A slice of New York in Boulder - - - - - - - - June, 2026 Visit We visited friends in Boulder and they highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza, for good reason - this is good salad and pizza. The gluten free is quite good - amazingly close to typical NY-style crust. Good cheese and toppings. Brooklyn has typical topping combinations and you can order your favorite off-menu combo, too. We also enjoyed the Caesar salads. Thanks, Brooklyn Pizza! ----- ----- ----- read more

Love their pizza. Ordered a prosciutto pizza the other day though and it had like *a piece* of prosciutto on it. Please add more.

Nice little pizza shop but I am glad I finished my slice of pie before I noticed a few things. I watched an employee grab a slice of pizza with his bare hands, Now, that's not too bad since it was gonna go in the oven to reheat but he did this after running his hands through his hair. No gloves! Then I watched the pizza prep guy raising the dough to blow the flour around under the uncooked pizza. He did this about 6 times. Had I seen these actions prior to eating, I would have asked for a refund and walked out. My coworker pointed out a bug walking on the shelf behind the glass. Not the best pie I've had but not the worst. It was the unsanitary actions is what made my review go south. Never going back. read more

The vibe there is like going to an authentic pizza shop in New York. I love it. It feels like you're going to see your neighbor to get a slice of pizza. The pizza is always amazing and their slices never miss but I suggest always getting a whole pie. It's quick, easy cheap and it taste good! It's my favorite pizza place in Boulder. read more

Pizza hits the spot every time!!! Family oriented and counter style service with a small area for counter top seating - service was great, you feel like family here!! It's also very reasonably priced. read more

I come here all the time. Normally, it's very good pizza. Today must've been one of their off days, I ordered two pizzas one pepperoni and one cheese for our family dinner. The boys are meat lovers so they love their pepperoni and the girls and I are vegetarian so we love our cheese pizzas. Unfortunately for us while the boys had a very nice meal and me and the girls were stuck with burnt pizza. Not very good at all. I called and they said they were gonna make it right so let's see how that turns out. We are to pick up a fresh cheese pizza tomorrow. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Burnt four cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

I love this place! So authentic and just amazing NY style pizza, just like I grew up with.

I fw this place heavy. Pizza 10/10. Service 10/10. No bathroom which was unfortunate but overall great experience. The prices were cheap as well. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza w dope guy who made it in background - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Real New York style pizza in Boulder with quality ingredients! I stopped in with my brother on a Saturday for lunch and ordered a large cheese pizza, the owner was there and we chatted a bit while he was making our pizza, he was very friendly.It was done pretty quickly and we decided to just eat it there at the countertop. It was so good we ate the whole thing, Sorry, I should've taken a picture for you yelp viewers (next time). read more

Best pizza around, great crust, sauce is delicious and always ready in a flash. We drive from out of town a few times a month. Always worth it! read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Little Rob waiting for his favorite pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Great pizza, 16" custom (half pepperoni and jalepeno half mushroom and jalepeno) piping hot and really friendly owner. Will be back. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 16" half pepp half mushroom with jalepeno - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

The pizza here, is to died for. The thin and crispy pizza are sliced to perfection. The flavor is superb

Came out to the Denver area with our NJ high school football team of almost 100 people. Mike was absolutely wonderful with working with us to get a large pizza order done with very short notice. The service was above and beyond excellent and the pizza was great-and coming from NJ, that is a big compliment :) read more

I love Brooklyn pizza, my favorite pizza in Boulder. The people are also so so so so so nice!!!!

Pizza here is VERY good NY style pizza, however cleanliness and hygiene is clearly not a priority to the staff. No gloves worn at all in the kitchen. The girl went back and forth from the register to tossing/mixing the cheese around without washing her hands. If cross contamination and hygiene wasn't an issue, Brooklyn would've been 5 stars!! read more

See all

This place is horrible. I ordered a pizza early Saturday evening and showed up to pick it up exactly 15 minutes later. When I told them my order, they said they needed to "heat up the pie." Why would you have to heat up the pie if it was made fresh! I was told by the manager, an extremely rude woman, that they don't make pizzas to order and that they have to heat up all there pizzas. What?!???!!! That's idiotic. what Kind of pizza place doesn't sell fresh pies. What a joke. I lived in Brooklyn for 25 years.. if this place opened there, it would be out of business within a week! They should change their name to "Crap Pizza!" Save your money. This isn't any better quality than a frozen pizza from a grocery store, but twice the price! And on top of that, the place is filthy. read more

When the owner is making you a pizza it's a 5 out 5. He is away for the summer so we got a crust that was hard and chewy. Next day the crust could be used as a weapon. read more

I am so upset. My husband and I love Brooklyn Pizza...but tonight,after our pizza was made incorrectly after waiting 30m and I watched numerous customers being offered free slices because of the cook's mistakes..I was told by the cook I'm going to have to wait again because it's busy...other customers received their orders before me...way before..and the pizza maker appeared not sober. He was all over the place and told me "you gonna have to wait". The younger man who had originally taken my order and was super friendly got nasty when I was told, again, "just 10 minutes" and I requested a refund. He told me I was being racist??? And that I shouldn't say out loud in front of customers that the cook was high. He told me you can have a cash refund (I paid cash!) and he shorted me $4 and told me to get the fuck out of the restaurant. Not ok. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Real East Coast Pizza... - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Great pizza. Nice texture. Thin slice and with a crunch. The crust is really good. None of that soggy greasy stuff either. The service has been great the few times I've been there. I've only been there for lunch time so it hasn't been packed. It's one of those spots where you just grab a slice and go. Seating and parking is very limited. read more

See all

Been coming here for years! The owner Genc has become a personal friend over the years, starting when I used to regularly pickup dinner on the way home from work, balancing a pizza box on my bike. The recipes have always been excellent, especially the pesto pie, and the recreation of a classic NY pie shop is fabulous. Gritty, blue collar ambiance, fantastic food, and the company over years. Hope to keep coming back for many more years!! read more

Very very disappointed, asked for large pizza , extra crispy and paid for online "extra pepperoni" on both sides. I forgot to give them my sons apartment number so I called up to give them info. The nice lady who answered the phone said she received the order snd understood "extra pepperoni" and would make sure there was extra. Then I also asked her to make it extra crispy. She said she would, confirmed my address. I am absolutely astonished that this is extra, checked other reviews and same comments. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - This is extra crispy and extra pepperoni??? You've got to be kidding me!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

If I could give more than five stars, I absolutely would! Hands-down, best pizza I've tasted in Northern Colorado! We live in Longmont, but I'll be looking for every excuse to come to Boulder so that I can taste this extraordinary combination of flavors on a regular basis! Brooklyn Pizza is more than just a pizza place... it's an exquisite experience! Thank you for making dinner a delight tonight!!! read more

Authentic NY style pizza by the slice. Not much ambiance, but order to go. Service is quick, and prices are cheap. They usually have interesting music playing to enjoy during the very short wait. No frills but worth it for the pizza! read more

Small place, great pizza and nice worker. This will be our new spot. it was a lot more affordable and less crowded than cosmos

I went back again after my last review i thought id try it again. I got a slice cant remember what topping i told them WELL DONE on the slice. The put it on the counter and the tip flopped over and under the plate touching the counter top, this went unnoticed or uncaring by the server. The crust was the only thing cooked the whole underside was soggy, very thin dough. I suspect the oven had a cold spot or was turned too low, but honestly worst slice, soggy floppy, 5$ is steep ive had better for 1$ in nyc read more

Food was amazing and the owner was very nice. May be the best pizza in all of CO. Imported ingredients giving the food a great fresh taste.

Diamond in the rough, but this is fantastic real - deal NYC pizza. Thin crust, great sauce and not gobs of cheese. You can tell the ingredients are all fresh. Prices were great. If I lived here it would definitely be my go to! read more

Bringing Brooklyn to Boulder, this place is awesome. If you're looking for a crispy thin crust with the perfect balance of cheese & sauce, and deliciousness without too much salt - then eat here. Your taste buds will thank you. If you're looking for any bit of Boulder swank, you might not be impressed. Love this no-nonsense, let the food deliver the experience, place. read more

My wife and I were with my father in boulder for one more day and we decided to try another pizza spot. We tackled pizza colore a couple blocks down and loved it. We now decided to come to Brooklyn pizza and man we are on the fence for which is better. Brooklyn pizza's slices were HUGE. These came at a pretty decent price too. We ended up ordering three pepperoni slices, a cheesecake and a tiramisu. Onto the food! The pizza was amazing! It comes pre-made(I'm guessing from the morning) and they put it into the oven to reheat it. They leave a nice crunchy and burnt area on the crust. Extremely greasy for those wondering. Loved that, but take it as a warning if you don't like greasy. The tiramisu was a hefty piece of dessert. Creamy and extremely thick. Worth the buy. The cheesecake was tiny for the price. Very skinny and not that long. Don't get me wrong, it was very good but if it were a little bigger then definitely worth the price. My wife personally loved it! read more

See all

They got the order wrong and didn't even cut the pizza into slices. Yeah, it got delivered as a whole pie. I'm at work and don't have a knife and I can't leave. The staff was unhelpful on the phone. If zero stars are as an option, I'd leave zero stars. read more

We love CHEF GENC!!! High quality ingredients, you can taste the difference. The crust. Amazing. I could eat a just crust pizza it is so good. Highly recommend the Italian sausage and rabe pizza. I have only had this pizza here and we will come back forever for it. My boyfriend and I have been coming here for years and have always been served with love from Chef read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 12' Italian Sausage with Rabe - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Literally disgusting... this is the worst pizza I have ever had in my whole life. Thinner than a cracker. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - 2. 12" Pizza Margarita - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

We loved coming here for a slice of pizza! The owner was very attentive right when we walked in! And we saw him making the pizza right behind glass windows. He explained how he only uses the freshest ingredients and let me tell you, it shows. read more

I've been driving by here for 8 years and today finally decided to stop in. Shame on me because I've been missing out all this time. This is true NY style thin crust pizza. The crust is outstanding and the cheese is very good quality as well. The sauce is nice and mild. I will be coming back here whenever I'm in the neighborhood. Genc the owner is a total gentlemen and the young men working here are all class acts too. Give this place a shot you won't regret it! A+ read more

I wish I would have read the reviews before ordering. This place was not great and leaves a lot to be desired for even just a decent pizza. The actual pizza overall was at best maybe slightly better than the cheaper chain pizza places, which might only be the wish in my mind that it would be better. We ordered the bacon pizza which was huge disappointment because we ended up getting a pizza topped with a lot of almost raw chewy bacon fat (almost no meat). Ultimately we ended up pulling off the chunks of fat and adding our own decent bacon to salvage the pie. Tried calling to ask if this was normal and they offered me a desert instead. Sad. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Super fun environment, owner was really nice. Best pizza in boulder if you are looking for a New York slice or whole pie. Barstool would give it an 8 plus for sure iykyk read more

Went here before the Dead show. They were so nice and accommodating. Their pizza is pretty good, fresh and reasonably priced. When I'm back in Boulder, I will definitely stop by for a slice and a coke read more

Not impressed at either of the two times I ordered from this place. First time was a delivery and the pizza was cold and looked like the toppings had slid around the pie in transit. Second visit was a pick up and it was disappointing too. Apparently it seemed like it was a cheese pizza made earlier than the time I ordered it with a topping added and reheated after the fact. At the time of the order I said pepperoni and black olives and when I arrived about 20 minutes later pizza not even warm with no black olives. At this time a scant amount of black olives added and reheated while I was waiting for it. Place looked unkept with various types of pizza laying around behind the counter that were not being kept warm. Not much else to-say except parking lot behind business was packed and I was barely able to park on a Monday despite no other customers on site. read more

Was told to order online and half and half pizzas were fine, " just put it in the comments". Ordered "half regular pepperoni and jalepeno and the other half margarita with basil". Received completely wrong pizza - called store and when I told the owner what happened I was told to "go F myself". What a joke of an illiterate pizza shop. read more

Brooklyn Pizza - Obviously couldn't understand the written instructions I was to told to provide. - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Rude & unsanitary owner. When he brought me my pizza, I asked him if I could have it for to-go. He told me, "would have been easier if you told me before." It took him 2 seconds to transfer from a plate to a box. He was also touching my pizza with his bare hands right after I saw him smoking & on his phone. Totally ruined my meal. Don't waste your time here. Go to pizza Colóre or Cosmos instead. read more