I am not a big YELP reviewer, as if I have a compliment or a concern, I usually have no issues bringing it to the attention of a manager or an owner. Welcome to my exception to the rule.
I've been to Dottie's before, and I know that the food can take a little while to arrive. I have no issues with that, whatsoever, given the high quality of its menu and food. Today, my girlfriend and I decided to grab breakfast, and we excitedly drove to Dottie's.
We arrived at 10:39 am. I know, pretty specific. You'll see where it's going in a minute. We ordered off what is a diverse menu. Our order seemed to be pretty simple. One Diner Plate with eggs, sausage, home fries, and avocado toast. The second order was exactly the same, but with an additional egg. Perhaps that third egg put our experience over the edge. We likely placed our order somewhere around 10:50 am.
While patiently waiting, I enjoyed my conversation and company with my girlfriend. After about 30 minutes, our server came to the table and noted that somehow our order did not make it into the system, he apologized for the wait and noted that he would expedite the order. Within the next thirty minutes, additional staff came to the table, again apologizing for the wait. Several tables in the immediate area were served their food, and they had arrived well after us. The table directly next to us, who placed their order immediately after us, received their order. Another 10-15 minutes elapsed and my girlfriend and I set our limit... if the food's not here in the next ten minutes, we're out.
Ten minutes came and went, and so did another apology and assurance that our food would be out shortly. As we started to leave, I saw the hostess in the kitchen. I went to her, told her we had been waiting for over an hour for food, and that we were opting to leave. That's when things took a turn, and my exception to my Yelp Rule came into effect.
The cook, perhaps also the manager, or maybe even the owner, appeared and asked what our order was. I told her the Diner Plates, and that we had been waiting for over an hour. She apologized, and I replied that it wasn't necessary to apologize, but that we were choosing to leave. I again reiterated that waiting for such a long time for an egg dish wasn't working for me, that other tables got their orders well ahead of us despite arriving well after us, and it was simply time for us to leave. After telling her I didn't need an apology, she said, "sir, I can see your upset, I'm sorry." I reiterated that apologies weren't needed, but that we were leaving. There was an edge in her tone with me. I won't deny being frustrated, but the time limit we set for ourselves had been met.
I saw our server, Tim, out in the front area of the restaurant. I told him I wanted to pay for the coffee, as we were leaving, having waited far too long. He indicated there to be no need to pay. I thanked him, and we went on our way.
As we stepped outside, the cook came out with our slip. She indicated that the order came in at 11:24 am and that we hadn't been waiting as long as we had indicated. I took exception, told her we were there at 10:39 am, and as it was now noon, we were leaving. "Your order is on the grill, and now I'm going to have to throw it out," was her reply. When I told her that we had, in fact, placed our order long before that, she refuted us, telling us again, that the order was placed at 11:24 am, and, basically, that we were misrepresenting the time frame. We left and headed to Dunkin Donuts, right down the street, where our order was filled within minutes.
So what about 10:39 am? that's pretty detailed and exact. You see, the exact nature of 10:39 am was verified through my girlfriend's LIFE 360 app, which told us our arrival time at Dottie's. When we left shortly before noon, we had been waiting for nearly an hour and a half.
I'm a patient person and I eat out with great regularity. I have no problem waiting for good food. What I do take exception to is being treated rudely. Our waiter and busboy were apologetic and polite around the delay. The order got lost in the shuffle, things happen. What i would have expected that once that happened and was realized, that the order would have been prioritized, and we then we would get our food in short order. Not so. To characterize a customer who had been waiting over an hour for the Diner Plate as a liar, didn't sit well.
What also won't sit well is my behind in a seat at Dottie's restaurant, ever again. read more