We did take out- ordered a large and 2 salad types. Said 15 minutes and it was ready to go that quickly. The pizza is wood fired and was full of veggies. We are from out of town so our 1st visit the pizza is good but wasn't outstanding. read more

See all

All around a pure delightful & delicious evening. We were early in the evening (5pm) because we'd never had lunch. Staff greeted us with a warm welcome & the offer to sit wherever we liked. All of the staff were very attentive & helpful. We started with drinks & salads, which were both delicious. The Sangria was yummy, with pieces of fruit mixed in. The salads were top notch. I had the Capri salad & couldn't eat it quick enough, lol. Romaine, ham, hearts of palm, corn, feta cheese, tossed in extra virgin olive oil & balsamic vinegar. My husband had the mixed greens & it was equally delicious. We split a medium Margherita Pizza & it was divine! Light, fresh ingredients, thin crust...couldn't have asked for anything better. We finished up with a double scoop of gelato (pistachio & salted caramel). We dug in & I didn't get a pic, oops! New favorite, local restaurant. Definitely busy & a favorite of many. We will be back & will bring friends!!! read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - Margherita Pizza - so fresh, hot, & delicious - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Some of the best most interesting pizza around. Service is always excellent. My assistant loves the lunch specials. Desert is excellent especially the cannoli. The ambience is nice. Lots of windows and a nice bar. read more

If you have eaten at Proto's Pizza in Longmont - you will not be disappointed. The pizza here is fabulous too! And they're open for lunch too. read more

Aug 19, 2025, not taking online orders, can't reach them via phone... New owners as I understand. read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Always amazing food and drinks! Love the drink of the day deal. Our servers are always super nice as well. We are regulars for sure!

I ordered a large pizza (to go) with 6 different toppings plus a "large" tomato mozzarella salad, which consisted of MAYBE two of those small Roma tomatoes and a few slices of mozzarella. The total bill was over $50 ... The pizza wasn't terrible and it wasn't unbelievably delicious. It was good. But $55!! Huh?!?! It was ready quickly but wowza! That's too much for a pizza and a salad. read more

I went for a quick bite at Happy hour. Ordered a drink and a small white pie added spinach & the helpful server suggested prosciutto. It was delicious. I ordered Affogato with a salted Carmel gelato. It was perfect read more

Great Caesar salad. The thin crust pizza is delicious and the service is friendly and attentive. The outside patio is quite nice on a sunny day. read more

Their pizza is just like the pizza I ate in Rome. Very good and authentic. It's a thin crispy crust that I love.

I recently moved here from California and was desperate to find a delicious pizza place. Yay! Protos! Yummy brick oven pizza. Perfect crisp crust with soft inside. I love the char on it. It's a perfect dough thinness. And the flavor of the sauce and cheese and right amount of grease ( I like it when the pepperoni oozes a little grease.) not too much. Just right! I look forward to eating it tonight and will be trying their flourless chocolate cake. Can't wait! read more

Proto's pizza is not much better than frozen grocery pizza. I had a 16", half plain, half pepperoni. Both sides were too salty. The taste of the sauce was overwhelmed by the salt. The crust was like store bought. Anyone who has eaten pizza on the East Coast understands how deficient this pizza is. read more

A special occasion brought my colleagues and I to this spot for lunch (a going away/birthday). I called the day before and made a reservation for seven. It's located in the up and coming area of Gunbarrel, just north of the King Soopers complex. While I typically find it challenging to find parking, lunchtime awarded us with our choice of nearby spots. Upon arrival Callie greeted us warmly and brought us to just the right sized and shaped table. She made great recommendations about how many pies and salads to order. We ordered quite a bit of food and were super impressed that she not only memorized our entire order but that she was so helpful and friendly (she for serious refilled my diet coke 3+ times during the lunch). We started with the salads. A Caesar (with the anchovies on the side) as well as a Capri salad (sliced ham, hearts of palm, and corn). Both salads were fresh, crunchy, and delicious. The Caesar dressing was especially creamy and flavorful (I couldn't help but enjoy some on my pizza crust). The pizzas came out fast and hot. The pizza stands were especially helpful in ensuring we had enough room for all of our plates and drinks. We went for the special (feta, mozzarella, pesto, tomatoes, and basil - crowd favorite), a pepperoni and pesto, the last pizza being an Atomica pie (Italian sausage, black olives, garlic, oregano, etc.). This was my best Proto's experience so far (I've been to one other location). I'll definitely be back to check out their happy hour ($3 large panini, $10 beer & pizza, $5 cocktail of the day, and more). read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - So many pizzas so little time! - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Overpriced. Not very good pizza. I went there once. That was enough. Too bad. I live right across the street. Wouldn't recommend this one at all. read more

Hidden gem, for sure. I got a small Tuscan salad. My friend got a small Pesto Pie and an Izzi's. Everything was delicious! Service was good. And even with a 25% tip it was still only $22! Best restaurant in the are, for sure. And with prices like that, it's just one more reason why Gunbarrel should have its own city and zip. If you ordered that in Boulder, it would have been $30 plus tip with a far longer wait for service. read more

The dough is clearly premade and the large pie was smaller than expected. You're better off warming up a digiorno in the oven -- save yourself the money and the pain of choking down this "pizza." read more

My rating Just went to 5 stars!!! The owner responded immediately and said they've been trying and finally have a contractor set up to come and fix the A/C. Hooray--we'll be back when it's fixed! Andy was great and we love Dakota! Ann G read more

Pretty disappointing for an almost 20$ pizza :/ Barely any sauce and was supposed to have garlic, oregano, and red peppers which you can't even tell are there. Unfortunately will not be returning. read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - Atomica - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Food is great yet unfortunately service is lacking. My friend and I just sat at the bar for pizza and Prosecco. The bartender was rude and dismissive. She never checked in with us after the meal was served and when I called out to her, as she sat playing cards at a nearby table, to ask for another drink she rudely said, "I can't serve you. We're closed." Yet, according to their hours online they close at 9:00. This went down at around 8:15/8:20. A little communication would have been nice. Ive always been taken care at the bar with great staff but seems a whole new crew is on board so I'm not sure I'll be back. Too bad since Gunbarrel doesn't have many options and Protos, up till now, had always been a sure thing. read more

Overpriced and flavorless , I have had Napolitano style pizza in Rome, New York, Boston and philly, this does not even come close to the flavor profile expected of this kind of pizza. The traffic jam sold as a "big mess" of toppings were sparse and flavorless. The crust was thin as expected but No flavor. Very disappointed for the price paid, could have gone to dominos and gotten more flavor. A sad statement. read more

Really yummy pizza and fast service! Got a Caesar salad for takeout which was kind of disappointing (just lettuce and one anchovy) but the pizza is great! Staff is friendly and there isn't usually a wait read more

Had takeout dinner here tonight. Service was quick and friendly. Ordered a house salad with the traffic jam pizza which included all kinds of veggies with sausage. The pizza was excellent. Crust was delicious with good dough and you can tell all the toppings were fresh. I've had plenty of pizza in New York and this on par with the neopolitan style pizza I've had out there. This is a must if you're looking for pizza in Gunbarrel. On a side note the bar looks like a fun place to hang out for a drink. read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - House salad - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

YES and NO!!!! I'm very happy that this establishment is now at Gunbarrel (finally another place to eat)!!! No, because my belt can't simply stretch out further!! Came here for a quick lunch break from school. I was promptly seated, there's plenty of room and is the biggest one I've been to (compared to the Denver and North Boulder location). I ordered a Caesar's salad and the small Proto's Pie ($6). Unlike other chains, I didn't get a chance to see if they had the lunch special available (side salad, pizza, and non-alcoholic drink $12), but wanted the Proto pie, so I didn't care. The waitress was very friendly and attentive, she did a great job! The wood oven pizza came out hot and fresh, the pizza tasted great. However, I can't say that the Caesar salad was the best, it tasted more on the tarty side, the whole bowl had one anchovy in it, and the ciabatta-flat bread like crouton tasted a lot tougher than crispy. Overall, I'd recommend this place to anyone around this area, it's worth the drive!! The pizzas never disappoint me, and the service was awesome. I may have to forgive the salad and give it another date, but for now, I'm just going to stick with the pie! :-) read more

See all

Pretty good. Above average pizza. Mini cannollis (3rd is half off lately) are to die for. Wine is overpriced. Kind of have a good system for zipping in to pick up a takeaway pizza. Don't think I'd hang around. read more

Seriously expensive mediocre pizza! $43 for 2 medium 2 topping pizzas! Plus, they had obviously dropped my pizza as when I opened it at home (was flat the entire time) ALL of the toppings and cheese had slid to one side of the box and were in a gloppy pile so I had an empty crust smeared with sauce! Big Bummer. Won't go back. read more

Uncommonly good pizza and one of my go-tos on this end of town. They usually have a dessert special, I always ask. And their Caprese is excellent, but they call it a tomato mozzarella, they have a separate salad called a Caprese, so good to be clear about what you want. Staff is friendly, during Covid they bring it to your car. It's popular enough that if you have a common first name I suggest adding a last name initial to your order! read more

Overpriced thin-crust (paper thin) and rude staff. Unresponsive to requests and they ignore multiple email attempts to discuss problems. Go to BlackJack Pizza, California Pizza Kitchen or Street Legal Pizza To get your moneys worth. This place thinks their pizzas are made out of gold. Hell, even DiGiono's Pizza is better. read more

My 8 yr old son wants you to know the Shirley Temples are the best (three cherries!) and the pizza is yummy too.

YUM! Love this place and the low-key vibe too. Staff is friendly, and you can watch your pizza being made which I really like. The Goombah pizza is one of our favorites, it has prosciutto and capers on it and the whole thing just tastes great. The pizza menu has about 15 to choose from and a build your own option too. You can get them in different sizes, every time I've been my boyfriend and I each get a medium sized (we eat a lot and we always go when we're starving) we almost always have a piece or two (each) of leftovers! They've got a decent selection of wines and beers, and a bar which people sometimes come to sit at and watch sports. I just love that it's freshly baked yummy pizza and it's close to where I live! Can't go wrong with any of that :) read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - The Goombah - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

I wanted to revisit my comments. We have visited Proto's many times since the last review and I was wrong. It is very good pizza and worth the premium over basic pizza. I eat Gluten Free crust and theirs is some of the best. They are always willing to substitute and accomodate. Highly recommended. read more

I love the Proto's in Longmont. This Gunbarrel location doesn't have a wood fired oven, but a decent gas one. My pizza wasn't brought to me right out of the oven so it wasn't quite hot enough for my liking. Maybe most people don't care if their food is hot or not, but I do. A restaurant's main job is to provide delicious and hot food as appropriate. read more

Absolutely delicious fresh pizza! The crust is just the way it should be, light and thin. The ingredients were fresh and yummy. I had the white pie with Italian sausage and it was perfect and reasonably priced! The drinks were great, a cape cod and Italian soda. On a whim I tried the chocolate gelato and it was like a spoonful of heaven! Loved the decor and the bar mosaic. Will definitely be returning, so scrumptious! read more

Stood in the lobby waiting for my order for quite a long time. Food is okay but nothing to write home about.

Another great Proto's! While one may or may not be thrilled about the infill in Gunbarrel; this is a welcome addition to dining options. The atmosphere is warm and inviting and the staff a delight. Anyone who has lived in Boulder County for a while is familiar with their pizza, a light thin crispy crust and delicate flavors create a truly delicious pizza. If you are looking for a big fat gut-buster pizza, stay at home and order Dominos. Salads are fresh and delicious and sized just right. read more

I regularly come here for lunch with coworkers, and we always have a wonderful time. Their lunch menu is the perfect portion for me (a personal pizza and a side salad), although several of my coworkers with get a larger pizza for themselves and eat most or all of it. They have a good variety of toppings, their combinations are both unique and delicious, and everything comes out fast and fresh. The staff is always helpful and friendly, and I've been told they have a good beer selection as well. Highly recommend them! read more

Had a great time here (first time). They were busy but service was prompt and in good spirits. Pizza (got the low rider) was awesome, and I would definitely recommend it. Also caught happy hour, which is $1 off drafts and wine. read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - The Low Rider - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Service was prompt and friendly after seating ourselves on a Monday night. The atmosphere was great but seating for larger groups looked to be a challenge. Lots of two seat high tops. We had some wine, a mixed green salad with balsamic dressing, and two pizzas (the margherita and the pontiff). Simple pizzas that were tasty but could have had an extra kick to them for being a pizza place (hence the 3 stars). read more

Proto's Pizzeria Gunbarrel - Margherita DOCG - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

I showed up with a group of 7 at lunch and they were able to seat us immediately. We got wonderful service and the pizza tasted very fresh.

Horrible! $28 for a cold take-out pizza with very little sausage and the added pepperoni might have been an ounce. Maybe a 1/4 cup of cheese. It was about 7 pm and maybe they were out of EVERYTHING, but at least give someone the heads up that they are serving junk. Never will return! Caesar salad Ok, but anchovies was stated in the menu. Only had an (1) anchovie. read more

Same solid service and product as the one in North Boulder. If you're in the (still sleepy) area, a worthy choice.