Which by the way, it seems like they know everyone's name there. I LOVE it. The other thing that is amazing about this place is that the prices are super cheap! You can get a great breakfast here for $10 or under. My breakfast was the "breakfast special" and it's literally $7.50. It comes with a small oj but that OJ is hilariously small, so either buy something else or be aware it's not gonna be thirst quenching. The amount of food though is perfect. Honestly there's no other place to grab breakfast than this place. I love love love the vibe of this place. I made sure when we passed through this time we came back for food. See you soon Fays! read more

See all

Good home cooking. Fresh and Tasty. Excellent service. Homey, sunlit interior. Close to the courthouse . What's not to love? Oh... and the coffee is great! Wish I lived closer so I could go often. read more

Fay's Country Kitchen - Breakfast & Brunch Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

See all