We had a large team gathering while in for Cooperstown and the place was GREAT! We had called ahead and got everything set up for our whole team and all the parents. We probably took up most of the restaurant and they had pizza, salad, wings, and knots. Their pizza is New York style and REALLY good. They provided more than enough food and we had plenty for take home. If you are coming in town this is a perfect place to have authentic New York pies!!! read more

Pizza 23 West - Inside - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

See all

Excellent wings , great service , comfortable attractive atmosphere . Definitely will return

Prices were great- super clean, but the food - WOW! The wings were cooked perfect, the salad was so fresh, and the pizza was amazing! Great service, simple and perfect bar! So happy to have them here! read more

Pizza was reasonably good for outside of NYC (I ordered takeout and the food was ready at exactly the promised time) but I ordered wings to go with the pizza under the impression they were REAL wings (the full menu accessible via YELP does not indicate they are boneless balls of 'breaded chicken meat') and we were super disappointed with them. That is what brought this review down from 4 stars to 2 stars read more

Pizza 23 West - Screenshot of Pizza 23 menu on Yelp - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

Great local pizza place! The service was family oriented and run. We stopped in around 4 and the place was quiet the owners were very nice and we ordered a large pizza! The pizza was a bit oily and greasy but close to NYC style. Pizza was also a bit small so everyone needed at least 2 slices to be full. The restaurant was a bit old and run down but you could tell it was well established and standing a long time. They have large tables for large groups and teams!!! **WARNING THEY ARE A CASH ONLY BUSINESS** read more

Excellent pizza! Make sure you bring cash, as they don't take credit cards. They have a special summer menu of limited items during the summer for the kids that play in Cooperstown. read more

It was ok. Pizza was ok, wings were ordered mild yet they were missing sauce, still ok. I just personally like to give a tip/gratuity, when a place charges and as you pay let you know that was added ehhh I wouldn't go again. read more

Pizza 23 West - a plate of chicken wings and a pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

They delivered pizza to our entire team at All Star Village after our late game was over tonight! Kudos for delivering 30 minutes past their closing time!! This baseball Mom is happy and I had to try a slice and it was absolutely delicious! Just remember to ask them to slice it "smaller" for the kiddos because original slice is big. Slices were still big and everyone raved about the flavor! Thanks again Pizza 23 for yummy dinner for the baseball team tonight!! Delivery was right on time!! read more

Was recommended this place and tried it 3 different times and I can't find 1 good reason to ever come back. Their red and vodka sauces are bland and below average. The garlic knots were just okay and the boneless wings were again bland and below average . The menu seams to have reasonable prices but instead it's just small portions. The garlic knots, boneless wings and cannolis were tiny. The final straw for pizza 23 west was when I received my large pepperoni pizza in a box too small so a large portion of the pizza was folded over. The pizza came out late and also was drowning in grease and the undercooked cheese just slid right off. I will never be coming back to this restaurant and would never recommend it to anyone, quite frankly I have no idea how this place is still in business. "Under new management" but they certainly need new management again. read more

Terrible, terrible, terrible. Placed an order with them 2 weeks ahead for an event. 1 hour before the event, they sent an email cancelling. Didn't even bother to call us, just an email "too booked tonight". Left a whole team of 15 boys without food. Unreliable. Don't waste your time. -1 review if that was an option. read more

Been there 2 times in the last month or so. Food wasn't necessarily bad. It was ok. But both times they messed up the ordered. It's Disappointing when you order and pay for something and get something different. One time maybe a fluke, so we gave them a second chance. It happened again. The food was fair but nothing great. Portions were very generous. read more

The food was amazing. Owners treated us like family and really made us fill welcomed. Highly recommend this restaurant!

Do not go here. We waited 30 minutes for this place to open only for them to tell us that an entire team rented the dining room and they could not seat us because we weren't with the team. Really? Can't serve a family of 4 and an entire team needed the whole place. Won't go here again. read more

AMAZING Team dinner!!! We reserved the dining area for our baseball team and family to have a dinner. Food and service was top notch! Extremely quick service, great wings and pizza. The staff was abundantly kind and took care of us! If you are in town for CASV, this is a must for a private party! read more

We had such a great time with our baseball Team here! So grateful for the service, the incredible food, and the company. Highly recommend having a team party here! read more

Pizza 23 West - an instagram of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

See all

We got three pizzas plus a pepperoni roll for a family dinner. The grease level? I could've filled a swimming pool with how much grease was on the food. Had to deploy a stack of towels to combat the oil spill before we could eat. And the pepperoni roll was playing hide and seek--turns out, the pepperoni was the one hiding. Felt more like a pricey cheese roll than anything else. After eating my stomach was churning all night. read more

Great service. Tasty pizza. Cash only! We had our entire baseball team and families there for a party and they were very accommodating.

Way over priced and I understand why ...... Their influx of business comes from the Cooperstown rush. Cash only and they charge tax and bake in the tip. DO NOT ORDER VEGGIE FOR WHATEVER REASON. you're there for the total experience but the food is whatever read more

We live in the area and decided to try the pizza from here after reading all the positive reviews. The good: They were friendly and had our order ready on time. The bad: No one was masked, staff or customers. Considering the numbers and transmission risk in our area, that's disappointing. The pizza was covered in crushed garlic. This appears to be a standard thing here, but it was not mentioned or described anywhere on their website. I know some people think there is no such thing as too much garlic-- but my wife and I are not in that group. The pizza was so strongly flavored of garlic, it was inedible. We threw it away. If we had known, we could have asked they not put it on. The only other thing we ordered were two large cannolis -- and the shells were both stale and soggy. They also ended up in trash. $40 spent and wasted. We will not be ordering from there again. read more

Pizza 23 West is a great take out pizza place for out-of-towners looking for good food for a good price. If I were a local resident, we'd order from the place often. We recently ordered and picked up on a Saturday evening not long before closing and it was ready when promised and served piping hot-along with a cold antipasto salad. The round pizzas are giant and loaded with toppings-a sausage and onion had a lot of both ingredients and the sauce to ingredient to cheese content was perfect. I'm a rare Chicago-area native/resident who prefers NY style pizza, so this was a treat! The White Pizza was terrific-I only had a bite, but I'll attach a photo to my review. Fried ravioli and mushroom appetizers were solid as was the aforementioned antipasto salad. read more

See all

The food was so good here! The owners are fantastic and awesome people! Between pin trading and food this place was must go to! I 10/10 recommend when you get here! They let us close down the place for our team and service was fast and amazing!! read more

If you happen to be in Oneonta area and looking for something to eat checkout Pizza 23 West.... we got one of their specialty pizzas and some wings... they were great. Nice little place and service and staff was awesome they made us feel like we were old friends. read more

Pizza 23 West - pepperoni and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

Wonderful food and a great atmosphere. The food was very tasty and they had a quite a cute doggo name ravioli. The owners were super friendly and the decor is very neat country. The prices were more than fair to boot. Visit this family owned joint when in the area. read more

See all

When traveling I love to eat at family-owned restaurants. Pizza 23 was so good. The people are amazing and the food is excellent. I would recommend this anytime you're in the Cooperstown NY area! read more

Philly Cheesesteak pizza is good but a bit watery due to the ingredients. It could use more cheese and salt. The garlic wings are a go to. We couldn't stop eating them. Get two orders cause they're so good. read more

See all

Worst place ever! We ordered a pizza to go, when I opened the box it looked like they had poured watered down spaghetti sauce on top of pizza dough! There was literally standing liquid with huge chunks of onion and green peppers! You would need a knife and fork to cut them up that is how large. Unfortunately, I had already paid. They refused to make it right, I was told I ordered it so to bad. When I pushed the issue I was told to leave or they would call the police. Seriously, worst place ever! read more

Pizza 23 West - I ordered pizza not the water from your sink on pizza crust! - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

Went in last night to pick up a to go order, was automatically greeted with were not ready for you without even knowing what I needed. Staff was not friendly at all. read more

Rich does a great job at an affordable price with portions that are more than fair, traditional Italian food served with impeccable attention to quality read more

I don't know why it took us 3 years if CASV visits to finally go here, but once we finally did we went 3 times during our week. Penny & team are great. My daughter and I went in after opening ceremonies and debated margherita or cheese... we decided on margherita. Without asking the chef / owner (?) brought my daughter a slice of cheese and said "just in case". While there we discussed having our two team party (95 people) there later in the week. After contemplating the layout they decided they couldn't accommodate that many... but offered other options including hosting the party at Neahwa Park and having pizza delivered... which is exactly what we did, and it worked out perfectly. Best NY pizza I've had in a long time, comfortable environment & super friendly & helpful staff. (Penny also gave great recommendations for local & Cooperstown options). Pizza 23 was a big hit... all 3 times! read more

Pizza is awesome. We drive all the way from afton area. Just to have their pizza...........

It was pretty good. Ordered a couple of pies and both hot and mild chicken wings only problem was they didn't have jalapeños available as a pizza topping. Other than that the quality of the food is good and customer service was good too. read more

Pizza 23 West - Had to substitute jalapeños for green peppers - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

I usually love the pizza from here but tonight was a different night. I ordered an 18" pie that should have been 1/2 pepperoni and sausage on the left side ONLY with extra cheese on the WHOLE pie via Menufy. Menufy stated I would receive my order by 838pm EST. At 850pm, when I still had not received my order, I called as anyone who had $31 out in the universe would. Upon making the call, I had the pleasure of speaking to the delivery person JJ, who told me he had delivered my pizza to a building where I don't live and left it in the laundry room. When I asked for specifics and why he had not called me, he shared that he called three times and even used due diligence by using the emergency button to contact Campus Safety on the college campus where I live. When I asked what number he called, he shared that he had in fact dialed the last number of my cell # incorrectly- instead of dialing 7, he had dialed 4- which would explain why I never received any of the calls. The good sir JJ was apologetic and admitted it was his error. All fine. I then calmly requested to speak to the manager as anyone else would in this case. Things took a sharp turn when Penny, the manager, answered the phone. Penny came on the phone with a raised voice and firmly stated, "He kept calling you! So you can come here and pick it up bc I told him that after 20 mins of trying to contact you that he should come back to the store." (Mind you, I still had not shared that JJ admitted to calling the wrong number and that he left the pizza in a random place.) When I attempted to share that much and that I wanted a refund, Penny abruptly cut me off, raised her voice another octave and said, "You will not be getting a refund when he delivered it!" Feeling myself rise to Penny's level, I did the better thing and hung up, especially since she was clearly not in a state of mind where active listening was a priority. I then went on the hunt for my pizza. Here's where it got fun. Upon calling Campus Safety to inquire if JJ had in fact spoken to someone after pushing the emergency button, the dispatcher said yes he had called but that when they were about to call the number he provided, they saw on the cameras that he had gained access into a residence hall (the wrong one) by someone who opened the door at the same time. This prompted the safety dispatcher to believe JJ had met who he needed to meet, thus they never actually called me. When JJ recognized the person who opened the door wasn't waiting for a pizza delivery, he took the opportunity of utilizing the open door and walked in the building to the laundry room where he left the pizza on top a machine. Upon my entering the laundry room and opening the box - guess what? To add insult to injury, THE ORDER WAS WRONG!!! The WHOLE pie had sausage and pepperoni on it, much to the dismay of my partner. Still don't think I deserve that refund Penny? read more

Terrible service and very unaccommodating. Charged $150 venue fee, which we were not told about, didn't have a place set up separately and all together. Charged for ranch when asked for that in place of marinara sauce. Has a dog under the counter but won't allow outside cupcakes. No cups of water even offered, purchased bottle water of course. And it's cash only. Just all around terrible. read more

Ordered a large buffalo chicken pie. Omg so disgusting. Before we even git home the pizza box was saturated with grease and the taste was nothing like I have ever had. Couldn't eat it. Don't waste your money! read more

While I had the pizza there when I first moved in and it was good, the next round had hair in it. SO, I then checked their health score and it was 29! It went up to 45 and now it is at 65. I think I need at least a 90. So, I won't be going again. No more hair, thank you. read more

Not impressed at all with the food, the only reason they get my business is the fact that they are the only place that delivers to my area..

Millie would love what Richie & Penny have done with her old place. Had to stop in when visiting my wife's family after reading the reviews. Would Aunt Millie agree? Between the generous portions, the delicious pizza pizza (we tried a slice of cheese and a slice of the white) and lunch special (salad, garlic knots, chicken parmigiana and meat lasagna) we were full and sated. Richie & Penny are friendly hosts. They shared the history since Millie sold the place and now. If you come to Oneonta, be sure to stop in here! read more

Amazing staff, great place for a team party while visiting Cooperstown. Penny was so organized that we ended up doing the pizza party package delivery the night of opening ceremonies too! Would definitely recommend this place! read more

Pizza 23 West - Pizza Near Me - West Oneonta, New York

See all

Just had dinner here tonite Pizza was hot and tasty just the way I love it The eggplant ritolini was so good too! All this and a few drinks for the three of us for alot less than I'm used to paying in the city Highly recommend! read more

The best pizza in Oneonta!!!! The sauce is made from scratch The crust is the best crust I ever tasted on pizza. If your in Oneonta get your pizza at Pizza 23 West read more