This is one of the cornerstone businesses in this town. The owners are gracious and decent and…read moretreat all their customers like family. They work hard to make your experience there positive. A good measure of Nina's, aside from the greet food, is the fact their staff has been with them for years. If you are looking for good food and a familiar, home feel, spend some time there: you won't regret it! -Mark

I like their pepperoni rolls, they're cheesy and huge! However the chicken Caesar salad was not a…read moretypical chicken Caesar salad. It was chicken salad plopped on top leaf lettuce with carrots. Super disappointed. It looked completely unappetizing. I honestly wouldn't have been surprised to find raisins in the chicken salad too lmaoo. I wish I had checked the reviews before ordering. I ordered on the phone and they said 30 mins for just the salad... I arrive 30 minutes later and the doors are locked, I made eye contact with someone inside and waited till I pointed at my phone to let me in the spot. I did notice they closed at 8 but I was there before 8 and I thought they were expecting me considering they told me to be there in 30 minutes.

Great food. New York style pizza didn't disappoint. Whenever I'm Oneonta, I'll go back!read more

We were in Vermont and ran into a family and they told us that they were Oneonta, NY. We said that…read morewe were headed to The Hall of Fame and they recommended we stop at Tino's. I am so glad we did. The staff was super friendly and they gave us some great suggestions. I was shocked to hear about the cold cheese pizza. It was really good. We will definitely go back when in New York again.

We took a pit stop in Oneonta, because it is where I graduated college from in 2011. I have many…read morefond memories of eating pizza from Sals, although it was often at 2am. Sals is a classic small college town pizzeria. Sals employees have always been consistently friendly. You have to try the Cold Cheese pizza, it's an Oneonta specialty and even though it's simple no one else can replicate it.

This was our most delicious fast-casual meal of our week in Oneonta for CASV. The service was very…read morefriendly, especially because the menu was extensive and we needed guidance on the best items to order. We shared the mozzarella sticks as an appetizer and they were good. My husband and son each had the meatball parmigiana sub and it was HUGE! They definitely could have split it, but we were happy to have leftovers. I had a slice of veggie pizza with a dollop of goat cheese and it was really tasty. They gave us garlic knots to try for free just to be nice ;) and that was an added bonus. We all recommend this restaurant and appreciate their kindness!

This place was amazing! We went on Easter Sunday and had reservations for 5. They sat us right away…read moreand service was great especially for the place being packed. We didn't walk up to the front but I heard people were going to sit at the bar. Good draft beer selection and wine and cocktails. Great rotating food menu. I had the bolognese and it was the best I ever had! Focaccia bread was delish! My husband had. A pizza that he said was amazing as well. Prices were a little expensive for small portions but I would definitely go again! You pay for the delicious food and good service! My kids had the shrimp pasta and hanger steak. They both loved their meals too!

The best restaurant in our part of the state, hands down. Food is always perfect - amazing flavors,…read morewell cooked, gorgeous presentation. Love the space, and thanks staff is the best. So grateful to have them in Oneonta.

The best pizza in Oneonta!!!! The sauce is made from scratch…read more The crust is the best crust I ever tasted on pizza. If your in Oneonta get your pizza at Pizza 23 West

Pizza was reasonably good for outside of NYC (I ordered takeout and the food was ready at exactly…read morethe promised time) but I ordered wings to go with the pizza under the impression they were REAL wings (the full menu accessible via YELP does not indicate they are boneless balls of 'breaded chicken meat') and we were super disappointed with them. That is what brought this review down from 4 stars to 2 stars

Usually get takeout. The pizza is the best in town! Also love the eggplant parm. Always our go to…read moreplace for pizza!

Ordered a pizza for take out. Fantastic pizza as a whole. Cooked through, not burned, generous…read moretoppings, crispy crust.

Always Get a Medium thin Crust Pizza with Extra cheese Perfect Two Day meal, 20OZ Diet Coke always…read moreis Good! Really should be top Rated But one Bad Rating pulls it down alot. Eat at home cause I'm disabled and don't drive.

I love our Oneonta Domino's! Hear me out: we all know that Domino's isn't authentic pizza. But it's…read moredang good Americanized pizza! Always fresh and delivered piping hot, Domino's is a guilty pleasure. We have never gotten a bad meal either.

What a cozy place, a small place with a wide selection of food and beverages. This is what I…read moreordered! House buffalo chicken wings - The size of the wing was quite large. It was definitely great value for its price. The wing was perfectly fried. The meat was tender and the skin was crispy while coated nicely with the buffalo sauce. I don't usually get buffalo sauce, but since it was homemade, I had to try it. Let me tell you, this is one of my favorite sauces now. The buffalo sauce was tangy with a kick. The sauce wasn't overpowering at all. It had a well-rounded flavor. Cubano Sandwich - The sandwich was enough to share between 2 people. The bread was airy with a nice toasted crust. Everything in the sandwich was laid beautifully. It had a great ratio between the meat, the vegetable, and the sauce. However, I think there was a bit too much mustard. The mustard was overpowering the rest of the flavor. All and all, the food here was really good. I paired my meal with a pint. It was perfect. The service was also really great. If you enjoy bar food and beer, I recommend this place!

Very disappointed with my order like everything else, price went up and quality went downread more

Definitely a diner too!…read more Went here for breakfast one Saturday morning, and we were not disappointed. I had the BST Omelet (Bacon, Spinach and Tomato) and my partner had French Toast with eggs and bacon. Service was top notch, food was great, so were the prices.

Nicks diner does it right. Portions are large, service is good and they pay attention to quality…read more My favorite is Crispy Chicken Bacon Hogue.

Had an issue with our pie the first time we ordered from them but I brought it to their attention…read morewhen I decided to give them a 2nd chance at redemption and Chef Jordan made it right. Pizza was great and I'm ordering again tonight. Thanks Jordan!

Reviewed before but have to say something. They recently started doing barbecue on Sundays. I…read morewasn't expecting it to be as good as it was as all we had ever tried were pizza and knots. While they did overcharge slightly as the pulled pork was ten with a side ie the dinner should've just been normal price which was a extra five but they charged us eighteen dollars. Still amazing though.