Cancel

Open app

Search

Cosmo's Pizza

3.2 (55 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

Cosmo's Pizza Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Cosmo's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Meghan T.

I dont know if it was because I came here after a hike or something but it was one of the tastiest pizzas. We made a cosume pie with mushroom, pep, sausage, and basil (which it couldve done without because the basil ended up wilting anyway).

They have real sprite
Mir C.

The workers are very nice and it is always very clean but when you walk in the door it smells too much like Lysol lemon scented cleaning spray. cosmos on baseline is so much better because it's so stinky when you walk in so maybe if they made this one stinkier I'd like it more

THIS is pie/pizza by the slice. You know that scene in the Goofy Movie with the pizza slice? Yeah thats Cosmo's. This is the kind of pizza I envision when it's friday night and I need something to pair with my Coors Banquets. Real pizza for real people.

Pizza
Maritza S.

THIS WAS AMAZING. We come from texas so after a 16hr drive this definitely made everything worth it.

Greek veggie but I added a bunch of stuff and changed everything
Frankie C.

Well back in college I visited a friend in Fort Collins once for a long weekend. Yes, you know what i'm going to say. We ate some pizza from this cosmo and I guess the spicy ranch stuck with me. Thousands of years later my partner and I are checking out Boulder and we needed a lunchdinner. We were famished and happy. After accidentally ending up in the college restaurant area of this town surrounded by scary loud boys i ditched all my hopes and dreams of getting some sort of veggie tales dish and said let's just get a pizza and get out of this loud boy area. That's exactly what we did. At first I couldn't remember what this place is called ... Carlos pizza... Colins pizza... capricorn pizza I don't know... spicy ranch ...COSMOS PIZZA ! That's what it is. Well five stars because it's pretty good and I added a bunch of stuff and swapped and the whole nine yards on my pozza and they got it all right. Also. They are not wimps on the sauce. You get a real serving of the ranch. Thank you cosmo and thank you to the cosmos for this linner. It was great to get away from those terrifying young men and end up in the cosmos with some spicy ranch after all this time. God bless

Coming from Houston with my family and we all enjoyed this huge pizza we were all stuffed and the spicy ranch was amazing, will definitely come back again one of the best pizzas I've ever tasted!!

a hand holding a piece of pizza
Mountain M.

Entire pie was burnt on the bottom. Ovens should be cleaned daily this is completely unacceptable. I threw the whole pie away because my dogs wouldn't even eat it! Wasted $30 and my kids are still starving.

Mediterranean veggie pizza slice.
Michelle H.

Came here after climbing at the nearby Movement Gym - one Mediterranean pizza slice w/ the SPICY RANCH (of course) really hit the spot. Don't even bother thinking you will be able to share one spicy ranch - just get one per person. Definitely would return again after a hike in the Flat Irons or another climbing session at the gym.

cheese pizza with some "oh yeah that happens" bits, apparently
Taylor J.

bit into my pizza, and found burnt charcoal pieces of other crust stuck to the bottom of my slice. i called and all they said was "oh yeah that happens." no apology, just a refund of this one slice. and this was after i already didn't get the spicy ranch i'd asked for in my original order, and they were not helpful on the phone then! no dinner for me tonight, won't be eating this for sure. the way i was talked to on the phone the second time was bad enough to come here and write this review. i bit into something that, frankly, doesn't look all that sanitary and their attitude was as if this was just a normal occurrence. i have been eating cosmos for years but this here is straight up not good pizza. why i'm really here tho is because their reaction to it was even more upsetting. they did not care that they are serving food like this!!! tldr check your crust, because this just "happens sometimes" at cosmos, leaving you shit out of luck with no appetite

See all

Photo of Sarah M.
101
12
0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Mary H.
209
9
0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Amazing pizza! Even more friendly and dedicated staff! Don't go anywhere else for pizza! All the workers deserve the highest tips!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of J B.
0
5
0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tommy W.
152
20
1

8 years ago

Helpful 3
Thanks 0
Love this 5
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Cosmo's Pizza

What's with the polar reviews here? A friend of mine recommended this place & their spicy ranch. Any Yelp elites care to chime in?

Great question, I’d look at what time most negative posts occur. I think you’ll see that a large portion of them come after 2am. Being open late is definitely a part of Cosmo’s. However, it’s not always easy to please everyone late night.

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Review Highlights - Cosmo's Pizza

“I have been going here for years, and even during COVID, I was always treated great.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Flower Child

Flower Child

4.4(388 reviews)
1.2 mi
•$$
Healthy dining
Gluten-free friendly

Excellent food. Solid ambiance. They have recently changed how people go about getting food from…read morethem, so the line area is strangely blocked off. But I'd go back any time. Love their teas and they variety of healthy options. A Flower Child is opening in my area of the KC metro - my family and I are SO excited to have one in the neighborhood!

The friend I had lunch with today is vegan, and she suggested this place. It's loud and rather…read morestark, but inside is air-conditioned, which was needed in this 100-degree day. However, there were people sitting on their outside patio. Hardy folks, I guess! My friend was nursing a sore tummy, so she just had some grilled veggies and mashed potatoes. She loves everything she's had here. It was my first time. I ordered the chicken bowl with yakisoba noodles. It was lukewarm, but that's fine for me. I think they must have microwaved it because it was steamier as you ate down the bowl. The veggies were crisp, the noodles perfect, the chicken was tender. It was spiced at what I'd call a medium level, and quite yummy. My friend then ordered their vegan chocolate pudding, which we shared. Yummy and light. My one big criticism is that they charge $4 for iced tea. I questioned it and the cashier was kind of snippy about it, but the customer behind me approached after I dispensed my tea and said she agreed it's too expensive. The meal was appropriately priced and there is plenty of food, but the drinks? C'mon. It's worth maybe $2.50. They really should reevaluate that. It's the main reason that I gave the place 4 stars instead of 5. The other people who work there were nice and helpful. I didn't grab a fork but the server who brought my bowl cheerfully went and got me a fork and napkin. Very nice. It's obviously popular, it filled up as we sat, with quite a variety of people, from babies to seniors. I might go back, but perhaps next time I'll just get water. I hope they don't charge for that!

Photos
Flower Child
Flower Child
Flower Child

See all

Boychik - Boulder - Falafel plate

Boychik - Boulder

4.5(72 reviews)
1.3 mi•Downtown

I came here with my friend and his son on a Saturday afternoon…read more I wasnt too hungry yet as I had a good breakfast and did a very minor hike/stroll around Chautauqua Park so only wanted something light to munch on. Boychik sells Mediterranean style food and when I saw what was on their menu, I knew exactly I wanted to eat here. I lovr Mediterranean style dips, I could eat this everyday. I chose the 3 dip option and got muhummara, babaganoush and whipped feta and asked for two servings of veggie and one serving of pita. Portion size was massive so I am glad I shared with my friends. My favorite was the muhummara, that was so good and my buddy was also like wow this is sooo good!! Babaganoush was ok for me and whipped feta didnt work for me. Veggies were great and the pita was the soft, pillowy ones, which I love! Staff were helpful and order came up quick. Guy ringing me up also told me that upstairs they have plates and cutlery so no need to have my dips wrapped to-go. Overall, great food here, take it upstairs and enjoy the views! I'd definitely come back again!

Located in Avanti Food Hall, Boychik offers the typical Mediterranean options. We ordered chicken…read moreshawarma wrap, lamb gyro and shared a falafel plate as appetizer. While the portion is pretty decent, the price is slightly higher than other fast casual Mediterranean spots. The meats in the wrap were juicy and tender, the overall flavor was solid. I'm actually pretty impressed by the falafel. The falafel tasted very fresh, crunchy on the outside, moist, airy and crumby on the inside. I'd definitely come back for some falafel when I'm in town again!

Photos
Boychik - Boulder
Boychik - Boulder - Lamb Hummus Bowl | Instagram: @telephonesmoothie

Lamb Hummus Bowl | Instagram: @telephonesmoothie

Boychik - Boulder

See all

Leaf Vegetarian Restaurant - Chilaquiles

Leaf Vegetarian Restaurant

4.2(712 reviews)
1.1 mi•Whittier
•$$

my partner and I have had many a delicious meal here, they have many well thought out dishes…read morepresented nicely. menu often has some staples for a while, but still changes up their offerings seasonally for some entrees/smaller plates/deserts and definitely cocktails! we have loved everything we have tried here, and it's so nice to have the peace of mind of eating vegetarian or vegan without constantly questioning if an ingredient is hiding in the dish that is not. servers have a always been lovely and accommodating, and everything has always been well-seasoned! highly recommend overall!

The worst service I've ever experienced in my life... I had the young brunette girl today and 2.5…read morehours total for a basic lunch!!! She never checked on us. Took order once and that's it. I had to keep flagging her down for plates, water, silverware... and all we ordered was two meals and one appetizer... and to be honest, we barely ate any of the food. It wasn't even good. She was standing around not doing anything too. I was trying to take my mom to a nice lunch and we both were so incredibly upset with how horrible this waitress was... and then paying expensive food that wasn't even Tasty was just a cherry on top ugh. I used to love this place. I used to come all the time but every time I come lately it's just getting worse and worse. It's really too bad I won't be back for a long time. Hopefully they get new server and work on the food more

Photos
Leaf Vegetarian Restaurant - Indoor outdoor seating

Indoor outdoor seating

Leaf Vegetarian Restaurant - Peanut crunch salad

Peanut crunch salad

Leaf Vegetarian Restaurant - Large Farm Summer Salad

See all

Large Farm Summer Salad

The Kitchen American Bistro - Black Spaghetti, pink shrimp, nduja, fennel, citrus, bread crumb

The Kitchen American Bistro

4.1(1.1k reviews)
1.5 mi•Central Boulder
•$$

Looooved our brunch at The Kitchen! We walked in with no reservation at around 11:30 and were able…read moreto snag a table right away. The space is cozy and bright. I loved the big chandeliers and brick wall. Our server, Skylar, was fantastic. She was personable, welcoming, and enhanced the entire dining experience. My friend and I started with the churro donuts to share. These were the perfect sweet treat (because who can have brunch without something sweet for the table?) It comes with a dulce de leche and a coffee anglaise that was so delicious. For my main I went with the fireside eggs. This was exceptional! Flavourful shakshuka with perfectly poached eggs, avocado and feta served alongside naan bread. This meal was comforting and delicious without being overly filling. I can't recommend The Kitchen enough! If I'm ever back in Boulder I will definitely be back. I would love to try the lunch or dinner menu!

What started as a promising dinner turned into a disappointing experience, especially considering…read morethe restaurant's premium pricing. We were seated promptly for our 7:45 p.m. reservation. The service was excellent, and the drinks and appetizers (carrots, beets, arancini, and gnocchi) were all very good and arrived surprisingly quickly. At 8:30 p.m., we were told that our ribeye, ordered medium rare, had been overcooked to medium well. The manager apologized and said they would prepare another one. She also offered complimentary garlic fries ( very tasty) and desserts, which we appreciated. At 9:08 p.m., the replacement steak finally arrived, but this time it was rare, possibly even blue rare. We sent it back again. At 9:15 p.m., it returned mostly medium rare, although several pieces were still noticeably undercooked. To make matters worse, the butter sauce was so overpowering that it completely masked the flavor of the beef. By this point, we were tired and declined the offer of free dessert. And more frustratingly, despite two failed attempts to properly cook their signature entree, the $155 steak, and a lengthy delay, no adjustment was offered. I politely asked if something could be done, and they removed the carrots from our bill - comping an order of carrots after mishandling a $155 steak twice seemed like a pretty weak gesture. I've dined at many excellent restaurants in my hometown of Chicago, New York, Las Vegas, and internationally. Mistakes happen, but what separates a great restaurant from an average one is how it handles them. When your prices are 10-15% higher than comparable restaurants, expectations are understandably higher as well. Would I return? Possibly. The service was excellent, and the appetizers were good enough to warrant another visit. But I would definitely think twice before ordering another steak. Overall, a disappointing experience where both the kitchen's execution and management's response should have been considerably better.

Photos
The Kitchen American Bistro - Short Rib, tomato jam, taleggio, crispy shallots

Short Rib, tomato jam, taleggio, crispy shallots

The Kitchen American Bistro - Crab Fried Rice, thai lime-nam jim, crushed peanuts, crispy egg

Crab Fried Rice, thai lime-nam jim, crushed peanuts, crispy egg

The Kitchen American Bistro - Smoked Salmon Rillette, hot smoked salmon, chipotle-cream cheese, red onion, caper, cilantro, house-made tortilla chips

See all

Smoked Salmon Rillette, hot smoked salmon, chipotle-cream cheese, red onion, caper, cilantro, house-made tortilla chips

Gemini - PRAWNS A LA PLANCHA arroz negro, chorizo, squid ink, chili crisp

Gemini

4.4(147 reviews)
1.5 mi
•$$

Everything we tried was excellent! There are lots of vegetarian options, and I especially enjoyed…read moretheir patatas bravas and gazpacho. The sangria was tasty too! The servers were super friendly and always there when we needed something. And the location is excellent! It's noisy inside if you like that but quiet and fun at the outside tables, right on the Pearl Street Mall.

I visited Gemini after being invited to a work dinner by my husband's coworkers. We had a large…read moreparty -- 11 people -- but the restaurant gave us a lovely table by the window facing Pearl Street. My half of the table ended up ordering one of everything in the hot tapas section of the menu and two pitchers of sangria. The tomato crostini was so nice and crisp. The focaccia was toasted to perfection, the slow roasted tomatoes had a bright and rich flavor, and the olive oil drizzled on top pulled all the flavors together. The meatballs were incredibly flavorful. Everyone loved the croquettes, which were nice and fluffy inside. The baked goat cheese was incredibly creamy and the honey gave it a wonderful sweetness. It was delicious on top of the slices of baguette they were served alongside of. The champinones/mushrooms were just alright to me -- they had a dark, earthy flavor but I wish it had a more complex flavor profile. I felt similarly about the fried artichoke hearts. The lamb sausage was delicious and had a nice heat to them. We were also served bacon wrapped dates, but I found the dates to be too sticky and sweet. We also ordered every dessert - caramel flan, basque cheesecake, and chocolate cake. I found the caramel flan disappointing. I prefer my flan to be more solid, but this one was mostly cream that was melting on the dish once you dug into it. The cake was good and paired well with the ice cream and candied almonds it was served with. The basque cheesecake was also okay, but I think I enjoyed the apricots it was served with more than the actual cake. Overall, very beautiful restaurant with great tapas.

Photos
Gemini - Interior

Interior

Gemini - OCTOPUS A LA PLANCHA  fingerling potatoes, saffron aioli, grilled red onion, roasted tomato, pimenton

OCTOPUS A LA PLANCHA fingerling potatoes, saffron aioli, grilled red onion, roasted tomato, pimenton

Gemini - GEMINI G & T

See all

GEMINI G & T

Cosmo's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...