El Paso Bakery made a custom cake for my birthday in December 2025. It was a surprise to me but they worked with my family to easily place the order, choose flavors and colors and design, and coordinate pickup. Everyone was pleased with the result. read more

El Paso Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

I called El Paso around 3pm Saturday afternoon needing a cake for that night! I was so last minute and the lady who answered the phone was so nice and understanding. She even asked if the cake was for anything special and if I wanted to add any color. I let them know it was for a birthday and the name to use. The cake was ready at 530 like I requested and it was sooo pretty! Way better than I imagined!! And it taste really good and moist! Gracias El Paso Bakery !!! Muy rico!!! read more

El Paso Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

Best tree leches cake ever! My family and friends go to place for cakes! They not only taste amazing but look good too! They did an amazing job for my baby shower. read more

El Paso Bakery - Picture doesn't do it justice but it was exactly what I wanted :) - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

Great cake turnout and guests loved the consistency/flavor of cake. Fair price but the only negative thing was the inconsistency when placing the order. I first text what I needed with pictures and received a price but no order confirmation. I called a week later to make sure that the order was received but they didn't have it on their books so I went ahead and gave them all the information again. When I went in to place the deposit, the order was not on the books. That was frustrating however they were friendly about the whole situation. read more

El Paso Bakery - Peter rabbit two tier cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

I wanted to purchase a custom cake for my wife's birthday. I stopped into El Paso Bakery early Friday morning and brainstormed with the associate as to what I wanted it to look like and what flavor I wanted it to be. I went with a 6" Tres Leches Cake with Strawberry Mouse filling and a pink fondant. The cake was ready first thing Saturday morning. I was very impressed with the outcome. She loved the look and the taste of the cake. I will definitely purchase another cake from El Paso Bakery and would recommend them if you're looking for a custom cake to celebrate any special occasion. read more

El Paso Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

I give a 3 star because the presentation was so great and pretty. But the taste of the cake was bland and dry, we ordered a tres leche cake (which it should be moist). Highly disappointed we heard such great things about this place so I had high expectations. read more

El Paso Bakery - Cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

A nice little bakery on the edge of downtown cotati. They are quite a few pastries to choose from and it looks like they have cakes that can be decorated anyway that you want. I tried one of their pastries, and it was very good. read more

Love this place. Ordered a 2 tower custom cake for my child's birthday and it was beautiful, and delicious. Very moist and frosting tasted great. Also ordered a regular sheet cake ready to be decorated. Everyone there had great costumer service as well. Very friendly people. Ambiance good as well. Their flan and pastries 10/10. 100% recommend this bakery. I will be getting all of my cakes here from now on. read more

Cake was not what we ordered, not 3 leches and everyone was so disappointed with the flavor. It was a big cake to so ppl describe it as dried PASTEL DE CAJA. The service when trying to complain was horrible, the girl even said to go to costco instead lol .. the only good thing i received from this place was a good laugh. read more

Have to say we tried this bakery for the first time. Had a specific picture and color/ flavors we wanted and only gave 3 day notice. They not only said they could do it for us, but the cake was to perfection of the picture, with added flowers I asked for on the side. I don't think we will ever go to another baker again but them! The flavor was soooo moist and delicious to top it off. read more

See all

Hidden gem alert! Can't attest to their baked goods, but their tortas are awesome! Not over the top and sloppy, easy to eat and delicious. Check it out! The place is extremely clean and seems very Covid compliant. The service is super friendly. They have ice cream and coffee things. read more

We ordered two big sheets of tres leches sheet cakes for our wedding. The staff were great to work with, the delivery was smooth, and the cake was great (and not too sweet!) read more

Excellent cake inside and out. Found a photo online and asked the person who was taking our order if they could reproduce it. They ended up making an even better looking cake. Inside it was red velvet. Guests were amazed and were asking where I got it. We also had to move the date twice which was no problem to them. Will definitely be ordering more cakes from this place! read more

El Paso Bakery - Spider-Man birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

Legit fresh Mexican bread!! Clean location and amazing customer service. Everyone is so kind and ready to help you out. We've ordered our tres leches cakes from here, so many options! And an amazing bonus... they have ice cream! read more

We had a heart shape three tier cake made for a wedding, and it was lovely!! Tasted very good! Also we had them make about 100 iced cookies for favors and they were great as well, all individually wrapped! Ruffina and her husband were both very easy to work with and I highly recommend them! Also fair prices!! Good job El Paso Bakery!! read more

They were amazing! The place was welcoming, clean, and organized. The service was wonderful. They accommodated a very last minute request for a cake order. The cake turned out beautiful and was delicious. We were pleasantly surprised to find out they had tortas and they were pretty tasty too. read more

I needed a fondant cake for my daughters birthday. I explained how I wanted the cake to look. Paid for it in full. When the cake arrived to the party it was a completely different color. I called the lady to let her know she was rude and said she couldn't help me in any way. I told her the cake was very expensive and the least she could do would be to give me half my money back but she said no. This place lacks customer service and should not be running a business if they do not know how to treat customers. I would not recommend them. Oh yeah and the cake was disgusting I felt bad serving it to my guests. read more

Not good customer service and old bread without notice sold at same price. The bread is good, but it's not fresh. I would give them a higher rating if it was for taste. You can tell when bread is fresh and this was on the dryer side and a bit hard. Also, they sold them at full price. (a dollar a piece for everything except bolillo can be expensive for some of the bread wouldnt mind paying if it was fresh) I think the point of going to the bakery is to have fresh bread and usually bakeries sell old bread for a cheaper price and let you know its old. Maybe you want to ask when it was made. Also, the card reader wasn't working and they weren't very nice about it, not very good customer service.I offered to come back and pick it up later so that they wouldn'thave to put it back and I can give them some business. When I did come back they didn't have change. That wasn't that big of deal but you can think differently of it. For me it was the fact that I went out of my way to purchase and it wasn't fresh. It was at least a day old. read more

love, love, love, LOVE! this place. Their cakes are soo delicious, the people that work here are very nice. They have cakes, pinatas, sweet bread, sandwiches (love their milanesa tortas) they have flan and everthing its just really good. I ordered a cake for my parents 25th anniversary and it was delicious and a few weeks ago i ordered my wedding cake, and i loved it too! it was beautiful and they have really good prices, totally affordable! i recommend this place to everyone i know. If i lived closer i would go here every day! read more

El Paso Bakery - I loved my wedding cake. Thank you El Paso Bakery :) - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

I have to write this because it's the third time got bad experience I'm ok with the personal, the bread some time is so hard like rocks! And we can't check before because is not allowed to pick up by your self any ways and today I bought a cake but wasn't what I want. And I ask them before if is 3 leches (3 milks) the cake was to dry and .... I just not good! read more

Best cake we have ever had. The Tres Leches is to die for, and the employees are sweet as can be.

One of the very best bakeries around RP/Cotati area. We ordered Tres Leches cake for my husband's birthday this weekend for 100 people and everyone loved the cake. The cream on top is the most delicious people said they'd had. A friend called today and asked for the bakery's info for her mother's birthday. It's delicious! read more

Hands-down this is my go to place for birthday cakes. My family is of Mexican heritage so we always buy a tres leches cake for special occasions and birthdays. The family who owns this shop is very nice and accommodating. The cake that they serve is by far the best in the area. Despite the fact that I live in Marin, I always make the hour drive to pick up cake from El Paso Bakery when there are special occasions. I am very fond of this business and will keep visiting and this place will definitely be my birthday cake destination! read more

I've been to this bakery a couple times to buy their pre-made cakes and I've yet to be failed. I've tried their vanilla and tres leches and it's so delicious! The last cake I bought was a yesterday and everyone at the party was pleased! The customer service has been great and it's visible how hard they work. Los pasteles están deliciosos!! read more

El Paso Bakery - Tres leches con fruta. Delicioso! - Bakeries Near Me - Cotati, California

Im giving them 3 cause they are nice ppl. I am mexican so I know what good bread is. This bread is kinda hard. But I really was craving some pan dulce, and it was close. The cookies are better than the actual bread. read more

Best Place to Get a Cake! The customer service was excellent. My kids love their ice cream. It is easy to park there and the business appears to be family owned. That feels better than buying from a "warehouse" with no parking. read more

This place is awesome! been buying cakes from them since opened up for business. Great people, Great food, Tortas are amazing! Cakes are delicious, they will make anything you want and it will be perfect! Also had cupcakes made, ERRRRR MAHHHHH GERD DELICIOUS! Best service ive ever had and great prices! read more

Their cake and sweetbread are VERY scrumptious! I have been ordering cakes here for the last 5 years, and they are the best I have ever had! They do not over sweeten their cakes, like a lot of other bakeries do. I am ordering my son's cake today for his first birthday because I know that he will love it. read more