Pizza was delicious and portion sizes were good. Prices add up fast the more in the partyread more

While visiting Oneonta for a baseball tournament, several locals recommended both Nina's and…read moreTino's. Unfortunately, we never made it to Tino's, but Nina's absolutely lived up to the hype. The pizza slices were outstanding. You could immediately taste the quality of the ingredients. The sauce was flavorful and complemented the high-quality mozzarella perfectly. Every bite delivered that classic stretch and pull of fresh cheese, making for a truly satisfying slice. As good as the pizza was, the service impressed us even more. The staff was friendly, attentive, and genuinely focused on making sure we had everything we needed. If you're in Oneonta, hether for baseball, sightseeing, or just passing through, Nina's is definitely worth a stop. Great pizza, quality ingredients, and exceptional service make it an easy recommendation.

In town for baseball and ate here the first night and it was all really good! The menu has a lot to…read morechoose from so everyone should be able to find something they like. I got their Blackened Catfish with house potatoes and smoky mac 'n cheese. Everything tasted amazing and service was great! They serve Pepsi products is one bummer. The place was clean and super homey. It is a little pricey but worth the extra dough IMO.

Once again had an amazing meal at Jay's Place in Oneonta NY…read more Husband had their prime rib cooked to perfection and I had the Seaford Newburgh over linguine. So tasty and filling. Serves was topnotch. If you haven't been to Jay's try them. You won't be disappointed

Second visit and Brunch was even better than the first time and that was terrific!…read moreOur server, Clayton, was a delight. Professional, funny and spot on with taking care of our needs. Don't hesitate to treat yourself to excellent food,ambiance and service.

first of all let me stop by saying the service was excellent five. The view was also five star…read more However, my husband and I went to the in October 2025 this time we were there on July 4, 2026. We were very disappointed between October and July. The wine menu had been paired down, which was OK. They still offered many wonderful wines. However, my steak was so rich. I could hardly eat it. I ordered a ribeye. It had excessive butter. It was greasy. The side vegetables were very good. But our desserts were tasteless and disappointing My husband had the lamb very much. Appetizers of salad and carpaccio were wonderful Overall, I love this but I do hope that the entrées can improve

Unbelievably outstanding food. High quality. Fresh and delicious. I ate here everyday they were…read moreopen during my trip to the area.

I never want to leave negative reviews but I came here after reading reviews, so hoping to help…read moreothers-- We came in to pick up dinner after being at AllStar Village. The town of Oneonta lacks restaurants that are open past 5pm or are even open Sunday-Thurs. The location is good and the menu looks like it should be a yummy gem. We ordered a pizza and a salad. The portions were large but neither had much taste. Save your money and settle for something else.

This eatery is Just as closed today as it was in January. Great location but the doors are locked.read more

This is a bar and grill in the downtown area. Parking can be difficult but it looks like if you…read moreknow the area there is a lot of public parking. The menu is very diverse and I had a hard time deciding. After asking the server way to many questions I chose the Mongolian BBQ bowl. She told me it would be VERY spicy. That was fine with me. This came in a big bowl with chili pepper and Sriracha sauce. It had a good kick to it and my mouth knew the spice was there but I thought it was milder that I expected. The chicken was grilled and had an amazing flavor. It had the fat noodles, i am not sure what they are called but they were good. It was served in a broth but all the broth was soaked up before I was finished. Service was great and the food was amazing. This was awesome

Ambience -My son and I just happened to choose this restaurant by happenstance on our way to…read moreCooperstown. What great luck! We sat at the bar to eat. Each chair has a name engraved on the bar in front of it. From this, I knew this would be a friendly place. This is a family owned and operated business. The dad greeted us warmly and manned the bar. The mom was the chef who made wonderful, homemade food like you'd expect from your grandma. Their son was helping out in kitchen. We met and chatted with them all. The food - yummy!! Local, fresh and made with love. I had meatloaf sandwich. Great taste. My fave was my son's BBQ pulled pork which was smoked for 12 hours behind the restaurant. The side of mac and cheese out of this world I had potato wedges topped with cheese, bacon and scallions. So good. Best part - I had rented a hotel that was 45 Min from Cooperstown. Oops. The dad and two other locals eating at bar helped me tremendously in finding new lodging. They gave me Many options. Turns out I rented a beautiful house on the owners' property up a small Hill. They said I could pay them after my stay. I'm from Detroit so this small town trust warmed my heart.

Service is amazing. All the food is homemade, fresh, and made with love. Ron and Don always deliver…read morequality food and service. Their muled cider is my favorite cocktail that they offer. In oneonta good quality food is hard to come by but Humphreys has you covered. The ambiance is great and the restaurant is always clean.

This is right down the street from the Baseball Hall of Fame and in the middle of the quaint…read moredowntown area of small town Cooperstown, NY. You cannot help but fall in LOVE with the this town and this little hometown cafe!!! I always expect subpar food in these type places, but we got excellent food and even better service. My cheeseburger was cooked to perfection and tasted amazing. Everyone else loved their food as well. It is clean with plenty of seating, right in the middle of town; so be sure and stop by!

We had lunch at the bar. The server was very friendly and helpful. Ambiance was very much…read moreCooperstown. I had an egg salad sandwich and would happily eat another anytime!

The Glimmerglass at the Otesaga Hotel in Resort in Cooperstown is a throwback to the old style…read moreelite hotel dining. Unfortunately, it is no longer appreciated for it's greatness as times have changed. As a Resort Guest, I had the breakfast option which was a great choice to enjoy such elite dining on premises. Convenient and top notch. In the times I visited (July 2021) it was trailing to the end of the COVID nightmare (but before Delta) and the buffet was open and full quality was there. About all a guest could notice was the diligent wearing of masks by staff. The buffet was as good as you can get. Full fruit and Continental options, or hot eggs, meats, potatoes, biscuits, and gravy. And eggs/omelets made to order. The only drawback was that I didn't want to over eat to start the day. needed a second stomach. Upon sitting the wait staff gets any drink you need (coffee/juices) as part of my breakfast included price. I was only brought a check at the end for a gratuity. Some uneven service getting to drinks quickly but it wasn't hard to get their attention if needed. There is a fancy dining room (I dropped a couple of photos) and a nice outdoor patio facing the lake. The outdoor seemed to fill up first albeit the weather was near perfect so can't blame. A point of confusion was logistics and dress code. Upon check in, the desk clerk let me know where it was and strongly advised a reservation and let me know it was fine dining and dress code was appreciated. Not knowing what time I wanted to eat I called late and no answer. I called restaurant services when I woke up and was forwarded to the casual dinner restaurant. I called the desk and had them transfer me, same as just calling, forwarded to casual not answered. No worry, I arrived and they had the guests on a list and it wasn't crowded enough to be an issue. Other thing was dress code. Some things I'd read in the literature was no sports gear, no hats, etc. Since most of the patrons were at the hotel for recreation (kids baseball tournaments, Hall of Fame, etc.) I didn't think wearing a T-shirt and tennis shoes would be an issue. It wasn't. Just don't wear swimwear. At the time I went it was breakfast only. If and when it opens for dinner do not listen to this advice and discuss with the management. Really nothing wrong here, can't withhold even a star. If you stay here, eat here. If the cost is too much, then find a place in your range but you won't beat the quality. This buffet was as good as it gets.

Timeless elegance of a bygone era paired with impeccably charming and attentive service and…read moreexceptional cuisine. Real silverware. And the VIEWS! Every angle provides a feast for the eyes. I absolutely adore this place.