My husband and I had to stop by this place after seeing it on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives and it did not disappoint. We had the lunch special which was a great deal! One big slice of pizza, salad and a drink. The pizza was delicious. All the staff were very friendly and welcoming. The restaurant is small so I could see seating being limited at peak times. I will definitely be back to try the wings! read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Lunch Special - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Ys, each of these plates hold a single slice order, split for our eating convenience. I had the veggie which as a long list of tasty veggies, slightly different assortment from time to time. There are a few that might be on so I order others. Or at least that the plan because I have not found a veggie selection I would refuse. My husband almost always has a meat option and usually pepperoni is one. I cannot eat pepperoni myself on medical grounds so we each order and eat what we want. With separate soda choices, this is a great lunch for. This is where we get our slice fix. And have for years. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Veggie pizza, split for us though an actual single slice! Great value and flavor. - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Great lunch deal - huge pizza slice, salad and a drink! Nice to sit on the patio. Yummy food!

Pizza was very good. Love how big the slides are and toppings are generous. Good flavor and definitely thin crust like NY style. read more

See all

Had to try this place after seeing it on Guy Fieri's DDD and hearing that the owner studied under famous Tony Gemignani. The thin pizza was excellent 10/10, perfectly done, crispy and light and cheesy at the same time. Unfortunately the thick pizza was underwhelming, like a 4/10. Small restaurant with an easy ambiance. Would probably go back and order a whole pie of the thin style pizza to go. read more

See all

This is absolutely in my top 5 pizzas of all time in any place. We had the spicy pig and the PB&AJs, and there aren't enough exclamation marks for how good they both were. We did the Sicilian style crust because I dont like NY, and first off, if you don't care for square pizza or Detroit style, it doesn't matter because this crust is airy and crispy and the perfect counter point to all the toppings. The Spicy pig is SPICY- my lips were burning but I 0% cared, it was that good. The PB&AJ was stellar as well, in a different way. I think with the jam, it had a great sweet and savory mix, and I loved the ricotta as sauce rather than tomato sauce. You can order a whole pizza and get it freshly made (and do 1/2 and 1/2 to try different kinds like we did) or you can get pre made slices that they then warm up. We wanted our judgement to be based off the fresh pizza, and I'm glad we did, but this pizza could have fed 8 people, so be aware! read more

See all

After a long day of floating down the Colorado River, my friends and I landed on Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage while searching on Yelp for easy dinner options. In our large group of 13 -- with some being vegetarian, Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage was perfect, as there were a ton of vegetarian options that sounded delicious to everyone. We ordered four large pizzas, with one being New York style, two Sicilian style, and one "Patty" style. It's hard to choose a favorite crust because every crust was so well made and delicious. I can't say for sure, but the dough tastes as if its made with a sourdough starter, as it has a subtle tang to it. The New York crust is thin and foldable while the other crusts are thick and fluffy like a pan foccacia. Between the Italian Mamma Sauce, kale -- mozzarella, hand-pinched Italian sausage, roasted sweet onions, shaved parmesan, Hot Honey Disco Pie -- Sauce, mozzarella, salami picante, mushrooms, Calabrese honey, basil, Drunken Vita (Vegetarian) -- Vodka Sauce, Eggplant, ricotta, mozzarella, basil, shaved parm, and PB & J -- Prosciutto, Burrata, Arugula, Jam, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Mozzarella, the crowd favorite was the PB & J by a long-shot. Everyone loved the sweetness of the fig jam. After everyone had their fill of pizza, we ended up having about a whole pizza leftover. The pizzas here are huge! If you're in the area and are craving pizza, Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage is the place to go -- easily some of the best pizza I've ever had. read more

See all

Had a pizza craving so we decided to try Audrey Jane's because of the good reviews. 10/10 experience--definitely felt like I was grabbing a slice in NY...oh how I've missed pizza from the east coast. Staff was friendly and kind enough to explain what some of the toppings were on the pizzas on display. Price was around $15 for 2 slices, which wasn't bad considering the size of the slices they give you. I had trouble carrying both slices to the table, but I do kinda have small hands lol. All I could think was, don't drop it! My dining companion got the meatball and ricotta deep dish, while I stuck with the classic cheese pizza. I'd totally get mine again, but we probably would pass on the meatball and ricotta next time. Definitely coming back in the near future and would highly recommend. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Meatball and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Excellent price for what you get in the lunch special $13.95 for a slice of pizza which is huge a salad they fill to the brim and a drink. I even came in when it was passed lunch time and they still gave me the special. Pizza had great dough and used quality ingredients. Highly recommend for value vs. money. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Pizza slice w Pepperoni, sausage, and jalepenos. Caesar salad. Photo doesn't do justice how large the slice was. - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Expensive but best pizza I've ever had in Boulder. I bought a whole pie. Two days latter I tried their slices- huge portions on their slices -really close to two slices read more

Really enjoyed the food! Pizza by the slice and they are HUGE!! A little confused when walking in as the guy at the register mumbled and I couldn't understand a word or if he was even speaking. Inside was cramped but we are on patio and it was fine. Good pizza! read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

The people were genuinely very nice, and I appreciate the friendly service. Unfortunately, the pizza didn't work for me. It was pretty greasy and seemed light on cheese, and the slice I had may have been sitting for a while--because it was very hard and the cheese was tough and chewy. I really wanted to like it, but the quality just wasn't there this time. Wishing the staff all the best. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - The mushroom pizza I got tonight - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Small cool place. Order at the register and not too many places to sit. Pizza was sooooo good, thin and crispy. Would go back. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Cheese slice, pepperoni slice, and spicy pig Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

We ordered a few different pizzas. Not one of them gave me that wow factor. I was most definitely disappointed. After reading all the reviews my hopes were high. The staff was friend and atmosphere was nice. read more

Amazing food. I came here once a decade ago and it was good then and still great today. Amazing food. Friendly staff. Good environment. Always a pleasure coming here. read more

Pizza was good but the price for 4 slices of pizza was $32. Cosmos is a much better deal. If you like paying an exorbitant price for pizza, then this might be the place for you. Tried this place but will go back to Cosmos. read more

Biggest slice of pizza in Boulder not just the size but the flavor as well. The crust is crispy and delicious the tomato sauce won me over. It's not super greasy and they do pizza by the slice or you can order an entire pizza for Takeaway . I just wish they had one in Longmont. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

I started eating at Audrey Janes pizza as soon as they opened many years ago. This has been my goto pizza joint and is always really great pie. They have a sausage that is absolutely delicious and every pie I have tried has been great. The crust has a great chew and they use the right amount of cheese to make is taste heavenly. If you want a quality pizza pie then you need to order here. Enjoy! read more

Excellent pizza! You can taste the fermented sourdough in every bite of the crust. The slices are enormous, and I made the mistake of ordering two for my daughter who is eight years old and two for me. She actually managed to eat an entire piece, which was impressive. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Generally a fan of AJ's GF Pizzas. They're expensive AF but BIG and usually pretty tasty. Last week I ordered my usual - sausage on top of a margherita on GF crust. Picked it up as it was finishing. Got it home and whoa! Slimy, limp and almost wet crust. Fell apart as I was picking it up. Ate two pieces (b/c I was starving) and threw the rest out. What happened AJ? Will certainly give it another try at some point but at that price point, I'm now inspired to find other GF pizza options in Boulder. My fav closed. You guys know the one in South Boulder that was always in 'shade'. But others I haven't tried. Will report back if I find a worthwhile one. read more

I just moved to Boulder and I've tried 6 or 7 pizza places so far. Granted I am an East Coast pizza snob but Audrey's is one of my top two favorites so far. The meatball sub also smacks. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

4.5 stars. I gotta say, I'm impressed. I've been eyeing Audrey Jane's for awhile now and after a bunch of mediocre pizza experiences from other nearby establishments I was skeptical. Could this be as good as everyone says? Welp... the answer is a resounding YUP. We decided to start rather basic with a plain cheese NY style. I figured if this was good, the rest would be a nice bonus. It was very good - the cheese, sauce and crust were all tasty although I did find the crust to dry out a bit. Nothing major, but would take off a half star for it. On the other hand, I was not prepared to fall in love with the Patty style but good lawd I didn't realize that sesame seeds were the missing link to my latest food obsession. We decided on sweet onions and pepperoni as the toppings and mama mia I am so glad we did. The sesame seeds encrusting the whole bottom was so bizarre as I had never seen this before, but the added flavor and texture is beyond crave-able. I love the story that accompanies this style pizza and it made me want to try it all the more. This is a pizza I could gladly heat up leftovers and eat every day (which I sure did!) Can't wait to try some more combinations. The green ranch was also super delicious and idc if you judge me, I dipped the crust right in there and didn't regret a second of it. read more

See all

The slices are huge! I live in the area & will be stopping by here regularly! It might be a little on the high end for most people, but it's worth it in my opinion. read more

Nestled in a neighborhood we came here because we wanted a new pizza place that could accommodate my wife's allergies and still make something good for folks without restrictions. Did not disappoint at all. The gluten free crunchy vegan was a banger. Mounding with veggies, perfectly roasted and so many textural and flavor combinations. My wife said it was the best pizza she's ever had. The spicy pig was also phenomenal. Big...great chew on the crust, fresh ingredients, amazing sauce, and their sausage was insane. Friendly staff that gives a damn about folks with allergies and cares about their food. read more

The veg out pizza was delicious! I placed an online order for pick up and waited about 15 minutes once I got there. They were slammed for a Monday night. Not much seating on the inside but they have a nice patio. Prices are on the higher side but it's worth it. I believe they have a $12 slice, salad, and drink lunch special. Can't wait to try the spicy pig next time. read more

I can only rate on what I was served. I am short and couldn't see the top shelf of the pizzas I could pick from for an individual slice. So I ordered the sausage slice. It must have been up there since lunch and we were there for dinner. I couldn't even chew about a third of the piece. Cheese, sauce and crust were compacted into a thin inedible area. I added a couple of pieces of my husband's pepperoni. I could eat the tip and a small area on the right where the cheese hadn't hardened. My husband's slice was normal. Mine should not have been served. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Dried out slice with not much sausage for the price. - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Customer service is great and they have an amazing Tiramisu. BUT there is something wrong with the sauce. I feel a pizza place with bad tasting sauce is missing its core. Re-evaluate your recipe. It's too tangy and sweet. read more

We stumbled upon this place when the pizza spot we frequent was closed for the day. We had high hopes. Mediocre pizza, I would recommend trying by a slice before buying a pizza. We spent $100.00 and would not get anything we ordered again. read more

I have wanted to try Audrey Jane's for a while and decided to go and get a pizza today. We got the NY style cheese and pepperoni. I usually try a new place with a simple margherita so that I can get a taste for the dough, sauce, spices, etc. Today I felt a little crazy and added pepperoni, and while the natural casing pepperoni was excellent, it kind of got lost as a single ingredient. I would definitely get it as an addition with other extra toppings, but maybe not by itself. However, the pizza was outstanding, bringing back memories. I didn't try the Sicilian nor any of the sandwiches. But I will be back to try some more. read more

Great place to stop for a slice. They have a large selection that's ready by the slice, or you can order a whole pizza. The garlic loaf was crispy on the outside and soft and chewy on the inside. I got the spicy pig, and she got the cheese. We were both satisfied. I will say that parking can be a challenge, so if you're picking up takeout, it is best to bring a buddy to run in and get it whole you circle the block. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Date night to go! - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Nice friendly service, clearly a popular place! I was excited to try it out. The pizzas were creative and all sounded great. There are so many pizza crust options! I wasn't a huge fan of the style we got, as it didn't have as much sauce as I prefer but the ingredients were fresh. Not my preference of pizza, but I can see why it's popular. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Vegan pizza (add cheese - I know, not vegan ) & the pizza with fig jam - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

Delicious NY style pizza - OMG so good. I admit I have a low bar on pizza but this place reset it high. Service friendly and ambience matched NY of 70s late at night. read more

Excellent NY style pizza! Went at 5pm on a Saturday night for a slice and they had it warmed up to perfection within minutes. Perfect amount of oil, sauce and cheese and pepperoni was well seasoned. The crust was crispy but not burnt and slice was thin but still easy to hold without falling apart. 7$ which can seem like a lot but the slice is giant and is easily 2 normal slices . They have a lunch special for 11-12$ (depending on pizza slice you choose) for a slice, salad and drink. They have a few good amount of different pizza options including a pizza of the day. There is some seating indoors (a few tables and countertop space). Staff were very friendly. Free 2hr street parking just outside the store. Would highly recommend! read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

I love this place so much. The staff is always welcoming and the food is on POINT. The routine when I'm visiting family is to go on a hike then go eat pizza here. We always get the biggest size of the Green Mountain pizza available because it is so good. It's salty from the olives and creamy from the ricotta. This is a white pie that's fairly thin and a fluffy ass crust begging to be dipped in their herby ranch. We always get the Green Mountain pizza + another one, just to try and to support the place. The meatball sub is also spectacular - tons of cheesy, very flavorful meatball, all nestled in a garlic bread? *SOB* Guy Fieri has left his mark here, which I wasn't sure if that was good or bad at first. But now I understand... that guy gets it. read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Meatball sub and green mountain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

recently, we were up in Boulder to see our son and his girlfriend. We had an opportunity to get a two pizzas from Audrey Jane's... Absolutely incredible!!! read more

Best pizza in the area, so far! Hands down nailed it on crust, sauce and the leoparding of the crust with perfect char and crispy to soft ratio. I feel the price point is fair. Online ordering is easy and efficient for the customers and we enjoyed our pizza for a last minute dinner. A large pizza will feed 4 with a side salad and we feel that $30-$40 for a pizza of this caliber is reasonable and disagree with other reviews who find this place too expensive. We stopped by for slices last week to trial the place and it did not disappoint. We will adding this place to our rotation list as we dine out more than we dine in, lol. We did prefer the standard crust to the deep dish, but look forward the the Patty style crust for our next adventure. read more

Hmmm, confused on how to review AJPG. I grew up in the great state, or not so great state (depending how you look at it, of New Jersey. I spent the first 19 years of my life devouring Jersey and NYC style pizza. So here goes nothing: I think for the long NY style slice of pizza, AJPG is def probably a better slice than Abos or Cosmos. I def can say this with confidence! It's a better slice taste wise, texture wise, and such. The hard part I had is the price for the slices whether it be cheese or with toppings. I think a cheese is $6.50ish and a toppings slice is $7.75. I thought about it for while thinking well, it is a big slice and you could make argument that that slice is the size of two whole food slices. Now, this is really just my opinion, I know I know opinions are like as . . ., but pizza shouldn't be so expensive. Spending around $15 for two slices doesn't really get me that full either. I can't imagine having a family of four to feed and ordering a large pie or two on a Friday night. Seems like you could get more value somewhere else. That all being said, if you're looking for a decent NYC slice out here in Colorado then I think AJPG is probably your best bet. In general, it's a good tasting slice and it folds like a slice should too. Just know that if you are on a budget then AJPG is a nice treat once in a while. I think this is a great place for a tasty slice, a quick stop when you''re looking for something fast and don't care about the price, or your looking for a pizza night with your friends, family or date night. read more

See all

I came in for a slice and it was so greasy as to be inedible. Please adjust your recipes to be more edible. So many other good pizza places in Boulder to choose from. read more

The roll for the meatball grinder looked super tantalizing and I was craving a meatball sub. This place really delivered! Tons of quality mozz cheese, and fluffy, rich bread with plenty of hearty meatballs cooked perfectly. The green mountain pizza equally impressed as we got generous mounds of ricotta in a bite with plenty of olives. The crust was tasty and thin. We ordered online but came and they expedited the order. Staff was friendly. We would definitely be back to try something else! read more

Audrey Jane's Pizza Garage - Meatball grinder - Pizza Near Me - Boulder, Colorado

See all

Waaaaaay over-hyped. We saw this spot on TV and decided to stop on our next visit to Boulder. While the pizza was decent, it was nothing special and we will not be retuning. The dough is covered in corn meal or semolina which makes every bite gritty which I hate. Spicy Pig had a lot of garlic and a lot of grease making it quite hard to eat since the oversized slices can't handle the load. Again, not horrible but for the price there are plenty of local options that I prefer. read more