This place is right around the corner from All-Star Star Village - Cooperstown. We enjoyed coming here on one of our last days of the trip. The food is really good and they serve breakfast all day long and that is what most of is got. My Hungry Man Dish was a good one with pancakes, couple of eggs, ham, sausage, bacon and potatoes. My son got the chicken fingers, but he unfortunately did not like/eat much of them :( They also have PEPSI products, which is the norm up in these parts. It is hard to find Coke products here in New York! Service was pretty good as well. We had to find our waitress to get our refills a couple times. However, we enjoyed our visit here and would definitely be back as they have such a huger variety of options. read more

See all

Food was meh, ambiance is meh and the owner is even more meh. Just meh all around. It's like the breakfast version of Pondos....oh wait....

I placed my order at 4:30 in the afternoon. I was waiting on my wings when I got there at five the pizza sat there on the oven for 20 minutes before they gave me my food. When I got home, I was sad to see that the wings had barely any sauce, as for the pizza the cheese did not go up all the way on the slices nor was the pizza fully cooked through. It was still very doughy. Upon calling the manager she was quite nasty she said "I think you should go to 23 West and I hope they fuck your order up." Very unprofessional. Customer service is lacking to say the least. Wings and pizza don't order from here. Don't expect to be treated as a paying patron. read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Was visiting Cooperstown and we ate here. The food is wonderful! I had the pizza and a salad,out of this world. Everyone around me enjoyed their food generous portions and great prices. Service was great too.! We also had food delivered to our air b and b house. We will definitely order and dine here again. read more

Nicks diner does it right. Portions are large, service is good and they pay attention to quality. My favorite is Crispy Chicken Bacon Hogue. read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Unfortunately the hostess and staff were very rude to our party and said they would not accommodate a table of 10. We took our business elsewhere. read more

6/25/26-Great MONSTER SIZE bacon cheeseburger & BLT. Prompt, attentive service. A very busy place for very good reasons. Try it on pace & you will be back We will be back Carl L read more

Absolutely horrible food. Owner is arrogant. Extremely slow service. Mediocre at best food. Keep an eye on children they also employ sex offenders. read more

They rip people off. We ordered $70 worth of pizza and they never made it to be delivered. Three different dashers texted to say they were refusing to make because it was busy. I was charged $70 and never received anything. When I called to address it they basically said sorry about your luck take it up with door dash. read more

I ordered food from Nick's. I ordered garbage wings, boneless and pizza large with extra cheese and pepperoni. Wings were absolutely uneditable terrible and the pizza was barely cooked and the extra cheese only went halfway up all the way around the pizza and it was I called to the girl the manager how bad it was and how unhappy I was she was less than accommodating and her actual final comment was maybe you ought to go to 23 W. and get your food and hope they fuck it up too exact quote from a professional employee who calls herself manager suggest that you do not get food garbage wings or a pizza as it is absolutely horrific and they don't honor their mistakes read more

Was just in the area and if you are too this place is a must ! The first night we all got burgers and they have a nice selection so delicious I was stuffed but couldn't stop eating it was so good. We went back on night 2 because we saw other things we wanted on the menu which has an amazing selection. I had the chicken wrap it was so good. My brother had the buffalo chicken salad and my sister the turkey we all loved our food. Wish the trip was longer so we could try more of the menu. Amazing food the staff was great you will not be sorry best food I have had in a good long while. read more

We stopped in Sunday night. Waited behind another couple waiting for a table. The waitresses walked by a few times, looked and continued working. Not once did anyone say someone will be with you shortly. We left went to another restaurant and the service couldn't be better. No only did the seat us but brought free garlic knots because everything is made from scratch and the restaurant was full read more

Ambiance had the upper walls decorated with trading baseball pins. Parking lot set up backwards, with the to go Parking further than indoor dining parking. Western burger and Nick's burger were huge and delicious and could fill up lumber jack. We tried cheese curds with Chipotle sauce and giant onion rings with barbecue sauce and both were the best you have ever tried. I hope if you're traveling to Cooperstown for vacation that will try Nick's Diner and Pizzeria out. You will love this place and your team will also!!!!! read more

ordered DoorDash my order was wrong so I called them and they said they would bring it out to me I waited and waited and it never showed up. called the next day I just wanted my order made the way I ordered it. I was called a lier and hung up on. Andrew treated me very badly. All I wanted was to be treated fairly and have my ordered fixed. They refused to make things right for me. read more

Nick's diner is the most friendly and accommodating place in Oneonta. We went in 30 minutes before closing and everybody was more than accommodating. The general manager was friendly and said I'll get you food if you come in five minutes before closing. One minute I might turn you away. He traded pins with the kids and the food was great. I would highly recommend this place to anybody coming into town for All-Star village. read more

My wife and I started going to Nick's almost two years ago, simply because we heard they had a well-liked breakfast hash. We've gone back many times since, always for breakfast, and have never been disappointed in the food or the service, both of which are generous and well-polished. The portions are very large (by my standards) and I enjoy having leftovers at home.. considering I normally get two meals' worth of food from each visit, it's pretty economical for me. Nick's is a great community food stop for locals and visitors alike. read more

Definitely a diner too! Went here for breakfast one Saturday morning, and we were not disappointed. I had the BST Omelet (Bacon, Spinach and Tomato) and my partner had French Toast with eggs and bacon. Service was top notch, food was great, so were the prices. read more

Nick's Diner deserves a boost! This is a neat and tricky place to find. My ham sandwich was badly burned, but I think I came at the end of the day and there were numerous tables dining inside and out. Happy waitress. Chefs talking liquor in the very tight kitchen. Really neat table top and a nicely placed cooler with cakes and pies. The fillings of my sandwich were tasty, but like I said the bread was left to burn *black*on the griddle. Extensive menu that includes shrimp, pasta, pizza, salad, wraps and a nice cluster of desserts and drinks. Make sure to-go orders are not left to burn. Review: 4 read more

See all

Food is good but one waitress is rude and frankly Bi***y. I ordered food hours before hand to be delivered at a certain time which is offered on the Slice app they use. 20 minutes after the time it was not there. I called she was very patronizing and rushed off the phone he should be there soon bye instead of speaking to me and listening to my concerns. I understand they're busy then don't offer a specific time. read more

Ok for lunch (fries burnt), really great for breakfast. Big portions, cheap prices and friendly faces for a good hometown diner. read more

Half way through my cup of coffee realizing my cup was dirty! Not just a little dirty like make me want to vomit dirty. Ordered a omelette with peppers and onions they tasted sour eww didn't eat my food drank enough of my coffee to see the cup was filthy. They charged me full price and asked if I wanted my food to take to go ewww. Never will I ever go back !!! I would give less then a one star if I could! read more

Breakfast was fast , good, and nice size servings .. no bs service and food. Definitely a good spot to hit for a quick meal !

Great breakfast choice while in Oneonta for baseball! Quick service too! A solid local option!

fries are bad n cheese burger tastes horrible. Fries deeply fried hard as rock . Cheeseburger , bread with meat just thrown in bun no spread no nothing. Bad bad. Told waiter, he Did nothing just charged. Horrible. read more

I will start this, as I always do by saying that I do not give out five stars, unless I am really blown away. This diner was very nice on the inside it seemed rather small outside, but it was decently large. The waiter was busing tables in the only waiter in the place he had a lot of tables and did his best to take care of everyone. He was a very good server. The food was OK nothing to write home about. We got the appetizer platter which came with onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and a couple other things. I wasn't expecting much as it's just fried food. I also had a Ruben that was pretty good, but it didn't blow my mind. I will definitely eat here again and give it another try as I saw some other food that came out that looked really good. Overall, it was a good dining experience, and I will return. read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - Reuben Sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Hello, The staff were great and the food was amazing! Exactly what we were looking for. Spaghetti with meatballs, hungry man breakfast, cheese burgers, etc.... Everything we ordered was delicious! We ate here at least 5 times in the week we were in town. Great place to have some great food! Thank you for your hospitality and friendliness! read more

Amazing service and food. After a long week of 12u baseball we stopped in after checking out and was provided excellent service, large portions, and great tasting food. read more

See all

Really good Dinner food!! They cover everything. From pizza to breakfast all day. No problem parking.

We took our whole baseball team here, we also came back a second time. I got the gluten free Rueben, yummy. Whatever the heaven that gluten free bread is the best I have ever had. The French toast looked dreamy and everyone raved about it! The second time I got breakfast and it was also yummy. Going with a crowd you will always overwhelm the kitchen, have patience and they get the food out as fast as they can. It's worth a few extra minutes of waiting! If you need gluten free this is a safe place for you! read more

Everything is always delicious. One of my favorite places. Great Staff. Breakfast or dinner read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - Hamburger - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

I've had the French dip sandwich a few times and it was always very good made with ribeye steak This time I got a steak-umm sandwich on soggy bread with cold fries soaked in oil when I asked for chips, I couldn't even eat it. I'm very disappointed because I always craved this sandwich but I'll never go back. Not only was the food bad, the floors were filthy and the cook kept swearing read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - I ordered the French dip sandwich made with thinly sliced ribeye and fries, I got a steak-umm sandwich and soggy fries - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

In town for CASV and decided to give Nicks a try. Not going to lie the yelp reviews did scare me a bit. But I do like to be my own judge so I decided whatever what's the worst that can happen. Glad we tried it because we LOVED Nicks! We went three times in the week that we visited. The burgers and sandwich I had were so good. No one in my party had a complaint. The service was really fast every time we were there. We probably would have been there more had our trip been longer. If we're ever in Oneonta again we'll definitely stop by. read more

See all

We were there with a very large group of children and parents. Nick's diner probably doesn't get a full house in the early morning on a weekday since there was only one waiter and one chef working. I just want to say thank you for taking care of us. I know it is really difficult to accommodate a party of 30+ people at one time. We really appreciate your service. Now the food. This is what we ordered! Country Fried Steak - The dish came with a steak, scrambled eggs (my choice), biscuits, potatoes, and sausages. The beef had a nice layer of breadcrumb. It had a nice crunchy texture on the outside and tender on the inside. The beef was so tender that I could cut it with a butter knife. The sausage, I've never had a breakfast sausage like this before. It was juicy and flavorful. The biscuit was airy and fluffy. The real star of this dish was the gravy. It was rich, creamy, and aromatic but not overwhelming the base flavor. It complimented the beef and biscuit really well while elevating the entire dish. French Toast Platter - It came with french toasts, scrambled eggs, potatoes, and sausages. I love the french toast here. It was thick but fluffy. It was custardy on the inside with buttery crispy edges. Personally, I didn't even need syrup! Again, props to the waiter who was taking orders, running the food, providing service and props to the chef who was preparing the food all by themselves. We really appreciated it! Hopefully, I'll have a chance to come back here again. read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - French Toast with Home Fries - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

French toast with homemade bread was awesome. Veggie wrap was awesome, according to my friend. Home fries could have been better. Service was great. The ambiance was cool - still kinda felt like a railcar, and they have 100s of baseball pins along the wall. read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - French toast with sausage and over easy eggs. - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Went here twice so far in our week of being at All Star Village. The waitress is SO sweet! Food is amazing!! Best Calzone I have ever had! A hidden GEM! Will def be back! read more

Had the seafood platter, fish, shrimp and clams were fried perfectly. Also ordered mozzarella sticks, absolutely amazing 10/10. Can't wait to try this place again. read more

Nick's Diner & Pizzeria - Mozzarella Cheese Sticks - Pizza Near Me - Oneonta, New York

This is an amazing place! It started as a train car and built on. It opened in 1927, and the quality of the food and service is better than most! This is THE PLACE TO BE IN ONEONTA N.Y! Enjoy the classic atmosphere too. This isn't just pizza, Breakfast to dinner! Their Senior menu has nice size portions too! read more

This diner had one of the biggest menus. I ordered the cheeseburger and it was spot on. The window said it was the best burger in town and I would have to agree. Went during the week so it wasn't busy but I imagine on the weekend this place would be packed. 5 out of 5 would recommend read more

We love the food here! The only problem is when you go to order wings you can expect to only get one order of wings because they give out your order to the quickest DoorDash member As well as charge you an eat in tax for pick up 3$ so I'm very disappointed with the service here this has happened to me on more than one occasion and I have not been reimbursed for ANYTHING my credit card has also been used for tips from here. I'm not the only person this has happened to. read more

That was some response to my recent review. we were nothing but polite to our waitress, , who said she was indeed the manager. Not one guest knew we were totally disappointed with our meals and service. Your nasty remark about reading the menu is also out of line. why don't you take a picture of the Greek Salad description so your guests can see it in your response to me.It does not indicate it's a spinach salad with plain black olives. I was expecting an apology and please try us again. I guess your waitress/ manager was trained by you . read more