Absolutely fantastic--fresh, delicious, and not overpriced. This is the best-tasting food you'll find in Oneonta. Try it for yourself, and you won't be able to say I'm wrong--it's not going to happen! It's like eating a meal made by your grandmother, and the people are as nice as you could ever hope for. read more

Got takeout and it was a ton of food for the price. Salad was freshly cut, fries were still crispy and hot, and the mixed chicken and lamb shawarma were both tender and nicely cooked. Sauce was great. Not fancy but that wasn't what I needed on a late work night! read more

LOVE LOVE LOVE their Gyro fries! Packed with flavored, loaded with meat and covered with sauce. Great value, fast and filling! Really good quality fries, takeout never disappoints! (been 5+ times) Keep up the good work! read more

Nice food here. We only had a collection of apps as we passed through. Good falafel. The place is small and we almost missed it, but don't let the modest building dissuade you. read more

In a plain house sits a hidden treasure. Star delivers a range of Mediterranean food for anyone who likes to take a risk. The food is great and all of my family found something they enjoyed, even my child with a dairy and egg allergy. There was a steady stream of regulars who kept coming for pick up. That is a really good sign. The food was too good looking, I ate it before I could take a picture. read more

I am in love with this place. Excellent food and reasonably priced. Great service, not really a sit down place as most customers do take out. Ok atmosphere. read more

This place ain't much to look at but offers top notch Greek gyros and Philly cheesesteaks. We ate here 2x as a family while in Oneonta for Cooperstown Village baseball tournament. Prices are reasonable and service was quick. It's an excellent choice when you don't want to do full sit down restaurant or get it to go. read more

I remember when star mix was opening how exciting it was to get a new cuisine to the area. There's absolutely nothing like it anywhere near us. The gyros are spot on, and a good deal. I recommend the lamb gyro. I have gotten the chicken platter before, and was not a fan of the rice, lacked seasoning in my opinion. The family that runs this place is nothing but kind, and speedy with service. I have worked Doordash in the past, and they are always quick and ready with their orders. Will continue to be a loyal customer. read more

So good !!! Delicious !!! I would highly recommend this family run food establishment ! read more

Small little place that's definitely busy. Maybe 5 tables in this small restaurant. One outside. We grabbed a lamb gyro. Never had green peppers before, so not a fan and definitely well done and dry. My husband got the falafel. He liked his. Split a Greek salad. It was ok. Basically a tossed salad with black olives, and cubes of feta. Spinach pie was a disappointment. The grape leaves were good ! Something different. read more

Star mix Oneonta - Spinach pie - Mediterranean Near Me - Oneonta, New York

See all

I had the Lamb Gyro. Excellent, perfectly seasoned and a generous portion. Service was quick.

Hungry between baseball games at Cooperstown All Star Village and sick of bbq and fast food so we hit this place - so glad we did. Food was great - gyro, fried zucchini and lamb kabobs - all super tasty. Friendly service and gave helpful local tips. read more

Star mix Oneonta - Lamb kabob cooked to order medium. - Mediterranean Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Great food at a reasonable price. Always friendly service. Clean seating area. Definitely try the lamb gyro.

Coming from Ithica to Upton and wanted something different from traditional bar food. The owners are very nice. The food was delicious and everything was fresh. The gyro was well seasoned and delicious. The beef shwarma with rice was exactly what I was looking for. The baklava was not too sweet and perfectly delicate. They were out of spinach pie but I got to watch the wife make it from scratch. I bet it's delicious as the owner said it's VERY popular. I could see why, she was so careful with all of the steps and their feta cheese was delicious so I could only imagine.l the spinach pie. Very small seating area but they do have a picnic table outside. Not too far from the highway. read more

Food is OK however, service is not very friendly. Definitely wouldn't eat in to waste the tip.

The food here is amazing, fresh, healthy, cooked to order, the staff are nice, the portions are a good size, there is parking. So don't look any further. They were also super nice and split a gyros dinner into two containers for my children, and added the sauces on the side. I had the Kofka, it was amazing, they even cooked it medium well instead of well done for me. I want to try the lamb chops next time (and there will be a next time). read more

Best dinner in Oneonta In Oneonta for a week of baseball. Rain delay at 8:15 pm on a Sunday night. Not much open & came across this treasure. Greeted with a warm welcome and a menu. I ordered the chicken shawarma with rice. Plate was overflowing with goodness. Chicken was tender and tasty. Rice was nice and moist. A fresh side salad was also included. More food then I could eat. Leftovers for lunch the next day. A very nice family run the restaurant. read more

Star mix Oneonta - Chicken shawarma with rice. - Mediterranean Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Amazing food. There is a separate vegetarian/vegan menu, to ask for. The staff was really nice. I must remember to return in the future. Get the falafel anything and sweet potato fries! read more

This place was by far my favorite place to eat in Oneonta! It's a small restaurant so most of the time I ordered for pick up. The owners are so kind and generous. I never waited more than 10 minutes for my food, and it was DELICIOUS!!! Perfect meal for a college student, and their prices are respectable! I have spent the last two years searching for a pita that is even comparable to how good the ones from here are, and I have been unsuccessful. The secret is the tzatziki sauce they use!!! SO GOOD! Highly highly highly recommend. read more

Tiny place with big flavor. Don't go here for the atmosphere - the dining area is small - go for the great food and reasonable prices. The lamb gyro is amazing. Tender meat packed with flavor, rolled into a warm pita. The falafel is crispy on the outside and soft and savory inside. Add a bucket of tzatziki and you will be in heaven. I would go here every day if I lived in town. Except Monday. I think they are closed Monday. read more

Proud to review this place first: BEST LUNCH IN ONEONTA HANDS DOWN. Totally blown away by the prices, quality, flavor and service. Lunch under $8. Sauce comes out for free. Best lamb gyro I have ever had. Delicious original crepe sandwiches. This place will blow up for sure. read more

Star mix Oneonta - Mediterranean Near Me - Oneonta, New York

I saw that they had the best lamb...you ain't kidding! This place is so awesome. I had the lamb wrap and it was the best gyro meat I have ever had. So so good! Huge portions, great prices! I also suggest the Greek salad and pitas garlic cheese bread. read more

The food is great but a little salty but the staff is so friendly and helpful .they also listen how you want your food and the staff does the food the way you desire it. read more

This is a small place with just a few tables in an older building that looks like a former house. If not for the positive Yelp reviews, I definitely would have never stopped, and I probably would have walked out after looking inside. It is dated and not very clean looking or attractive inside, but I was just interested in grabbing a gyro to go. The mixed gyro (chicken and beef) was really flavorful with a nice ratio of seasoned meat and crisp vegetables. The price ($6.99 I think) was certainly reasonable and the sandwich was tasty. 4 stars for the food, 1 star for the ambiance. read more

Good gyro meat - moist and generous serving size. Was able to get a double serving of salad instead of rice or fries to try to stay healthy. read more

Went here for lunch the other day while my truck was getting new tires. Had the lamb gyro, omg so good, and huge. So tonight when thinking about dinner and realizing everything in the house was frozen decided to give another try. Tonight I ordered the Oneonta Mix platter because it had so much on it but the lamb. Chicken, super moist and tasty. Beef, omg tasty. Kofta, super tasty and large. Rice very good. Salad, amazing. White sauce, I'm in love with this stuff. Oh, Pita bread, super good too. This is my new favorite place in Oneonta. I'll be back, often. Quality and portions are excellent, tastes amazing, excellent value. Highly recommended read more

I got to say I have been to this place meny times and never been let down once. They have many stuff on your menu for vegetarians and for us meat lovers there's a lot of good choices the lamb is really good chickens got great marinade I highly recommend this place to anyone that's flying by and want some great Mediterranean food read more

Quick service place with four tables. Don't let the looks of the place fool you, the food is delicious! read more

Star mix Oneonta - Lamb Gyro - Mediterranean Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Correction I really didnt know there there was a different sauce. I'm a tzatziki fan,didnt know that you Just have to ask for it by name on that note my review needs an adjustment. Great food and I will be coming back for traditional greek sauce. Thanks for the info! read more

Star mix Oneonta - The tzatziki sauce needs alot of help sort of taste like ranch. . your greek you should know how to make a good cucumber sauce. - Mediterranean Near Me - Oneonta, New York

Very good middle-eastern food, especially considering that it is in Oneonta. The lentil soup and the hummus are both standouts. I also like the falafel. Warning: the pitas are made with a kind of a generic lettuce and tomato with mayonaisse-y white sauce accompaniment, so they are a little disappointing if you are used to eating Lebanese (etc) food in cities that have more options (or even in Rhinebeck!). But the chicken and lamb is good. All in all, I am very glad they are here. read more

The owners are one of a kind, friendly, always smiling and greeting customers. And the food is so rich and so delicious so Otentic. And the spot is always clean and very easy accessible for anybody even people are in wheelchairs. Price is very low foe the quality of the food . One of my favorite spot in town hands down. read more

The chicken and lamb mix wrap was perfect. Tasted great, put together nicely and easy to eat!

Our family was on vacation and stopped by Star Mix one of the first days, it was great. The employees were so nice and food was awesome! We loved it so much we went back again on the same vacation. Definitely recommend. read more

The Gyro is the best in the region. I love their lamb and white sauce, and will alternate between ordering the Lamb Gyro and the Lamb Platter. The family that runs the place are very welcoming. I always recommend to my friends and warn people new to town not to judge the exterior of the building. The best food in Oneonta comes out of this little converted house-turned restaurant. read more

This is a hidden gem! The owners are lovely and beyond accommodating. The gyros are delicious. I'm sad I just tried it after being in town so long. You must go!!!! Incredible prices for the fresh food. read more

Was not a fan of the food here. Got a Greek salad. Was bland. Not sure what else to say. read more

I can't believe I didn't know about this place sooner!!! Great food at such a low price, it's a hidden gem. I was just there again today and got a falafel appetizer (5-6 pieces) & a gyro for $10. Awesome for takeout, but if you want to dine in, they have a couple of little tables. This is one of those amazing "hole in the wall" places (which are usually the best places!) 10/10 recommend, love star mix!! read more

Love love love it here! Great food- good service. Did I mention great food? The gyros are great - Greek salad a home fun! read more

Very small place but huge flavor!!! An absolute must try!!! Best gyro ever, meat was very tender ..

This is fast becoming my favorite place to eat. The food is delicious with a good variety of American and Greek items. The service is great and the owners are very friendly and welcoming. For authentic Greek food this is the place to go! read more