As I drove to Communal, I started writing the glowing review in my head.
"Communal is a place that should be shared..."
"Communal is just what this community needed."
Alas, the before eating (imagined) version and after eating (reality) version don't quite gel.
It's a little bit pointless to go over exactly what we ate because the menu is ever evolving. I like that. I like that they use fresh, sustainable, local ingredients whenever possible. I like the decor - funky, eclectic, conscious, super clean, attractive. I like that the chef is present. Well...there are negatives to that too.
So, I want to address our esteemed chef. This is what I want you to know about my dining experience tonight:
I do like, Chef, that you have a lovely open kitchen that allows me to smell the butter browning and the steak sizzling. Just please bear in mind that open applies to smells and sounds.
Chef, I don't want to overhear that you think the table that just left contained a jerk. Are you going to think I'm a jerk if I don't love your food as much as you do? I don't want to hear you say that you thought we were still on our salad course while we were awaiting dessert (and had specifically ordered it ahead of time because we had an appointment to make). I don't really care that you lost track. That happens in this business from time to time. I get that. As the customer though, I don't want to know about it.
I do like that our server was attentive and made sure our glasses were always full of PH balanced water.
I don't like that he put his hands (the ones that have been touching all manner of things) directly into garnish that he then put on my dinner.
I do like that my salad contained perfect spinach leaves, not a hint of anything less than fresh as can be.
I didn't like that my salad was so underdressed that the flavor of the vinegar-based dressing only came through in one or two bites.
I don't like that my tri-tip was on the tough side. I know it's tri-tip, but for the portion you gave me at the price you gave me, I expected it to be perfect. It wasn't. And the sauce (like the dressing above) was very skimpy. I don't mean that it should have been drowning. I mean that I should have been able to taste it above the flavor of the meat beyond the very first bite.
I like that your ingredients are well thought out, cohesive, and selected with care.
I like that the asparagus with aioli was spot-on perfect.
I like that you left me with a good dessert. Good dessert forgives many sins in the restaurant world.
Overall, it was clear that everything was executed with thought and care. That being said, I'd only go back in a group with the aim of seeing if tonight was a fluke and Communal is the good egg it's cracked up to be.
I always say that my preferred places to eat are those that serve food that is laborious to prepare and/or contains hard-to-find ingredients. Communal delivers the former (and I think they think they deliver the latter but we're lucky and have good sources for great products).
Although the detailed elements (the mandolin sliced veg, the sauce on my steak, the poached egg on my salad, the mashed potatoes made with a ricer) were time-consuming, they weren't as perfect as they could have been. I think that's a shame because for the cost of dinner, and for the sake of dining, they should be.
So, Chef, I leave you with this heart-felt advice: Communal has gained a stellar reputation because it's one of the best Utah County has to offer. But, Chef, you worked at Sundance - you know Utah County is not known for it's fine dining. Compete on a higher level. I know the appropriate amount of sauce on an item is a matter of opinion, but I invite you to consider mine: You put a lot of time and effort into making those beautiful sauces. Make sure that when you put them on the plate, there's enough for the diner to relish them, to feel the luxury of them. Because if you do not, you won't earn the repeat business of diners who see and feel that your potential isn't fully being realized. And that would be a shame because you clearly have so much to offer.
Bottom line: Communal is good, but it's not amazing. I would never say stay away, but I couldn't recommend it wholeheartedly. And I wish I could. read more