While visiting Oneonta for a baseball tournament, several locals recommended both Nina's and…read moreTino's. Unfortunately, we never made it to Tino's, but Nina's absolutely lived up to the hype. The pizza slices were outstanding. You could immediately taste the quality of the ingredients. The sauce was flavorful and complemented the high-quality mozzarella perfectly. Every bite delivered that classic stretch and pull of fresh cheese, making for a truly satisfying slice. As good as the pizza was, the service impressed us even more. The staff was friendly, attentive, and genuinely focused on making sure we had everything we needed. If you're in Oneonta, hether for baseball, sightseeing, or just passing through, Nina's is definitely worth a stop. Great pizza, quality ingredients, and exceptional service make it an easy recommendation.

Pizza was delicious and portion sizes were good. Prices add up fast the more in the partyread more

Highly recommend this establishment. The food is delicious and the people are so friendly and…read morewelcoming. They also have some cools pins to trade if you're in town for the Cooperstown baseball tournaments! Thank you, Your customers who came all the way from Sacramento, CA!

I walked into Tinos unsure of my expectations but they were beyond met!…read more I tried a plain cheese slice to taste the base which was delicious. There was no overload on sauce it wasn't sweet and the crust was delicious!! Next I tried a buffalo chicken slice (my favorite) and it was SO GOOD!! I got a side of ranch with it which basically just topped it all off! Bit pricey per slice I will say but I'd definitely be back to order more pizza if I'm ever looking for something quick!! (They served me within 5 minutes) Everyone was so nice while ringing me up! Good vibes good people! Delicious pizza! (So far I'd rank tinos high for pizza in Oneonta based on the other places I've tried)

We took a pit stop in Oneonta, because it is where I graduated college from in 2011. I have many…read morefond memories of eating pizza from Sals, although it was often at 2am. Sals is a classic small college town pizzeria. Sals employees have always been consistently friendly. You have to try the Cold Cheese pizza, it's an Oneonta specialty and even though it's simple no one else can replicate it.

This was our most delicious fast-casual meal of our week in Oneonta for CASV. The service was very…read morefriendly, especially because the menu was extensive and we needed guidance on the best items to order. We shared the mozzarella sticks as an appetizer and they were good. My husband and son each had the meatball parmigiana sub and it was HUGE! They definitely could have split it, but we were happy to have leftovers. I had a slice of veggie pizza with a dollop of goat cheese and it was really tasty. They gave us garlic knots to try for free just to be nice ;) and that was an added bonus. We all recommend this restaurant and appreciate their kindness!

Absolutely INCONCEIVABLE how amazing this place is! We…read morerecently stayed in the area for a youth baseball tournament in Cooperstown and ended up eating here THREE nights in a row--that is how phenomenal it is. The food is incredible. The owner and chef is immensely talented, serving up fresh, farm-to-table dishes. Because everything is so fresh, the specifics change nightly, but everything we ordered was a huge win. The beef carpaccio was dynamite, and the Prosciutto Pizza, house-made focaccia bread, "farm goodies," bolognese, hangar steak, and caprese ravioli were all absolutely delicious. You can taste the quality and care in every single bite. (Sorry no pics...we were too busy eating!) Beyond the stellar food, the cocktail menu is an absolute blast. They have a whole lineup of delicious, creative craft drinks with "The Princess Bride" themed names! Trying the different drinks became half the fun of our dinners. What truly sets this place apart, though, is the service. We had a server named Beth whom we absolutely loved. By the third night, she knew exactly what my daughter wanted to drink as soon as we sat down! The owners and the entire staff are warm, welcoming, and treat you like family. If you are anywhere near Oneonta or Cooperstown, do yourself a huge favor and eat here. We will definitely be back the next time we are in town!

We moved out of our comfort zone to try a farm to table restaurant. It was a beautiful old house…read moreturned into a restaurant. We didn't have a reservation but went at 5:20 and they seated us. It did get busy, so if going - make one. Menu is a one page printed list of items for starters , entrée and other items. We ordered good glass of wine and started with some pastry filled items that were tasty. Focaccia bread was fresh and tasty. My husband ordered the steak which was grilled, and was so crispy on outside he couldn't eat it. He was just going to buck up and eat something he wasn't enjoying, until the manger came by and asked how things were? He told her it was too done on outside. Inside was pink and tender but the black outside - he just wasn't going for it... so she immediately said we will do another and put it in the oven. It came out great! Fingerlings and Brussels sprouts were a great side. I ordered the fried chicken- which was kinda a hot honey crispy delight. Tender, fresh and juicy. Served with a large piece of cornbread and green beans. We were full when time to pay, which was a little pricy, but with wine and appetizer was average for a good meal out- and this one was so fresh and creative. When in town- a nice evening. It's kinda close inside, so a bit noisy, but overall I recommend it as the service we received was the best of our road trip.

Traveling from other states away. Very welcoming and attentive staff. Enjoyed the NY style…read morepepperoni pizza with two friends. There was a variety of beers served. I would seek them out again just for the nice people on staff on Sunday and of course the pizza.

We had a large team gathering while in for Cooperstown and the place was GREAT! We had called ahead…read moreand got everything set up for our whole team and all the parents. We probably took up most of the restaurant and they had pizza, salad, wings, and knots. Their pizza is New York style and REALLY good. They provided more than enough food and we had plenty for take home. If you are coming in town this is a perfect place to have authentic New York pies!!!

Despite its name and its unappealing facade, this is, hands down, the best pizza you will ever…read morehave!!!! Absolutely amazing!!!! Only wish we lived closer so we could experience it again and again! If you're going to be at Cooperstown All Star Village, definitely stop here! It's just around the corner, reasonably priced and soooooo delicious!!!!

Ordered a pizza for take out. Fantastic pizza as a whole. Cooked through, not burned, generous…read moretoppings, crispy crust.

I love our Oneonta Domino's! Hear me out: we all know that Domino's isn't authentic pizza. But it's…read moredang good Americanized pizza! Always fresh and delivered piping hot, Domino's is a guilty pleasure. We have never gotten a bad meal either.

Always Get a Medium thin Crust Pizza with Extra cheese Perfect Two Day meal, 20OZ Diet Coke always…read moreis Good! Really should be top Rated But one Bad Rating pulls it down alot. Eat at home cause I'm disabled and don't drive.

Really good sandwiches and homemade chips, along with friendly customer service. I'm glad I found…read morethis spot downtown. Note that the higher-priced sandwiches are larger portions that can easily be shared, and they also come with fries. The staff at Wise Guys is warm and welcoming, making you feel like family from the moment you walk in. One minor note is that the draft beer selection is a bit limited. 10/10, would recommend

The person working the counter was nice. But my chicken sandwich came out super raw. They also…read moreforgot my friend's sandwich completely.

This place is right around the corner from All-Star Star Village - Cooperstown. We enjoyed coming…read morehere on one of our last days of the trip. The food is really good and they serve breakfast all day long and that is what most of is got. My Hungry Man Dish was a good one with pancakes, couple of eggs, ham, sausage, bacon and potatoes. My son got the chicken fingers, but he unfortunately did not like/eat much of them :( They also have PEPSI products, which is the norm up in these parts. It is hard to find Coke products here in New York! Service was pretty good as well. We had to find our waitress to get our refills a couple times. However, we enjoyed our visit here and would definitely be back as they have such a huger variety of options.

Food was meh, ambiance is meh and the owner is even more meh. Just meh all around. It's like the…read morebreakfast version of Pondos....oh wait....