Order Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax Takeout or Delivery
Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax Photos
Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax Popular Dishes
FAT SULLY'S NY PIZZA - COLFAX ATMOSPHERE
What's the vibe?
More like Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax
Recommended Reviews - Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
Food: Used to love the pizza here. So large. Such a lot of very good pizza for the money! But definitely NOT today. (And yes, I'm sending that as a shout (out) to the world). On Wednesday I buy my co-workers lunch to talk business. Today, I thought, they'll love a good Sully's salad and a pizza. Have done that many times in the past and they've all loved it. Today, it was still a good salad, but the pizza was absolutely the worst pizza I've had in Denver for decades. Really bad. No dough in the center area of the pizza and the edges were in places so thick they were undercooked and mushy. The "no dough in the center" issue resulted in a pizza so thin in the center 6" that all the pizza was in that area was a perhaps 1/16 of an inch of only burned cheese mixed in with some hardened red sauce. Crunchy to the touch and awful tasting. The pics show the absence of any dough and you could literally see through the pizza where the cheese had burned away leaving empty space. This is a sad story about a once-loved pizza institution in Denver I have frequented for way over 20 years. I'm sorry to tell this story. It may be that with the influx of East High students ordering a single slice at a time and swamping their resources the place just can't handle it any more. But the bottom line is, as my grandmother used to say, "if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen." Sully's, if you're gonna serve that kind of sorry excuse for pizza then give it up and get outta the kitchen! Sign me, David "so sorry to have lost an old friend" M PS They get 2 instead of 1 star because, like I said, the salad was good and the person behind the pickup window was nice.
We went here to eat their pizza. We ordered wings as well. Both the wings and pizza were very good and we felt the pricing was fair. Their sweet tea is hands down the best sweet tea I've ever had! They only let you get one free refill of the tea, but I liked it so much I purchased another one to go. The vibes in the place are good and the staff were all very friendly. If you are in the area and are craving pizza and wings, I recommend checking this place out!
OMG Denver Biscuit Company (also falls under the name of Atomic Cowboy/Fat Sully's) is absolutely fantastic! Their biscuits are some of the butteriest, moistest, flakiest biscuits I've ever had! I'm glad there are a handful of DBC locations throughout the city of Denver so the wealth is well spread. We came here for breakfast and I like that this DBC in particular is housed in the same space as two other restaurants, so that there's food options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and a wide variety of it all as well. Given that it was breakfast though, we all ordered the biscuits and what a hearty breakfast it was! These biscuits are massive - frankly, everything here comes in massive proportions including the largest cinnamon roll I've ever seen! Not only are the biscuits massive, but they're essentially sandwiches and come piled on with a ton of ingredients as well! I ordered the K-Mack biscuit sandwich, which had a Korean spin on all of it. It was Korean fried buttermilk chicken (so tender and flavorful!), toasted sesame seeds, sesame mayo, pickled daikon (the perfect burst of tart freshness - could've done with even more given how heavy all the other ingredients are), shredded cabbage, and green onions. The chicken was perfect, the biscuit was perfect, my belly was wildly happy! On top of it all, I added a side of McHashbrowns because I had to try what these were, given that I do really enjoy the McDonald's hashbrowns. These ended up being some of the best hashbrowns I've ever had. Twice the thickness of a McDonald's hashbrown and in a triangle shape, perfectly crispy on the outside and potato-y on the inside! It was way too much food and easily split into two full meals, but it was so worth it! The giant biscuit cinnamon roll that my friends and I ordered was so good as well. Like I said earlier in this review, it was truly massive and we also added the option of the bacon bits on top because we wanted to try that out. The result was delicious - salty and sweet! And even among the three of us, we couldn't finish the cinnamon roll given that we each had ordered biscuit sandwiches as well. We all ended up taking leftovers home for another meal in addition to not even being hungry by the time dinner rolled around that same day, even after a ton of hiking and exploring! Denver Biscuit Co. is worth all of it and then some! You won't regret coming here and are sure to leave SUPER satisfied!
Great place for NY style pizza in Denver! Idk why the reviews for this place are such a mixed bag, but I *almost* let that stop me from trying it out. On a whim, I ordered delivery for lunch because I didn't have time to go out and grab food. So I can't speak to the ambiance of the restaurant or the staff unfortunately. The pizza arrived hot, fresh, and earlier than the stated timeframe. (Kudos to my delivery driver, she was great!) The pizza was HUGE and tasted great. It had that crispy/chewing crust but was thin enough to fold in half. Just perfect. I ate two slices and was more than satisfied. There were 8 slices total, so plenty for leftovers! S/N: I love that they have the ordering and delivery process fully integrated. I just went to Fat Sully's website and checked out. No need to install a million apps or go to another wesbite. Now my only regret is not ordering the waffle fries, but I'll just have to try those next time. The dessert options looked good too. I definitely recommend giving this place a try. Either stop in for a slice or grab a whole pie via delivery!
I'm very surprised by the lower reviews. I've had nothing but good experiences at this location. I've tried the pizza which is delicious and the biscuits for breakfast which are always a hit. My review today is more about their smashed burger. It was outstanding! The beef was flavorful and the burger was cheesy with soft pillowy buns. The service is always good and it is a very low key place which is my favorite kind of vibe. I wish they would take reservations but if you join the waitlist, it rarely takes long to be seated
Of course, as usual Ben has a diners, drive-ins and dives locations on his list of places to go while we were in Denver. Our first stop after we checked into our hotel was to Fat Sully's Pizza. They are known for their giant slices of pizza that you can get anyway you want with the toppings they offer. The price is really good too for the size of the piece you get. It was the biggest piece I've ever personally had. It was really good too. I ordered several toppings which probably isn't the best idea since the pizza is thin new york style so my toppings made it heavy. Ben got less than I did and his held up better. LOL. The server was friendly and was attentive when needed and gave us our space as well which is always appreciated. We will definitely be back for more pizza.
My friends and I came here for lunch before our flight back to CA. The line was long so I had to grab a slice (love me some pizza) to hold me over. Oh man, the pep/mushroom slice was freakin phenomenal. A big slice, thin crust, undercarriage had decent char and their tomato sauce had the perfect combination of acid and sweetness, great balance. I'm drooling just thinking about it right now. I ended up getting another slice because it was soo good! Highly recommend, not sure why it's below 4 stars.
I don't know what's with all the negative reviews. This slice was very very good and truly a New York slice. Thin, crispy, slight chew, everything I'm looking for in an NY slice. Sauce was on point and not too overpowering and it's was cooked to perfection. Minimal to no flop which is the first sign of a good slice. So far, this is my favorite slice in Denver.
A great way to spend a Wednesday evening! The restaurant is very chilled on the week nights. They have a walk up window and it's open til midnight if you need a late night snack. We opted to dine in. We had great customer service from our waiter. Food came out timely and hot. I wanted to love the loaded garlic knots but I wasn't a huge fan. They were dry and crispy and I didn't like the sauces served with them. The slices are truly huge. One slice will most def fill you up. Next time, I would request to get the slice well done just to have some extra crisp to it!
Pretty bad. My family has eaten here three times. The first time was actually good. We liked the pizza, and our son enjoyed his chicken tenders. The only complaint was stylistic: the pizza is so large, and they don't offer other sized. The second time was good. We just got two slices. The third time was 0 stars, bad. We ordered at 5 PM, not a busy time, and everything arrived burned. The chicken tenders were too tough to chew through. It couldn't be eaten. The chicken sandwiches also were burned. Even the waffle fries were well over cooked, like crackers. We tossed most of the meal into the trash. Even with the first decent experience, I would not order chicken here again. Some other things to consider: the pizzas are really big, which, you have to plan for. Also, the accoutrements on the chicken sandwich are sweet - sweet tartar sauce (or whatever they call it) and the sweet pickles. These are stylistic choices by the chef (not bad, but not good), and we found them off putting.
4 months ago
This. Was. INCREDIBLE. I can't exaggerate enough how much I enjoyed Fat Sully's (also Atomic Cowboys/Denver Biscuit). Their pizza was, in all honesty, the best pizza I've ever had. I was in Colfax for the St. John Cathedral 'Celestia' show, and decided to stop for some food. It was late, around 10, so I did miss the biscuits but if they're as goos as the pizza, that says enough. And don't even get me STARTED on the garlic knots--I don't think I've ever seen better looking or better tasting garlic knots. The food came out quick, and the service in general was very nice. I kid you not, the smell throughout the place is just amazing. Fresh baked pizza, which is one of the best smells. If you're ever in Colfax area, I can't recommend this place enough! read more
Best pizza I've ever had!! Absolutely hit the spot. My husband and I were visiting Denver around the holidays and saw this place on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives and couldn't wait to check it out. We went around 4PM so unfortunately missed the opportunity to try the biscuits but the pizza was amazing. The server was great. We chatted about his experience living in Denver. The restaurant was decorated for the holidays which was fun. We enjoyed our experience so much we went back again but to the Tennyson location and brought our friends! read more
9 days ago
6 months ago
Food: Used to love the pizza here. So large. Such a lot of very good pizza for the money! But definitely NOT today. (And yes, I'm sending that as a shout (out) to the world). On Wednesday I buy my co-workers lunch to talk business. Today, I thought, they'll love a good Sully's salad and a pizza. Have done that many times in the past and they've all loved it. Today, it was still a good salad, but the pizza was absolutely the worst pizza I've had in Denver for decades. Really bad. No dough in the center area of the pizza and the edges were in places so thick they were undercooked and mushy. The "no dough in the center" issue resulted in a pizza so thin in the center 6" that all the pizza was in that area was a perhaps 1/16 of an inch of only burned cheese mixed in with some hardened red sauce. Crunchy to the touch and awful tasting. The pics show the absence of any dough and you could literally see through the pizza where the cheese had burned away leaving empty space. This is a sad story about a once-loved pizza institution in Denver I have frequented for way over 20 years. I'm sorry to tell this story. It may be that with the influx of East High students ordering a single slice at a time and swamping their resources the place just can't handle it any more. But the bottom line is, as my grandmother used to say, "if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen." Sully's, if you're gonna serve that kind of sorry excuse for pizza then give it up and get outta the kitchen! Sign me, David "so sorry to have lost an old friend" M PS They get 2 instead of 1 star because, like I said, the salad was good and the person behind the pickup window was nice. read more
Business owner information
Holly W.
Hi David,…
9 months ago
We went here to eat their pizza. We ordered wings as well. Both the wings and pizza were very good and we felt the pricing was fair. Their sweet tea is hands down the best sweet tea I've ever had! They only let you get one free refill of the tea, but I liked it so much I purchased another one to go. The vibes in the place are good and the staff were all very friendly. If you are in the area and are craving pizza and wings, I recommend checking this place out! read more
OMG Denver Biscuit Company (also falls under the name of Atomic Cowboy/Fat Sully's) is absolutely fantastic! Their biscuits are some of the butteriest, moistest, flakiest biscuits I've ever had! I'm glad there are a handful of DBC locations throughout the city of Denver so the wealth is well spread. We came here for breakfast and I like that this DBC in particular is housed in the same space as two other restaurants, so that there's food options for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and a wide variety of it all as well. Given that it was breakfast though, we all ordered the biscuits and what a hearty breakfast it was! These biscuits are massive - frankly, everything here comes in massive proportions including the largest cinnamon roll I've ever seen! Not only are the biscuits massive, but they're essentially sandwiches and come piled on with a ton of ingredients as well! I ordered the K-Mack biscuit sandwich, which had a Korean spin on all of it. It was Korean fried buttermilk chicken (so tender and flavorful!), toasted sesame seeds, sesame mayo, pickled daikon (the perfect burst of tart freshness - could've done with even more given how heavy all the other ingredients are), shredded cabbage, and green onions. The chicken was perfect, the biscuit was perfect, my belly was wildly happy! On top of it all, I added a side of McHashbrowns because I had to try what these were, given that I do really enjoy the McDonald's hashbrowns. These ended up being some of the best hashbrowns I've ever had. Twice the thickness of a McDonald's hashbrown and in a triangle shape, perfectly crispy on the outside and potato-y on the inside! It was way too much food and easily split into two full meals, but it was so worth it! The giant biscuit cinnamon roll that my friends and I ordered was so good as well. Like I said earlier in this review, it was truly massive and we also added the option of the bacon bits on top because we wanted to try that out. The result was delicious - salty and sweet! And even among the three of us, we couldn't finish the cinnamon roll given that we each had ordered biscuit sandwiches as well. We all ended up taking leftovers home for another meal in addition to not even being hungry by the time dinner rolled around that same day, even after a ton of hiking and exploring! Denver Biscuit Co. is worth all of it and then some! You won't regret coming here and are sure to leave SUPER satisfied! read more
3 years ago
Great place for NY style pizza in Denver! Idk why the reviews for this place are such a mixed bag, but I *almost* let that stop me from trying it out. On a whim, I ordered delivery for lunch because I didn't have time to go out and grab food. So I can't speak to the ambiance of the restaurant or the staff unfortunately. The pizza arrived hot, fresh, and earlier than the stated timeframe. (Kudos to my delivery driver, she was great!) The pizza was HUGE and tasted great. It had that crispy/chewing crust but was thin enough to fold in half. Just perfect. I ate two slices and was more than satisfied. There were 8 slices total, so plenty for leftovers! S/N: I love that they have the ordering and delivery process fully integrated. I just went to Fat Sully's website and checked out. No need to install a million apps or go to another wesbite. Now my only regret is not ordering the waffle fries, but I'll just have to try those next time. The dessert options looked good too. I definitely recommend giving this place a try. Either stop in for a slice or grab a whole pie via delivery! read more
I'm very surprised by the lower reviews. I've had nothing but good experiences at this location. I've tried the pizza which is delicious and the biscuits for breakfast which are always a hit. My review today is more about their smashed burger. It was outstanding! The beef was flavorful and the burger was cheesy with soft pillowy buns. The service is always good and it is a very low key place which is my favorite kind of vibe. I wish they would take reservations but if you join the waitlist, it rarely takes long to be seated read more
1 year ago
Business owner information
Holly W.
Hi Steve,…
1 year ago
Of course, as usual Ben has a diners, drive-ins and dives locations on his list of places to go while we were in Denver. Our first stop after we checked into our hotel was to Fat Sully's Pizza. They are known for their giant slices of pizza that you can get anyway you want with the toppings they offer. The price is really good too for the size of the piece you get. It was the biggest piece I've ever personally had. It was really good too. I ordered several toppings which probably isn't the best idea since the pizza is thin new york style so my toppings made it heavy. Ben got less than I did and his held up better. LOL. The server was friendly and was attentive when needed and gave us our space as well which is always appreciated. We will definitely be back for more pizza. read more
10 months ago
Business owner information
Holly W.
Hey Ellie,…
2 years ago
My friends and I came here for lunch before our flight back to CA. The line was long so I had to grab a slice (love me some pizza) to hold me over. Oh man, the pep/mushroom slice was freakin phenomenal. A big slice, thin crust, undercarriage had decent char and their tomato sauce had the perfect combination of acid and sweetness, great balance. I'm drooling just thinking about it right now. I ended up getting another slice because it was soo good! Highly recommend, not sure why it's below 4 stars. read more
I don't know what's with all the negative reviews. This slice was very very good and truly a New York slice. Thin, crispy, slight chew, everything I'm looking for in an NY slice. Sauce was on point and not too overpowering and it's was cooked to perfection. Minimal to no flop which is the first sign of a good slice. So far, this is my favorite slice in Denver. read more
1 year ago
A great way to spend a Wednesday evening! The restaurant is very chilled on the week nights. They have a walk up window and it's open til midnight if you need a late night snack. We opted to dine in. We had great customer service from our waiter. Food came out timely and hot. I wanted to love the loaded garlic knots but I wasn't a huge fan. They were dry and crispy and I didn't like the sauces served with them. The slices are truly huge. One slice will most def fill you up. Next time, I would request to get the slice well done just to have some extra crisp to it! read more
1 year ago
2 years ago
Pretty bad. My family has eaten here three times. The first time was actually good. We liked the pizza, and our son enjoyed his chicken tenders. The only complaint was stylistic: the pizza is so large, and they don't offer other sized. The second time was good. We just got two slices. The third time was 0 stars, bad. We ordered at 5 PM, not a busy time, and everything arrived burned. The chicken tenders were too tough to chew through. It couldn't be eaten. The chicken sandwiches also were burned. Even the waffle fries were well over cooked, like crackers. We tossed most of the meal into the trash. Even with the first decent experience, I would not order chicken here again. Some other things to consider: the pizzas are really big, which, you have to plan for. Also, the accoutrements on the chicken sandwich are sweet - sweet tartar sauce (or whatever they call it) and the sweet pickles. These are stylistic choices by the chef (not bad, but not good), and we found them off putting. read more
Business owner information
Holly W.
Hi Isaac,…
We were reaching approaching dangerous levels of hanger and decided to check out this pizza place right around the corner from us. Pieces are big, thin New York style pizza. It hit the spot. Ratios were good and the crust has a nice crunch to it while still offering a little bit of doughiness. There was quite a bit of grease dripping off our pieces, so make sure to grab some napkins for clean up afterwards. We ordered online and got our pizza within 20 minutes, freshly baked right out of the oven. We were able to snag one of the few seats new the outdoor window and enjoy the nice spring evening. I know I will be back here again while in Denver read more
4 years ago
Wholly smokes! They've got some ginormous pizzas!! Ordered delivery and although pricey for pizza, they did not disappoint. Huge slices with a good amount of toppings. Quite delicious and would definitely order again. read more
So, the pizza is good, the biscuit time is great too, but the bottom line is that they serve the best burger in Denver. First, it is the best burger. Second, it is $6 during HH and $9 the other times...ridiculous value. Pic below. I have raved about this in the past, so let me give you a new "level" talk. There are different levels of quality, as you can expect with any kitchen. On their worst day, the burger is in the conversation for the best in town still, but it is debatable. I would accept other people's lobbying on those days. On their GOOD days, there is NO argument. It is the best, hands down. Not even close. They have TV's with sports on, neutral music at an energetic level, and a massive bar area, where one side is a higher level (though I am a lower level person). They have fantastic beers on tap, and my go-to is Rare Trait. Oh, and they include IPA's on their HH specials. Score. Great selection of hot sauce, although you don't need ANYTHING on the burger. No hot sauce, ketchup, mustard, etc. The staff is always on point. Today, I had Mel and Jackie behind the bar, and my experience was flawless as usual. But, you sense the high level of service, along with cohesiveness with their colleagues no matter when you go. And, you should go there. Order the other stuff, and I am sure you will be happy. I will just stay in my groove of continuing to order my magical burger. Definitely recommend, and see you there. read more
1 year ago
Business owner information
Holly W.
Hi Doyle,…
3 years ago
This place never disappoints. They have happy hour from 3-6 drinks are half off and some of thr appetizers are half off also. This is my pizza go to spot. For two people it was $32 before tip. Service is always great here everyone is friendly. read more
1 year ago
Business owner information
Jamie W.
Hi Elizabeth/Erin,…
I had heard great things about this place and loved the biscuits at the Denver Biscuit Company, which is technically in the same building but a different kitchen...which prompted me to check it out. While decent in flavor, the pizza was just lacking. I tried the pepperoni and my friend tried a plain slice. When you buy by the slice it is a lot larger than a slice if you were to buy the whole pie. One slice is not quite enough for a meal, 2 is just too much. The flavoring of the sauce was superb but the crust was soggy and the top pretty oily. My sense is that the pizza is sitting for a while and they throw on toppings and stick it in the oven to order. I probably won't come back for a slice but may try a whole pie which is baked fresh to order. The best part of the meal were the biscuits we ordered on the side and the great service. read more
5 years ago
This was the choice to eat at before our timed zoo entry for zoo lights. I had seen this place on the 5280 top Denver pizza places bracket from 2020. As a family we love NY style pizza as we can get a lot and in this case go half and half. The 26" is dine in only so if you want the big one keep that in mind. Overall I was satisfied with the pizza. I was not satisfied with the time it took for the pizza. We had set out 1.5 hours to eat this pizza before our timed entry and we arrived at the gates 10 minutes late even thought it was only 7 min drive. It wasn't overly busy in the restaurant and the 26" took almost 50 minutes to be done. If I were to return I would only order Togo and skip the stop in. Pros- Service was very friendly Restaurant was well maintained and clean Pizza was pretty good Cons- Parking is extremely scarce so be prepared for a trek Only get slices if in a hurry Pizza was greasy so if you have a sensitivity stay clear read more
1 year ago
7 years ago
Hands down one of my favorite places in Denver. There's multiple locations around the city and I would highly recommend you go. Go often. Run, do not walk. I have no idea why, but the Fat Sullys Salad is one of my favorite things to order at any restaurant, anywhere. It's soooo good! All the ingredients are always fresh and everything just WORKS together. I could live off this salad. And I love that you can order it for one or more people. The dressings are incredible. The ranch and the chipotle ranch are to die for. Some of the best ranches in Denver. The pizza slices are HUGE and I love that I can order the salad and the pizza and be full but not feel like a glutton. You can get them any way you want, so what's not to like? They have so many options! I get a different slice every time I come. You can order whole pizzas but why conform everyone to the same thing when every person in your party can be their unique self? I also love that it comes QUICK and that if one if not enough, you can sit there and drink one of the amazing beers on tap and order yourself another! As if the salad and pizza isn't enough, I've never come across a rude bartender or server here. Even late at night they're still chatty and nice. It's one of my favorite places in Denver and I recommend it to everyone! read more
4 years ago
We ordered pizza (olives & mushroom) Garlic knots And wings + buffalo Wow, just delicious. The wings are my new fav! I'll be ordering every pizza night read more
Like the sister location in Colorado Springs, this place is legit. I do suggest ordering the pizza well done. It's always crispy and perfect. Not burnt, ever from my experience. Our favorite will always be spinach, mushroom and pepperoni. The 26" is big! One slice will leave you full, but! If your order the 26" you have leftovers for a couple of the days and this pizza heats up phenomenally in the oven. We got a table for 5 right away at 2 on a Saturday. The service was fast and friendly, this was a solid experience! read more
2 years ago
2 years ago
5 years ago
Any time we are craving pizza and aren't feeling lazy...we stop by Fat Sully's! You can get a Big Ass Slice for $3.95 plus toppings and they have great drink selections as well. We hadn't been here in awhile due to COVID and they added Garlic Knots to their menu. In my opinion they could have used more garlic lol but that's just me! The portion size was plenty for like 4 ppl! Staff is always friendly and check on you often. read more
This place is always a go too location for a late bite. Their pizza is always delicious. But I gotta tell you on the garlic knots, I've had plenty and they've never been this soft and flavorful. A must try! Also, never have I ever had melted Mozzarella cheese as a dip with pesto deeelicious!! read more
Pretty good pizza. I'm not sure what else to add. We actually ordered a slice of pizza while waiting 45 minutes for our table at Denver Biscuit company. The slice came out fast and was pretty darn big. Between my wife, son and myself we gobbled it down super fast. We were super hungry and it was a fantastic appetizer. Would recommend. read more
Page 1 of 17
More info about Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax
3237 E Colfax Ave
Ste 3
Denver, CO 80206
City Park, Northeast
Directions
(303) 339-3977
Call Now
Order Takeout or Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
https://www.theatomiccowboy.com/fatsullys
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
Ask the Community - Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
72 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
2 years ago
12 years ago
13 years ago
14 years ago
10 years ago
18 years ago
12 years ago
10 years ago
12 years ago
16 years ago
16 years ago
12 years ago
9 years ago
9 years ago
12 years ago
13 years ago
14 years ago
17 years ago
9 years ago
